Nicholas v Norwest Shipping

Link copied
Case Copied 75 min read

DECISION AND REASONS FOR DECISION [2002] AATA 806

ADMINISTRATIVE APPEALS TRIBUNAL      )

)          No W1999/321

GENERAL ADMINISTRATIVE  DIVISION       )          
           Re      GRANT NICHOLAS          
  Applicant
           And    NORWEST SHIPPING      
  Respondent

DECISION

Tribunal       Associate Professor S D Hotop, Deputy President      

Date13 September 2002

PlacePerth

Decision      The Tribunal sets aside the decision under review and, in substitution therefor, decides that: the respondent is liable, pursuant to ss 24, 25 and 26(1) of the Seafarers Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1992 ("the Act"), to pay compensation to the applicant in accordance with the Act in respect of an "injury" to his right hand (being an "aggravation" of a pre-existing symptomatic condition of his right hand) which he suffered while performing his employment duties on board the MV "Sina" in March 1999; and the respondent is liable, pursuant to ss 24, 25 and 26(1) of the Act, to pay compensation to the applicant in accordance with the Act in respect of a mental "injury" (namely, adjustment disorder) which he suffered in November 1998 in the course of his employment on board the MV "Sina", up until 23 August 1999 but not thereafter.

...........(sgd S D Hotop)..........

Deputy President

CATCHWORDS
COMPENSATION – seafarers – applicant employed by respondent as a seafarer from January 1998 – applicant certified as medically fit for employment at sea in December 1997 notwithstanding pre-existing right hand condition and history of anxiety/stress – applicant reported incident to master of ship on 30 March 1999 involving complaint of anxiety and right hand pain – applicant discharged from ship on 2 April 1999 on ground of "illness" – applicant certified as medically unfit for sea duty from 2 April 1999 by reason of occupational psychological stress and right upper limb pain – applicant certified by Commonwealth Medical Inspector of Seamen as not medically fit for employment at sea by reason of, inter alia, "significant chronic adjustment disorder" and chronic pain and functional impairment of right upper limb – whether applicant suffered right hand injury – whether respondent liable to pay compensation to applicant in respect of right hand injury – whether applicant suffered mental injury – whether respondent liable to pay compensation to applicant in respect of mental injury.

Seafarers Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1992 ss 3, 8, 9, 24, 25, 26, 58

Comcare v Mooi (1996) 69 FCR 439

REASONS FOR DECISION

13 September 2002           Associate Professor S D Hotop, Deputy President                  

  1. Grant Nicholas ("the applicant") lodged with the Tribunal, on 15 October 1999, an application for review of a reviewable decision made on behalf of Norwest Shipping ("the respondent") on 28 September 1999 rejecting his claim for compensation, dated 7 April 1999, pursuant to the Seafarers Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1992 ("the Act").

  2. At the hearing the applicant appeared in person without representation, and the respondent was represented by Mr A Stavrianou of counsel. The Tribunal had before it the documents ("T documents") lodged by the respondent pursuant to s 37 of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (T1-T178, pp1-488) and various exhibits…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Nicholas v Norwest Shipping and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2002] AATA 806
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Nicholas v Norwest Shipping involves the applicant, a seafarer, who was employed by the respondent from January 1998. The applicant claimed compensation for a right hand injury and a mental injury sustained during his employment at sea. The dispute was adjudicated by the Administrative Appeals Tribunal. The primary legal issues the court had to resolve were whether the applicant had suffered a right hand injury and a mental injury during his employment, and if so, whether the respondent was liable to pay compensation under the Seafarers Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1992. The applicant argued that his right hand injury was exacerbated by the use of a chipping gun at work, and that he suffered mental injury due to occupational stress.

The Tribunal found that the applicant had indeed suffered a mental injury in the form of an adjustment disorder, likely arising in November 1998. This mental injury was compensable under the Act as it occurred in the course of employment. The Tribunal rejected the applicant's claims regarding a right hand injury, noting that the pre-existing condition of the applicant's right hand was already significantly impaired before he began employment with the respondent. The Tribunal found that the use of the chipping gun did exacerbate the pain in the applicant's right hand, but this did not constitute a new injury warranting compensation. The Tribunal concluded that the respondent was liable to pay compensation to the applicant for the mental injury sustained, but not for the right hand condition.

