Northern Territory of Australia v CR

Link copied
Case Copied 73 min read

Northern Territory of Australia v CR [2007] NTSC 29

PARTIES:NORTHERN TERRITORY OF AUSTRALIA

v

CR

TITLE OF COURT:  SUPREME COURT OF THE NORTHERN TERRITORY

JURISDICTION:  SUPREME COURT OF THE TERRITORY EXERCISING APPELLATE JURISDICTION

FILE NO:LA 3 of 2006 to LA 11 of 2006

DELIVERED:  3 May 2007

HEARING DATES:  28 March and 2 April 2007

JUDGMENT OF:  MARTIN (BR) CJ

APPEAL FROM:  LOCAL COURT, 16 and 17 February 2006

CATCHWORDS:

CRIMINAL INJURIES COMPENSATION

Criminal Injuries Compensation – appeal – assessment of damages – relevant principles – multiple applications – series of offences causing injuries – method of assessing damages – individual and global awards – whether economic loss can be awarded as a global sum – award of maximum amount not automatic following certain offences – extent to which victim contributed to the injury – appeal dismissed – cross-appeal regarding contribution to injury allowed.

Crimes (Victims Assistance) Act 1983 (NT), s 5, s 8, s 9, s 10, s 11 and s 14; Local Court Act, s 19.

Semple v Williams (1990) 156 LSJS 40; LMP v Collins (1993) 112 FLR 289; Woodruffe v The Northern Territory of Australia (2000) 10 NTLR 52; Northern Territory of Australia v Dean (2006) 17 NTLR 178, applied.

Lanyon v Northern Territory of Australia and Staker [2002] NTSC 6;
Towers v Northern Territory of Australia (unreported Local Court No 9417216 delivered 8 September 1995); Allmich v Northern Territory of Australia and Long (unreported Local Court No 9705343 delivered 11 February 2000), distinguished.

Watts v Rake (1960) 108 CLR 158; Peach v Bird (2006) 17 NTLR 230; referred to.

REPRESENTATION:

Counsel:

Appellant:I Morris

Respondent:  D Alderman

Solicitors:

Appellant:Hunt and Hunt

Respondent:  Piper’s

Judgment category classification:         A

Judgment ID Number:  Mar0704

Number of pages:  58

IN THE SUPREME COURT
OF THE NORTHERN TERRITORY
OF AUSTRALIA
AT DARWIN

Northern Territory of Australia v CR [2007] NTSC 29

No. LA 3 of 2006 to LA 11 of 2006

BETWEEN:

NORTHERN TERRITORY OF AUSTRALIA

Appellant

AND:

CR

Respondent

CORAM:     MARTIN (BR) CJ

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

(Delivered 3 May 2007)

Introduction

  1. This is an appeal against amounts awarded in Assistance Certificates (“certificates”) issued by a Magistrate to the respondent pursuant to the Crimes (Victims Assistance) Act (“the Act”). The appeal is limited to a question of law: s 19 Local Court Act. The appellant asserted that the learned Magistrate erred in law in his method of assessing the amounts awarded in the certificates.

  2. The respondent cross appeals against orders by the Magistrate reducing two of the awards on the basis that the victim’s conduct contributed to the victim’s injury: s 10(2) of the Act. The respondent submitted that an error of law occurred because there was no evidence to support a finding of contribution. In addition the respondent contended that if the appellant’s appeal is successful, on a re-assessment this Court should increase the award for loss of earning capacity.

    Facts

  3. The respondent was born on 14 June 1983.  In August 2001 at…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Northern Territory of Australia v CR and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2007] NTSC 29
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Northern Territory of Australia appeals against a decision of a Magistrate awarding compensation to CR, the victim of a series of violent and sexual assaults by her former partner, Shane Hartree. CR cross-appeals against the Magistrate's reduction of two awards on the basis that she contributed to her own injury. The Territory's appeal focuses on the method of assessing damages under the Crimes (Victims Assistance) Act 1983 (NT) and whether economic loss can be awarded as a global sum. The court was required to determine the correct principles for assessing damages under the Act and whether the Magistrate erred in reducing two awards based on CR's conduct. The court held that the Magistrate's approach to assessing damages was correct, and that the reductions based on CR's conduct were not supported by the evidence. The appeal was dismissed, and the cross-appeal was allowed in part. The court set aside the Magistrate's orders reducing two awards and substituted new orders granting assistance certificates in the amounts of $14,500 and $22,500, respectively.

