Nguyen and Australian Community Pharmacy Authority

Link copied
Case Copied 13 min read

Nguyen and Australian Community Pharmacy Authority [2015] AATA 555 (30 July 2015)

Division General Division

File Number(s)

2015/1567

Re

John Nguyen

APPLICANT

And

Australian Community Pharmacy Authority

RESPONDENT

INTERLOCUTORY DECISION

Tribunal

Deputy President J W Constance

Date 30 July 2015
Place

Sydney

IT IS DIRECTED that, in accordance with section 30(1A) of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth), Mr Ranallo is to be joined as a party to the application for review.

................................[sgd]........................................

Deputy President J W Constance

Catchwords

PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – joinder - application to supply pharmaceutical benefits from particular premises – nearby pharmacy – consideration of whether interests are affected by decision under review - whether competitor should be joined as a party

Legislation

Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth) ss 30(1A), 31(1)
National Health Act 1953 (Cth)
National Health (Australian Community Pharmacy Authority Rules) Determination 2011

Cases

Alphapharm Pty Limited v Smithkline Beecham (Australia) Pty Limited and Anor [1994] FCA 996

Re Control Investments Pty Ltd v Australian Broadcasting Tribunal (1980) 50 FLR 1

Edwards v. Australian Securities Commission & Ors [1997] FCA 38.

United States Tobacco Company v Minister for Consumer Affairs and Ors (1988) 20 FCR 520

Walkerden v Wodonga Pharmacy Pty Ltd [2015] FCA 273

REASONS FOR INTERLOCUTORY DECISION

INTRODUCTION

  1. In September 2014, Mr Nguyen lodged an application under the National Health Act 1953 (Cth) for approval to supply pharmaceutical benefits from premises in Canning Vale, Western Australia.

  2. In accordance with procedures set out in the Act, the application was referred to the Australian Community Pharmacy Authority.  The role of the Authority is to recommend to the Secretary of the Department of Health that such an application be either approved or not approved.

  3. In February 2015, the Authority recommended to the Secretary that Mr Nguyen’s application not be approved.  On 2 April 2015, Mr Nguyen applied to this tribunal to review the Authority’s decision.

  4. Mr Ranallo is the owner of a pharmacy which is situated approximately 3.5 kilometres from the premises in Canning Vale at which Mr Nguyen is seeking to be authorised to supply pharmaceutical benefits.  On 21 May 2015, Mr Ranallo applied for an order making him a party to these proceedings.  Mr Nguyen opposes the making of such an order.

    LEGISLATION30 JULY 2015

  5. Subsection 30(1A) of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth) provides:

    Where an application has been made by a person to the Tribunal for a review of a decision, any other person whose interests are affected by the decision may apply, in writing, to the Tribunal to be made a party to the proceeding, and the Tribunal may, in its discretion, by order, make that person a party to the proceeding.

  6. Subsection 31(1) provides:

    Where it is necessary for the purposes of this Act to decide whether the interests of a person are affected by a decision, that matter shall be decided by the Tribunal and, if the Tribunal decides that the interests of a person are affected by a decision, the decision…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Nguyen and Australian Community Pharmacy Authority and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2015] AATA 555
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the matter of Nguyen v Australian Community Pharmacy Authority, the Federal Circuit Court was called upon to determine whether Mr. Ranallo, a nearby pharmacy owner, should be joined as a party to the appeal proceedings against a decision made by the Australian Community Pharmacy Authority. The decision in question pertained to an application by Mr. Nguyen to supply pharmaceutical benefits from a particular premises. Mr. Ranallo sought to intervene in the appeal on the basis that the establishment of a new pharmacy by Mr. Nguyen would negatively impact the profitability and value of his existing pharmacy business.

The primary legal issue before the court was whether Mr. Ranallo's interests were sufficiently affected by the decision under review to warrant his joinder as a party in the proceedings. This required the court to consider the definition of "interests" as it appeared in subsection 30(1A) of the relevant Act and to determine if the interests of Mr. Ranallo were indeed affected by the decision to refuse Mr. Nguyen's application. Additionally, the court needed to assess whether there were any valid reasons under subsection 30(1A) to refuse Mr. Ranallo's application to join the proceedings.

The court examined the statutory language and found that the term "interests" was not qualified, suggesting that it was not necessary for Mr. Ranallo to demonstrate that his interests were adversely affected by the decision under review. However, it was crucial that Mr. Ranallo could show that it was the decision under review that affected his interests, not any potential decision the Tribunal might make. The court also noted that Mr. Ranallo's interests were not affected because the Authority had recommended refusal of Mr. Nguyen's application, thereby maintaining the status quo. Furthermore, the court concluded that even if Mr. Ranallo's interests were affected, the Tribunal had the discretion to refuse his application to be joined, based on factors such as the potential increase in costs, Mr. Ranallo's alignment with the Authority's position, and the lack of substantive contribution he could make to the proceedings.

