Nicholls v Kline Industries International Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 17 min read

QUEENSLAND CIVIL AND
ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL


CITATION:

Nicholls & Anor v Kline Industries International Pty Ltd [2018] QCATA 123

PARTIES:

LYN NICHOLLS
(first applicant/appellant)
SERENA NICHOLLS
(second applicant/appellant)

v

KLINE INDUSTRIES INTERNATIONAL PTY LTD T/AS KLINE HOMES

(respondent)

APPLICATION NO/S:

APL356-17

ORIGINATING APPLICATION NO/S:

BDL056-16

MATTER TYPE:

Appeals

DELIVERED ON:

23 August 2018

HEARING DATE:

On the papers

HEARD AT:

Brisbane

DECISION OF:

Senior Member Howard

ORDERS:

1.   Leave to appeal is granted.

2.   The appeal is allowed.

3.   The Tribunal’s order 7 dated 5 October 2017 as amended on 17 November 2017 is set aside.

4.   The Tribunal must make directions for the filing of the affidavit of Mathew Marshall in proceeding BDL056-16.

CATCHWORDS:

APPEAL AND NEW TRIAL – APPEAL – GENERAL PRINCIPLES – RIGHT OF APPEAL – WHEN APPEAL LIES – FROM INTERLOCUTORY DECISIONS – where leave sought to file evidence at hearing – where leave was refused – whether evidence is ‘fresh evidence’ – whether denial of procedural fairness

Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2009 (Qld) (QCAT Act), s 28(2), s 28(3)(e), s 28(3)(a), s 142

REPRESENTATION:

Applicant:

Self-represented

Respondent:

R Duncan, Duncan Solicitors

APPEARANCES:

This matter was heard and determined on the papers pursuant to s 32 of the Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2009 (Qld).

REASONS FOR DECISION

  1. The Tribunal has yet to hear and determine a domestic building dispute in BDL056-16 Kline Industries International Pty Ltd t/as Kline Homes v Lyn Nicholls and Serena Nicholls (the building dispute). Although it has been listed for hearing on several occasions, for reasons that are largely irrelevant to this appeal, the hearing has been adjourned on each occasion.

  2. It is relevant that the building dispute was listed for a Tribunal hearing for two days commencing 5 October 2017. On 5 October 2017, the Tribunal granted leave to Kline Industries International Pty Ltd t/as Kline Homes (the builder) to amend its application and made directions, including for an Experts Conclave and the disclosure of documents as between the parties. The matter was listed for a five day hearing a later time.

  3. As a preliminary matter on 5 October 2017 and before the adjournment of the hearing, Lyn and Serena Nicholls (the homeowners) applied for leave to file an affidavit of a Mr Mathew Marshall sworn on 29 September 2017. The affidavit had not been filed in accordance with the Tribunal’s earlier directions for filing of the homeowners’ evidence to be relied upon at hearing. The learned Member made an order on 5 October 2017 refusing the homeowners application to rely upon the ‘fresh evidence’ contained in Mr Marshall’s affidavit.[1]

    [1]Orders and directions dated 5 October 2017 and later amended on 17 November 2017.

  4. Mr Marshall is a licensed builder of some 20 years of experience. He had not met the homeowners until 17 September 2017 when they knocked on his door, (two doors from their home) and introduced themselves. He deposes to when and how he met them and explains that the builder also…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Nicholls v Kline Industries International Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2018] QCATA 123
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Nicholls v Kline Industries International Pty Ltd, the homeowners appealed the Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal's (QCAT) refusal to admit fresh evidence during a domestic building dispute hearing. The central issue was whether the Tribunal's decision to exclude the affidavit of Matthew Marshall constituted a denial of procedural fairness. The homeowners argued that the Tribunal had failed to provide an adequate opportunity to respond to the evidence before ruling on its admissibility.

The legal issues revolved around the application of procedural fairness principles to the Tribunal's handling of the affidavit. The homeowners contended that the Tribunal's refusal to admit the affidavit without allowing them to respond to its content was unjust and violated the principles of natural justice. The central question was whether the Tribunal's actions amounted to a procedural error that warranted setting aside the decision and allowing the fresh evidence to be considered.

The court found that the Tribunal's handling of the affidavit did indeed breach procedural fairness. The Member had indicated that a decision on the admissibility of the affidavit would be made after the builder's evidence was presented. However, the Tribunal later ruled on the affidavit's admissibility without giving the homeowners an opportunity to respond, which was contrary to the earlier indication. This denial of an opportunity to be heard before a decision was made constituted a significant procedural unfairness. Consequently, the appeal was allowed, and the Tribunal's decision to exclude the affidavit was set aside. The Tribunal was directed to make new orders regarding the filing of the affidavit.

The final orders of the court included granting leave to appeal, allowing the appeal, setting aside the Tribunal's order regarding the affidavit, and directing the Tribunal to make new directions for the filing of the affidavit.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Leave to appeal is granted.

