Nicol v PGLE Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 34 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Nicol v PGLE Pty Ltd [2006] FCA 1669

PRACTICE & PROCEDURE – interlocutory application seeking final relief – adjournment application – opposing party claimed medically unfit to provide instructions – adequacy of medical evidence – delay in pursuing opposing application – adjournment application refused

PROPERTY LAW – equitable mortgage – whether any evidence in support of asserted equitable interest

Real Property Act 1886 (SA)

COLIN MCINTOSH NICOL & SAMUEL CHARLES DAVIES AS JOINT & SEVERAL RECEIVERS & MANAGERS OF THE PROPERTY OF GUISEPPE ANTONIO MERCORELLA & THE SCHEME & AS JOINT & SEVERAL LIQUIDATORS OF THE SCHEME v PGLE PTY LTD, KYTARA PTY LTD, MERBEL PTY LTD, MERCORELLA (PIRIE STREET) PTY LTD, SANCAT PTY LTD, T & G MERCORELLA PTY LTD, MZF PTY LTD, OPEY PTY LTD, UNLEY FINANCIAL STRATEGIES PTY LTD, WOL PROPERTIES PTY LTD, PACIFIC PLACE HOLDINGS PTY LTD, TULLOCH LODGE LIMITED, TULLOCH LODGE SYNDICATIONS PTY LTD, ZMMF PTY LTD, ZAPAC PTY LTD, GUISEPPE ANTONIO MERCORELLA, RAINWAY PTY LTD, SALISBURY MAUSOLEUM PTY LTD AND SALISBURY MAUSOLEUM DEVELOPMENT PTY LTD

SAD 185 OF 2005

MANSFIELD J
4 DECEMBER 2006
ADELAIDE


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

SOUTH AUSTRALIA DISTRICT REGISTRY

SAD 185 OF 2005

BETWEEN:

COLIN MCINTOSH NICOL & SAMUEL CHARLES DAVIES AS JOINT & SEVERAL RECEIVERS & MANAGERS OF THE PROPERTY OF GUISEPPE ANTONIO MERCORELLA & THE SCHEME & AS JOINT & SEVERAL LIQUIDATORS OF THE SCHEME
Applicant

AND:

PGLE PTY LTD
First Respondent

KYTARA PTY LTD
Second Respondent

MERBEL PTY LTD
Third Respondent

MERCORELLA (PIRIE STREET) PTY LTD
Fourth Respondent

SANCAT PTY LTD
Fifth Respondent

T & G MERCORELLA PTY LTD
Sixth Respondent

MZF PTY LTD
Seventh Respondent

OPEY PTY LTD
Eighth Respondent

UNLEY FINANCIAL STRATEGIES PTY LTD
Ninth Respondent

WOL PROPERTIES PTY LTD
Tenth Respondent

PACIFIC PLACE HOLDINGS PTY LTD
Eleventh Respondent

TULLOCH LODGE LIMITED
Twelfth Respondent

TULLOCH LODGE SYNDICATIONS PTY LTD
Thirteenth Respondent

ZMMF PTY LTD
Fourteenth Respondent

ZAPAC PTY LTD
Fifteenth Respondent

GUISEPPE ANTONIO MERCORELLA
Sixteenth Respondent

RAINWAY PTY LTD
Seventeenth Respondent

SALISBURY MAUSOLEUM PTY LTD
Eighteenth Respondent

SALISBURY MAUSOLEUM DEVELOPMENT PTY LTD
Nineteenth Respondent

JUDGE:

MANSFIELD J

DATE OF ORDER:

4 DECEMBER 2006

WHERE MADE:

ADELAIDE

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.The full amount of monies paid into the Minter Ellison Trust Account, being the surplus fund available from the proceeds of sale of the land comprised in Certificates of Title Volume 5339 Folio 53, Volume 5339 Folio 56 and Volume 5339 Folio 57, being the land situated at 22-32 Jerningham Street, North Adelaide in the State of  South Australia be paid to Colin McIntosh Nicol and Samuel Charles Davies in their capacity as joint Receivers and Managers of the property of Guiseppe Antonio Mercorella and the unregistered managed investment scheme operated by Guiseppe Antonio Mercorella (the Scheme) and as joint Liquidators of the Scheme and the corporate entities which were party to the Scheme, as the relevant parties entitled to receive such monies. 

