Applicant and Australian Offshore Solutions Pty Ltd (Compensation)

Link copied
Case Copied 51 min read

Applicant and Australian Offshore Solutions Pty Ltd (Compensation) [2016] AATA 331 (20 May 2016)

Division

GENERAL DIVISION

File Number(s)

2014/5074

Re

“Applicant”

APPLICANT

And

Australian Offshore Solutions Pty Ltd

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal

Senior Member CR Walsh
Brigadier AG Warner, Member

Date 20 May 2016
Place Perth

The Tribunal affirms the decision under review.

..........[Sgd].............................................

Senior Member CR Walsh

CATCHWORDS

COMPENSATION – claim for seafarers compensation – whether claimed injury (stress and digestive disruption) arose out of applicant’s employment as an Integrated Rating with the respondent – whether sign-off incident on board the vessel caused the claimed injury – no causal connection between alleged injury and the applicant’s employment with the respondent – decision under review affirmed

LEGISLATION

Seafarers’ Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1992 – s 3 – s 4(1) – s 9 – s 9(2)(b)(i) – s 66 – s 78

CASES

Charles R Davison and Co v M’Robb (1918) AC 304

Cutajar and Commonwealth (1985) 8 ALD N76
Humphrey Earl Ltd v Speechley (1951) 84 CLR 126
Nicholas and Norwest Shipping [2002] AATA 806 (13 September 2002)
Mendez v Telstra Corporation Limited (1998) (1998) 147 FLR 394

Tarry v Warringah Shire Council (1974) WCR 1

REASONS FOR DECISION

Senior Member CR Walsh
Brigadier AG Warner, Member

20 May 2016

INTRODUCTION

  1. The Applicant seeks a review of a decision made by Australian Offshore Solutions Pty Ltd (AOS) on 18 September 2014 declining the Applicant’s claim for compensation under the Seafarers’ Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1992 (SRCA) for injuries (namely “stress and digestive disruption”) allegedly sustained by the Applicant on 29 January 2014 whilst he was employed by AOS as an “Integrated Rating”, on a casual basis, on board the vessel Sapura Kencana Constructor.

    FACTUAL & PROCEDURAL BACKGROUND

  2. The Applicant was born on 11 November 1964.  He is currently 51 years of age.

  3. The Applicant entered into a Contract of Employment with AOS on 21 November 2013.

  4. The Applicant was employed by AOS as an “Integrated Rating”, on a casual basis, on board the vessel Sapura Kencana Constructor in the period from 21 November 2013 to 26 December 2013. 

  5. The Applicant returned to work on board the vessel Sapura Kencana Constructor on 24 January 2014 and worked for 5 days.

  6. The Applicant alleges that he suffered “stress and digestive disruption” on 29 January 2014, (5 days into his duties) when he was signed-off the Sapura Kencana Constructor by a Mr Ray Isted, a co-worker, when the vessel was laid up at Exmouth (Sign-off Incident).  It is not in dispute that Mr Isted signed the Applicant’s signature in the ship’s log book on 29 January 2014.  The Sign-off Incident is central to this application and is discussed in further detail below:  refer to paragraphs 40-49. 

  7. On 11 February 2014, the Applicant reboarded the Sapura Kencana Constructor and resumed his duties.  On 12 February 2014, he became ill with fever and vomiting and was flown off the vessel on 13 February 2014.

  8. On 13 February 2014,…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Applicant and Australian Offshore Solutions Pty Ltd (Compens... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2016] AATA 331
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned a claim for seafarers' compensation brought by the Applicant against Australian Offshore Solutions Pty Ltd (AOS). The Applicant alleged that he suffered an injury, specifically stress and digestive disruption, which arose out of his employment as an Integrated Rating with AOS. The dispute centred on whether there was a causal connection between the Applicant's alleged injury and his employment, and whether a sign-off incident on board the vessel caused the claimed injury. The decision was made by Cr Walsh SM.

The Tribunal was required to determine several key issues. These included whether the Applicant had suffered an "injury" as defined by the relevant legislation, and specifically whether any such injury arose out of or in the course of his employment with AOS. Further, the Tribunal had to consider whether there was any causal connection between the Applicant's employment and the alleged injury, and whether any claimed disability or incapacity was caused by a pre-existing, non-work-related condition. Finally, the Tribunal needed to ascertain whether the Applicant had suffered any incapacity at all.

