Nicholson v Carborough Downs Coal Management Pty Ltd (No 3)

Link copied
Case Copied 9 min read

INDUSTRIAL COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

Nicholson v Carborough Downs Coal Management Pty Ltd & Ors (No 3) [2023] ICQ 004

PARTIES:

SIMON NICHOLSON (WORK HEALTH AND SAFETY PROSECUTOR)

(appellant)

v
CARBOROUGH DOWNS COAL MANAGEMENT
PTY LTD
(respondent)

SIMON NICHOLSON (WORK HEALTH AND SAFETY PROSECUTOR)

(applicant)

v
CARBOROUGH DOWNS COAL MANAGEMENT
PTY LTD
(respondent)

SIMON NICHOLSON (WORK HEALTH AND SAFETY PROSECUTOR)

(applicant)

v
RUSSELL CLIVE UHR
(respondent)

SIMON NICHOLSON (WORK HEALTH AND SAFETY PROSECUTOR)

(appellant)

v
JEREMY DAVID FUTERAN
(respondent)

SIMON NICHOLSON (WORK HEALTH AND SAFETY PROSECUTOR)

(appellant)

v
BERNARD VANDEVENTER
(respondent)

SIMON NICHOLSON (WORK HEALTH AND SAFETY PROSECUTOR)

(appellant)

v
KEVIN JAMES CASEY
(respondent)

SIMON NICHOLSON (WORK HEALTH AND SAFETY PROSECUTOR)

(appellant)

v
GARY ROY JONES

(respondent)

FILE NO/S:

C/2022/16, C/2022/17, C/2022/18, C/2022/20, C/2022/21, C/2022/22, C/2022/23

PROCEEDING:

Applications

DELIVERED ON:

Orders made on 17 February 2023; reasons delivered on
23 March 2023

HEARING DATE:

17 February 2023

MEMBER:

Davis J, President

ORDERS:

1.    That the appeals and applications will be set down on a date to be fixed.

2.   Costs reserved.

CATCHWORDS:

CIVIL PROCEEDINGS IN STATE AND TERRITORY COURTS – CASE MANAGEMENT – ELIMINATION OF DELAY – where eight complaints were sworn alleging offences against the Coal Mining Safety and Health Act 1999 – where three complaints were accompanied by summonses requiring the defendants to appear at the Magistrates Court – where the summonses should have required the attendance of those defendants at the Industrial Magistrates Court – where a magistrate struck out all eight complaints – where the prosecutor appealed – where some appeals were abandoned – where applications for prerogative relief were filed out of time – where extensions of time were granted – where appeals were lodged to the Court of Appeal against the orders extending time – where no orders staying operation of the extensions of time had been sought or made – whether the appeals and applications ought not be heard pending the appeals to the Court of Appeal

Coal Mining Safety and Health Act 1999, s 255

Judicial Review Act 1991, s 46

Work Health and Safety Act 2011

CASES:

Du Preez v Chelden [2020] ICQ 008, cited
Gore v Carborough Downs Coal Management Pty Ltd & Ors [2022] ICQ 031, related
Nicholson v Carborough Downs Coal Management Pty Ltd & Ors [2022] ICQ 34, related

Yates v Wilson (1989) 168 CLR 338, followed

COUNSEL:

B J Power KC for the appellant in all appeals and the applicant in all applications
J A Bremhorst for the respondents in appeal number C/2022/16, and application numbers C/2022/17 and C/2022/18
P J Roney KC for the respondent in appeal number C/2022/20
S Dekker for the respondent in appeal number C/2022/21
K McAuliffe-Lake for the respondent in appeal number C/2022/22

No appearance for the respondent in appeal number C/2022/23

SOLICITORS:

Workplace Health and Safety Prosecutor for the appellant in all appeals and applications
McCullough Robertson for the respondents in appeal number C/2022/16 and application numbers C/2022/17 and C/2022/18
Australian Business Lawyers & Advisors for…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Nicholson v Carborough Downs Coal Management Pty Ltd (No 3) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] ICQ 4
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Nicholson v Carborough Downs Coal Management Pty Ltd (No 3) involves an appeal against orders that struck out complaints that were filed by the Work Health and Safety Prosecutor alleging offences under the Coal Mining Safety and Health Act 1999 (CMSH Act) following two incidents at the Carborough Downs Coal Mine. The prosecutor had filed complaints against various respondents in relation to the incidents, but the complaints contained formal defects and some were issued to be heard in the wrong court. The respondents applied to strike out the complaints and succeeded in doing so. The prosecutor then appealed the decisions to strike out the complaints, and some of the respondents made applications for prerogative relief. The appeals and applications are now before the court.

The central legal issues in this case are whether the appeals and applications should be heard now or whether they should be stayed pending the outcome of related appeals to the Court of Appeal. The court must also consider the potential for further fragmentation of the proceedings and the desirability of avoiding undue delay in the criminal process. The court noted that it is well established that criminal proceedings should not be unduly delayed and that it is undesirable to fragment the criminal process. The court observed that if the appeals and applications are not heard now, it could be well into 2024 before the complaints are returned to the Industrial Magistrates Court. The court found that it was in the interests of justice to determine the appeals and applications now, even though it might lead to further expense for the parties.