The Tribunal's decision hinged on a careful analysis of the medical evidence and the applicant's testimony. The Tribunal accepted the applicant's account of the exacerbation of his right hand pain due to work activities but found that this did not constitute a compensable injury under the Act. The findings on the mental injury were supported by medical reports and the applicant's testimony, which demonstrated that he had suffered a compensable mental condition during his employment. Consequently, the Tribunal ordered the respondent to pay compensation to the applicant for the mental injury, but not for the right hand condition.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

At the hearing the applicant appeared in person without representation, and the respondent was represented by Mr A Stavrianou of counsel. The Tribunal had before it the documents ("T documents") lodged by the respondent pursuant to s 37 of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (T1-T178, pp1-488) and various exhibits tendered in evidence by the applicant (A1-A14) and by the respondent (R1-R7). Oral evidence was given by the applicant and by the following additional witnesses: John Briggs, Dean Somers (who were called by the applicant), Paul Woollams, Geoffrey Read, Cleve Woollams, Dr Frank Bell, Dr Zelko Mustac and Dr Phillip Martin (who were called by the respondent).The Factual Background The relevant background facts, as found by the Tribunal on the basis of the T documents and the abovementioned exhibits, are as follows. The applicant, who was born on 11 November 1964, was employed by the respondent as an Integrated Rating (or general seaman) from 21 January 1998 and subsequently served in that capacity on board the ship MV "Sina" operated by the respondent. The applicant was finally discharged from the MV "Sina" at Broome on 2 April 1999 on the ground of "illness". A form entitled "Notification and Preliminary Particulars of Accident/Sickness or Incident" certified by Captain G Read, Master of the MV "Sina", and dated 2 April 1999 referred to a report of an incident involving the applicant on board the MV "Sina" on 30 March 1999. The nature and extent of the relevant injury/sickness were described as follows:"said to be suffering from anxiety and previous injury right hand and arm" A form entitled "Master's Report of Injury or Illness", signed by Captain Read and dated 3 April 1999, referred to an injury or illness suffered by the applicant at sea and reported on 30 March 1999. The nature of the illness or injury was described as follows:"1. Occupational Psychological Stress.2. Chronic pain related to past injury of right hand and elbow." A "First Medical Certificate", relating to the applicant's complaints of anxiety and right upper limb pain said to have occurred at sea on 30 March 1999, and supporting the commencement of weekly payments of compensation to the applicant in accordance with the Act, was issued by Dr M Dawson at Broome on 2 April 1999. The certificate stated that the provisional diagnosis of the applicant's condition was:"1.Occupational psychological stress due to industrial issues that have not been resolved2. Variable chronic pain related to right hand and elbow" A "Progress/Fitness Medical Certificate" in relation to the applicant was issued by Dr J Troy at Fremantle on 6 April 1999 stating the clinical findings and diagnosis as "pain in right upper limb and occupational stress" and certifying that the applicant would be totally unfit for work for four weeks from that date. The applicant lodged with the respondent a claim for compensation under the Act dated 7 April 1999 in respect of an injury said to have occurred on 30 March 1999 while working on the ship MV "Sina" and an illness said to have occurred while on long service leave. The circumstances in which the injury was said to have occurred were described in the claim form as follows:"Climbing a ladder to grease the points, once on top a fear of height overcame me, fearing my hand R H (sic) would seize on the way down the ladder. Due to the aggravation on my R H (sic)".

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

On 11 May 1999 the respondent rejected the applicant's abovementioned claim for compensation. Following a request by the applicant for a reconsideration the respondent, on 28 September 1999, again rejected his claim for compensation.The Applicant's Evidence Various written statements of the applicant, outlining the background to his present claim for compensation and the events immediately giving rise to that claim, appear in the T documents and in the exhibits tendered in evidence. The Tribunal has had regard to those statements but will not set them out here. The applicant also gave extensive oral evidence the substance of which was as follows. As regards his right upper limb, the applicant first referred to the history of injuries to that limb, namely, a broken wrist in 1981, a broken elbow in 1987, and a crush injury to the right hand in 1988. Asked by the Tribunal to recount the circumstances of the incident involving his right upper limb on 30 March 1999 referred to in his compensation claim form, the applicant explained that during the week immediately prior to that incident he had, in the course of his work duties on board the MV "Sina", used a "chipping gun" (which he described as "air-driven" with a "lot of vibration") and that this did not do his hand or arm "any good". He added that using a chipping gun (or "chipping hammer") was a common job for him, although he had told the bosun that he could not use it very well and that it did not do his arm and hand any good. He said that the bosun's response was that using a chipping hammer was part of his (the applicant's) job. He said that after using the chipping gun his hand was aching and that he had to sleep with it resting on a pillow. As regards the particular incident itself, the applicant said that as he climbed a ladder on the ship, holding a pot of grease, he "must have bumped" the ulnar nerve in his right hand and he felt a pain sensation like a "sharp electric shock" which lasted about five minutes. He said that he then could not really grip anything and "just sort of froze up there, just in fear" that he might fall. His evidence continued:"So then what happened? --- Well I think I knocked off in the afternoon, I think, I didn't report it to anybody, because I thought well they will just think I am trying to go on compo or something, you know, so why report it, I will just have to put up with the pain and then that night I had to – I was in pain, the whole arm and everything was in pain and I had medication for it, so I took that. Using the chipping hammer and climbing the ladder.All right and after this occurred, this was on 30 March '99 according to your claim form, how did that affect your work duties after that? --- Well, I just thought what can I do, you know, I really can't do anything, they are going to have a go at me because I don't like using chipping hammers, they make my arm sore and everything. I really couldn't do anything, you know, I can't really tell them because if I go on compensation, they will take away my medical certificate, the AMSA and then I haven't got a job. Meanwhile I had gone into debt with this company, thinking I had a secure job. So I couldn't really do much."(Transcript, p45)