2.The costs of and incidental to this application be paid by Anthony John Sobey.

Note:    Settlement…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Nicol v PGLE Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2006] FCA 1669
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Nicol v PGLE Pty Ltd involved a dispute over the distribution of surplus funds from the sale of a property located at 22-32 Jerningham Street, North Adelaide. The primary issue was whether Anthony John Sobey, who had advanced money to Giuseppe Antonio Mercorella, had an equitable interest in the proceeds from the sale of the property. The claim was contested by Colin McIntosh Nicol and Samuel Charles Davies, who were acting as joint receivers and managers of Mercorella's property and joint liquidators of a managed investment scheme associated with Mercorella. The case was heard by a court in South Australia, which needed to determine the rightful recipient of the surplus funds from the sale.

The court's primary task was to ascertain whether Sobey had an equitable mortgage over the property, which would entitle him to a share of the sale proceeds. Sobey argued that he had advanced $750,000 to Mercorella in 2004 and secured this advance by an equitable mortgage. However, the court found that there was insufficient evidence to substantiate Sobey's claim. The cheques purportedly showing the transfer of funds were not confirmed as presented, and there was no signed mortgage document or loan agreement dated 19 July 2005 as Sobey claimed. The court noted that the documents provided by Sobey's solicitors did not align with Sobey's oral testimony and were disavowed by him.

The court concluded that Sobey's claim to an equitable interest in the property was unfounded due to the lack of credible evidence. Consequently, the court ruled that the surplus funds from the sale of the Jerningham Street property should be paid to Nicol and Davies as joint receivers and managers of Mercorella's property. The court ordered that the full amount of the surplus funds, held in the Minter Ellison Trust Account, be paid to Nicol and Davies. Additionally, the court directed that the costs of the application be borne by Sobey.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The full amount of monies paid into the Minter Ellison Trust Account, being the surplus fund available from the proceeds of sale of the land comprised in Certificates of Title Volume 5339 Folio 53, Volume 5339 Folio 56 and Volume 5339 Folio 57, being the land situated at 22-32 Jerningham Street, North Adelaide in the State of South Australia be paid to Colin McIntosh Nicol and Samuel Charles Davies in their capacity as joint Receivers and Managers of the property of Guiseppe Antonio Mercorella and the unregistered managed investment scheme operated by Guiseppe Antonio Mercorella (the Scheme) and as joint Liquidators of the Scheme and the corporate entities which were party to the Scheme, as the relevant parties entitled to receive such monies.

2. The costs of and incidental to this application be paid by Anthony John Sobey.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case involves a dispute over the proceeds of the sale of a property located at 22-32 Jerningham Street, North Adelaide. Colin McIntosh Nicol and Samuel Charles Davies, as joint receivers and managers of the property of Guiseppe Antonio Mercorella and the unregistered managed investment scheme operated by Mercorella, claim the surplus funds from the sale of the property. Anthony John Sobey claims an interest in the property as mortgagee, alleging he advanced $750,000 to Mercorella in March and April 2004 and secured the advance by a mortgage in July 2005. The first mortgagee sold the property, and the proceeds after discharging the mortgage and sale expenses are in dispute. The court must determine whether Sobey is entitled to any part of these funds.

The matter came before the court as an application to determine the distribution of the sale proceeds of the Jerningham Street property. The application was made by Nicol and Davies, who were appointed as receivers and managers of Mercorella's property and liquidators of the unregistered managed investment scheme. The court considered evidence from all parties, including statements from Sobey, and documents produced by his solicitors. The primary focus of the hearing was on the validity of Sobey's claim to an equitable mortgage over the property.