The court decided to set the appeals and applications for hearing, notwithstanding that related appeals are pending before the Court of Appeal. The court found that it was preferable to avoid further fragmentation of the proceedings and to control delay. The court noted that if the appeals and applications are successful, there may be further appeals to the Court of Appeal, but that consideration is outweighed by the desirability of avoiding further fragmentation and delay. The court also noted that the respondents to the appeals in relation to the Best incident were ready to proceed with the appeals. The court made orders setting down the appeals and applications for hearing and reserved costs.

This case highlights the importance of ensuring that criminal proceedings are not unduly delayed and that the criminal process is not fragmented. The court found that it was in the interests of justice to determine the appeals and applications now, even though related appeals were pending before the Court of Appeal. The court also noted that it is undesirable to fragment the criminal process and that the respondents to the appeals in relation to the Best incident were ready to proceed with the appeals. The court's decision to set down the appeals and applications for hearing will hopefully lead to a more efficient and timely resolution of the issues in this case.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. That the appeals and applications will be set down on a date to be fixed.

2. Costs reserved.

Background

Background to the litigation

The appeals and applications have since been set down for hearing on 5 and 6 April 2023.Background On 7 September 2019, at the Carborough Downs Coal Mine (the mine), there was an accident which injured a mine worker, Cameron Best (the Best incident). On 25 November 2019, at the mine, there was another accident. This accident killed a mine electrician, Bradley James Duxbury (the Duxbury incident). In November 2020, complaints were sworn by Aaron Guilfoyle, the Work Health and Safety Prosecutor appointed under the Work Health and Safety Act 2011 (the prosecutor). Summonses were issued against three of the current respondents alleging offences against the Coal Mining Safety and Health Act 1999 (CMSH Act) arising from the Duxbury incident (the Duxbury charges, and the defendants to those charges being the Duxbury defendants). The summons issued in each of the Duxbury charges required the Duxbury defendants to appear before a nominated Magistrates Court. That was an error. Each summons should have required the attendance of the defendants at the Industrial Magistrates Court (the wrong court point). In January 2021, complaints were sworn by Mr Guilfoyle and summonses issued against five of the current respondents alleging offences against the CMSH Act arising from the Best incident (the Best charges and the defendants to those charges are the Best defendants). In each of the Duxbury charges and in each of the Best charges:1.the complaint did not state on its face the Magistrates Court district in which the offence occurred; and2.the complaint did not make express reference to s 255 of the CMSH Act which vests jurisdiction in the Industrial Magistrates Court; and3.the complaint did not make express reference to the Industrial Magistrates Court (all three being the formal defects points). Applications were subsequently made by the defendants in all eight cases to strike out the complaints. The Best defendants succeeded on the formal defects points. The Duxbury defendants succeeded on both the formal defects points and the wrong court point. The orders in the Best charges were made in the Industrial Magistrates Court. The orders in the Duxbury charges were made in the Magistrates Court. Assuming that the prosecutor is a “person aggrieved” by the orders striking out the Best charges,[1] the prosecutor has a right of appeal to this Court. The five appeals in relation to the Best charges were lodged on 22 August 2022.[1]Du Preez v Chelden [2020] ICQ 008. As to the Duxbury charges, the prosecutor filed appeals against all three Duxbury defendants to this Court and also filed appeals to the District Court. The rationale was, apparently, that there was confusion as to whether an appeal would lie to the District Court because the orders had been made by the Magistrates Court, or to this Court, on the basis that any orders should have been made in the Industrial Magistrates Court. Whether it was appropriate for the prosecutor to have different appeals being prosecuted in different courts at the one time is a matter of considerable doubt.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The respondents to the appeals in relation to the Best incident were not affected by the Court of Appeal appeals and they were ready to proceed with the appeals to this Court.Consideration It is well established that criminal proceedings should not be unduly delayed. It is also well established that it is undesirable to fragment the criminal process. In Yates v Wilson,[6] Mason CJ, delivering the judgment of the Court,[7] observed:“The undesirability of fragmenting the criminal process is so powerful a consideration that it requires no elaboration by us.”[8][6](1989) 168 CLR 338.[7]Mason CJ, Toohey and Gordron JJ.[8]At page 339. Appeals from decisions on the appeals to this Court and the applications to this Court lie to the Court of Appeal. If the appeals and the applications presently before this Court do not proceed until after the determination of the Court of Appeal appeals then it is foreseeable (depending on whether the Court of Appeal reserves its decisions and for how long) that it could be well into the second half of this year before those appeals and applications are determined. If the appellants to the Court of Appeal appeals are unsuccessful then it will take some time to have the appeals and applications presently before this Court listed, heard and determined. If the appeals and applications presently before this Court are successful then there is, no doubt, some prospect of appeals to the Court of Appeal from those orders. It might be well into 2024 before the complaints are returned to the Industrial Magistrates Court if the complaints do proceed. The Industrial Magistrates Court would then hear the complaints in relation to events which would by then have occurred over four years previously. The more desirable course is to determine the appeals and applications in this Court and any appeals from those decisions could hopefully be considered by the Court of Appeal quickly. That course might lead to further expense being incurred by the parties. That consideration is outweighed by the desirability of controlling delay and avoiding the further fragmentation of what has been a calamitous process. For those reasons I set the appeals and applications for hearing.