Nguyen (Migration)

Link copied
Case Copied 19 min read

Nguyen (Migration) [2022] AATA 5237 (20 December 2022)

DECISION RECORD

DIVISION:Migration & Refugee Division

APPLICANT:  Ms Thi Ve Nguyen

REPRESENTATIVE:  Ms Pamela Nhi Tieu

CASE NUMBER:  2208343

HOME AFFAIRS REFERENCE(S):          CLF2014/81293

MEMBER:Deputy President Justin Owen

DATE:20 December 2022

PLACE OF DECISION:  Sydney

DECISION:The Tribunal affirms the decision not to grant the applicant an Other Family (Residence) (Class BU) visa.

Statement made on 20 December 2022 at 11:24am

CATCHWORDS
MIGRATION – Other Family (Residence) (Class BU) visa – Subclass 836 (Carer) – Federal Court remittal – ‘carer’ of the Australian relative – Australian relative requiring care deceased – compelling and compassionate circumstances – lengthy legal process – request for Ministerial referral declined – decision under review affirmed

LEGISLATION
Migration Act 1958 (Cth), ss 65, 351
Migration Regulations 1994 (Cth), rr 1.12, 1.15AA; Schedule 2, cls 836.212, 836.213, 836.221

CASES
Nguyen v MICMSMA [2020] FCA 1732

STATEMENT OF DECISION AND REASONS

APPLICATION FOR REVIEW

  1. This is an application for review of a decision made by a delegate of the Minister for Home Affairs on 20 May 2022 to refuse to grant the review applicant an Other Family (Residence) (Class BU) visa under s 65 of the Migration Act 1958 (Cth) (the Act).

  2. The applicant applied for the visa on 28 May 2014. At that time, Class BU contained three subclasses, Subclass 835 (Remaining Relative); Subclass 836 (Carer) and Subclass 838 (Aged Dependent Relative: item 1123B of Schedule 1 to the Migration Regulations 1994 (Cth) (the Regulations)). In the present case, the applicant is seeking to satisfy the criteria for the grant of a Subclass 836 visa. The criteria for a Subclass 836 visa are set out in Part 836 of Schedule 2 to the Regulations. Relevantly to this matter, the primary criteria to be met include cl 836.221.

  3. The delegate refused to grant the visa on the basis that cl 836.221 was not met because the applicant did not meet reg 1.12(e)(ii), and subsequently did not meet reg 1.15AA(1)(b)(i).

  4. On 23 February 2016, a differently-constituted Tribunal upheld the delegate’s refusal of the application.  The Tribunal found the applicant met reg 1.15AA(1)(b), but was not satisfied the assistance provided by the applicant to the Australian relative could not reasonably be provided by a relevant relative, or obtained from welfare, hospital, nursing or community services, and found therefore that the requirements of reg 1.15AA(1)(e) were not met. The Tribunal notes reg 1.15AA(1)(e) was not considered by the delegate.  

  5. The applicant applied for review of the differently-constituted Tribunal’s decision in the Federal Circuit Court.  It was argued before the Federal Circuit Court that the Tribunal had committed jurisdictional error in construing and applying reg 1.15AA(1)(e). On 28 February 2017, the Court quashed the Tribunal’s decision of 23 February 2016 and issued a writ of mandamus directed to the Tribunal requiring it to reconsider and determine the applicant’s application for review made on 28 October 2014 according to law.

  6. The Minister appealed the Court’s decision to the Federal Court.  On 20 September…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Nguyen (Migration) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2022] AATA 5237
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Administrative Appeals Tribunal considered the application of Ms Nguyen for an Other Family (Residence) (Class BU) visa, specifically a Subclass 836 (Carer) visa. The applicant's claim was based on her alleged role in caring for her sister, who in turn was caring for their mother, Ms Thi Noa Nguyen. However, the central issue before the Tribunal was that the Australian relative requiring care, Ms Thi Noa Nguyen, had passed away prior to the decision being made.

The primary legal issue before the Tribunal was whether the applicant met the criteria for a Subclass 836 visa, particularly the requirement under clause 836.221 that the applicant be a "carer" of the Australian relative at the time of the decision. The Tribunal also considered whether the applicant met the criteria for a Subclass 838 (Aged Dependent Relative) visa and a Subclass 835 (Remaining Relative) visa.

The Tribunal reasoned that the definition of "carer" under regulation 1.15AA of the Migration Regulations 1994 necessitates that the person requiring care be alive at the time of the decision. As the applicant's mother had deceased, the applicant could not, at the time of the decision, be a carer of her late mother, nor could she be providing assistance to her sister in caring for their mother. Consequently, the applicant failed to satisfy clause 836.221. Regarding the other visa subclasses, the Tribunal found the applicant was not old enough for the Aged Dependent Relative visa and had near relatives residing outside Australia, thus not meeting the criteria for a Remaining Relative visa. The Tribunal also considered the applicant's circumstances in relation to Ministerial intervention guidelines but determined not to refer the matter to the Minister.

