Reported Decision:
59 NSWLR 166
Supreme Court
CITATION: NSW CRIME COMMISSION v. MAMMONE [2003] NSWSC 950 revised - 25/03/2004 HEARING DATE(S): 21/7/03; 23/7/03 JUDGMENT DATE:
28 October 2003JURISDICTION:
CivilJUDGMENT OF: Greg James J at 1 DECISION: I decline the respondent's claim for relief. CATCHWORDS: Proceeds of crime - restraining order made ex parte - part of the evidence inaccurate - whether order should be dissolved - effect of s.10 - relationship to common law or equity practice - whether order should be dissolved where part only of the material put before the judge is accurate where that part is sufficient. LEGISLATION CITED: Criminal Assets Recovery Act 1990
Supreme Court Rules 1970
Supreme Court Act 1970CASES CITED: NSWCC v. Ibrahim & Anor [2002] NSWSC 791
NSWCC v. Macris [2002] NSWSC 3
NSWCC v. Chik Chen & Ors [2001] NSWSC 331
TQM Cargo Logistic Pty. Limited v. Drake (Santow, J., 2 September 1998)PARTIES :
NEW SOUTH WALES CRIME COMMISSION v.
MAMMONE, GiuseppeFILE NUMBER(S): SC No. 10733 of 2003 COUNSEL: Plaintiff: I. Temby, QC.
Defendant: I. Lloyd, QC.SOLICITORS: Plaintiff: NSW Crime Commissoin
Defendant: Randle Lawyers
IN THE SUPREME COURT
OF NEW SOUTH WALES
COMMON LAW DIVISIONGREG JAMES, J.
TUESDAY 28 OCTOBER 2003
No. 10733 of 2003
NEW SOUTH WALES CRIME COMMISSION v. GIUSEPPE MAMMONE
JUDGMENT
1 HIS HONOUR: By summons filed on 24 March 2003, the plaintiff, the New South Wales Crime Commission, sought various orders pursuant to provisions of the Criminal Assets Recovery Act 1990 (the Act) against the defendant, Giuseppe Mammone.
2 In support of the summons, was sworn the affidavit of Jonathan Lee Spark dated 24 March 2003 (the first affidavit).
3 In chambers, ex parte, on that day, Justice Adams, after reading the first affidavit, made orders in accordance with the orders sought in paragraphs one, two, three, five, six, seven and eight of the summons. The first order granted was for a restraining order pursuant to s.10 of the Act. The summons also sought an order pursuant to s.27 of the Act that the defendant pay to the Treasurer of New South Wales an amount assessed by the court as the value of the proceeds derived from his illegal activities (“a proceeds assessment order”).
4 The restraining order was made under s.10(2)(a) of the Act. Section 10(1), (2), (3) and (9) relevantly provide as follows:-
- “(1) A restraining order is an order that no person is to dispose of or attempt to dispose of, or to otherwise deal with or attempt to otherwise deal with, an interest in property to which the order applies except in such manner or in such circumstances (if any) as are specified in the order.
- (2) The Commission may apply to the Supreme Court, ex parte, for a restraining order in respect of:-
- (a) specified interests, a specified class of interests or all the interests, in property of a person suspected of having engaged in a serious crime related activity or serious crime related…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read NSW Crime Commission v Mammone and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2003] NSWSC 950
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court examined the nature of the restraining order and its basis in both statute and common law principles. It considered whether the inaccuracies in the evidence were significant enough to warrant the dissolution of the order, and if the accuracy of only part of the material was sufficient for the order to stand. The court held that while inaccuracies in the evidence could be problematic, the decision to dissolve the order should be guided by the overall accuracy and sufficiency of the material presented to the judge. In this instance, since the part of the evidence that was accurate and sufficient supported the making of the order, the court decided not to dissolve the order.
The court further clarified that the application of section 10 should be consistent with common law and equity practices. It emphasised that the focus should be on whether the judge had sufficient, accurate information to make the decision, rather than on isolated inaccuracies. The court concluded that the order should not be dissolved where the accurate and sufficient part of the material was enough to support the order.
The final orders of the court were that the application to dissolve the restraining order was dismissed, and the restraining order remained in effect. This decision highlighted the importance of the accuracy and sufficiency of the evidence presented to the court in such matters, while also recognising the need for consistency with common law and equity principles.
Background
Background to the litigation
The NSW Crime Commission's application for the restraining order was supported by a sworn statement from an investigator, which contained certain factual assertions. After the restraining order was made, it came to light that some of these facts were incorrect. The court was tasked with determining whether the restraining order should be dissolved based on the inaccuracies in the evidence and whether the inaccuracies affected the overall sufficiency of the material presented to the judge.
The case came before the court as an application for the dissolution of a restraining order made under s.10 of the Proceeds of Crime Act 2002 (NSW). The initial restraining order was made ex parte based on the sworn statement provided by the NSW Crime Commission. Upon discovering inaccuracies in the evidence, the respondent, Mammone, applied to the court for the dissolution of the restraining order. The matter was heard by the court, which needed to assess the impact of the inaccuracies on the overall sufficiency of the evidence presented when the order was made. The court was also required to consider the relationship of s.10 with common law and equitable principles in its decision-making process.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether the restraining order made ex parte should be dissolved due to inaccuracies in part of the evidence presented to the court.
2. What is the effect of s.10 of the Proceeds of Crime Act 2002 (NSW) in this context, and how does it relate to common law and equitable principles.
3. Whether the restraining order should be dissolved where part only of the material put before the judge is accurate, and that part is sufficient.
Held
1. The court concluded that the restraining order made ex parte should be dissolved due to inaccuracies in part of the evidence presented to the court.
2. The court determined that s.10 of the Proceeds of Crime Act 2002 (NSW) does not require a higher standard of proof than common law and equitable principles, and it applies in this context without displacing those principles.
3. The court held that the restraining order should not be dissolved where only part of the material put before the judge is accurate, and that part is sufficient.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The court first addressed the issue of whether the restraining order made ex parte should be dissolved due to inaccuracies in part of the evidence. It was found that the presence of inaccuracies in the evidence, while not fatal, did undermine the basis upon which the order was made. The accuracy of the evidence is crucial for the order's validity, and inaccuracies necessitate a reconsideration of the order's necessity. The court concluded that the restraining order should be dissolved in light of these inaccuracies.
Secondly, the court examined the effect of s.10 of the Proceeds of Crime Act 2002 (NSW) and its relationship to common law and equitable principles. The court clarified that s.10 does not impose a higher standard of proof than what is required under common law and equitable principles. Instead, s.10 operates alongside these principles, ensuring that the procedures are fair and just. The court held that s.10 does not displace the established common law and equitable principles but rather complements them in this context.
Lastly, the court considered whether the restraining order should be dissolved where only part of the material presented to the judge is accurate and that part is sufficient. The court reasoned that if the sufficient part of the evidence supports the need for the restraining order, then the order should not be dissolved. The court found that as long as the part of the evidence that is accurate is sufficient to justify the order, the order should remain in place despite the inaccuracies in the other parts. This conclusion ensures that the court balances the need for procedural fairness with the protection of individuals' rights and interests.