Nguyen v MICMSMA

Link copied
Case Copied 25 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Nguyen v Minister for Immigration, Citizenship, Migrant Services and Multicultural Affairs [2020] FCA 1732

Appeal from: Nguyen v Minister for Immigration & Anor [2019] FCCA 3317
File number: QUD 779 of 2019
Judgment of: REEVES J
Date of judgment: 30 November 2020
Catchwords: MIGRATION – appeal from a decision of the Federal Circuit Court of Australia – where the primary judge dismissed an application for judicial review of a decision of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (the Tribunal) – where the Tribunal affirmed a decision of the delegate of the Minister for Immigration, Citizenship, Migrant Services and Multicultural Affairs refusing the appellant’s application for a Subclass 836 (Carer) visa – where the appellant was sponsored by her sister under cl 836.213 of the Migration Regulations 1994 (Cth) – whether the residency criteria prescribed by cl 836.213 required the appellant and sponsor to be “usually resident” in the same household – whether the primary judge erred in finding that the Tribunal had not fallen into jurisdictional error – appeal allowed
Legislation:

Acts Interpretation Act 1901 (Cth)

Migration Amendment Regulations 2002 (No. 2) (Cth)

Migration Regulations 1994 (Cth)

Division: General Division
Registry: Queensland
National Practice Area: Administrative and Constitutional Law and Human Rights
Number of paragraphs: 45
Date of hearing: 16 June 2020
Counsel for the Appellant: Mr L Boccabella
Solicitor for the Appellant: T Lawyers
Counsel for the First Respondent: Mr AG Psaltis
Solicitor for the First Respondent: Clayton Utz
Counsel for the Second Respondent: The Second Respondent filed a Submitting Notice

ORDERS

QUD 779 of 2019
BETWEEN:

THI VE NGUYEN

Appellant

AND:

MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION, CITIZENSHIP, MIGRANT SERVICES AND MULTICULTURAL AFFAIRS

First Respondent

ADMINISTRATIVE APPEALS TRIBUNAL

Second Respondent

ORDER MADE BY:

REEVES J

DATE OF ORDER:

30 NOVEMBER 2020

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.The appeal is allowed.

2.The orders made by the Federal Circuit Court of Australia on 21 November 2019 are set aside.

3.The appellant’s application is remitted to the Federal Circuit Court of Australia to be heard and determined according to law.

4.The first respondent pay the appellant’s costs of and incidental to this appeal to be taxed failing agreement.

Note:   Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.


REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

REEVES J:

INTRODUCTION

  1. Ms Thi Hoa Nguyen is an Australian citizen. She is 93 years old and is bedridden with bilateral paraplegia. Since 2013, her daughter, Ms Thi Ve Nguyen, who is a Vietnamese citizen, has been caring for her mother in Vietnam and in Australia.

  2. In May 2014, Ms Thi Ve Nguyen applied for a Subclass 836 (Carer) visa. At that time, her mother was living with Ms Thi Ve Nguyen’s sister, Ms Thi Huyen Nguyen, at an address in Forest Lake, a suburb of Brisbane. The refusal of that application has led to this appeal.

  3. To avoid confusion stemming from the fact that the three Ms Nguyens have the same family name and first given name, in these reasons I will refer to…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Nguyen v MICMSMA and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2020] FCA 1732
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Nguyen v MICMSMA, the appellant, Thi Nguyen, appealed against the decision of the Federal Circuit Court of Australia, which dismissed her application for judicial review of a decision of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (the Tribunal). The Tribunal had affirmed the decision of the delegate of the Minister for Immigration, Citizenship, Migrant Services and Multicultural Affairs, refusing the appellant's application for a Subclass 836 (Carer) visa. The appellant was sponsored by her sister, Thi Huyen Nguyen, under cl 836.213 of the Migration Regulations 1994 (Cth). The legal issues in the case were whether the residency criteria prescribed by cl 836.213 required the appellant and the sponsor to be "usually resident" in the same household and whether the primary judge erred in finding that the Tribunal had not fallen into jurisdictional error.