In reaching its decision, the Tribunal considered extensive documentary and oral evidence, including witness statements from the Applicant, ship's officers, and medical experts. The relevant legislation, the *Seafarers Rehabilitation and Compensation Act* (SRCA), defines "injury" to include a disease or a physical or mental injury arising out of or in the course of employment, or an aggravation of such an injury. The Tribunal noted that it was not in dispute that the Applicant was employed as an Integrated Rating on the vessel at the material times and was on board during the alleged incident, which satisfied certain conditions under s 9(2)(b)(i) of the SRCA. However, for compensation to be payable, the Tribunal had to be satisfied on the balance of probabilities that the Applicant sustained an injury that arose out of or in the course of his employment.

The Tribunal affirmed the decision under review.

Orders

Orders of the court

The Tribunal affirms the decision under review.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The relevant issues for consideration by the Tribunal in this application are whether: (i)The Applicant suffered an “injury”; (ii)The Applicant suffered an injury “arising out of” his employment with AOS on or about 29 January 2014 and/or on or about 12 February 2014; (iii)there is any causal connection between the Applicant’s employment with AOS and the alleged “injury”; (iv)The Applicant’s disability/incapacity, if any, was caused by a non-work related pre-existing condition; and(v)The Applicant suffered any incapacity at all. EVIDENCE The documentary evidence before the Tribunal comprised:·the “T Documents” (T1-T107, pp 1-548) (Exhibit 1);·the “Respondent’s Statement of Facts, Issues and Contentions”, dated 30 October 2015 (Exhibit 2);·a bundle of documents (67 pages), called “Applicant’s credentials” (Exhibit 3) ·an Australian Maritime Safety Authority (AMSA) “Medical Examination Report”, dated 28 October 2008 (Exhibit 4);·two pages of “Logbook” (i.e. from the vessel Sapura Kencana Constructor), dated 11 February 2014 and 13 February 2014 (Exhibit 5);·two medical reports by Dr Eileen Tay dated 18 November 2015 (Exhibit 6);·a two page document from Western Australia Police website, titled “Effects of Fraud” and AMSA documents (Exhibit 7);·medical evidence under cover of a letter from Jarman McKenna (AOS’ solicitors), dated 22 March 2016 (Exhibit 8); ·four Medical reports by Dr Jane Fitch dated 16 January 2015, 15 August 2015, 21 October 2015 and 18 March 2016 (Exhibit 9);·the “Applicant’s Statements of Facts”, dated 8 February 2016 and 6 March 2016 (Exhibit 10); and ·a medical report by Dr Raj Sekon, dated 22 September 2014 (Exhibit 11). Exhibit 1 contains the following Witness Statements:· a Statement from the Applicant, dated 6 May 2014;· the Witness Statement of Mr Ray Isted, dated 21 September 2015;· the Witness Statement of Captain Trond Breivik, dated 23 September 2015;· the Witness Statement of Mr John Morris, dated 5 October 2015; and· the Witness Statement of Captain Trond Breivik, dated 9 October 2015. In addition, oral evidence was given by the following people:· The Applicant (in person),· Dr Eileen Tay, Consultant Psychiatrist (in person);· Dr Jane Fitch, Consultant Psychiatrist (in person);· Dr Eoin McDonnell (by telephone);· Mr Ray Isted (by telephone);· Captain Trond Breivik (by telephone);· Mr John Frewin (by telephone); and· Mr John Morris (by telephone).CONSIDERATIONRelevant law The SRCA is an Act relating to rehabilitation and workers’ compensation for seafarers and certain other persons, and for related purposes. Section 3 of the SRCA defines “injury” as follows:“injury” means:(a)a disease;(b)an injury (other than a disease) suffered by an employee, being a physical or mental injury arising out of, or in the course of, the employee’s employment; or(c)an aggravation of a physical or mental injury (other than a disease) suffered by an employee (whether or not that injury arose out of, or in the course of the employee’s employment), being an aggravation that arose out of, or in the course of, that employment;but does not include anything suffered by an employee as a result of reasonable disciplinary action taken against the employee, or failure by the employee to obtain a promotion, transfer or benefit in connection with his or her employment. [Emphasis added]