Orders

Orders of the court

(i) In respect of application 20406177 the order of the Magistrate allowing 25% reduction and awarding $11,250 is set aside. In substitution there will be an order granting a certificate in the amount of $14,500. (ii) In respect of consolidated claims 20406180 and 20406182, the order of the Magistrate allowing 25% deduction and awarding $16,875 is set aside. In substitution I order the assistance certificate be granted in the amount of $22,500.

Background

Background to the litigation

The respondent cross appeals against orders by the Magistrate reducing two of the awards on the basis that the victim’s conduct contributed to the victim’s injury: s 10(2) of the Act. The respondent submitted that an error of law occurred because there was no evidence to support a finding of contribution. In addition the respondent contended that if the appellant’s appeal is successful, on a re-assessment this Court should increase the award for loss of earning capacity.Facts The respondent was born on 14 June 1983. In August 2001 at the young age of 15 years, the respondent entered a relationship with Shane Hartree (“the offender”) who was then aged 18 years. Initially the offender was gentle and loving, but after a relatively short time he became physically and emotionally abusive. In December 2001 the respondent was sent to the Gold Coast by her parents where she stayed with a member of the family. The respondent and the offender spoke on the telephone every day and, after about two weeks, the offender persuaded the respondent to return to Darwin and live with him. Within about a week of the respondent’s return the offender displayed irrational jealousy and became abusive. For the next two years the relationship was marked by repeated physical violence perpetrated by the offender against the respondent. Unfortunately, the violence, domination, humiliation and degradation brought by the offender against the respondent is all too familiar to Judges who have sat in the criminal court. The respondent filed fourteen claims for certificates. After consolidation of claims and settlement of two claims, the Magistrate was presented with nine claims based on twelve offences of violence, including sexual violence, committed by the offender against the respondent between January and December 2002. Those offences did not represent all the acts of violence committed by the offender against the respondent, but the claims for certificates were based only upon each of the offences and the injury said to have been caused by those individual offences. The offender was charged with ten of the twelve offences. Each was an offence of unlawful assault accompanied by circumstances of aggravation. A convenient summary of the facts of each offence is found in the Crown facts presented to the learned sentencing Judge. These facts were in the material provided to the Magistrate as evidence supporting the claims (where necessary additional facts placed before the Magistrate have been added):“Count 1 – On or about 10 January 2002 (Application 20406177)On the evening of 9 January 2001 [the victim] and the offender had argued. At about 1:00am on the morning of 10 January 2001, [the victim] decided to physically leave the offender who was asleep at the house at the Leanyer Sewerage Ponds. She told the offender’s sister, Beverley Hartree, that she was leaving, packed her bag and walked to the gate of the property, which was 2 to 3 hundred metres away. Once there, [the victim] realised that she had left her mobile phone behind and went back to retrieve it. By this time the offender had woken up and was angry with [the victim] for trying to leave him. The offender rang his ex-girlfriend, Dianna Nilsson, on the phone, which was attached to the wall, and spoke to her in front of [the victim]. He demanded to know where [the victim] had been and accused her of having been away from the house for hours and of sleeping with other men. [The victim] denied being away for more than 10 minutes. She was upset that the offender was talking to his ex-girlfriend in front of her so she hung up the phone.At this time the offender hit [the victim] forcefully across the side of the face with the phone. He then grabbed [the victim] by her hair and bashed her head against the wall. The offender punched [the victim] between the eyes causing a 2cm laceration on the bridge of her nose. He then slapped [the victim], grabbed her hair and punched her in the nose and lip area. He also punched her in the stomach. The laceration was bleeding. [The victim] ran into Beverley’s room to get help. The offender continued to abuse and swear at [the victim] and asked her where her suitcase was. The victim told him it was at the gate. The offender told his sister to go with [the victim] to retrieve the suitcase. [The victim] was bleeding and in a lot of pain. On the way to retrieve the suitcase [the victim] passed out for a period. When she returned to the house, the offender took [the victim] into the bathroom and attempted to clean the blood from her face. He said he was sorry, that he loved her and that he wouldn’t do it again.That night the victim slept in the caravan next to the offender. He told her never to try and run away again. In the morning, after the offender’s father had left for work, the offender took the victim to hospital. She initially told the triage nurse that the laceration to her forehead had been caused after a fall from a bike. Dr Ngo then saw and treated her. With some encouragement, [the victim] told the doctor that the offender had assaulted her the night before. She complained of blurred vision and bruising and a loss of consciousness for about 2 minutes. Dr Ngo observed and treated a 2cm laceration, nose midline, septal haematoma. The laceration did not require stitching. She administered panadeine for pain relief and advised [the victim] to remain at the hospital for observation given her loss of consciousness, but the victim did not do so as the offender came and picked her up. [The victim] was sore and bruised for several days after the assault.