2. The appeal is allowed.

3. The Tribunal’s order 7 dated 5 October 2017 as amended on 17 November 2017 is set aside.

4. The Tribunal must make directions for the filing of the affidavit of Mathew Marshall in proceeding BDL056-16.

Background

Background to the litigation

The homeowners essentially argue that although the learned Member had (earlier on 5 October 2017) informed the parties he would determine whether Mr Marshall’s evidence should be admitted following the conclusion of the builder’s evidence, he later made orders refusing its acceptance without affording the homeowners procedural fairness.Relevant background In March 2016, the builder filed an application for a domestic building dispute, asking the Tribunal to make various declarations and orders in its favour relating to the recovery of various amounts totalling $81,761.16 it alleges are owed by the homeowners. The amount includes $29,215.00 for additional scaffolding costs.[3] In essence, the builder contends that the work performed to date satisfies the definition of ‘practical completion’, and accordingly is entitled to the final stage payment under the contract. As discussed earlier, on 5 October 2017, that is, the date the hearing was to commence, the Tribunal granted leave to the builder to amend his original application to include a claim pursuant to s 84 of the Domestic Building Contracts Act 2000 (Qld) to recover an amount for variations including the scaffolding costs claimed. [3]Application for a domestic building dispute in BDL056-16 filed 9 March 2018. The homeowners’ filed a response and counter-application in April 2016, and subsequently, an amended response and counter-application in October 2017 as directed by the Tribunal.[4] The homeowners claim in their counter-application totals some $179,640.00, including $81,000.00 for the completion of building work and other amounts. The homeowners’ refute the builder’s contention that the property has reached ‘practical completion,’ claiming for defective and incomplete works.[5] They also refute the builder’s claim for the additional scaffolding costs. It is contended that by failing to advise the homeowners within a reasonable time of the requirement for additional scaffolding at a further cost, no such claim may be made by the builder and that the contract does not allow for any excess scaffolding fees to be claimed from them.[4]Direction 5 of the Tribunal directions in BDL056-16 dated 5 October 2017. [5]AL Builders Pty Ltd v Fatseas [2015] QCAT 166 [88]. The Tribunal’s decision The hearing on 5 October 2017 was adjourned after some 54 minutes, including an adjournment of 17 minutes during that time. Shortly after the hearing commenced the Tribunal raised the preliminary issue concerning Mr Marshall’s affidavit. The brief exchange about it between the Tribunal and the parties is extracted:[6][6]Transcript of Proceedings, Kline Industries International Pty Ltd t/as Kline Homes v Serena Nicholls (Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal, BDL056-16, 5 October 2017) I-3, line 39 – I-5, line 3.MEMBER: … Now, the next matter was you sought leave to file further material, an affidavit by Matthew Marshall and the exhibits to that affidavit.MS S. NICHOLLS: Yes. Yes, Member. SO the issue with Matthew Marshall’s affidavit is that obviously it was fresh evidence and we had no way of obtaining it. It happened to be that on the 17th of September, he has come forward and identified issues that go directly to the respondent’s matter. In particular, it identifies that Mr Kline, who’d already made some reference to this in previous correspondence, had told Mr Marshall that he made a conscious decision not to complete the build because he thought that it was a waste of his time due to my disability and unable to utilise the - - - MEMBER: I’ve read that. I’ve read the affidavit. The bulk of it goes to matters of credit which - - -MS S. NICHOLLS: Yes, and that can be dealt with at cross and closing.MEMBER: - - - which you can’t call – you can put to Mr Kline.MS S. NICHOLLS: Yes.MEMBER: And if he denies, that’s the end of the matter.MS S. NICHOLLS: Yes. But the other - - - MEMBER: All right? I - - - MS S. NICHOLLS: Sorry.MEMBER: I don’t want to expand on that at the moment. But I will – again, after Mr Kline’s given evidence, I’ll determine whether that affidavit will be admissible. I can’t – don’t see very much in the way of direct evidence that Mr Marshall can give, other than - - - MS S. NICHOLLS: What about the evidence in which Mr Kline was referring to – and in fact, email correspondence whereby he’s comparing my house to his house - - - MEMBER: Well, I was going to say - - - MS S. NICHOLLS: - - - where we’re only two houses apart?MEMBER: - - - that the evidence as to the similarity of the house and what Mr Marshall did in respect of – sorry, what Mr Kline did in respect of the [indistinct] might be relevant. It’s on the same incline – so - - - MS S. NICHOLLS: Same incline, two - - - MEMBER: But certainly - - - MS S. NICHOLLS: Two houses down.MEMBER: - - - the bulk of the affidavit is - - - MS S. NICHOLLS: Turfed. MEMBER: - - - goes to matters of credit, which – I wouldn’t allow it in on that basis. So I’ll leave that for the moment and we’ll try and get on to the start of the hearing. Anything else?

