LAND COURT OF QUEENSLAND
CITATION: Noble v Yarrabah Aboriginal Shire Council
[2024] QLC 19PARTIES: Glennis Noble
(applicant)v
Yarrabah Aboriginal Shire Council
(respondent)FILE NO: LCA163-24
PROCEEDING: Application for injunction under the Land Court Act 2000 and adverse possession DELIVERED ON: 30 September 2024 DELIVERED AT: Brisbane HEARD ON: On the papers HEARD AT: Brisbane MEMBER: JR McNamara ORDER: I declare that the proceeding LCA163-24 has not, for want of jurisdiction, been properly started. The proceeding is dismissed. CATCHWORDS: PROCEDURE – STATE AND TERRITORY COURTS: JURISDICTION, POWERS AND GENERALLY – JURISDICTION – GENERALLY – where the applicant claims adverse possession – where the Land Court does not have the power to hear or decide an application for adverse possession – jurisdiction of the Land Court – whether the proceeding has been properly started
ABORIGINAL AND TORRES STRAIT ISLANDER PEOPLES – HERITAGE PROTECTION – OTHER STATES AND TERRITORIES – where the applicant alleges harm to cultural heritage – where the harm alleged is not continuing – whether the Land Court has the jurisdiction to grant a stop order in the circumstances
APPEARANCES: Not applicable
Background
The applicant, Ms Noble, filed an Originating Application in the Land Court Registry on 12 June 2024. The grounds for the orders sought in the Originating Application state: “I’m seeking adverse possession of the parcel of land (Lot 616 SP 167913)”. The respondent Yarrabah Aboriginal Shire Council (YASC) is the trustee of the Yarrabah Deed of Grant in Trust (DOGIT) within which sits Lot 616.
The facts stated in support of the application are that Ms Noble’s family have been ‘caretakers of the land’ in question for ‘the past two decades’ with no objection from the respondent as the trustee council; and Ms Noble’s family have a ‘cultural and sacred connection’ to the land arising from ‘traditional birth practice’ in relation to Ms Noble’s first grandchild and a family pet (sites). Ms Noble claims that both sites have been desecrated by the YASC. Ms Noble says the YASC has breached their cultural heritage duty of care and in response, that there should be ‘fair compensation’.
On 28 June 2024, I made orders requiring Ms Noble to file and serve a statement of facts and issues (SFI), including all evidence relied on in support of the Originating Application. Ms Noble filed the SFI on 26 July 2024. The outcome Ms Noble seeks is “either the transfer of the property located at 14 Smith Street, Yarrabah, or the sum of $161,300 as appropriate compensation for the emotional trauma, pain and harm caused by the council’s actions.”
At a review of this matter on 9 August 2024, the YASC raised issues concerning the jurisdiction of this court to hear and determine the originating application. I made orders requiring the YASC to file and serve submissions in relation to their submission that the application should be dismissed, and for Ms Noble to file and serve a response, if any, to the YASC’s submissions. Both parties filed submissions.
A further…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Noble v Yarrabah Aboriginal Shire Council and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2024] QLC 19
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The legal issues that the court was required to decide were whether the Land Court had the jurisdiction to hear an application for adverse possession and whether the court had the jurisdiction to grant a stop order in circumstances where the alleged harm to cultural heritage was not continuing. The court had to examine the legislative framework governing the Land Court's jurisdiction and determine whether the proceeding had been properly started.
The court found that the Land Court did not have the power to hear or decide an application for adverse possession. It held that the proceeding LCA163-24 had not been properly started for want of jurisdiction. Furthermore, the court found that it did not have the jurisdiction to grant a stop order in circumstances where the harm alleged was not continuing. The court dismissed the proceeding for lack of jurisdiction.
As a result, the court declared that the proceeding had not been properly started and dismissed it. The Land Court was found to lack the necessary jurisdiction to hear the adverse possession claim and to grant the stop order, leading to the dismissal of the proceeding.
Orders
Orders of the court
I declare that the proceeding LCA163-24 has not, for want of jurisdiction, been properly started. The proceeding is dismissed.
Background
Background to the litigation
The case originated in the Queensland Land Court, where Mr Noble filed an application seeking a declaration of adverse possession and a stop order to prevent the respondent from causing harm to cultural heritage sites. The respondent, Yarrabah Aboriginal Shire Council, challenged the jurisdiction of the Land Court on both grounds. The matter was then heard by the Land Court, which concluded that it did not have the necessary jurisdiction to hear Mr Noble's claims. Consequently, the court dismissed the proceeding for want of jurisdiction.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Does the Queensland Land Court have the jurisdiction to hear an application for adverse possession?
2. Does the Queensland Land Court have the jurisdiction to grant a stop order in relation to alleged harm to cultural heritage sites when the harm is no longer continuing?
Held
1. The Queensland Land Court does not have the jurisdiction to hear an application for adverse possession. The court concluded that the proceeding was not properly started due to the lack of jurisdiction, and the proceeding LCA163-24 was dismissed.
2. The Queensland Land Court does not have the jurisdiction to grant a stop order in relation to alleged harm to cultural heritage sites when the harm is no longer continuing. The court found that the proceeding was outside the jurisdiction of the Land Court, and no such order could be made.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The Queensland Land Court examined the scope of its jurisdiction in two distinct matters. Firstly, regarding the adverse possession claim, the court held that it does not have the jurisdiction to hear or decide such applications. The court based its conclusion on statutory interpretation and existing case law, finding that the Queensland Land Court Act does not confer the necessary jurisdiction over adverse possession claims. The court emphasised that the statutory framework does not provide for the Land Court to entertain claims based on adverse possession, and thus, the proceeding was dismissed for lack of jurisdiction.
Secondly, concerning the alleged harm to cultural heritage sites, the court ruled that it lacks the authority to grant a stop order when the harm is no longer ongoing. The court applied the statutory provisions and relevant case law to determine that its jurisdiction is limited to cases where the harm is continuing or imminent. Since the alleged harm had ceased, the court found that it could not exercise its power to grant a stop order. This decision underscores the importance of ongoing or imminent harm as a jurisdictional requirement for issuing such orders. The ratio decidendi of this case is that the Queensland Land Court does not have jurisdiction to hear adverse possession claims or to grant a stop order for cultural heritage harm that is no longer continuing.