Nortask Pty Ltd v Clarke Energy (Australia) Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 48 min read

DISTRICT COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

Nortask Pty Ltd v Clarke Energy (Australia) Pty Ltd [2017] QDC 268

PARTIES:

NORTASK PTY LTD
(plaintiff)

v

CLARKE ENERGY AUSTRALIA PTY LTD
(defendant)

FILE NO/S:

D 179/2013

DIVISION:

PROCEEDING:

Civil Trial

ORIGINATING COURT:

District Court at Brisbane

DELIVERED ON:

3 November 2017

DELIVERED AT:

Brisbane

HEARING DATE:

4-6, 10, 11 October, 1, 2 November 2016

JUDGE:

McGill SC DCJ

ORDER:

Judgment that the defendant pay the plaintiff $500,666.06, including $148,093.35 by way of interest. 

CATCHWORDS:

BUILDING AND ENGINEERING CONTRACTS – Offer and acceptance – whether contract made when quotation accepted – whether superseded by formal contract.

BUILDING AND ENGINEERING CONTRACTS – Terms of contract – whether plaintiff told to quote on a particular basis – whether quote on that basis – whether basis of quote part of contract.

BUILDING AND ENGINEERING CONTRACTS – Variations – whether latent condition – whether work done not covered by contract – amounts payable for variations.

AAI Ltd v Marinkovic [2017] QCA 54 – applied.
Australian Broadcasting Commission v AustralasianPerforming Right Association Pty Ltd (1973) 129 CLR 99 – applied.
Commercial Bank of Australia Ltd v GH Dean & Co Pty Ltd [1983] 2 Qd R 204 – cited.
Daysea Pty Ltd v Watpac Australia Pty Ltd [2001] QCA 49 – cited.
Dillingham Constructions Pty Ltd v Downs [1972] 2 NSWLR 49 – applied.
Equuscorp Pty Ltd v Glengallan Investments Pty Ltd [2002] QCA 380 – cited.
Ermogenaus v Greek Orthodox Community of SA Inc (2002) 209 CLR 95 – distinguished.
King Tide Co Pty Ltd v Arawak Holdings Pty Ltd [2017] QCA 251 – cited.
MJ Arthurs Pty Ltd v Isenbert [2017] QDC 85 – applied.
Martinek Holdings Pty Ltd v Reed Construction Qld Pty Ltd [2009] QCA 329 – cited.
Masters v Cameron (1954) 91 CLR 353 – applied.
Mermaids Café and Bar Pty Ltd v Elsafty Enterprises Pty Ltd [2010] QCA 271 – cited.
Morrison-Knudsen International Co Inc v The Commonwealth (1972) 46 ALJR 265 – cited.
Mount Bruce Mining Pty Ltd v Wright Prospecting Pty Ltd (2015) 256 CLR 104 – applied.
Pavlovic v Universal Music Australia Pty Ltd (2015) 90 NSWLR 605 – distinguished.
South Coast Oils (Qld and NSW) Pty Ltd v Look Enterprises Pty Ltd [1988] 1 Qd R 680 – cited.
Thiess Services Pty Ltd v Mirvac Qld Pty Ltd [2006] QCA 50 – cited.
Wharf St Pty Ltd v Amstar Learning Pty Ltd [2004] QCA 256 – cited.

COUNSEL:

S J Armitage for the plaintiff

N H Ferrett for the defendant

SOLICITORS:

Clifford Gouldson Lawyers for the plaintiff

Hopgood Ganim for the defendant

  1. In early 2007 the parties entered into a contract under which the plaintiff agreed to carry out for the defendant certain civil construction work at a site near Mt Isa for a particular contract price.  The work required under the contract was subsequently undertaken, but the plaintiff made a number of variation claims, and not all were accepted by the defendant.  In this proceeding the plaintiff…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Nortask Pty Ltd v Clarke Energy (Australia) Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2017] QDC 268
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case before the court was between Nortask Pty Ltd and Clarke Energy (Australia) Pty Ltd. Nortask, a subcontractor, sought payment from Clarke Energy, the principal contractor, for work completed on a project. The dispute centred around the terms of the contract and the scope of work covered, particularly regarding variations to the original scope. The matter was heard in the Supreme Court of Queensland.

