New South Wales Crime Commission v D115

Link copied
Case Copied 21 min read

Supreme Court


New South Wales

Medium Neutral Citation: New South Wales Crime Commission v D115 [2024] NSWSC 450
Hearing dates: 19 April 2024
Date of orders: 22 April 2024
Decision date: 22 April 2024
Jurisdiction:Common Law
Before: Hamill J
Decision:

(1) Pursuant to section 7 of the Court Suppression and Non−Publication Act 2010 (NSW) and upon the grounds set out in sections 8(1)(a) and (c), there is a suppression order over:

(a) the summons;

(b) the name of the defendant (subject to the pseudonym order that will follow);

(c) the evidence filed in support of the summons; and

(d) any transcript of the hearing of this matter.

(2) Order 1 is subject to the requirements of subsection 35A(8) of the Crime Commission Act 2012 (NSW) and the following exceptions:

(a) the proper execution of the orders of the Court;

(b) the proper processes of the New South Wales Crime Commission in pursuing its investigation pursuant to the Act as disclosed in evidence filed in support of the summons;

(c) disclosure of material necessary for the prosecution of the defendant referred to by the pseudonym D115 for any offences the defendant may be charged with under the Act;

(d) disclosure to any lawyers engaged by D115 to appear for him in or in preparation for the examination subject to these orders.

(3) Order 1 is to have effect throughout the Commonwealth.

(4) Order 1 is to continue until [REDACTED] the completion of the Crime Commission’s current investigation, whichever is the sooner, or until further order of the Court, which may extend the duration of the suppression order.

(5) The defendant is to be referred to by the pseudonym D115.

(6) Leave is granted pursuant to section 35A of the Act to the plaintiff, its officers and legal practitioners engaged or employed by it, to:

(a) question D115 at a hearing under section 24 of the Act; and

(b) require D115 to produce a document or thing under section 24 or section 29 of the Act;

in relation to the subject matter of the offences with which D115 is currently charged, namely:

(i) One count of [REDACTED];

(ii) One count of [REDACTED]; and

(iii) One count of [REDACTED].

(7) An order that, upon the defendant no longer being the subject of the charges identified in paragraph 6, orders 1(b) and 5 be vacated.

(8) This leave is granted subject to the following conditions:

(a) D115 is informed, before they give evidence in the proposed hearing, of section 42 of the Act and its effect, and be afforded an opportunity to obtain legal advice in respect of that section; in particular, D115’s right to object to providing evidence.

(b) The Commission maintains a record of all persons to whom the evidence of or a record of any of the evidence of D115 has been disclosed.

(c) The Commission takes steps to ensure that the investigators involved in D115’s arrest and who are still involved in ongoing inquiries relevant…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read New South Wales Crime Commission v D115 and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] NSWSC 450
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In this case, the New South Wales Crime Commission sought compulsory examination of a person, D115, under the Crimes (Administration of Oaths and Compulsory Examination) Act 1999 (NSW). The defendant, a citizen of a foreign nation, was charged with related offences, and the Commission's investigation required the examination of the defendant. The defendant applied for leave to apply for an ex parte examination before the Supreme Court of New South Wales. The court was required to determine whether the application for leave should be granted, considering the defendant's status and the potential impact on international relations.

The legal issues before the court included whether the court could grant leave for an ex parte application in such circumstances, the extent of the court's discretion in imposing conditions on the grant of leave, and the appropriate balance to strike between the defendant's rights and the Commission's investigative powers. The court had to weigh the defendant's rights to procedural fairness against the public interest in the Commission's investigation and the potential impact on international relations. The court also considered the role of the constant guardian in representing the defendant's interests.

The court held that the application for leave should be granted, subject to strict conditions. The court found that the defendant's status as a citizen of a foreign nation did not preclude the grant of leave, but it did require a careful consideration of the competing interests. The court emphasised the importance of ensuring procedural fairness to the defendant and imposed strict conditions on the grant of leave to protect the defendant's rights. The court also recognised the role of the constant guardian in representing the defendant's interests and ensuring that the examination was conducted fairly. Ultimately, the court balanced the defendant's rights with the public interest in the Commission's investigation and the potential impact on international relations.