[In an affidavit of 27 September 2004 the respondent said these events occurred on 4 January 2002. The date is not of significance.]Count 2 – On or about 14 January 2002 (Application 20406180)On 14 January 2002 [the victim] was listening to music in the offender’s family home. The offender came home from work. He was drunk and angry because he believed [the victim] had been out. He grabbed [the victim] by the arm and said ‘Who the fuck have you been touching’. The offender started hitting [the victim] in the face with open hands and fists. He grabbed her hair, picked her up by the neck, dragged her across the room and threw her against the wall. The offender said ‘Why do you make me so fucking angry’. [The victim] said ‘I didn’t do anything wrong’. He then said ‘I’m sorry, I can’t control myself’. During the course of the assault the offender re-opened the laceration between the victim’s eyes. It bled again.The following day [the victim] went to Casuarina Shopping Square. She ran into Dianna Nilsson who observed the open wound between [the victim’s] eyes and the bridge of her nose. Dianna asked what had happened and [the victim] told her that the offender had bashed her. [The victim] went back to Dianna’s house and stayed the night. Dianna’s brother, Allan Maloney, also enquired as to how [the victim] received the injury and [the victim] told him that the offender had hit her.The following morning Allan Maloney reported the matter to the police (recorded as 15/1/02 at 8:38am). Senior Constable Kate MacMichael of the Domestic Violence Unit attended and observed the injury to [the victim] but [the victim] declined to make a complaint.[The victim] was in pain, experienced headaches and suffered bruising as a result of the assault. She had to take painkillers for several days afterwards.As a result of the assaults (the subject of counts 1 and 2) [the victim] has a visible scar on the top of her nose which is about 2cm in length.”[Application 20406180 based upon count 2 was consolidated with Application 20406182. The latter application related to an additional offence committed on 14 January 2002. Immediately preceding the events described in count 2, as part of challenging the respondent about being out with another male, the offender grabbed the respondent by her arm and inserted his fingers into the respondent’s vagina, without her consent, saying that he was able to “tell” if she had recently had sexual intercourse or not. The respondent unsuccessfully endeavoured to prevent the offender from inserting his fingers.]“Count 4 – On 28 January 2002 (Application 20406183)At about 1am on the morning of 28 January 2002, [the victim] was outside McDonalds in Smith Street, Darwin with her friend Kym Sondergard. She gave first aid assistance to a person who had been assaulted (time and date established by record of phone call to police). Kym and [the victim] subsequently split up. [The victim] was extremely upset and was acting somewhat hysterically on the footpath in front of Rorke’s Drift.The offender was with friends, Greg Williams, Andrew Eillersen and Macey Smith in Greg William’s car. They were driving past Rorke’s Drift when the offender spotted [the victim] and told Greg to pull up in Knuckey Street, in front of Red Rooster. The offender got out of the car, walked to [the victim], grabbed her and dragged her back to the car. The offender told [the victim] to get into the car and tried to push her in. [The victim] grabbed the roof in an attempt to stop herself from being pushed. The offender slapped [the victim’s] face and she fell to the ground near the bin. The offender kicked her with his steel capped boots. The offender grabbed her and pushed her into the car. [The victim] told the offender she did not want to go with him, and the offender slapped her and told her to shut up. Under the direction of the offender, Greg Williams drove [the victim] and the offender to the offender’s home and dropped them off. [The victim] was crying and hysterical during the trip saying she did not want to go to the offender’s home but wanted to go to her parent’s home. The witnesses in the car corroborate this.Count 5 – Between 8 February 2002 and 11 February 2002 (Application 20406376)[The victim] was in the lounge room of the offender’s family home in Leanyer. The offender became angry with the victim and hit the side of the victim’s head hard with the heel of his hand causing pain to her inner ear. [The victim] was unable to stand without feeling dizzy for several days and presented to Dr Duthie on 11 February 2002 complaining of dizziness following a blow to the head.Count 6 – On 2 August 2002 (Application 20406379)Shortly after the offender was released from prison [the victim] was walking in the street with a girlfriend, Kym Sondergard. The offender drove past and they went with him in his car to Casuarina Beach and Buffalo Creek. [The victim] was telling the offender how much she loved him and the offender was calling [the