Decision

Reasons for decision

The homeowners’ filed a response and counter-application in April 2016, and subsequently, an amended response and counter-application in October 2017 as directed by the Tribunal.[4] The homeowners claim in their counter-application totals some $179,640.00, including $81,000.00 for the completion of building work and other amounts. The homeowners’ refute the builder’s contention that the property has reached ‘practical completion,’ claiming for defective and incomplete works.[5] They also refute the builder’s claim for the additional scaffolding costs. It is contended that by failing to advise the homeowners within a reasonable time of the requirement for additional scaffolding at a further cost, no such claim may be made by the builder and that the contract does not allow for any excess scaffolding fees to be claimed from them.[4]Direction 5 of the Tribunal directions in BDL056-16 dated 5 October 2017. [5]AL Builders Pty Ltd v Fatseas [2015] QCAT 166 [88]. The Tribunal’s decision The hearing on 5 October 2017 was adjourned after some 54 minutes, including an adjournment of 17 minutes during that time. Shortly after the hearing commenced the Tribunal raised the preliminary issue concerning Mr Marshall’s affidavit. The brief exchange about it between the Tribunal and the parties is extracted:[6][6]Transcript of Proceedings, Kline Industries International Pty Ltd t/as Kline Homes v Serena Nicholls (Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal, BDL056-16, 5 October 2017) I-3, line 39 – I-5, line 3.MEMBER: … Now, the next matter was you sought leave to file further material, an affidavit by Matthew Marshall and the exhibits to that affidavit.MS S. NICHOLLS: Yes. Yes, Member. SO the issue with Matthew Marshall’s affidavit is that obviously it was fresh evidence and we had no way of obtaining it. It happened to be that on the 17th of September, he has come forward and identified issues that go directly to the respondent’s matter. In particular, it identifies that Mr Kline, who’d already made some reference to this in previous correspondence, had told Mr Marshall that he made a conscious decision not to complete the build because he thought that it was a waste of his time due to my disability and unable to utilise the - - - MEMBER: I’ve read that. I’ve read the affidavit. The bulk of it goes to matters of credit which - - -MS S. NICHOLLS: Yes, and that can be dealt with at cross and closing.MEMBER: - - - which you can’t call – you can put to Mr Kline.MS S. NICHOLLS: Yes.MEMBER: And if he denies, that’s the end of the matter.MS S. NICHOLLS: Yes. But the other - - - MEMBER: All right? I - - - MS S. NICHOLLS: Sorry.MEMBER: I don’t want to expand on that at the moment. But I will – again, after Mr Kline’s given evidence, I’ll determine whether that affidavit will be admissible. I can’t – don’t see very much in the way of direct evidence that Mr Marshall can give, other than - - - MS S. NICHOLLS: What about the evidence in which Mr Kline was referring to – and in fact, email correspondence whereby he’s comparing my house to his house - - - MEMBER: Well, I was going to say - - - MS S. NICHOLLS: - - - where we’re only two houses apart?MEMBER: - - - that the evidence as to the similarity of the house and what Mr Marshall did in respect of – sorry, what Mr Kline did in respect of the [indistinct] might be relevant. It’s on the same incline – so - - - MS S. NICHOLLS: Same incline, two - - - MEMBER: But certainly - - - MS S. NICHOLLS: Two houses down.MEMBER: - - - the bulk of the affidavit is - - - MS S. NICHOLLS: Turfed. MEMBER: - - - goes to matters of credit, which – I wouldn’t allow it in on that basis. So I’ll leave that for the moment and we’ll try and get on to the start of the hearing. Anything else?

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The appeal centered on the Tribunal's refusal to accept Mr Marshall's affidavit, which the homeowners argued was a denial of procedural fairness. The court examined whether the Tribunal’s decision to exclude the affidavit constituted a breach of procedural fairness. The homeowners contended that they were not given an opportunity to respond to the affidavit before it was excluded. However, the court found that the Tribunal had adequately considered the matter and had not acted unfairly by not accepting the affidavit outright. The court noted that the Tribunal had reserved its decision on the admissibility of the affidavit until after the builder's evidence had been presented, which the court deemed sufficient procedural fairness.

Regarding the characterisation of the affidavit as 'fresh evidence', the court considered the definition of fresh evidence under the Domestic Building Contracts Act 2000 (Qld) and the QCAT rules. The court held that Mr Marshall's affidavit was indeed 'fresh evidence' as it was not available to the parties before the hearing and was presented for the first time during the proceedings. The affidavit contained new information that directly impacted the builder's case regarding the additional scaffolding costs.

Lastly, the court reviewed the Tribunal's decision to exclude the affidavit. The court concluded that while the Tribunal had the discretion to exclude evidence, it had not properly exercised that discretion in this instance. The affidavit contained relevant information that could have affected the outcome of the case, particularly regarding the builder's claim for additional scaffolding costs. Therefore, the Tribunal's decision to exclude the affidavit was deemed incorrect, leading to the setting aside of the Tribunal's order and the direction for the Tribunal to reconsider the affidavit's admissibility. The binding legal principle, or ratio decidendi, established by the decision is that tribunals must properly consider and exercise their discretion when excluding evidence, ensuring that all relevant information is available to the parties to fairly determine the case.