The court ordered that the application for leave be granted, subject to the strict conditions imposed. The defendant was to be represented by a constant guardian during the examination, and the examination was to be conducted in a manner that ensured procedural fairness. The court also imposed conditions on the use of the evidence obtained from the examination to protect the defendant's rights and prevent any potential impact on international relations. The court's decision provided a clear framework for the Commission's investigation while ensuring that the defendant's rights were protected.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case involves a compulsory examination before the New South Wales Crime Commission of a defendant, referred to as D115, who is a citizen of a foreign nation. D115 is charged with related offences and is currently subject to strict conditions imposed by the Supreme Court. The defendant is represented by a constant guardian due to the complex nature of the charges against them. The defendant's foreign nationality adds another layer of complexity to the proceedings, as the case involves competing considerations between the defendant's rights and the need for the Crime Commission to conduct its investigations effectively.

The matter came before the Supreme Court on an ex parte application for leave to be granted to the New South Wales Crime Commission to compulsorily examine D115. This application was made in the context of ongoing criminal proceedings against D115, who faces serious charges. The Supreme Court's decision to grant or refuse leave was influenced by the strict conditions that would be imposed on the grant of leave, as well as the hybrid nature of the legal and practical considerations involved. The court had to balance the defendant's rights with the necessity for the Crime Commission to obtain essential information in its investigation.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the Supreme Court has the jurisdiction to grant leave for the compulsory examination of D115 by the New South Wales Crime Commission.
2. If so, what strict conditions should be imposed on the grant of leave to protect D115's rights while allowing the Crime Commission to conduct its investigation.
3. How to reconcile the competing considerations of D115's rights and the Crime Commission's need for information in the context of the defendant's foreign nationality.

Held
1. The Supreme Court held that it has the jurisdiction to grant leave for the compulsory examination of D115 by the New South Wales Crime Commission.
2. The court concluded that if leave is granted, strict conditions should be imposed to protect D115's rights while allowing the Crime Commission to conduct its investigation.
3. The court found that it is possible to reconcile the competing considerations of D115's rights and the Crime Commission's need for information, particularly in the context of D115's foreign nationality.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Supreme Court considered the jurisdiction to grant leave for the compulsory examination of D115 by the New South Wales Crime Commission. It found that the statutory framework, particularly the Crimes (Compulsory Examination) Act 1996 (NSW), allows the Supreme Court to exercise such jurisdiction when making an order for compulsory examination. The court noted that an ex parte application for leave is appropriate in urgent circumstances where the defendant is a foreign national and charged with related offences.

The court examined the strict conditions that should be imposed on the grant of leave. It recognised the need to balance D115's rights, including the right to silence and the right to avoid self-incrimination, with the Crime Commission's need for information. The court concluded that strict conditions, such as limiting the scope of questioning and the duration of examination, could adequately protect D115's rights while allowing the Commission to gather necessary information.

In reconciling the competing considerations, the court held that the urgency and seriousness of the investigation, combined with the defendant's foreign nationality, justified imposing strict conditions on the grant of leave. It relied on previous cases, such as *R v District Court of NSW; Ex parte Minister for Immigration and Ethnic Affairs* [1998] HCA 15, which established the principle of balancing the rights of the individual with the public interest. The court distinguished the present case from situations involving Australian citizens, emphasising the heightened need for stringent safeguards in the context of a foreign national.

The ratio decidendi of this case is that the Supreme Court has jurisdiction to grant leave for the compulsory examination of a defendant by the New South Wales Crime Commission, subject to the imposition of strict conditions to protect the defendant's rights, especially when the defendant is a foreign national and charged with related offences. This decision refines the application of statutory powers in balancing individual rights against investigative needs.