victim] a slut. They stopped near the Ampol in Jingili and Kym got out of the car. The offender punched [the victim] in the face. Kym got back into the car and they drove to Harry Chan Avenue, outside the doors of the CSJ. Kym got out of the car. The offender and [the victim] were still arguing. [The victim] was attempting to give the offender a book of letters she had written for him while he was in gaol. [The victim] was crying and pleading with the offender, telling him how much she loved him. The offender did not want to have anything to do with [the victim].Outside the Court of Summary Jurisdiction the offender told [the victim] to get out of the car. [The victim] refused and the offender threw her shoe and belongings into the bushes. Kym went to retrieve these items. [The victim] punched and smashed the offender’s windscreen. The offender then punched [the victim] in the face and pushed her forcefully out of the car causing her to fall into the gutter. She received grazing to her side. [The victim] again attempted to give the book of letters to the offender but the offender threw them out of the car. [The victim] then put the book under the passenger seat of the car and the offender drove off.On 10 August 2002 [the victim] was admitted to Cowdy Ward at the Royal Darwin Hospital for self-harming and stress. She received psychiatric treatment and counselling as an in-patient for approximately 2 weeks.On 2 September 2002 [the victim] made a statement of complaint to police. On 18 September 2002 a Non-violence Domestic Violence Order was granted for a period of 6 months without the consent of either the offender or [the victim].By this time the victim was living in her own flat at Nightcliff which her parents had assisted her to set up. Shortly after moving in the victim and the offender resumed their relationship. Count 7 – On 24 October 2002 (Application 20406174)On 24 October 2002, the offender and [the victim] were arguing in her unit at Nightcliff. The offender punched [the victim] in the face. The offender gave [the victim] a baseball bat, which he kept by their bed, and told her to hit him with it by the time he counted to 5 or he would hit her. [The victim] was terrified and on the count of 5 made a half hearted swing at the offender. The offender took the bat off [the victim] and told her that she should have knocked him out while she had the chance. The offender then struck [the victim] over the back of her head with the bat. [The victim] fell to the bed and blacked out. When she came to she had difficulty seeing and cried out to the offender that she could not see. [The victim] felt blood in her hair, on her face and on her clothes. The offender said he was sorry and took [the victim] to his car. She was bleeding profusely.The offender told her that he did not want to go to gaol. Because the injury to the back of [the victim’s] head was obviously serious the offender and [the victim] concocted a story to avoid him getting into trouble with the police. [The victim] was still in love the offender at this time. The story was that unknown females had bashed her with a baseball bat on the beach. The offender and [the victim] began driving to the hospital but then returned to the unit. The offender collected the baseball bat and blood soaked linen from the flat. The offender drove [the victim] to the hospital and they disposed of the linen and bat in the hospital grounds.[The victim] attended at Accident and Emergency where Dr Stephanie Hyams treated her. Dr Hyams observed a large open wound to the back right upper head. The wound was cleaned and irrigated. The wound was very deep and bone was visible. The doctor explored the injury digitally to determine if the skull was fractured. No fractures were detected. Six stitches were inserted into the wound. [The victim] was advised to remain at the hospital for observation given the serious nature of the injury but she left with the offender. [The victim] did not say the offender had inflicted the injury, she relayed the concocted story to the hospital staff. The offender remained with the victim during the examination.On 30 November [the victim] reported the incident to Constable Christopher Smith and her father, … after the incident outlined in Count 12. On 30 November 2002 she showed them the area where the linen and bat had been secreted but the items were not able to be located in the dark. [The victim’s father] returned to the area shown to him (an area near the hospital incinerator) the following morning and located the items. He reported the matter to police and Acting Sergeant Garry Johnston attended and seized the items.On 29 October 2002 the victim attended at Dr Annie Wells’s surgery to have her stitches removed. She told Dr Wells that the offender had hit her with a baseball bat. Dr Wells was very concerned for the victim’s welfare and reported the injury to the victim’s counsellor Melinda Hazel. She made an appointment to see the victim on 1 November 2002 to remove the stitches, as they were not ready to come out. Melinda Hazel visited the victim at her flat and observed the injury to the back of the victim’s head and multiple bruising, and swelling to the victim’s face. The victim told her that the offender had caused the injury with the baseball bat. Melinda told the victim she was going to report the matter to the police, which she did.Count 8 – Between 28 October and 1 November 2002 (Application 20406165)One night during the intervening period of seeing Dr Wells, [the victim] had been at the beach drinking and passed out. She came home later than she had intended. The offender accused her of sleeping around. The offender punched [the victim] in the face and her nose started bleeding. The offender punched [the victim] in her right ear causing her extreme pain. The complainant vomited from the pain and the shock.