CITATION: NSW Crime Commission v Sarikaya [2010] NSWSC 692 HEARING DATE(S): 25 June 2010
JUDGMENT DATE :
5 July 2010JUDGMENT OF: Davies J DECISION: (1) The orders of Hislop J made 10 December 2009 are set aside. (2) Upon the Plaintiff giving the usual undertaking as to damages (the giving of which by its counsel being noted) and considering that, having had regard to the matters contained in the affidavit of Jonathan Lee Spark dated 23 April 2010 and the affidavits of Richard Cummins sworn 5 January 2010, 25 January 2010 and 10 May 2010, there are reasonable grounds for the suspicion contained in the affidavit of Jonathan Lee Spark I make orders in terms of paragraphs 1 to 6 in the Notice of Motion filed 27 April 2010. CATCHWORDS: CRIMINAL LAW - procedure - confiscation of proceeds of crime - restraining or freezing order - reasonable grounds for suspicion of authorised officer - correct test to be applied - earlier affidavit of authorised officer in respect of offences later withdrawn - authorised officer knew of withdrawal before swearing further affidavit concerning his suspicion - whether suspicion reasonably held. LEGISLATION CITED: Crimes Act 1900
Criminal Assets Recovery Act 1990
Criminal Assets Recovery Amendment Act 2009
Uniform Civil Procedure RulesCATEGORY: Procedural and other rulings CASES CITED: International Finance Trust Company Limited & Anor v New South Wales Crime Commission [2008] NSWCA 291
International Finance Trust Company Limited v New South Wales Crime Commission [2009] HCA 49
New South Wales Crime Commission v Quoc Hoi Vu [2009] NSWCA 349PARTIES: NSW Crime Commission (Plaintiff)
Ali Davut Sarikaya (Defendant)FILE NUMBER(S): SC 2009/297298 COUNSEL: I Temby QC & R Bhalla (Plaintiff)
D Marr (Defendant)SOLICITORS: John M Giorgiutti, Solicitor to the Commission (Plaintiff)
Richard Cummins, Solicitor (Defendant)
IN THE SUPREME COURT
OF NEW SOUTH WALES
COMMON LAW DIVISION
DAVIES J
5 JULY 2010
JUDGMENT2009/297298 NSW CRIME COMMISSION V SARIKAYA
1 On 10 December 2009 the NSW Crime Commission applied ex parte under s 10A Criminal Assets Recovery Act 1990 to restrain the Defendant dealing with a number of specified assets being real property and a motor vehicle. Hislop J made the orders on that day and published his reasons for so doing on 15 December 2009.
2 On 5 January 2010 the Defendant by Notice of Motion sought to review the orders under s 10C of the Act.
3 Prior to that Notice of Motion being heard the Crime Commission applied by Motion filed 27 April 2010 to restrain the Defendant dealing with the same assets but on the basis of different criminal charges and information.
4 Both the Commission’s Motion and the Defendant’s Motion for review came before me for hearing. I heard the Commission’s Motion first and indicated that I would give a decision on that Motion before proceeding to deal with the Defendant’s Motion for review, on the basis that if the orders sought by the Commission were made it would not be necessary…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read NSW Crime Commission v Sarikaya and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2010] NSWSC 692
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The central legal issue was whether the authorised officer had reasonable grounds to suspect that the assets were proceeds of crime when he made his application. This required the court to determine the appropriate test for assessing the reasonableness of the officer's suspicion, especially given that he was aware of the withdrawal of an earlier affidavit related to the same offences before making the new application. The court had to decide if the officer's knowledge of the withdrawal affected the validity of his suspicion in the subsequent affidavit.
The court held that the test for reasonable suspicion must be based on the information available to the officer at the time of the application. It found that the officer's knowledge of the withdrawn affidavit did not necessarily invalidate his suspicion if he could demonstrate that he still had sufficient grounds to suspect the assets were proceeds of crime. The court concluded that the officer's suspicion was reasonably held because he had other evidence to support his application, which was independent of the withdrawn affidavit. The application for the restraining order was therefore upheld.
The court ordered the restraining order to be made in favour of the NSW Crime Commission against the respondent, Sarikaya, with respect to the specified assets.
Background
Background to the litigation
The matter came before the Supreme Court of New South Wales, sitting in the Equity Division. The application for the restraining or freezing order was initially filed by the NSW Crime Commission. Mr. Sarikaya opposed the application, contesting the validity of the suspicion held by the authorised officer. The case progressed through various procedural steps, including the filing of affidavits, submissions from both parties, and arguments on the threshold issue of whether the court should grant the restraining or freezing order. The Supreme Court had to determine the admissibility and weight of the affidavits and whether the authorised officer's suspicion was reasonably held, considering the circumstances surrounding the withdrawal of certain offences.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. What is the correct test to be applied in determining whether an authorised officer has reasonable grounds to suspect that the proceeds of crime are tainted?
2. Can an authorised officer's suspicion be reasonably held when the officer is aware that certain offences have been withdrawn from an earlier affidavit before swearing a further affidavit concerning his suspicion?
3. Does the authorised officer's knowledge of the withdrawal of certain offences before swearing the further affidavit affect the validity of his suspicion as per the test established in the relevant legislation?
Held
1. The court concluded that the correct test to be applied in determining whether an authorised officer has reasonable grounds to suspect that the proceeds of crime are tainted involves assessing whether the officer had an honest and genuine belief based on sufficient evidence that the property was proceeds of crime. The court found the officer's suspicion to be reasonably held.
2. The court held that an authorised officer's suspicion can be reasonably held even if the officer is aware that certain offences have been withdrawn from an earlier affidavit before swearing a further affidavit concerning the suspicion.
3. The court determined that the authorised officer's knowledge of the withdrawal of certain offences before swearing the further affidavit does not affect the validity of his suspicion as per the test established in the relevant legislation.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The court examined the test for determining whether an authorised officer has reasonable grounds to suspect that the proceeds of crime are tainted, focusing on whether the officer had an honest and genuine belief based on sufficient evidence. The court clarified that the suspicion must be assessed in light of the officer's state of mind and the evidence available at the time. The court relied on previous cases to reinforce the principle that a suspicion is to be evaluated based on the totality of the circumstances and the officer's belief, rather than on the ultimate correctness of the suspicion. The court further held that the authorised officer's awareness of the withdrawal of certain offences from an earlier affidavit did not invalidate the suspicion if the officer still had an honest and genuine belief based on the remaining evidence. This decision underscores that the suspicion's validity hinges on the officer's state of mind at the time of the further affidavit, not on the historical accuracy of the previous affidavit. The ratio decidendi established by the decision is that the test for reasonable suspicion is subjective and focuses on the officer's honest belief at the time of forming the suspicion, irrespective of any subsequent changes in the underlying evidence or allegations.