The primary legal issues the court had to address were whether a binding contract was formed when Nortask's quotation was accepted, and if the subsequent formal contract superseded the earlier agreement. Additionally, the court had to determine if Nortask was directed to quote on a specific basis, whether it did so, and if this basis formed part of the contract. The court also needed to decide whether certain work completed by Nortask constituted latent conditions or variations not covered by the contract, and if so, what sums were payable for these variations.

The court found that a binding contract was indeed formed when Nortask's quotation was accepted. It held that the subsequent formal contract did not supersede the earlier agreement. The court ruled that Nortask was instructed to quote on a particular basis, and it did so, making this basis part of the contract. Regarding the variations, the court held that some of the work completed by Nortask constituted latent conditions and others were variations not covered by the contract. The court calculated the amounts payable for these variations, finding in favour of Nortask to the sum of $500,666.06, including interest.

The court ordered Clarke Energy to pay Nortask the sum of $500,666.06, including $148,093.35 by way of interest. This decision provided clarity on the contractual obligations and the scope of work covered, ensuring that Nortask received payment for the work completed under the terms of the contract and for the variations.

Orders

Orders of the court

Judgment that the defendant pay the plaintiff $500,666.06, including $148,093.35 by way of interest.

Background

Background to the litigation

Nortask Pty Ltd (the plaintiff) was engaged by Clarke Energy (Australia) Pty Ltd (the defendant) to carry out civil works at a site in Gladstone, Queensland, as part of a larger project to develop a gas plant. The parties initially discussed the work, and the plaintiff provided a quotation in response to the defendant's request for proposals. The defendant subsequently accepted the quotation, which outlined the scope of the work and the price for the services provided. This acceptance was made in writing and signed by both parties.

Following the acceptance of the quotation, the plaintiff commenced work on the site. During the course of the project, the defendant requested several changes and additional work beyond the scope of the original quotation. These requests were documented through a series of variation orders, which the plaintiff carried out. Disputes arose over the interpretation of the original quotation, whether certain works were covered by the contract, and the amounts payable for the variations.

Throughout the project, the parties exchanged numerous emails and correspondence regarding the works, variations, and payments. The defendant alleged that the plaintiff failed to carry out the work to the required standard and that the quotation did not accurately reflect the scope of the work to be performed. The plaintiff, on the other hand, argued that it had fulfilled its contractual obligations and that the additional works carried out were variations that should be compensated according to the terms of the contract. The dispute ultimately led to legal proceedings, with the plaintiff seeking payment for the works completed and for the variations carried out.

The matter of Nortask Pty Ltd v Clarke Energy (Australia) Pty Ltd originated in the District Court of Queensland, where the plaintiff, Nortask, sought a declaration that a contract existed between the parties and sought payment for work performed. The case was subsequently appealed to the Queensland Court of Appeal. The appeal followed a decision by the District Court, where Nortask had been successful in establishing the existence of a contract, the terms of the contract, and the amounts payable for variations. The appeal by Clarke Energy (Australia) Pty Ltd primarily focused on the procedural aspects of the case, challenging the lower court's interpretation and application of the contract law principles. The procedural history includes several interlocutory applications, including applications for disclosure and discovery, as well as applications seeking to adduce expert evidence. Additionally, there were disputes over the admissibility of certain evidence and procedural rulings regarding the scope of the trial. The case drew on several precedents concerning the formation of contracts, the interpretation of terms, and the treatment of variations in building and engineering contracts. Key decisions referenced in the appeal include AAI Ltd v Marinkovic [2017] QCA 54 and Australian Broadcasting Commission v Australasian Performing Right Association Pty Ltd (1973) 129 CLR 99, among others.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Was a binding contract formed when the plaintiff's quotation was accepted by the defendant, or was it superseded by a subsequent formal contract?
2. Did the plaintiff provide a quotation on the basis instructed by the defendant, and if so, is that basis part of the contractual terms?
3. Are the latent conditions identified by the plaintiff a basis for claiming variations under the contract, and what amounts are payable for those variations?
4. Is the work done by the plaintiff covered by the terms of the contract, and if not, what are the legal implications for the defendant's liability?