[The victim] presented to Dr Wells on 1 November 2002 as a result of the blow to her ear. Dr Wells observed blood and swelling in the victim’s eardrum and detected a perforated eardrum. The victim lost her hearing in this ear for several days due to the perforations. She has some hearing loss in this ear as a result of the assault.”[Application 20406165 based upon count 8 was consolidated with Application 20406166. The latter application related to events that occurred following the assault charged in count 8. After that assault the offender said words to the effect, “You want to act like a slut, …, I’ll fucking treat you like one” and, with soap on his penis, forced the respondent to her knees and made her perform oral sex on him by inserting his penis in her mouth.In an affidavit dated 17 May 2005 the respondent stated that her nose was bleeding and she screamed at the offender to stop. She was in so much pain that she vomited over the offender’s penis and legs and was choking on the vomit. The offender continued to push the respondent’s face onto his penis.]“Count 15 – On 30 November 2002 (Application 20406169)On 30 November 2002 [the victim] was at a house drinking with friends including Megan Ellis, Kyahane Rata and a boy she had just met that evening, Nathan De Leeuw. [The victim] learned from phone calls that the offender was with his ex-girlfriend, Dianna Nilsson. [The victim] was intoxicated and became angry and upset by this because the offender had telephoned her to say he was out of town. She went with her friends, looking for the offender. At about 10.30pm they entered Planet Tenpin and [the victim] saw the offender, Dianna Nilsson, Kim Hartree and others in the pool table area.[The victim] confronted the offender and said she would tell the police everything. She was swearing and yelling at the offender. Kim Hartree grabbed [the victim] by the throat and started to strangle her. Dianna Nilsson hit [the victim] over the head with a pool cue. The offender then approached [the victim] and king hit her to the back of her head. [The victim] fell to the ground.Nathan De Leeuw was standing next to the pinball machine. He heard a commotion and saw the two girls fighting [the victim]. He then saw the offender walk up to [the victim] and punch her with a right hook into the back of her head and [the victim] hit the ground. The offender then walked over to Nathan and punched him hard a few times in the face and mouth knocking him to the ground. The offender lifted his foot to stomp on Nathan’s face but Nathan rolled to the side and stood up. Nathan then punched the offender in the face. Management and security intervened and required [the victim] to leave the premises. Nathan assisted them in removing [the victim].[The victim] left with Nathan. They saw cars drive past which contained the offender and his friends. They were afraid and [the victim] rang ‘000’ on her mobile. [The victim] then rang her dad who collected [the victim] and Nathan and took them back to [the victim’s] flat. Police attended and complaints were made. [The victim] had bruising and a headache from the punch to her head. Nathan suffered extensive bruising, swelling and pain to his left cheek and jaw area. He could not close his mouth for several weeks and was unable to chew and swallow food for several days. He had difficulty eating for some time.After this incident the victim and the offender continued to see each other. The police told [the victim] that on 3 December 2002 they intended on interviewing the offender about the incidents. [The victim] was still in love with the offender at this time. She told him that the police would be attending.Count 13 – On or about 2 December 2002 (Application 20406170)On the evening of 2 December 2002 the offender knew that police were intending to interview/arrest him the next day. [The victim] was with the offender’s sister drinking. The offender collected [the victim] in his car and took her to Buffalo Creek. The offender told [the victim] to get out of the car and to take her clothes off. She did this. The offender told [the victim] that he was going to kill her and that he had a shovel in the back of the car. [The victim] backed away. The offender then told [the victim] that he was joking and told her to get dressed.”[Application 20406170 based upon the events charged in count 13 was consolidated with Application 20406172. The latter application related to the events charged in count 14.]Count 14 – On or about 2 December 2002 (Application 20406172)Shortly afterwards, the offender forced [the victim] to return to his home in his car. He accused her of being filthy alleging she had sex with other men and forced her to wash herself in the shower. While [the victim] was showering the offender threatened to break the beer bottle he was drinking from and cut her with it.On 3 December 2003 the police attended at the offender’s residence and arrested him in relation to these matters. He was taken to the Peter McAuley Centre but refused to answer any questions when interviewed.The matter proceeded as an oral committal on 23 and 24 December 2002 and 6, 7 and 10 January 2003. The offender has been remanded in custody since 31 December 2002.”