Decision

Reasons for decision

Accordingly, the Tribunal finds that, pursuant to s 26(1) of the Act, compensation is payable to the applicant in accordance with the Act in respect of a mental "injury", namely, adjustment disorder, which he suffered in the course of his employment on board the MV "Sina", probably in November 1998. The Tribunal also finds that such compensation is payable to the applicant in respect of that "injury" up until 23 August 1999 (by which date he was no longer suffering from that "injury") but not thereafter. It follows, by reason of ss 24 and 25 of the Act, that the respondent is liable to pay such compensation to the applicant for the abovementioned period only.Conclusion The Tribunal concludes, therefore, that: For the above reasons the Tribunal sets aside the decision under review and, in substitution therefor, decides that:

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The issue in this case is whether the respondent is liable, pursuant to ss 24, 25 and 26 of the Act, to pay compensation to the applicant in accordance with the Act in respect of his alleged right hand condition and/or his mental condition. There is no dispute, for the purposes of determining that issue, that, at all relevant times, the applicant was a "seafarer" and an "employee", and the respondent was an "employer", within the meaning of the Act.Consideration and Findings The Tribunal will now consider the relevant material before it and, on the basis of that material, make the necessary findings, first in relation to the applicant's right hand and, secondly, in relation to his mental state.Right Hand It is an undisputed fact that the applicant sustained a serious crush injury to his right hand on 31 May 1988, and subsequently aggravated that injury on 4 November 1995 and 10 May 1996, resulting in impairment of that hand. Accordingly, when the applicant commenced employment with the respondent on 21 January 1998, his right hand was already functionally impaired by reason of that pre-existing injury and those subsequent aggravations thereof. The question is, however, whether the applicant sustained a further "injury" (as defined in s 3 of the Act) to his right hand while employed by the respondent on board the MV "Sina", and, if so, whether such injury resulted in his incapacity for work, or impairment. The applicant's claim for compensation in this matter specifically referred to an incident involving his climbing a ladder on board the MV "Sina" on 30 March 1999 when the alleged injury to his right hand was said to have occurred. In his oral evidence the applicant said that, during the week immediately prior to the abovementioned incident, he had, in the course of his normal work duties on board the MV "Sina", used a chipping gun which caused his hand to ache to such an extent that he thereafter had to rest his hand on a pillow when he went to sleep. As regards the abovementioned incident itself, the applicant elaborated that, as he climbed the ladder, he "must have bumped" the ulnar nerve in his right hand resulting in a pain sensation like a "sharp electric shock" which lasted about five minutes, following which he was unable to grip the ladder properly and was afraid that he might fall. The Tribunal accepts the applicant's evidence regarding the use of the chipping gun and finds that his using the chipping gun in the course of his duties on board the MV "Sina" caused him to suffer increased pain in his right hand. The Tribunal notes that, as from 2 April 1999, medical certificates were issued, first by Dr Dawson and subsequently by Dr Troy, certifying that the applicant was totally unfit for work by reason of right upper limb pain and occupational stress. The Tribunal also notes the subsequent medical reports of Drs Martin, Williams and Somers. In the Tribunal's opinion that medical evidence supports the proposition that the applicant, at least from 2 April 1999, suffered chronic pain in his right hand to such an extent that it resulted in a functional impairment of that hand which of itself was sufficient to render him medically unfit for employment at sea – whereas for some years prior to that time he had, notwithstanding his then existing right hand condition, been consistently certified as medically fit for employment at sea. In particular the Tribunal places great weight on the medical reports of Dr Martin (who, in his capacity as Medical Inspector of Seamen, had examined the applicant on numerous occasions between July 1990 and September 1999 and prepared numerous medical reports on his condition), Dr Williams and Dr Somers (see paragraphs 42-45 above). The Tribunal also notes that Dr Martin, in his oral evidence, confirmed that on 29 December 1997 he had certified the applicant as medically fit for employment at sea (shortly before he commenced employment on board the MV "Sina"), but that on 18 May 1999 (following his discharge from the MV "Sina" on 2 March 1999 on the ground of "illness") he had, for the first time, certified him as medically unfit for employment at sea and that the applicant's right hand condition itself, by reason of increased pain symptoms therein, now constituted an "unacceptable workplace risk" (see paragraph 53 above).