2009607 (Migration) [2024] AATA 2832 (22 July 2024)
DECISION RECORD
DIVISION:Migration & Refugee Division
REPRESENTATIVE: Mrs Anne O'Donoghue (MARN: 9368943)
CASE NUMBER: 2009607
MEMBER:Glynis Bartley
DATE:22 July 2024
PLACE OF DECISION: Sydney
DECISION:The Tribunal affirms the decision not to grant the applicants Other Family (Residence) (Class BU) visas.
Statement made on 22 July 2024 at 8:29am
The issue in this review is whether the first named applicant (the applicant), [named], is the ‘carer’ of an Australian relative at the time of this decision.
APPLICATION FOR REVIEW
This is an application for review of a decision made by a delegate of the Minister for Home Affairs to refuse to grant the applicants Other Family (Residence) (Class BU) visas under s 65 of the Migration Act 1958 (Cth) (the Act).
The applicants applied for the visas on 6 March 2020. At that time, Class BU contained three subclasses: Subclass 835 (Remaining Relative); Subclass 836 (Carer) and Subclass 838 (Aged Dependent Relative): item 1123B of Schedule 1 to the Migration Regulations 1994 (Cth) (the Regulations). In this case, the applicant is seeking to satisfy the criteria for the grant of a Subclass 836 visa. The criteria for a Subclass 836 visa are set out in Part 836 of Schedule 2 to the Regulations. Relevantly to this matter, the primary criteria to be met include cl.836.221.
At the time of application, the applicant claimed that he was providing care to his sister, [Sister A], who was diagnosed with metastatic breast cancer in February 2019.
The delegate refused to grant the visas on 28 May 2020 on the basis that the applicant did not satisfy cl.836.213 of the Regulations because he was sponsored by his daughter, [Daughter A], rather than his sister.
The applicants applied to the Tribunal for review of the delegate’s decision on 9 June 2020.
Sadly, the applicant’s sister, [Sister A], died [in] May 2021, aged [age] years.
On 21 June 2024, the Tribunal invited the applicants to attend a hearing to give evidence and present arguments.
The applicants’ representative declined the hearing invitation on their behalf on 8 July 2024, and requested that the matter be determined on the papers.
For the following reasons, the Tribunal has concluded that the decision under review should be affirmed.
BACKGROUND
The applicant is [an age]-year-old citizen of Sweden. According to the application, he was born in Iraq and migrated to Sweden in 2000. The applicant’s wife, [named], is [an age]-year-old Swedish citizen who was also born in Iraq. She is included in the application as a secondary applicant. The applicant and his wife have [number] adult children; [most] of whom live in Sweden. One daughter, [Daughter A], is an Australian citizen and lives in Australia.
The applicant has travelled to and from Australia on numerous occasions since 2005 on various Tourist, Visitor and E visas.
CONSIDERATION OF CLAIMS AND EVIDENCE
The applicants’ representative provided additional documents to the Tribunal, including but not limited to the following: a Bupa Carer Visa…
Grounds of appeal
[14] The appellant contends that the primary judge erred in finding that the respondent had discharged the onus of establishing the matters required under the relevant provision.
[15] It was submitted that his Honour failed to give adequate weight to the evidence of the second witness, and that the findings of fact were not reasonably open on the material before the Court.
[16] The respondent, for its part, submits that no error is disclosed, and that the conclusions reached were well within the range of outcomes available to the primary judge.
Consideration
[17] It is convenient to deal first with the question of construction, as the resolution of that issue informs the remaining grounds advanced by the appellant.
[18] For the reasons that follow, we are of the view that the appeal should be allowed in part and the matter remitted for further determination.
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read 2009607 (Migration) and more:
This matter concerned an appeal to the Tribunal regarding a decision to refuse a Subclass 836 (Carer) visa. The applicant, a citizen of Sweden, applied for the visa on the basis that he was the carer of his sister, who was an Australian citizen residing in Australia. The secondary applicant was the applicant's wife. The primary issue before the Tribunal was whether the applicant met the criteria for the visa, particularly in light of the subsequent death of his sister.
The Tribunal was required to determine whether the applicant claimed to be the carer of an Australian relative at the time of application, whether the sponsorship requirements were met at that time, and crucially, whether the applicant was the carer of an Australian relative at the time of the Tribunal's decision. The Tribunal also considered whether the secondary applicant met the criteria and whether the matter warranted referral for Ministerial Intervention.