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

In my opinion, the evidence was not capable of supporting a conclusion that, for the purposes of s 10, the conduct of the respondent in returning from Brisbane and resuming the relationship with the offender “contributed” to the injuries she sustained as a result of the offences committed on 10 and 14 January 2002. Evidence The most detailed description of the initial stages of the relationship is found in the statutory declaration of the respondent dated 2 September 2002:“I have been in a relationship with Shane HARTREE as boyfriend and girlfriend since about August/September 2001. I was 15 years old and Shane was 18 years old when we first met. I would stay with Shane for weeks at a time at his parents house at Leanyer Pond in Leanyer. His parents, Martin and Thaclea HARTREE, are the caretakers of the Leanyer Pond.Shane was real sweet to me at first and wouldn’t even swear in front of me. Shane even used to say to me, ‘If anyone ever touched you, I would kill them.’ Then he changed and started crying over his ex-girlfriend, Dianna NILSEN, who was 15 years old at the time. After a few weeks he became jealous of other people and would say to me, ‘What, you want to go there so you can fuck your flings, you stupid little slut.’ Other times he’d say to me, ‘I’d give you up for a carton of beer.’ He used to hold my arm and make me stay with him while he talked to Dianna over the phone about how much he loves her and wants her to have his baby.I’d ask him, ‘Why are you hurting me?’Shane would say, ‘I only do it, because I love you. No-one will love you like I love you. They’re just gonna use you and won’t be there in the morning when you wake up. You want to get smart, you wanna play fucking games. Let’s play games, [the victim], come on.’Shane would play mind games and tease me, so I’d end up crying and then he’d tease me even more. I felt confused and helpless.I gave up school for Shane, gave up my friends, my family and 10 years of dancing just so I could be with him. He wouldn’t let me be with anyone else without him being there. He used to scare me by saying he would kill my parents and stuff like that.At first I had sex with Shane, because I loved him and didn’t want to lose him. If I didn’t he’d threaten to leave me and say, ‘Fine then. I’ll go get it somewhere else.’ He would say to me that he wanted me to have his baby and how he’d look after me. That was when he was nice, but then he would just snap and swear at me and abuse me again. I felt trapped and he wouldn’t let me go anywhere without him. I was afraid to leave him in fear of him hurting me.All through our relationship Shane would come home from work and check for footprints outside the house to see if I had left the house, check the redial on the phone to see who rang in or out and he’d say to his Mum, ‘Did she leave the house today, go anywhere or ring anyone?’ He was paranoid about me leaving him and would not let me be or talk to anyone. He quite often grabbed my arm when he came home and forced either one or two of his fingers insider my vagina or touch the outside of my vagina and then smell his fingers. He checked me that way all the time.He said things to me like, ‘Come here you little cunt.’ ‘Come here! Come here [the victim]!’I said things like, ‘No.’ and ‘Fuck off. I’m sick of playing your stupid little games.’ ‘Do what I tell you when I tell you to.’ And then he’d check my vagina that way to see if I’d been with anyone. I never stopped him from doing this to me, because I was scared of him getting angry and hurting me. It was easier to let him do it than fight him.I told him, ‘I haven’t gone anywhere or been with anyone.’ He had convinced himself I had been having sex with someone. This sort of thing happened nearly every day that he had been out and I was left at home. On the 1st of December 2001, my parents sent me to the Gold Coast to live with my Auntie Debbie WAGSTAFF, to start a new life for a month and a bit. I spoke to Shane on the phone every day and he eventually talked me into coming back to Darwin to him. I used money sent to me for Christmas to fly back to Darwin a couple of weeks after arriving in the Gold Coast. That night I went and stayed with Shane in the caravan at his parents house at Leanyer Pond.”

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established