NRM Trading Pty Ltd v Australian Competition and Consumer Commission

Link copied
Case Copied 18 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

NRM Trading Pty Ltd v Australian Competition and Consumer Commission [2015] FCA 595

Citation: NRM Trading Pty Ltd v Australian Competition and Consumer Commission [2015] FCA 595
Parties: NRM TRADING PTY LTD (ACN 151 469 493), NRM CORPORATION PTY LTD (ACN 151 468 601) and DR JACOV VAISMAN v AUSTRALIAN COMPETITION AND CONSUMER COMMISSION
File number: VID 239 of 2015
Judge: MIDDLETON J
Date of judgment: 28 May 2015
Legislation: Competition and Consumer Act 2010 (Cth)
Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth)
Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth)
Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth)
Cases cited: Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v ACN 117 372 915 Pty Limited (in liq) (formerly Advanced Medical Institute Pty Limited) [2015] FCA 368
Commissioner of Taxation v Donoghue [2015] FCA 337
Date of hearing: 28 May 2015
Place: Melbourne
Division: GENERAL DIVISION
Category: No Catchwords
Number of paragraphs: 47
Counsel for the Appellants: Mr DL Williams SC with Mr SC Ipp
Solicitor for the Appellants: Stevens Vuaran Lawyers
Counsel for the Respondent: Mr JWK Burnside QC with Ms LM Nichols
Solicitor for the Respondent: Corrs Chambers

IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

VICTORIA DISTRICT REGISTRY

GENERAL DIVISION

VID 239 of 2015

BETWEEN:

NRM TRADING PTY LTD (ACN 151 469 493)
First Appellant

NRM CORPORATION PTY LTD (ACN 151 468 601)
Second Appellant

DR JACOV VAISMAN
Third Appellant

AND:

AUSTRALIAN COMPETITION AND CONSUMER COMMISSION
Respondent

JUDGE:

MIDDLETON J

DATE OF ORDER:

28 MAY 2015

WHERE MADE:

MELBOURNE

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.Order 12 of the orders made by North J on 22 April 2015 (‘Orders’):

(a)be stayed until 5 p.m. on Friday, 12 June 2015; and

(b)is modified such that:

(i)the words “subject to appeal” will be inserted in the text of the “click-through” icon referred to in order 12(c) of the Orders after the words “Unconscionable Conduct by Advanced Medical Instituted (AMI) – ”;

(ii)A new paragraph will be inserted as the first paragraph of Annexure A to the Orders, as follows:

“The notice below is published by order of the Federal Court of Australia as the result of a judgment which is under appeal. NRM denies that it engaged in unconscionable conduct in 2011 and 2012 as the Court has found (and as set out below). It has appealed against the decision of the Federal Court of Australia and will pursue the appeal vigorously.”

(iii)In paragraph 2 of Annexure A, the words “The Court found that” be inserted as the opening words of the paragraph prior to the words “NRM promoted its business”.

(iv)Following the bullet points which follow paragraph 2 of Annexure A, a new paragraph will be inserted as follows:

“NRM is appealing some of these findings and the overall conclusion that it engaged in unconscionable conduct.”

(v)At the conclusion of paragraph 3 of Annexure A (that is, following the words “the refund policy is void”), a new paragraph will be inserted as follows:

“NRM is not appealing against the finding in relation to the refund…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read NRM Trading Pty Ltd v Australian Competition and Consumer Co... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2015] FCA 595
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of NRM Trading Pty Ltd v Australian Competition and Consumer Commission involved an appeal against orders made by North J in a previous proceeding. The primary concern of the applicants, NRM Trading Pty Ltd and others, was the potential impact of specific orders on their business operations. The court was required to determine whether a stay should be granted on certain orders made by North J that restricted their business activities.

The legal issues before the court included the potential hardship and irreparable damage that the applicants might suffer if the orders were enforced without a stay. The court also had to consider whether the appeal grounds presented by the applicants were arguable and bona fide. The applicants argued that the orders would significantly impact their ability to conduct business, particularly orders requiring face-to-face consultations with medical practitioners and the publication of a notice regarding the court's findings.

In considering these issues, the court found that the applicants had not provided sufficient evidence to demonstrate that the orders would cause undue hardship. The court was not convinced that the requirement for video-link consultations would be technologically or logistically impossible for the applicants to implement. Additionally, the court noted that the applicants had not contested the terms of the injunctions against them, despite the significant changes they imposed on the operation of their business. The court was also mindful of the need to maintain confidentiality and the potential embarrassment patients might feel, which the applicants had not adequately addressed.

