North Shore Property Developments Pty Ltd (in liq) v Haddad (No 2)

Link copied
Case Copied 41 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

North Shore Property Developments Pty Ltd (in liq) v Haddad (No 2) [2025] FCA 642

File number(s): NSD 1047 of 2023
Judgment of: KENNETT J
Date of judgment: 18 June 2025
Catchwords:

CONTRACTS – where the applicants allege a deed of settlement and release was entered into in reliance on fraudulent misrepresentations made by the first respondent – whether fraudulent representations were made by the first respondent – whether the first respondent knew of the representations’ falsity – whether the first respondent intended for the representations to be relied on – whether the first applicant acted in reliance on the representations – whether the applicants validly rescinded the deed

DAMAGES – indemnification in equity – tort of deceit – where the second applicant seeks damages or equitable compensation for losses suffered due to the reliance on alleged fraudulent misrepresentations – where it is not alleged that the second applicant relied on the fraudulent misrepresentations

Legislation: Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) ss 588FB, 588FDA, 588FF, 610AH
Cases cited:

Commercial Banking Co of Sydney Ltd v RH Brown & Co (1972) 126 CLR 337

Edgington v Fitzmaurice (1885) 29 Ch D 459

Erskine as liquidator of North Shore Property Developments Pty Ltd (in liq) v 72-74 Gordon Crescent Lane Cove Pty Ltd [2019] FCAFC 62

Krakowski v Eurolynx Properties Ltd (1995) 183 CLR 563

Magill v Magill [2006] HCA 51; 226 CLR 551

Nadinic v Drinkwater [2017] NSWCA 114; 94 NSWLR 518

Re North Shore Property Developments Pty Ltd (in liq) [2018] FCA 1094

Stuart v Rabobank Australia Ltd [2021] FCA 1388

Division: General Division
Registry: New South Wales
National Practice Area: Commercial and Corporations
Sub-area: Corporations and Corporate Insolvency
Number of paragraphs: 83
Date of hearing: 24-27 February 2025
Counsel for the Applicants: S Aspinall
Solicitor for the Applicants: Norton Rose Fulbright Australia
Counsel for the Respondents: D Pritchard SC with A Macauley
Solicitor for the Respondents: Piper Alderman

ORDERS

NSD 1047 of 2023
BETWEEN:

NORTH SHORE PROPERTY DEVELOPMENTS PTY LTD ACN 141 597 622 (IN LIQUIDATION)

First Applicant

ROBYN-LEE ERSKINE IN HER CAPACITY AS LIQUIDATOR OF NORTH SHORE PROPERTY DEVELOPMENTS PTY LTD ACN 141 597 622 (IN LIQUIDATION)

Second Applicant

AND:

EDDY SAMUEL HADDAD

First Respondent

72-74 GORDON CRESCENT LANE COVE PTY LTD ACN 168 361 662

Second Respondent

ORDER MADE BY:

KENNETT J

DATE OF ORDER:

18 JUNE 2025

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.The application be dismissed.

2.The respondents file and serve submissions (not exceeding five pages) and any relevant evidence on the question of costs by 4pm AEST on 2 July 2025.

3.The applicants file and serve any submissions in response (not exceeding five pages) and any relevant evidence by 4pm AEST on 16 July 2025.

4.Unless the Court otherwise directs, the question of costs will be determined on the papers.

Note:   Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.


REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

KENNETT J:

Background

  1. The first applicant (North Shore) is a…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read North Shore Property Developments Pty Ltd (in liq) v Haddad... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2025] FCA 642
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The liquidators of North Shore Property Developments Pty Ltd sought to set aside a settlement deed and release, as well as claim damages and equitable compensation, on the basis that the deed was entered into as a result of fraudulent misrepresentations. The first respondent, Mr Haddad, denied any wrongdoing and claimed that the liquidators' case was speculative and should be dismissed. The key legal issues for the court to decide included whether fraudulent representations were made by the first respondent, whether the first respondent knew of the representations’ falsity, whether the first respondent intended for the representations to be relied on, whether the applicants acted in reliance on the representations, and whether the applicants validly rescinded the deed. The court also needed to determine whether the second applicant was entitled to damages or equitable compensation for losses suffered due to the reliance on alleged fraudulent misrepresentations.

The court found that the liquidators had not provided sufficient evidence to establish that the first respondent made fraudulent representations regarding the value of the property or that the liquidators relied on such representations. The court highlighted that there was no evidence of reliance on the valuation representation, and the only evidence of the rationale for agreeing to enter into the settlement deed did not mention any valuation. The court concluded that it had not been established that the valuation representation provided a basis for the liquidators to rescind the settlement deed. The court also found that even if the condition representations were true, they did not constitute fraudulent misrepresentations because the defects were known and could have affected the price that a willing buyer would offer. Therefore, the court dismissed the liquidators' application and ordered that the respondents file and serve submissions on the question of costs by 4pm AEST on 2 July 2025.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The application be dismissed.

2. The respondents file and serve submissions (not exceeding five pages) and any relevant evidence on the question of costs by 4pm AEST on 2 July 2025.

3. The applicants file and serve any submissions in response (not exceeding five pages) and any relevant evidence by 4pm AEST on 16 July 2025.