The Tribunal found that the applicant did meet the requirement of claiming to be the carer of an Australian relative at the time of application, and that the sponsorship requirements were also met at that time, with the applicant's daughter being the sponsor. However, the Tribunal determined that the applicant did not meet the requirement of being the carer of an Australian relative at the time of the decision, as his sister had passed away in 2021. Consequently, the applicant did not satisfy the criteria for the Subclass 836 visa, and by extension, the secondary applicant also did not meet the requirements. The Tribunal also found that the applicant did not meet the criteria for a Subclass 838 (Aged Dependent Relative) visa or a Subclass 835 (Remaining Relative) visa. While acknowledging the difficult circumstances, including the death of the applicant's sister and the applicant's family ties in Australia, the Tribunal concluded that these factors did not alter the legal requirements for the visa.
The Tribunal affirmed the decision under review, finding that the applicant did not meet the criteria for the Subclass 836 visa. The Tribunal also found that the applicant was not entitled to the grant of a Subclass 838 or Subclass 835 visa. The Tribunal considered the request for Ministerial Intervention but ultimately concluded that the applicant did not meet the criteria for the visa.
Orders
Orders of the court
Full text does not contain this section.
Background
Background to the litigation
For the following reasons, the Tribunal has concluded that the decision under review should be affirmed.BACKGROUND The applicant is [an age]-year-old citizen of Sweden. According to the application, he was born in Iraq and migrated to Sweden in 2000. The applicant’s wife, [named], is [an age]-year-old Swedish citizen who was also born in Iraq. She is included in the application as a secondary applicant. The applicant and his wife have [number] adult children; [most] of whom live in Sweden. One daughter, [Daughter A], is an Australian citizen and lives in Australia. The applicant has travelled to and from Australia on numerous occasions since 2005 on various Tourist, Visitor and E visas. CONSIDERATION OF CLAIMS AND EVIDENCE The applicants’ representative provided additional documents to the Tribunal, including but not limited to the following: a Bupa Carer Visa Report, dated [in] February 2021, which gave [Sister A] a total impairment rating of 40 points, a medical report regarding [Sister A] by [Doctor A], palliative care advanced trainee at [a named] Local Health District, dated 27 April 2021, a copy of [Sister A’s] death certificate, and written submissions by the applicants’ representative. Whether the applicant claimed to be the ‘carer’ at the time of application Clause 836.212 of the Regulations requires that the applicant claims to be the carer of an Australian relative. In the present case, the visa application was made on the basis that the applicant was the carer of his sister, [Sister A]. For the purposes of a Carer visa, ‘Australian relative’ is defined as a relative of the visa applicant who is an Australian citizen, an Australian permanent resident, or an eligible New Zealand citizen: cl 836.111. The terms ‘relative’, ‘Australian permanent resident’ and ‘eligible New Zealand citizen’ are defined in reg 1.03 of the Regulations. There is a copy of the carer visa application made by the applicant in the Department file. In the application, the applicant claimed to be the carer of his sister, who was an Australian citizen by grant, as evidenced by a copy of her passport provided to the Department. After having regard to the above, I was satisfied that at the time of application the applicant claimed to be the carer of an Australian relative and met the requirements of cl.836.212. Were the sponsorship requirements met at the time of application? Clause 836.213 requires that at the time of application, the applicant is sponsored by the Australian relative, or the spouse (or de facto partner, where applicable) of the Australian relative, who has turned 18. If sponsored by the spouse or de facto partner, the spouse or de facto partner must cohabit with the Australian relative and must be an Australian citizen, permanent resident or eligible New Zealand citizen. For these purposes, ‘relative’, ‘Australian permanent resident’ and ‘eligible New Zealand citizen’ are defined in reg 1.03 of the Regulations. ‘Spouse’ is defined in reg 1.15A (for visa applications made before 1 July 2009) and s 5F of the Act (for visa applications made after that date, whilst ‘de-facto’ partner is defined in s 5CB of the Act).
