Jaworski and Australian Information Commissioner (Practice and procedure)

Link copied
Case Copied 10 min read

Jaworski and Australian Information Commissioner (Practice and procedure) [2025] ARTA 1847 (8 September 2025)

Applicant/s:  Gerald Jaworski

Respondent:  Australian Information Commissioner

Tribunal Number:                2025/1424

Tribunal:General Member J Ross

Place:Canberra

Date: 8 September 2025

The Tribunal by order DIRECTS:

1.Under 22(1)(c) of the Administrative Review Tribunal Act 2024 (Cth) that Chartered Accountants Australia and New Zealand be made a party to the proceedings.

And the Tribunal NOTES that a further interlocutory hearing is to be scheduled to consider the interim orders issued under s 70(2) of the ART Act on 19 June 2025.

................[SGD]...............

General Member J Ross

Catchwords

PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – joinder – interests affected – whether reasonable delay in making joinder application – nature of business interests of affected party – consequence of delay to proceeding – whether ulterior purpose of joinder application – joinder granted

Legislation

Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth) s 30(1A)

Administrative Review Tribunal Act 2024 (Cth) s 22(1)(c)

Cases

‘ATP’ and ART; (Privacy) [2025] AICmr 18

Re Davey and Australian Electoral Commission (2013) 137 ALD 184; [2013] AATA 794

Nguyen and Australian Community Pharmacy Authority [2015] AATA 555
Peters and Department of Health and Aged Care (1999) 56 ALD 561
Sanwa Pty Ltd, Comptroller-General of Customs, Austube Mills Pty Ltd [2019] AATA 5166

Secondary Materials

L Holcombe, Australian Administrative Law, LexisNexis, Sydney

Revised Explanatory Memorandum to the Administrative Review Tribunal Bill 2024

Statement of Reasons

INTRODUCTION

  1. On 17 July 2025, Chartered Accountants Australia and New Zealand (CA ANZ or Joinder Applicant) applied to be made a party to this review application pursuant to s 22(1)(c) of the Administrative Review Tribunal Act 2024 (Cth) (ART Act). The Joinder Applicant was the respondent to the privacy complaint. The reason provided in the application to be made a party is that the Joinder Applicant was the ‘other party’ to the Reviewable Decision.

  2. The Respondent does not oppose the joinder and the Applicant opposes it.

  3. The proceedings before the Tribunal involve a review of a determination made by the
    Australian Information Commissioner (IC) on 23 January 2025, dismissing the Applicant’s complaint that CA ANZ had interfered with his privacy (Reviewable Decision).

  4. On 18 August 2025, the Tribunal heard the joinder application. The Tribunal has considered the written submissions of the Applicant, the Respondent’s Decision dated 23 January 2025 and the oral submissions made during the hearing by the Joinder Applicant and the Applicant.

    RELEVANT LEGISLATIVE PROVISIONS

  5. Section 22(1)(c) of the ART Act provides any other person can become a party to a proceeding for review by the Tribunal of a decision if:

    (i) the person applies to the Tribunal to become a party to the proceeding; and

    (ii) the Tribunal is satisfied that the person’s interests are affected by the decision; and

    (iii) the Tribunal considers it appropriate that the person become a party to the proceeding.

    POSITION OF THE PARTIES

    Joinder Applicant

  6. In the hearing, it was confirmed by Counsel for the Joinder Applicant…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Jaworski and Australian Information Commissioner (Practice a... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2025] ARTA 1847
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Jaworski and Australian Information Commissioner (Practice and procedure), the Australian Information Commissioner is reviewing a decision that dismissed the Applicant's complaint regarding privacy interference by CA ANZ. The proceedings involve a joinder application by CA ANZ, seeking to become a party to the review. The Applicant opposed the joinder application, arguing that CA ANZ's involvement would complicate the proceedings and that its motivations may not be bona fide. The Tribunal considered the written submissions of the Applicant and the oral submissions made during the hearing by the Joinder Applicant and the Applicant.

The primary legal issues before the Tribunal were whether CA ANZ's interests were affected by the decision under review and whether it was appropriate to exercise the discretion to add CA ANZ as a party to the proceeding. The Tribunal examined previous Tribunal decisions, which held that it is not necessary for the Joinder Applicant to show that their interests may be adversely affected by the decision under review. The Tribunal concluded that CA ANZ's interests were indeed affected by the decision and that it was appropriate to exercise the discretion to add CA ANZ as a party to the proceeding.

The Tribunal granted the joinder application, finding that CA ANZ had an interest affected by the decision under review and that it was appropriate to exercise the discretion to add CA ANZ as a party to the proceeding. The Tribunal considered the arguments presented by the Applicant but ultimately determined that CA ANZ's involvement was necessary to protect its interests and assist the Tribunal with the consideration of any fresh evidence.

The final orders of the Tribunal were that CA ANZ be granted leave to be joined as a party to the proceeding and that the review of the Reviewable Decision would proceed with CA ANZ as a party.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