4. Unless the Court otherwise directs, the question of costs will be determined on the papers.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

However, there is no evidence of reliance on the valuation representation.(a)No evidence was called from Mr Iannuzzi or anybody who was working for him at the relevant time.(b)The representation was made after the settlement conference and there is therefore no reference to it in the records of that conference.(c)Mr Iannuzzi, the relevant decision-maker, was not an addressee of the email from the respondents’ solicitors and there is no evidence of the email having been forwarded to him (or the contents of the dropbox folder being put before him in some other way).(d)The only evidence of the rationale for agreeing to enter into the settlement deed is a document entitled “File Note – Decision Sheet” (the decision file note) prepared by Mr Jimenez and dated 12 July 2017. That document made no reference to any valuation. It referred to the agreed price for the units and the option fee of $320,000. The author appears to have understood that the option fee was in substance a “deposit” for the sale price of $400,000 each rather than an additional amount. Under the heading “Recommended Action” in connection with the units, the document said:A.Unitsi.The sale of the properties to Eddy Haddad was not undervalue, as he purchased the property at the time “as shell”, no construction has occurred at the time, thus he could argue:Ø Valuable consideration was given.Ø He acted in good faith.Ø There was no reason to suspect the Company’s insolvency.ii.As there is a deed option in place and provision of the Deed of option were meet accordingly and all the sale proceeds have been accounted, there is an unlikely a claim against EH for the uncommercial transaction regarding the under value of the sale of the property.iii.The initial Information provided by the ATO regarding the sale of the properties does not conclude that a deed option was in place which allow EH to purchase the property for the lower value, which is not uncommon with the development of the plan.Thus, there is no claim for the above purported uncommercial transactions.(Emphasis in original.)(e)The Reston appraisal was part of a bundle of documents of around 339 pages that was sent to Mr Naidenov. It is reasonable to infer that one of Mr Iannuzzi’s staff would have noticed it and read it. However, there is no reason to conclude that Mr Iannuzzi himself would have read the document, let alone given it any thought, without having his attention drawn to it. For these reasons, it has not been established that the valuation representation provided a basis for the applicants to rescind the settlement deed.The condition representations Assuming the condition representations to be true, there were several faults in the construction of the development which required money to be spent by the purchaser of the units and thus reduced their value. The earliest communication in the evidence concerning construction defects appears to be an email received by Mr Haddad (presumably in his capacity as the project manager) on 3 April 2014, listing a significant number of (mostly minor) defects that had been noted in several units. This was before the contracts for sale were entered into and could rationally have affected the price that a willing buyer would offer (and that a willing seller would accept) for the units. The point is not simple, however, because the sale of the units involved the exercise of an option to purchase them, granted to Mr Haddad (at an agreed price) before construction had begun.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

On 20 February 2017, Mr Iannuzzi wrote to Mr Haddad as director of 72-74 Gordon asserting that the units had been sold to 72-74 Gordon at an undervalue, being an uncommercial transaction for the purposes of s 588FB of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) (the Corporations Act), and demanding repayment of an amount of $7,550,000. He made the same claim in a letter dated 18 April 2017. 72-74 Gordon denied that the units had been sold to it at an undervalue. The claims advanced in Mr Iannuzzi’s letters of 20 February and 18 April 2017 proceeded on an incorrect understanding that the car spaces attached to the units acquired by 72-74 Gordon were additional units. Once this misunderstanding was corrected, Mr Iannuzzi’s claim was effectively that the units that had been sold to 72-74 Gordon for $400,000 each were worth, respectively, $700,000 (unit 5.01), $750,000 (each of units 2.03 and 7.04) and $850,000 (unit 9.01); so that the total difference between true value and sale price was $1,450,000. It is also not necessary, for the purposes of these reasons, to discuss a claim advanced by Mr Iannuzzi (by a letter dated 21 February 2017) that Mr Haddad had benefited from an unreasonable director-related transaction caught by s 588FDA of the Corporations Act. On 20 June 2017 a settlement conference (the settlement conference) was held at the office of Mr Iannuzzi’s firm (Veritas Advisory). Mr Haddad attended with a lawyer. Mr Naidenov and another employee of Veritas Advisory, Mr Roer Jimenez, attended representing Mr Iannuzzi. During the discussions at this conference Mr Haddad asserted that the prices 72-74 Gordon had paid for the units were fair because they had significant construction defects which he had had to rectify. As will appear below, there was an in-principle agreement at the settlement conference to settle the claims against the respondents for $32,500; however, this was subject to documentary material supporting Mr Haddad’s assertion being provided. Two days later an email containing a link to a dropbox folder was sent by the lawyers for the respondents to Mr Naidenov. The folder (the dropbox folder) included a number of documents, one of which was the Reston appraisal. The Reston appraisal was on the letterhead of “Reston Real Estate”, dated 6 February 2012, and apparently signed by “Eric Muriniti, Manager”. Its text was as follows.Sales Appraisal for Units off the plan for 72-74 Gordon Cres Lane Cove NorthTo whom it may concern,RestOn Real estate appreciates your interest in sale prices for the above mentioned development: we are happy to provide you with a complimentary market appraisal for the current sale value of the property.Based on the current strength in the current marketing and taking comparable sales into consideration and advanced pre purchase off the plan, RestOn Real Estate believes that the values for the below apartments as follows:Lot 5 – 3 Bedroom - $485,000.00Lot 23 – 3 Bedroom - $475,000.00Lot 49 - 3 Bedroom apartment - $490,000.00Lot 53 - 1 bedroom apartment - $445,000.00These prices reflect the current market condition within the next 60 days based on the option agreement supplied by Eddy Haddad.The team at RestOn Real Estate Looks forward to hearing from you soon and continuing a long term relationship.