Ultimately, the court determined that Mr. Ranallo's application to be joined as a party should be refused. The reasoning included the potential for increased costs, Mr. Ranallo's alignment with the Authority, and the lack of substantive contribution he could make to the proceedings. The court also highlighted that the Authority had not regarded Mr. Ranallo's views as relevant during its initial consideration of the application.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

It was put on behalf of Mr Nguyen that Mr Ranallo must show that his interests are affected by the decision under review, rather than any decision the Tribunal may make in exercising its power to review. It is insufficient for Mr Ranallo to show that his interests may be adversely affected by a decision of the Tribunal recommending that Mr Nguyen’s application be granted. As the Authority recommended that Mr Nguyen’s application be refused, the status quo has not changed so far as Mr Ranallo is concerned. Further it was argued that consideration of the relevant provisions of the National Health Act indicates that Mr Ranallo’s interests are not affected. Section 105AD of the Act permits an application to be made to the Tribunal only when the Authority recommends that an application to supply pharmaceutical benefits be refused; there is no right to seek review given to any person or body corporate adversely affected by the decision. If Mr Ranallo’s application to be joined is successful he will enjoy a right to oppose Mr Nguyen’s application which he did not have when the matter was being considered by this Authority. Finally, it was put that even if I am satisfied that Mr Ranallo’s interests are affected, subsection 30(1A) clearly gives the Tribunal a discretion refuse his application. The reasons the Tribunal should exercise the discretion given to it were stated to be:(a)the joinder of a further party would increase the costs associated with the proceedings;(b)Mr Ranallo ultimately seeks to support the position of the Authority; the Authority is in a position to advance its position without the support of Mr Ranallo;(c)Mr Ranallo cannot add anything of substance to the proceedings as the primary issue in dispute turns on the interpretation of the term “supermarket” and the location of a supermarket within a certain distance of the proposed premises; and(d)The Respondent did not regard the views of Mr Ranallo as relevant when considering the application; a number of pharmacy owners were invited to comment on the application however not Mr Ranallo.ReasoningIs Mr Ranallo a person whose interests are affected by the decision under review? The first step is to look to the words used in subsection 30(1A). It provides that any person (other than the Applicant) “whose interests are affected” may apply to be made a party. It is important to note that the word “interests” is not qualified. This suggests that it is not necessarily a requirement of the subsection that an applicant to be joined as a party show that his or her interests were adversely affected by the decision under review. It is clear however that the applicant must show that it is the decision under review, rather than any decision that this Tribunal may make, which affects his or her interests. In Edwards v. Australian Securities Commission & Ors[2] the Full Court of the Federal Court considered an appeal from a decision of this Tribunal. The decision of the Tribunal was that the appellant was not entitled to apply to the Tribunal for a review of the Commission’s decision to register a company as a foreign corporation under the Corporations Law. The Tribunal had decided that the appellant was not a person whose interests were affected by the decision under review. The application to the Tribunal was made under section 27 of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth) rather than under section 30, but the relevant wording of each section is the same.[2] [1997] FCA 38.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Subsection 31(1) provides:Where it is necessary for the purposes of this Act to decide whether the interests of a person are affected by a decision, that matter shall be decided by the Tribunal and, if the Tribunal decides that the interests of a person are affected by a decision, the decision of the Tribunal is conclusive.CONSIDERATIONThe grounds of Mr Ranallo’s application In his application, Mr Ranallo stated:… if the Applicant’s appeal against the decision of the Respondent is upheld by the Tribunal and the proposed pharmacy is established, it is likely that the Applicant’s proposed pharmacy will have a significant negative impact on the profitability and value of Mr Ranallo’s existing pharmacy business.[1][1] Application to be made a Party to a Proceeding, filed 21 May 2015.Mr Nguyen’s argument It was put on behalf of Mr Nguyen that Mr Ranallo must show that his interests are affected by the decision under review, rather than any decision the Tribunal may make in exercising its power to review. It is insufficient for Mr Ranallo to show that his interests may be adversely affected by a decision of the Tribunal recommending that Mr Nguyen’s application be granted. As the Authority recommended that Mr Nguyen’s application be refused, the status quo has not changed so far as Mr Ranallo is concerned. Further it was argued that consideration of the relevant provisions of the National Health Act indicates that Mr Ranallo’s interests are not affected. Section 105AD of the Act permits an application to be made to the Tribunal only when the Authority recommends that an application to supply pharmaceutical benefits be refused; there is no right to seek review given to any person or body corporate adversely affected by the decision. If Mr Ranallo’s application to be joined is successful he will enjoy a right to oppose Mr Nguyen’s application which he did not have when the matter was being considered by this Authority. Finally, it was put that even if I am satisfied that Mr Ranallo’s interests are affected, subsection 30(1A) clearly gives the Tribunal a discretion refuse his application. The reasons the Tribunal should exercise the discretion given to it were stated to be:(a)the joinder of a further party would increase the costs associated with the proceedings;(b)Mr Ranallo ultimately seeks to support the position of the Authority; the Authority is in a position to advance its position without the support of Mr Ranallo;(c)Mr Ranallo cannot add anything of substance to the proceedings as the primary issue in dispute turns on the interpretation of the term “supermarket” and the location of a supermarket within a certain distance of the proposed premises; and(d)The Respondent did not regard the views of Mr Ranallo as relevant when considering the application; a number of pharmacy owners were invited to comment on the application however not Mr Ranallo.ReasoningIs Mr Ranallo a person whose interests are affected by the decision under review?