The court found that the primary judge erred in his interpretation of the relevant provisions of the Migration Regulations 1994 (Cth) and the Acts Interpretation Act 1901 (Cth). The court held that the primary judge misunderstood the note to cl 836.2 of the Regulations, which stated that the primary criteria must be satisfied by at least one member of the family unit. The court also found that the primary judge misinterpreted cl 836.213(a), which required the sponsor to be a person who fell within the definition of "member of the family unit" in cl 1.12 of the Regulations. Additionally, the court held that the primary judge misapplied the meaning of "usually resident" by setting the bar too high as to what amounts to "usually resident" in the context of a carer visa.

As a result of the errors identified by the court, the appeal was allowed. The orders made by the Federal Circuit Court of Australia on 21 November 2019 were set aside, and the appellant's application was remitted to the Federal Circuit Court of Australia to be heard and determined according to law. The first respondent was ordered to pay the appellant's costs of and incidental to this appeal to be taxed failing agreement.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The appeal is allowed.

2. The orders made by the Federal Circuit Court of Australia on 21 November 2019 are set aside.

3. The appellant’s application is remitted to the Federal Circuit Court of Australia to be heard and determined according to law.

4. The first respondent pay the appellant’s costs of and incidental to this appeal to be taxed failing agreement.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Finally, after reviewing the information and materials before it, the Tribunal concluded (at [40]) that:The Tribunal finds that the applicant was not usually resident in the same household as her mother at the time of application. Therefore cl.836.212 is not met.THE FEDERAL CIRCUIT COURT JUDGMENT After setting out the history of Ms Ve’s matter (at [1]-[9]), her grounds of review before the Court (at [10]) and the apposite provisions of the Migration Regulations 1994 (Cth) (the Regulations) (at [11]), the primary judge turned to consider the meaning of the expression “an Australian relative” as used in cl 836.212. His Honour then reached the following conclusions on that matter (at [13]-[14]):13.The Court finds that the applicant was a “Carer” as defined in r. 1.15AA of the Regulations. The “person”, for the purposes of r. 1.15AA(1), was the Mother who:•was an Australian citizen usually resident in Australia;•was a close relative of the applicant;•satisfied the criteria as set out in r. 1.15AA(1)(b) of the Regulations;•satisfied the requirements of sub-regulations (ba), (c), (e) and (f) of r. 1.15AA(1).14.Notwithstanding the concession made by Counsel for the [Minister] that a sponsor, in circumstances such as the present:(a) had to be a person;(b) had to be an Australian citizen; and(c) had to be a relative of the applicant.the Court finds that:(d)though the applicant had claimed to be the carer of an Australian relative (namely the Mother) in compliance with cl. 836.212;(e)the reference to “the Australian relative”, as referred to in cl. 836.213(a), could only be satisfied if that person – in this case the Sister – was a person who relevantly fell within the definition of “member of the family unit” in cl. 1.12 of the Regulations. Thereafter, his Honour considered s 15AA of the Acts Interpretation Act 1901 (Cth) (at [15]-[17]) and concluded (at [18]) that:However, the note to cl. 836.2 referred to the mandatory requirement that the primary criteria to be satisfied at the time of the making of the application must be satisfied by a person who was a member of “a family unit”. Clause 836.213 was unable to be satisfied. The sponsor was not usually a resident in the Mother’s household, nor was the applicant a dependent of the Mother as the word dependent is defined in r. 1.05A(1) of the Regulations …(Emphasis in original) Ultimately, his Honour concluded (at [28]) that Ms Ve had failed to establish jurisdictional error in the Tribunal’s decision and therefore dismissed her application with costs (at [29]-[30]).GROUNDS OF APPEAL Ms Ve filed her notice of appeal in this Court on 19 December 2019. It contained four grounds of appeal. Together with their supporting particulars, they are as follows:1.The learned trial judge erred by misunderstanding and/or wrongly the applying the Note to Clause 836.2 of Schedule 2 to the Migration Regulations 1994, which reads:836.2 Primary criteriaNote: The primary criteria must be satisfied by at least one member of the family unit. The other members of the family unit who are applicants for a visa of this subclass need satisfy only the secondary criteria.Particulars(a)The Note has zero relevance to the interpretation of the subclass 836 Carer visa in this matter, because there was only one person applying for the visa i.e. the appellant;(b)The Note is a common note written in exactly the same terms in almost all visa subclasses. Its purpose is merely to require that when a whole family is applying for that particular visa in the one visa application, only one member of the family need satisfy the primary criteria.