Decision

Reasons for decision

On 23 February 2015, AOS affirmed the determination it made on 18 December 2014 (refer to paragraph 22 above) on the basis that the Applicant did not have a “reasonable excuse” for failing to attend the three medical appointments arranged by AOS on 15 July 2014, 5 August 2014 and 15 December 2014, pursuant to s 66 of the SRCA (Suspension Decision). The Applicant subsequently applied to the Tribunal for a review of the Suspension Decision and, on 13 August 2015, Deputy President Kendall affirmed the Suspension Decision on the basis that the Applicant had not provided a “reasonable excuse” for failing to attend the three medical examinations concerned. This application was heard over three days, on 30 and 31 March and 1 April 2016. The Applicant presented as proud of his family history in seafaring and of his own career as a seafarer, with his related achievements and qualifications. However, the Applicant was a very difficult applicant before the Tribunal. The Applicant repeatedly interrupted, objected, refused to answer questions and made inappropriate and disrespectful comments to the Members, AOS’s counsel and instructing solicitor and to AOS’s medical expert (Dr Eileen Tay), even continuing to do so after a formal warning by the Tribunal. ISSUES The relevant issues for consideration by the Tribunal in this application are whether: (i)The Applicant suffered an “injury”; (ii)The Applicant suffered an injury “arising out of” his employment with AOS on or about 29 January 2014 and/or on or about 12 February 2014; (iii)there is any causal connection between the Applicant’s employment with AOS and the alleged “injury”; (iv)The Applicant’s disability/incapacity, if any, was caused by a non-work related pre-existing condition; and(v)The Applicant suffered any incapacity at all. EVIDENCE The documentary evidence before the Tribunal comprised:·the “T Documents” (T1-T107, pp 1-548) (Exhibit 1);·the “Respondent’s Statement of Facts, Issues and Contentions”, dated 30 October 2015 (Exhibit 2);·a bundle of documents (67 pages), called “Applicant’s credentials” (Exhibit 3) ·an Australian Maritime Safety Authority (AMSA) “Medical Examination Report”, dated 28 October 2008 (Exhibit 4);·two pages of “Logbook” (i.e. from the vessel Sapura Kencana Constructor), dated 11 February 2014 and 13 February 2014 (Exhibit 5);·two medical reports by Dr Eileen Tay dated 18 November 2015 (Exhibit 6);·a two page document from Western Australia Police website, titled “Effects of Fraud” and AMSA documents (Exhibit 7);·medical evidence under cover of a letter from Jarman McKenna (AOS’ solicitors), dated 22 March 2016 (Exhibit 8); ·four Medical reports by Dr Jane Fitch dated 16 January 2015, 15 August 2015, 21 October 2015 and 18 March 2016 (Exhibit 9);·the “Applicant’s Statements of Facts”, dated 8 February 2016 and 6 March 2016 (Exhibit 10); and ·a medical report by Dr Raj Sekon, dated 22 September 2014 (Exhibit 11).

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In addition, oral evidence was given by the following people:· The Applicant (in person),· Dr Eileen Tay, Consultant Psychiatrist (in person);· Dr Jane Fitch, Consultant Psychiatrist (in person);· Dr Eoin McDonnell (by telephone);· Mr Ray Isted (by telephone);· Captain Trond Breivik (by telephone);· Mr John Frewin (by telephone); and· Mr John Morris (by telephone).CONSIDERATIONRelevant law The SRCA is an Act relating to rehabilitation and workers’ compensation for seafarers and certain other persons, and for related purposes. Section 3 of the SRCA defines “injury” as follows:“injury” means:(a)a disease;(b)an injury (other than a disease) suffered by an employee, being a physical or mental injury arising out of, or in the course of, the employee’s employment; or(c)an aggravation of a physical or mental injury (other than a disease) suffered by an employee (whether or not that injury arose out of, or in the course of the employee’s employment), being an aggravation that arose out of, or in the course of, that employment;but does not include anything suffered by an employee as a result of reasonable disciplinary action taken against the employee, or failure by the employee to obtain a promotion, transfer or benefit in connection with his or her employment. [Emphasis added] Section 3 of the SRCA provides that “employee” has the meaning given by s 4 of the SRCA. Section 4(1) of the SRCA defines “employee” as follows:“employee” means:(a) a seafarer; or(b) a trainee; or(c)a person (other than a trainee) who, although ordinarily employed or engaged as a seafarer, is not so employed or engaged but is required under an award to attend at a Seafarers Engagement Centre for the purpose of registering availability for employment or engagement on a prescribed ship. Section 9 of the SRCA provides:Injury arising out of, or in the course of, employment(1)This section does not limit the circumstances in which an injury to an employee may be treated as having arisen out of, or in the course of, his or her employment.(2)An injury is also to be treated as having so arisen, for the purposes of this Act, if it happened:(a)…………………….; or(b) if the employee is a seafarer;(i)while the employee was on board the prescribed ship on which he or she was employed or engaged; or(ii)while the employee was temporarily absent from that ship during an ordinary recess in that employment and not at his or her place of residence. It is not in dispute that at all material times the Applicant was employed by AOS as an “Integrated Rating”, on a casual basis, on the Sapura Kencana Constructor and that the Applicant was on board the Sapura Kencana Constructor at the time of the alleged injury on 29 January 2014, for the purposes of s 9(2)(b)(i) of the SRCA. For liability for worker’s compensation to exist in the Applicant’s case, the Tribunal must be satisfied, on the balance of probabilities, that the Applicant sustained an “injury” that “arose out of, or in the course of” his employment with AOS.