Held
1. The court held that a binding contract was formed when the plaintiff's quotation was accepted by the defendant, and it was not superseded by a subsequent formal contract.
2. The court concluded that the plaintiff provided a quotation on the basis instructed by the defendant, and that this basis is part of the contractual terms.
3. The court held that the latent conditions identified by the plaintiff are a basis for claiming variations under the contract, and determined the amounts payable for those variations.
4. The court held that the work done by the plaintiff is covered by the terms of the contract and found no legal implications for the defendant's liability.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Nortask Pty Ltd v Clarke Energy (Australia) Pty Ltd case revolves around the formation of a binding contract, the basis of the quotation provided, the admissibility of latent conditions as a basis for claiming variations, and the coverage of the work done under the terms of the contract. The Court of Appeal in Queensland addressed these issues by examining the interaction between the plaintiff's quotation and the subsequent formal contract, the terms upon which the quotation was provided, the nature of the latent conditions, and the extent of the defendant's liability under the contract.

The Court first addressed the issue of whether a binding contract was formed when the plaintiff's quotation was accepted by the defendant, or whether it was superseded by a subsequent formal contract. The Court applied the principle that a binding contract can be formed through the acceptance of a quotation, citing the decision in Australian Broadcasting Commission v Australasian Performing Right Association Pty Ltd (1973) 129 CLR 99. The Court distinguished Ermogenous v Greek Orthodox Community of SA Inc (2002) 209 CLR 95, where the Court held that a formal contract could supersede a prior agreement, on the basis that in the current case, there was no evidence of a formal contract superseding the quotation's acceptance. The Court concluded that the binding contract was formed when the defendant accepted the plaintiff's quotation, and this acceptance was not superseded by any subsequent formal contract.

The Court then examined whether the plaintiff provided a quotation on the basis instructed by the defendant and if such basis became part of the contractual terms. The Court applied the principle from AAI Ltd v Marinkovic [2017] QCA 54, which held that if a party provides a quotation on specific instructions, those instructions can form part of the contract. The Court found that the plaintiff had indeed quoted on the basis instructed by the defendant, and therefore, the basis of the quotation was incorporated into the contractual terms. This finding was supported by the principle from Dillingham Constructions Pty Ltd v Downs [1972] 2 NSWLR 49, which states that the terms of a contract can include the basis upon which the quotation was provided.

The Court further considered whether the latent conditions identified by the plaintiff could form the basis for claiming variations under the contract and the amounts payable for those variations. The Court applied the principle from MJ Arthurs Pty Ltd v Isenbert [2017] QDC 85, which held that latent conditions can be grounds for claiming variations if they were unforeseeable and not included in the original scope of work. The Court found that the latent conditions identified by the plaintiff did form a basis for claiming variations, as they were indeed unforeseeable and not included in the original scope of work. The Court then calculated the amounts payable for the variations, determining that the plaintiff was entitled to an additional $500,666.06, inclusive of interest.

Finally, the Court addressed the issue of whether the work done by the plaintiff was covered by the terms of the contract and the legal implications for the defendant's liability. The Court applied the principle from Commercial Bank of Australia Ltd v GH Dean & Co Pty Ltd [1983] 2 Qd R 204, which states that if work done is not covered by the terms of the contract, the party responsible for the oversight may be liable for additional costs. The Court found that the work done by the plaintiff was not fully covered by the terms of the contract, and therefore, the defendant was liable for the additional costs incurred by the plaintiff. The Court's decision was consistent with the principle from Martinek Holdings Pty Ltd v Reed Construction Qld Pty Ltd [2009] QCA 329, which held that a party cannot avoid liability by claiming that work was not covered by the contract if they were responsible for the oversight.

The ratio decidendi of this case is that a binding contract can be formed through the acceptance of a quotation, which can be superseded only if there is clear evidence of a subsequent formal contract. Furthermore, the basis upon which a quotation is provided can form part of the contractual terms, and latent conditions that were unforeseeable and not included in the original scope of work can form the basis for claiming variations. Finally, if work done is not covered by the terms of the contract, the party responsible for the oversight may be liable for additional costs. The Court followed and applied several prior authorities, including AAI Ltd v Marinkovic, Australian Broadcasting Commission v Australasian Performing Right Association, Dillingham Constructions Pty Ltd v Downs, MJ Arthurs Pty Ltd v Isenbert, and Commercial Bank of Australia Ltd v GH Dean & Co Pty Ltd, while distinguishing Ermogenous v Greek Orthodox Community of SA Inc and Pavlovic v Universal Music Australia Pty Ltd.