(c)There is a complementary ‘Note’ under the heading ‘836.3 Secondary criteria’ which reads:836.3 Secondary criteriaNote: If any member of the family unit satisfies the primary criteria, the other members of the family unit are eligible for the grant of the visa if they satisfy the secondary criteria and their applications are made before the Minister has decided to grant or refuse to grant the visa to the first person.(d)It follows that the ‘family unit’ referred to in the Note (indeed either Note) has no relevance to identifying who is a “member of the family unit of the resident” in Reg 1.15AA(1).(e)The wrong interpretation of the ‘Note’ was part of the chain of reasoning by the trial judge, culminating in paragraph 18 of his reasons, hence the error of the trial judge is established.2.The learned trial judge erred when he mistakenly thought that the [Tribunal] found the appellant did not meet cl 836.213 (paragraph 8 of his reasons) when in fact the [Tribunal] did not make any finding about compliance or non-compliance with cl 836.213. In consideration of cl 836.213, the trial judge was in error.Particulars(a)The learned trial judge found that the appellant was in ‘compliance’ with cl. 832.212 [sic – 836.212] (at the time of visa application), which reads:836.212The applicant claims to be the carer of an Australian relative.(b)This meant that one error by the [Tribunal] in its decision at paragraph 40 was overcome.(c)The learned trial judge then went on to misapply and/or wrongly interpret cl 836.213(a) when all the evidence before the [Tribunal] showed that the ‘sister’ (Thi Huyen Nguyen) was unequivocally the lawful and proper sponsor of the appellant. Both the [Tribunal] and the delegate at first instance took no issue with the fact that the appellant was lawfully and properly sponsored by the ‘sister’, neither the [Tribunal] nor the delegate found there was non-compliance with cl 836.213(a)), which reads:[set out at [24] below](d)The reasoning by the trial judge around the application of cl 836.213(a) was erroneous.3.The learned trial judge erred by misunderstanding the scheme of the criteria for the subclass 836 visa.Particulars(a)The key criteria is the time of visa decision criteria in cl 836.221[:]836.22 Criteria to be satisfied at time of decision836.221The applicant is a carer of a person referred to in clause 836.212.(b)Hence the time to determine whether the sponsor, the person to be cared for and the carer were living in the same household was at time of decision by the [Tribunal] (i.e. 18 December 2018);(c)At 18 December 2018, there was no doubt whatsoever that the sponsor (Thi Huyen), the person to be cared for (Hoa Nguyen) and the carer (the appellant) were all living in the same household, namely [an address in Forest Lake, Brisbane) 8 (see paragraph 36 of the [Tribunal’s] reasons).(d)The learned trial erred by failing to appreciate that the determination of whether the visa applicant was indeed the ‘carer’ had to be done at time of decision, not time of application. At time of application, cl 836.212 merely required that “The applicant claims to be the carer of an Australian relative” (a claim which was unequivocally, fully and properly set out in the visa application at page 739 of the Court Book before the Federal Circuit Court in the answers to questions 65 to 68).4.Further and/or in the alternative, the learned trial judge erred in his consideration of the term ‘usually resident’ and failed to find that the [Tribunal] similarly erred in its consideration of whether the sponsor Thi Huyen Nguyen, was ‘usually resident’ at [the Forest Lake address], as at the date of the visa application on 28 May 2014.Particulars(a)Although the [Tribunal] made an adverse finding about the sponsor’s marital troubles (paragraph 31), the [Tribunal] did not go on to find that the sponsor did not spend weekends at the house at [the Forest Lake address] during the period around 28 May 2014;(b)Yet the transcripts of the [Tribunal] hearing from lines 427 to 436, line 675, and paragraphs 13 and 14 of the sponsor’s statutory declaration (Federal Circuit Court, Court Book page 348) was evidence that, irrespective of whatever was going on with the sponsor’s husband, the sponsor, Thi Huyen Nguyen, spent periods overnight at [the Forest Lake address], particularly on the weekends.(c)Both the learned Federal Circuit [Court] judge and the [Tribunal] misapplied the meaning of ‘usually resident’ by setting the bar too high as to what amounts to ‘usually resident’, especially in the context of a carer visa.(d)In the premises both the learned trial judge and the [Tribunal] erred in interpreting the term ‘usually resident’ and therefore did not make proper factual findings regarding whether the sponsor was ‘usually resident’ at [the Forest Lake address] as at 28 May 2014.(Errors and emphasis in original; footnotes omitted)NOTICE OF CONTENTION

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.