The court decided to grant a limited stay on certain orders, with modifications to ensure that the applicants' position regarding the appeal was clearly communicated. Specifically, the court stayed Order 12, requiring the publication of a notice on the applicants' website, with modifications to clarify that the notice was published by court order and that the applicants were appealing the findings. Order 13, which required the payment of costs, was also stayed pending the outcome of the appeal. The court dismissed the rest of the interlocutory application and reserved the costs of the application to be dealt with at the hearing of the appeal.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Order 12 of the orders made by North J on 22 April 2015 (‘Orders’):

(a) be stayed until 5 p.m. on Friday, 12 June 2015; and

(b) is modified such that:

(i) the words “subject to appeal” will be inserted in the text of the “click-through” icon referred to in order 12(c) of the Orders after the words “Unconscionable Conduct by Advanced Medical Instituted (AMI) – ”;

(ii) A new paragraph will be inserted as the first paragraph of Annexure A to the Orders, as follows:

“The notice below is published by order of the Federal Court of Australia as the result of a judgment which is under appeal. NRM denies that it engaged in unconscionable conduct in 2011 and 2012 as the Court has found (and as set out below). It has appealed against the decision of the Federal Court of Australia and will pursue the appeal vigorously.”

(iii) In paragraph 2 of Annexure A, the words “The Court found that” be inserted as the opening words of the paragraph prior to the words “NRM promoted its business”.

(iv) Following the bullet points which follow paragraph 2 of Annexure A, a new paragraph will be inserted as follows:

“NRM is appealing some of these findings and the overall conclusion that it engaged in unconscionable conduct.”

(v) At the conclusion of paragraph 3 of Annexure A (that is, following the words “the refund policy is void”), a new paragraph will be inserted as follows:

“NRM is not appealing against the finding in relation to the refund policy which applied in 2011 and 2012 because it had already replaced that policy prior to the commencement of the trial. Despite its introduction of another policy, the Court ordered a variety of changes to NRM’s terms and conditions, including new terms relating to a cooling off period, refunds, and payments”.

2. Order 13 of the Orders be stayed (pending the hearing and determination of the present appeal) until further or other order of the Court.

3. The Appellants’ Interlocutory Application otherwise be dismissed.

4. The costs of the Appellants’ Interlocutory Application are reserved to be dealt with at the hearing of the present appeal.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

The orders made by North J which are relevant for this application are orders 9(a), 9(c), 9(e), 10(b), 12 and 13. They are set out below:9Each of the sixth and seventh respondents be permanently restrained, whether by themselves, their servants or agents or otherwise, in trade or commerce, from:(a)making an agreement with a patient for or in respect of the supply of medications or medical services for the treatment of male sexual dysfunction, unless the patient for whom the medications or medical services are intended has had a consultation with a duly qualified medical practitioner either in person or by video-link;…(c)making any statement or representation to any patient or prospective patient as to:(i)the efficacy of NRM treatments;(ii)the efficacy of any medications or medical services offered by parties other than the sixth and seventh respondents; or(iii)the patient’s need for the NRM treatments and any adverse consequences that might result if the patient:(A)does not acquire the NRM treatments, or (B)does not receive NRM treatments for male sexual dysfunction.except if that statement is made directly to a patient or potential patient by a duly qualified medical practitioner during a consultation either in person or by video-link;…(e)accepting in advance any payment or any other consideration from a patient in connection with the supply of NRM treatments for a future period of more than two months.10The third respondent be restrained, for a period of seven years from the date of this order (unless otherwise specified below), in trade or commerce, from:…(b)from having a role in connection with training, supervising, counselling or terminating employees, agents or contractors of the sixth and seventh respondents and their related bodies corporate.…12The sixth and seventh respondents cause to be published, at their own expense, within 21 days of the date of this order, a notice in the form contained in Annexure A to this order (website notice) on its website located at (AMI website) and, if the URL of such website is replaced, changed or redirected to another website, on the corresponding website, for a continuous period of 90 days and use its best endeavours to ensure that:(a)the website notice shall be viewable by clicking a “click-through” icon located on the AMI website;(b)the “click-through” icon referred to in (a) is located at the top of the homepage of the AMI website and any corresponding websites;(c)the “click-through” icon shall appear as follows, with the words printed prominently in bold red text, in a font size no smaller than 14-point, on a white background:Unconscionable Conduct by Advanced Medical Institute (AMI) –Notice Ordered by Federal Court of Australia.Click Here13The third, sixth, and seventh respondents pay the applicant’s costs of the proceeding, except for the applicant’s costs of and incidental to the proceeding against the fourth and fifth respondents. BACKGROUND The background to the proceeding and the appeal was outlined by the Applicants, which I adopt.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