The proceedings before the Tribunal involve a review of a determination made by the Australian Information Commissioner (IC) on 23 January 2025, dismissing the Applicant’s complaint that CA ANZ had interfered with his privacy (Reviewable Decision). On 18 August 2025, the Tribunal heard the joinder application. The Tribunal has considered the written submissions of the Applicant, the Respondent’s Decision dated 23 January 2025 and the oral submissions made during the hearing by the Joinder Applicant and the Applicant. RELEVANT LEGISLATIVE PROVISIONS Section 22(1)(c) of the ART Act provides any other person can become a party to a proceeding for review by the Tribunal of a decision if:(i) the person applies to the Tribunal to become a party to the proceeding; and(ii) the Tribunal is satisfied that the person’s interests are affected by the decision; and(iii) the Tribunal considers it appropriate that the person become a party to the proceeding.POSITION OF THE PARTIESJoinder Applicant In the hearing, it was confirmed by Counsel for the Joinder Applicant that CA ANZ was the respondent to the Reviewable Decision. Several reasons were provided by Counsel for the application including the need to ensure the Joinder Applicant can protect its interests and to assist the Tribunal with the consideration of any fresh evidence. In relation to the latter reason, it was claimed that the Respondent is not as well placed to provide the Tribunal with this assistance. Counsel for the Joinder Applicant referred the Tribunal to two previous Tribunal decisions – Sanwa Pty Ltd, Comptroller-General of Customs, Austube Mills Pty Ltd[1] and Peters and Department of Health and Aged Care (1999) 56 ALD 561 – which I will consider in more detail below. [1] [2019] AATA 5166.Applicant The Applicant opposed the application on several grounds. His written submission is extracted in full below.(i)‘The complaint to the ART relates to the decision made by the Respondent who does not need any support from CA ANZ.(ii)The involvement by CA ANZ is likely to obfuscate/complicate the proceedings to befuddle the ART, as CA ANZ succeeded in doing with the Respondent.(iii)CA ANZ’s track record points to a significant lack of bona fides, including colluding with the Respondent to hide information from both the public and the complainant/applicant.(iv)CA ANZ’s involvement would give rise to a double breach of directors’ fiduciary duties (i.e. the duty to be free of conflict (since the privacy breach was driven by the CA ANZ board which continues to have the same chair) and the duty to use the corporation’s resources for a proper purpose (since members have not ratified use of expensive lawyers by the directors to protect their personal interests)).(v)Any action by the CA ANZ controlling officers to hinder or quash a proper investigation would be ultra vires the purpose of the corporation which is to uphold the highest standards of transparency, accountability and integrity as a self-regulated conduct review body.(vi)The HSF lawyers used by the controlling officers are also not free of personal conflict since they were involved in supporting the directors to (alleged unlawfully) quash the 38 member requisitions at the heart of the dispute.(vii)The allegations against the Respondent include a failure to recognise and properly deal with the misleading nature of the information provided by CA ANZ and its lawyers which is now exacerbated through the conspiracy of secrecy which has come to light during the preliminary stage of this ART proceeding.(viii)Further to point 7, I suspect that the secret information includes information which is misleading and this may be exposed through revealing that information (noting that misleading the Privacy Commissioner is a criminal offence under section 65(3) of the Privacy Act). In other words, the participation by CA ANZ in this proceeding may be motivated by a desire to continue hiding incriminating material.’CONSIDERATION

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Applicant opposed the application on several grounds. His written submission is extracted in full below.(i)‘The complaint to the ART relates to the decision made by the Respondent who does not need any support from CA ANZ.(ii)The involvement by CA ANZ is likely to obfuscate/complicate the proceedings to befuddle the ART, as CA ANZ succeeded in doing with the Respondent.(iii)CA ANZ’s track record points to a significant lack of bona fides, including colluding with the Respondent to hide information from both the public and the complainant/applicant.(iv)CA ANZ’s involvement would give rise to a double breach of directors’ fiduciary duties (i.e. the duty to be free of conflict (since the privacy breach was driven by the CA ANZ board which continues to have the same chair) and the duty to use the corporation’s resources for a proper purpose (since members have not ratified use of expensive lawyers by the directors to protect their personal interests)).(v)Any action by the CA ANZ controlling officers to hinder or quash a proper investigation would be ultra vires the purpose of the corporation which is to uphold the highest standards of transparency, accountability and integrity as a self-regulated conduct review body.(vi)The HSF lawyers used by the controlling officers are also not free of personal conflict since they were involved in supporting the directors to (alleged unlawfully) quash the 38 member requisitions at the heart of the dispute.(vii)The allegations against the Respondent include a failure to recognise and properly deal with the misleading nature of the information provided by CA ANZ and its lawyers which is now exacerbated through the conspiracy of secrecy which has come to light during the preliminary stage of this ART proceeding.(viii)Further to point 7, I suspect that the secret information includes information which is misleading and this may be exposed through revealing that information (noting that misleading the Privacy Commissioner is a criminal offence under section 65(3) of the Privacy Act). In other words, the participation by CA ANZ in this proceeding may be motivated by a desire to continue hiding incriminating material.’CONSIDERATION Section 22(1)(c) of the ART Act requires the Tribunal to consider two factors. The first is whether the Joinder Applicant has an interest affected by the decision. The second, which only comes into play if the Joinder Applicant has interests affected, is whether it is appropriate to exercise the discretion to add the person as a party to the proceeding. Whether CA ANZ is a person whose interests are affected by the decision under review Previous Tribunal decisions have held that it is not necessary for the Joinder Applicant to show that their interests may be adversely affected by the decision under review.[2] As noted by Deputy President Constance in Nguyen and Australian Community Pharmacy Authority the word ‘interests’ is not qualified in any way and, in reference to s 30(1A) of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth) (AAT Act), he concluded that there is nothing in the words of the section to suggest that it should be read down.[3] [2] Nguyen and Australian Community Pharmacy Authority [2015] AATA 555 at [17].[3] Ibid at [11] with reference to the Full Court of the Federal Court’s decision in United States Tobacco Company v Minister for Consumer Affairs and Ors [3] and in particular to the following at [527]: ‘The term “interest” has long been an expression used in the law with respect to parties so as to require an involvement with a case greater than the concern of a person who is a mere intermeddler or busybody. Nevertheless, the criterion for standing prescribed by the Act is not a restrictive one. The broadest of technical terms has been selected. The necessary interest need not be a legal, proprietary, financial or other tangible interest. Neither need it be peculiar to the particular person.’