Decision

Reasons for decision

MANSFIELD J
Accordingly, the evidence does not disclose that Mr Sobey had any interest in the Jerningham Street property at any material time by way of mortgage, even if it be assumed in his favour that he advanced certain moneys to Mr Mercorella in March and April 2004 as he claimed. There is simply no document produced which can support his claim to having been granted an equitable mortgage over the Jerningham Street property in about July 2005. The documents produced by his solicitors with their letter of 13 December 2005 do not support such an interest, because Mr Sobey disavowed them and they do not accord with his oral description of the documents upon which he asserts such an interest. The identification and presentation of the documents upon which Mr Sobey said he relied would have been a straightforward task, and could have been pursued through the professional persons then acting for him. That did not happen.CONCLUSION For those reasons, in my judgment, Mr Nicol and Mr Davies are entitled to an order that the full amount of monies paid into the Minter Ellison Trust Account, being the surplus funds available from the proceeds of sale of the land comprised in Certificates of Title Volume 5339 Folio 53, Volume 5339 Folio 56, and Volume 5339 Folio 57, being the land situated at 22-32 Jerningham Street, North Adelaide in the State of South Australia be paid to Colin McIntosh Nicol and Samuel Charles Davies in their capacity as joint receivers and managers of the property of Mercorella and the Scheme, and as joint liquidators of the Scheme and the Scheme companies, as the relevant parties entitled to receive such monies.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: MANSFIELD J

It is necessary finally to turn to the determination of the application.CONSIDERATION On the evidence, I have come to the view that the surplus funds from the sale of the Jerningham Street property should be paid to Messrs Nicol and Davies in their capacity as joint receivers and managers of the property of Mr Mercorella (and, to the extent to which it is necessary to distinguish between Mr Mercorella and the Scheme, as joint liquidators of the Scheme and of the Scheme companies). In my view, Mr Sobey has no entitlement to those funds. I am satisfied on the evidence that Mr Sobey is not entitled to participate in any of those funds. The claim of Mr Nicol and Mr Davies is quite straightforward, given their status as receivers and managers of the property of Mr Mercorella. The Jerningham Street property was registered in his name. It was sold by the first mortgagee. The proceeds of that sale, after payment to discharge the first mortgagee and the expenses of sale, are available as the equity in that property available to Mr Mercorella, and so to the receivers and managers of his property. The only other potential contender for an interest in those funds is Mr Sobey. His interest depends upon him having:(1)advanced moneys to Mr Sobey of $750,000; and(2)having secured that advance by a valid and effective mortgage.In my view there is no satisfactory evidence that Mr Sobey advanced such funds to Mr Mercorella. The evidence discloses that there are two copy cheques revealing the apparent payment to Mr Mercorella by Mr Sobey of the amounts of $350,000 on 16 March 2004 and $400,000 on 20 April 2004. It is unclear that those cheques were ever presented, despite persistent requests for confirmation of those cheques having been presented. It should have been possible for Mr Sobey to adduce that evidence. I have considered above the ways in which he might have done so. It is a documentary trail, and such difficulty as Mr Sobey may have had in providing detailed instructions in more recent times would not impede the proper investigation of an obvious documentary trail and its confirmation, if confirmation were available. There is no evidence of any mortgage securing the payment of any such advances. Mr Sobey’s solicitors, by letter of 13 December 2005, asserted an interest in the Jerningham Street property by way of an equitable mortgage. Copies of a mortgage document and loan agreements were enclosed. I have referred to them above. There is no loan agreement dated 19 July 2005, but only an undated loan agreement not signed by Mr Sobey. There are no loan agreements as referred to in that letter. The caveat lodged by Mr Sobey claims the interest as mortgagee pursuant to a loan agreement dated 19 July 2005 and refers to the interest as granted by way of mortgage pursuant to cl 5 of the loan agreement. It does not separately deal with any mortgage. The solicitors on 13 December 2005 did produce a mortgage dated 19 July 2005, but it was not signed by Mr Sobey. Neither of the loan agreement nor the mortgage then produced accord with the evidence given by Mr Sobey at his examination on 22 December 2005.