On 22 April 2015, North J delivered judgment and made orders in in Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v ACN 117 372 915 Pty Limited (in liq) (formerly Advanced Medical Institute Pty Limited) [2015] FCA 368 (the ‘Decision’) The Applicants filed a notice of appeal in respect of that decision. On 18 May 2015, the applicants filed an interlocutory application for a stay of orders 9 to 13 of the orders made by North J on 22 April 2015. The orders made by North J which are relevant for this application are orders 9(a), 9(c), 9(e), 10(b), 12 and 13. They are set out below:9Each of the sixth and seventh respondents be permanently restrained, whether by themselves, their servants or agents or otherwise, in trade or commerce, from:(a)making an agreement with a patient for or in respect of the supply of medications or medical services for the treatment of male sexual dysfunction, unless the patient for whom the medications or medical services are intended has had a consultation with a duly qualified medical practitioner either in person or by video-link;…(c)making any statement or representation to any patient or prospective patient as to:(i)the efficacy of NRM treatments;(ii)the efficacy of any medications or medical services offered by parties other than the sixth and seventh respondents; or(iii)the patient’s need for the NRM treatments and any adverse consequences that might result if the patient:(A)does not acquire the NRM treatments, or (B)does not receive NRM treatments for male sexual dysfunction.except if that statement is made directly to a patient or potential patient by a duly qualified medical practitioner during a consultation either in person or by video-link;…(e)accepting in advance any payment or any other consideration from a patient in connection with the supply of NRM treatments for a future period of more than two months.10The third respondent be restrained, for a period of seven years from the date of this order (unless otherwise specified below), in trade or commerce, from:…(b)from having a role in connection with training, supervising, counselling or terminating employees, agents or contractors of the sixth and seventh respondents and their related bodies corporate.…12The sixth and seventh respondents cause to be published, at their own expense, within 21 days of the date of this order, a notice in the form contained in Annexure A to this order (website notice) on its website located at (AMI website) and, if the URL of such website is replaced, changed or redirected to another website, on the corresponding website, for a continuous period of 90 days and use its best endeavours to ensure that:(a)the website notice shall be viewable by clicking a “click-through” icon located on the AMI website;(b)the “click-through” icon referred to in (a) is located at the top of the homepage of the AMI website and any corresponding websites;(c)the “click-through” icon shall appear as follows, with the words printed prominently in bold red text, in a font size no smaller than 14-point, on a white background:Unconscionable Conduct by Advanced Medical Institute (AMI) –Notice Ordered by Federal Court of Australia.Click Here13The third, sixth, and seventh respondents pay the applicant’s costs of the proceeding, except for the applicant’s costs of and incidental to the proceeding against the fourth and fifth respondents. BACKGROUND

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Secondly, I note that various appeal grounds have been identified in the Applicants’ notice of appeal and whilst I make no comment about their validity, they are, at the very least, arguable and bona fide. In an application such as this, I need not elaborate. CONSIDERATION The primary relief sought was that a stay be granted in respect of orders 9 to 13 of North J. However, during the course of discussion with counsel, it emerged that a stay was sought in respect of those orders which were specifically identified as impacting upon NRM’s business. Those orders were 9(a), 9(c), 9(e), 10(b), 12 and 13, and are reproduced above. I now turn to consider each order sought to be stayed.Order 9(a) — Face-to-face medical consultations Order 9(a) deals with the requirement that the Applicants arrange personal or video-link consultations for patients with medical practitioners. I am not satisfied, on the material before me, that order 9(a) is necessarily going to have the impact that is feared by the Applicants in this application. There is existing technology or software which may be used for video-links, and I am not persuaded that prospective or current patients will necessarily have limited access to that technology or software, which will prevent such consultations in the way in which his Honour has ordered. The Applicants submitted that patients may experience embarrassment if required to attend face-to-face consultations, as ordered by North J. However such embarrassment is likely to be commonplace in many medical contexts, and typically sensible patients will endure any such embarrassment (or disregard any risk of embarrassment) if a face-to-face consultation with a medical practitioner is required or beneficial. This embarrassment is often accepted by patients, especially in the knowledge that some form of confidentiality will exist between the patient and medical practitioner. I assume that such confidentiality will also be maintained in relation to patients of NRM. In arriving at this view, I am mindful of the comments made by North J at [994–5] of the Decision:The exercise of discretion should also take into account the impact of the injunctions on NRM. Although negative in form, the injunctions are in substance mandatory injunctions. Caution should be exercised in making orders of that type.The injunctions impose significant changes for the operation of the NRM business. Despite this, NRM did not make any submissions of substance contesting the terms of the injunctions against it. The failure to make such submissions has particular significance because the Court directly raised with Mr Shrestha the potential impact on NRM of injunctions requiring face-to-face consultations. He explained that in 2001 AMI operated 38 clinics, but gradually reduced the number because the number of patients attending clinics declined [TS 2026]. Mr Shrestha said that NRM would not be able to trade if it had to provide face-to-face consultations. This bald assertion was not persuasive. NRM did not seek to make a case that such an order or an order for consultation via video-link would cause undue hardship on it. The evidence demonstrated that a significant proportion of patients in the NRM period attended clinics. Those clinics did not provide doctor consultations on-site but only by phone. NRM did not establish that providing doctors on-site or by video-link would place an unreasonable burden on it.(Emphasis added)