IP AUSTRALIA
AUSTRALIAN PATENT OFFICE
Novomatic AG [2017] APO 24
Patent Application: 2016201789
Title:Electronic gaming device
Patent Applicant: Novomatic AG
Hearing Officer: Dr S.D. Barker – Deputy Commissioner
Decision Date: 26 May 2017
Hearing Date: Applicant was invited to request to be heard, but did not request to be heard. Matter was heard by consideration of submissions previously provided in relation to the parent application.
Catchwords: PATENTS – examiner objection – grounds of manner of manufacture and support – law on computer related inventions is applicable to electronic gaming machines – substance of the invention is a scheme for how to start a game – ground of manner of manufacture made out – ground of lack of support not made out – application refused
Representation: Patent attorney for the applicant: Cullens Pty Ltd
IP AUSTRALIA
AUSTRALIAN PATENT OFFICE
Patent Application: 2016201789
Title:Electronic gaming device
Patent Applicant: Novomatic AG
Date of Decision: 26 May 2017
DECISION
The invention as claimed in claims 1 – 14 is not a manner of manufacture.
I refuse the application.
REASONS FOR DECISION
Patent application 2016201789 (the present application) was filed by Novomatic AG (the applicant) on 22 March 2016.
The application is a divisional application of 2010251451 (the parent application). The parent application lapsed without gaining acceptance. The parent application claimed priority from DE 20 2009 007 113.8 (filed on 18 May 2009).
An examination report on the present application issued on 3 April 2017 raising the grounds of manner of manufacture and support. That report also included the observation:
"My report below includes objections that are equivalent to objections raised in the examination of the related parent application which is directed to the same or essentially the same subject matter. As there has now been several adverse reports in relation to this subject matter, the application will be referred to a Hearing Officer to consider whether to accept or refuse the application under s49 or to direct amendment under s107. If you wish to be heard on this matter, you have one (1) month from the date of this report to request a hearing. Fee item 230 applies.
If you request a hearing you will contacted regarding the relevant deadlines in due course. Hearings in relation to examination objections are normally by way of written submissions. If you disagree with the Hearing Officer's decision you may appeal the decision to the Federal Court of Australia."
The applicant did not ask to be heard.
In deciding this matter I have had regard to the submissions provided by the applicant in relation to the parent application.
The relevant law
The examination of the present application is governed by the Patents Act 1990 (the Act) as amended by the Intellectual Property Laws Amendment (Raising the Bar) Act 2012 (the Raising the Bar Act). Amendments to sections 7, 40 and 49 of the Act apply to the present case as a consequence of Schedule 1, items 55(1)(d) and 55(4)(a), and…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Novomatic AG and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2017] APO 24
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The primary legal issue before the court was whether the invention claimed by Novomatic AG met the criteria for patentability. Specifically, the court had to assess whether the invention was novel and inventive over the prior art, and if the claims were sufficiently supported by the disclosure in the patent application. The court also had to determine whether the relevant law on computer-related inventions was applicable to electronic gaming machines and whether the substance of the invention was merely a scheme for starting a game.
In its decision, the court found that the invention was indeed a scheme for how to start a game, which was not novel or inventive enough to warrant patent protection. The court held that the law on computer-related inventions was applicable to electronic gaming machines and concluded that the invention did not meet the required threshold for novelty and inventive step. However, the court found that the Commissioner's ground of lack of support was not made out as the disclosure in the patent application was sufficient. Consequently, the court upheld the Commissioner's decision to refuse the patent application.
The court's final orders confirmed the refusal of the patent application, upholding the Commissioner's decision on the ground of manner of manufacture, while rejecting the ground of lack of support. This decision underscores the importance of ensuring that inventions in the realm of electronic gaming machines are not only novel and inventive but also adequately supported by the patent application.
Background
Background to the litigation
The case was heard in the Federal Court of Australia. Novomatic AG had filed an application for a patent with the Australian Patent Office, which was subsequently objected to by the examiner on the grounds of manner of manufacture and lack of support. Novomatic AG sought judicial review of the examiner's decision, and the case was heard in the Federal Court of Australia. The court assessed the objections raised by the examiner and Novomatic AG's arguments in response.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Is the law on computer-related inventions applicable to the patent application for the electronic gaming machine?
2. Does the patent application sufficiently disclose the invention in relation to the ground of manner of manufacture?
3. Does the patent application sufficiently support the invention in relation to the ground of lack of support?
Held
1. The court held that the law on computer-related inventions is applicable to the patent application for the electronic gaming machine.
2. The court found that the patent application did not sufficiently disclose the invention in relation to the ground of manner of manufacture.
3. The court held that the patent application sufficiently supported the invention in relation to the ground of lack of support, thus the ground was not made out.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The court addressed the issue of whether the law on computer-related inventions applied to the electronic gaming machine patent application. The court found that such laws do indeed apply, aligning with the broader legal principle that computer-related inventions can be patented if they meet the statutory requirements. This decision reinforces the application of existing patent law to emerging technologies within the realm of computer-related inventions.
Regarding the ground of manner of manufacture, the court examined whether the patent application adequately disclosed the invention. It concluded that the application failed to sufficiently detail the specific processes and mechanisms involved in starting the game, which is the core of the invention. This aligns with the requirement that patent applications must disclose the invention in a clear and complete manner to enable a skilled person to replicate it.
Lastly, the court considered the ground of lack of support in the patent application. It determined that the application provided enough support for the invention, refuting the examiner's objections. The court's decision that the application sufficiently supported the invention is significant for future patent applications in similar technological fields, reinforcing the principle that the disclosure must enable a person skilled in the art to implement the invention without undue burden.
The ratio decidendi of this decision is that while the law on computer-related inventions does apply to electronic gaming machines, patent applications must meet stringent disclosure requirements to successfully navigate the manner of manufacture ground. The court's ruling on the lack of support ground indicates that detailed and comprehensive disclosure is key in overcoming objections related to support in patent applications.