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
The applicant has travelled to and from Australia on numerous occasions since 2005 on various Tourist, Visitor and E visas. CONSIDERATION OF CLAIMS AND EVIDENCE The applicants’ representative provided additional documents to the Tribunal, including but not limited to the following: a Bupa Carer Visa Report, dated [in] February 2021, which gave [Sister A] a total impairment rating of 40 points, a medical report regarding [Sister A] by [Doctor A], palliative care advanced trainee at [a named] Local Health District, dated 27 April 2021, a copy of [Sister A’s] death certificate, and written submissions by the applicants’ representative. Whether the applicant claimed to be the ‘carer’ at the time of application Clause 836.212 of the Regulations requires that the applicant claims to be the carer of an Australian relative. In the present case, the visa application was made on the basis that the applicant was the carer of his sister, [Sister A]. For the purposes of a Carer visa, ‘Australian relative’ is defined as a relative of the visa applicant who is an Australian citizen, an Australian permanent resident, or an eligible New Zealand citizen: cl 836.111. The terms ‘relative’, ‘Australian permanent resident’ and ‘eligible New Zealand citizen’ are defined in reg 1.03 of the Regulations. There is a copy of the carer visa application made by the applicant in the Department file. In the application, the applicant claimed to be the carer of his sister, who was an Australian citizen by grant, as evidenced by a copy of her passport provided to the Department. After having regard to the above, I was satisfied that at the time of application the applicant claimed to be the carer of an Australian relative and met the requirements of cl.836.212. Were the sponsorship requirements met at the time of application? Clause 836.213 requires that at the time of application, the applicant is sponsored by the Australian relative, or the spouse (or de facto partner, where applicable) of the Australian relative, who has turned 18. If sponsored by the spouse or de facto partner, the spouse or de facto partner must cohabit with the Australian relative and must be an Australian citizen, permanent resident or eligible New Zealand citizen. For these purposes, ‘relative’, ‘Australian permanent resident’ and ‘eligible New Zealand citizen’ are defined in reg 1.03 of the Regulations. ‘Spouse’ is defined in reg 1.15A (for visa applications made before 1 July 2009) and s 5F of the Act (for visa applications made after that date, whilst ‘de-facto’ partner is defined in s 5CB of the Act). As noted above, the delegate refused the visa on 28 May 2020 on the basis that the sponsor (the applicant’s daughter), was not the person requiring care (the applicant’s sister). The applicants’ representative submitted that the delegate incorrectly construed the meaning and legal confines of ‘the Australian relative’ referred to within cl.836.213 as it is taken to be the Australian relative referred to within cl.836.212. She submitted that the applicant is sponsored by his daughter, [Daughter A], who is an Australian citizen. As a daughter falls within the definition of ‘close relative’, the applicant is sponsored by an Australian relative. The applicants’ representative submitted that the applicant met cl.836.213 when the delegate made her decision.
Decision
Reasons for decision
Consequently, I find that the applicant was sponsored at the time of application as required and met cl.836.213.Whether the applicant is the carer of an Australian relative at the time of this decision Clause 836.221 requires that at the time of this decision, the applicant is a carer of the Australian relative (or ‘resident’). The term ‘carer’ is defined in reg 1.15AA of the Regulations which is set out in the attachment to this Decision. The applicants’ representative acknowledged in her written submissions dated 8 July 2024 that the applicant cannot meet this clause because his sister died in 2021. I agree and find that the applicant is not the carer of an Australian relative at the time of this decision. Consequently, the applicant does not satisfy cl.836.221.Conclusions For the reasons above, the applicant does not meet the criteria for a Subclass 836 visa. I also find that the applicant is not entitled to the grant of the Subclass 838 (Aged Dependent Relative) visa. There is no evidence that the applicant is dependent upon an Australian relative as required by the definition of ‘aged dependent relative’ in reg 1.03. Therefore cl.838.212 is not met. Furthermore, I find that the applicant is not entitled to the grant of Subclass 835 (Remaining Relative) visa as many of the applicant’s near relatives, as defined in reg 1.15(2), reside in the same country as the applicant. According to the application, [most] of the applicant’s adult children and one of his sisters live in Sweden. As such, the applicant is not a ‘remaining relative’ and is therefore unable to meet cl.835.212.Secondary applicant For the secondary applicant to be entitled to a visa under cl.836.321, she must continue to be a member of the family unit of a person who satisfies the primary criteria in subdivision 836.2. As the Tribunal has found that the applicant does not meet cl.836.221, the secondary applicant does not meet the requirements of cl.836.321. Request for Ministerial Intervention The applicants’ representative requested that the Tribunal refer the matter to the Department for consideration by the Minister pursuant to s 351 of the Act, which gives the Minister discretion to substitute a decision of the Tribunal with another decision that is more favourable to the applicant, if the Minister considers that it is in the public interest to do so. The applicants’ representative submitted that the following circumstances are unique and exceptional in this case:·The applicant cared for his sister until her death, which caused him trauma.·The applicant’s daughter was eligible to sponsor the applicant. If the applicant’s sister had not died, there was a chance that the applicant may have been granted the subclass 836 visa. ·The applicant has substantial family ties in Australia.·The applicant and his wife are in their [age range], and it would be harsh for them to reside offshore away from their close family in Australia. I have considered the above submissions and the Ministerial Guidelines relating to the discretionary power set out in the Department’s Procedural Advice Manual (PAM3). I was mindful of the extensive delays in the review process and that the applicant’s sister died approximately one year after the application was lodged to the Tribunal. The illness and subsequent death of the applicant’s sister undoubtedly caused the applicant and other members of the family considerable distress.