The Tribunal affirmed the decision not to grant the applicant an Other Family (Residence) (Class BU) visa.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

For the following reasons, the Tribunal has concluded that the decision under review should be affirmed.CONSIDERATION OF CLAIMS AND EVIDENCE The applicant applied for the visa on the basis that her sponsor and sister, Ms Thi Huyen Nguyen, requires assistance in providing care to the sponsor’s (and applicant’s ) mother Ms Thi Noa Nguyen. The issue before the Tribunal is the member of the family unit requiring care, Ms Thi Noa Nguyen, deceased on 11 May 2019. Whether the applicant is a carer Clause 836.221 requires that at the time of decision, the applicant is a carer of the Australian relative (or ‘resident’). The term ‘carer’ is defined in reg 1.15AA of the Regulations which is set out in the attachment to this Decision. At the Tribunal’s hearing of 14 December 2022, the applicant confirmed orally that her mother the Australian relative (or ‘resident’) requiring care deceased on 11 May 2019. The Tribunal explained that there were time of application and time of decision criteria that needed to be satisfied in order to meet the requirements for the grant of the visa. The Tribunal noted that the applicant could not, at the time of decision, be the carer of a person that was deceased, and could not obviously be providing assistance to her sister and sponsor in providing care to the sponsor’s mother Ms Thi Hoa Nguyen given her death on 11 May 2019. Given these findings, at the time of decision the applicant is not a carer of the Australian relative, being her late mother Ms Hoa Thi Nguyen, and therefore does not satisfy cl 836.221. For the reasons above, the applicant does not meet the criteria for a Subclass 836 visa. In respect of the other visa subclasses, there is no material which would permit a finding that the applicant meets prescribed criteria for the visa sought. The evidence before the Tribunal is that the applicant was born on 15 June 1962. The Tribunal finds that the applicant is not entitled to the grant of Subclass 838 (Aged Dependent Relative) visa as the applicant is not old enough to be granted an age pension under the Social Security Act1991 (Cth). Therefore, the Tribunal is not satisfied that the applicant meets the definition of ‘aged dependent relative’ in reg 1.03 for the purposes of cl 838.212 of Schedule 2 to the Regulations. The Tribunal finds that the applicant is not entitled to the grant of a Subclass 835 (Remaining Relative) visa. The test in reg 1.15(1) is about whether the applicant is the remaining relative of the Australian citizen, in this case her sister, the sponsor. The Tribunal has considered whether the applicant’s sponsor is the sister of the applicant; whether the applicant’s sister is usually resident in Australia; and relevantly whether the applicant has no near relatives other than near relatives who are usually resident in Australia and Australian citizens, Australian permanent residents or eligible New Zealand citizens. The applicant stated at the Tribunal’s hearing that she has four adult married children aged between 33 and 40 years of age that live in Vietnam. As the applicant has children who are not Australian citizens, Australian permanent residents or eligible New Zealand citizens who are usually resident in Australia, it appears she has a near relative as per reg 1.15(2)(b)(i) and is therefore not a remaining relative as per reg 1.15(1). As such, the applicant is not a ‘remaining relative’ and therefore is unable to meet cl 835.212.Ministerial Intervention

Decision

Reasons for decision

Having regard to the applicant’s circumstances, and having considered the Ministerial guidelines relating to the Minister’s discretionary power under s.351, set out in the Department’s Procedures Advice Manual (PAM3), the Tribunal has determined not to refer the matter to the Department, to be brought to the Minister’s attention. The Tribunal notes of course that the applicant retains the ability to make her own request directly to the Minister. DECISION The Tribunal affirms the decision not to grant the applicant an Other Family (Residence) (Class BU) visa.Justin OwenDeputy PresidentATTACHMENTMigration Regulations 19941.15AA Carer1.15AA (1)An applicant for a visa is a carer of a person who is an Australian citizen usually resident in Australia, an Australian permanent resident or an eligible New Zealand citizen (the resident) if:(a)the applicant is a relative of the resident; and(b)according to a certificate that meets the requirements of subregulation (2):(i)a person (being the resident or a member of the family unit of the resident) has a medical condition; and(ii)the medical condition is causing physical, intellectual or sensory impairment of the ability of that person to attend to the practical aspects of daily life; and(iii)the impairment has, under the Impairment Tables (within the meaning of subsection 23(1) of the Social Security Act 1991), the rating that is specified in the certificate; and(iv)because of the medical condition, the person has, and will continue for at least 2 years to have, a need for direct assistance in attending to the practical aspects of daily life; and(ba)the person mentioned in subparagraph (b)(i) is an Australian citizen, an Australian permanent resident or an eligible New Zealand citizen; and(c)the rating mentioned in subparagraph (b)(iii) is equal to, or exceeds, the impairment rating specified in a legislative instrument made by the Minister for this paragraph; and(d)if the person to whom the certificate relates is not the resident, the resident has a permanent or long-term need for assistance in providing the direct assistance mentioned in subparagraph (b)(iv); and(e)the assistance cannot reasonably be:(i)provided by any other relative of the resident, being a relative who is an Australian citizen, an Australian permanent resident or an eligible New Zealand citizen; or(ii)obtained from welfare, hospital, nursing or community services in Australia; and(f)the applicant is willing and able to provide to the resident substantial and continuing assistance of the kind needed under subparagraph (b)(iv) or paragraph (d), as the case requires.(2)A certificate meets the requirements of this subregulation if:(a)it is a certificate:(i)in relation to a medical assessment carried out on behalf of a health service provider specified by the Minister in an instrument in writing; and(ii)signed by the medical adviser who carried it out; or(b)it is a certificate issued by a health service provider specified by the Minister in an instrument in writing in relation to a review of an opinion in a certificate mentioned in paragraph (a), that was carried out by the health services provider in accordance with its procedures.(3)The Minister is to take the opinion in a certificate that meets the requirements of subregulation (2) on a matter mentioned in paragraph (1)(b) to be correct for the purposes of deciding whether an applicant satisfies a criterion that the applicant is a carer.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.