New Image Photographics Pty Ltd v Fair Work Ombudsman

Link copied
Case Copied 51 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

New Image Photographics Pty Ltd v Fair Work Ombudsman [2013] FCA 1385

Citation: New Image Photographics Pty Ltd v Fair Work Ombudsman [2013] FCA 1385
Appeal from: Fair Work Ombudsman v New Image Photographics Pty Ltd (No.3) [2013] FCCA 1016
Fair Work Ombudsman v New Image Photographics Pty Ltd [2013] FMCA 227
Fair Work Ombudsman v New Image Photographics Pty Ltd (No.2) [2013] FCCA 209
Parties: NEW IMAGE PHOTOGRAPHICS PTY LTD (ACN 010 823 042) and BRYAN CHARLES BEDINGTON v FAIR WORK OMBUDSMAN
File number: QUD 271 of 2013
Judge: COLLIER J
Date of judgment: 17 December 2013
Catchwords:

INDUSTRIAL LAW – Federal Magistrate held appellants contravened civil penalty provisions in s 182(2) and s 185(2) Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) – whether Federal Magistrate erred in finding first appellant was employer of employee – principles relevant to identity of employer – where Federal Magistrate made adverse findings of credit against witnesses of appellant – whether Federal Magistrate erred in holding that appellants could not set off overpayment of ordinary pay to employee against underpayment of ordinary pay – principles in relation to set off of payments – no mutuality of overpayment and underpayment, designation of overpayment being referable to underpayment, or consent of employee to receive set off – whether multiple contraventions of civil penalty provisions or single course of conduct – Federal Magistrate correct to treat underpayment of ordinary rate of pay and underpayment of casual loading as distinct contraventions – whether Federal Magistrate correct to mitigate penalties by respondent media releases – whether use of “prosecution” in media releases misleading – whether evidence of impact of media releases on appellants necessary

PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – where Federal Magistrate refused appellants leave to file affidavit on first day of three day trial and refused to adjourn trial – whether trial Judge erred in refusal – case management principles in Aon Risk Australia Services Ltd v Australian National University (2009) 239 CLR 175 relevant to exercise of discretion – cogency of evidence in affidavit to outcome of trial

Legislation: Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) s 545
Fair Work (Transitional Provisions and Consequential Amendments) Act 2009 (Cth) item 5 of Sch 16
Workplace Relations Act 1996 (Cth) ss 719(6), 182(1), 185(1), 185(2)
Cases cited: Ahern v Deputy Commissioner of Taxation (Qld) (1987) 76 ALR 137 cited
Aon Risk Services Australia Ltd v Australian National University (2009) 239 CLR 175 applied
Australian Competition & Consumer Commission v Nissan Motor Co (Australia) Pty Ltd (1998) ATPR 41-660 cited
Cousins v Merringtons Pty Ltd (No 2) [2008] VSC 340 cited
Denham v Midland Employers Mutual Assurance Ltd [1955] 2 QB 437 cited
Fair Work Ombudsman v Land Choice Pty Ltd [2009] FMCA 1255 cited
Fair Work Ombudsman v Offshore Marine Services Pty Ltd [2012] FCA 498 cited
Foster v Faulkhead and Faulkhead Nominees Pty Ltd [2005] SAIRC 86 cited
House v The King (1936) 55 CLR 499 cited
McIver v Healey [2008] FCA 425 cited
Pearce v The…
CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read New Image Photographics Pty Ltd v Fair Work Ombudsman and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2013] FCA 1385
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of New Image Photographics Pty Ltd v Fair Work Ombudsman, the parties involved were New Image Photographics Pty Ltd and the Fair Work Ombudsman, who was acting on behalf of a former employee, Ms Keen. The dispute centered on whether New Image Photographics Pty Ltd had failed to pay Ms Keen the appropriate casual loading for her hours worked during her employment period from 3 April 2006 to 2 September 2009. The case was heard in the Federal Court of Australia. The primary legal issues in this case were whether the Federal Magistrate was correct in denying the appellants leave to file an additional affidavit and to adjourn the trial, and whether there was sufficient evidence to support a finding that New Image Photographics Pty Ltd had failed to pay Ms Keen the correct casual loading. The court found that the Federal Magistrate's decisions regarding the additional affidavit and the adjournment of the trial were within his discretion and were justified by the need to manage the proceedings and avoid unnecessary disruption. Additionally, the court concluded that the evidence presented did not unequivocally support a different outcome regarding the payment of casual loading to Ms Keen.

The court's reasoning was grounded in the principles of judicial discretion and the management of court proceedings. The court noted that the appellants' application to file an additional affidavit and to adjourn the trial came at a late stage and would have disrupted the trial without a compelling reason. The court found that the Federal Magistrate's concern for the impact on the respondent and the need to maintain the progress of the hearing were valid considerations. Furthermore, the court held that the evidence, including the 2006 memorandum regarding the transfer of employment, did not conclusively establish that Ms Keen had consented to the change of employer or that this would have affected the outcome regarding the payment of casual loading. The court emphasized that any variation of the employment contract, such as a change of employer, requires the employee's real consent.

In conclusion, the court upheld the decisions of the Federal Magistrate, finding them to be within his discretion and justified under the circumstances. The appeal was dismissed, and the original decisions regarding the refusal to permit the additional affidavit and to adjourn the trial were affirmed. The court's decision ensures that the proceedings were managed effectively and that the evidence presented did not warrant a different outcome on the issue of casual loading payments.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Before turning to the grounds of appeal it is useful to consider the background facts, and then the relevant decisions of his Honour the subject of this appeal.Background facts At [7] of his Honour’s judgment of 2 April 2013 (Fair Work Ombudsman v New Image Photographics Pty Ltd [2013] FMCA 227) the background facts are summarised in some detail. His Honour described these facts as “uncontentious”. It appears that this description is itself not contentious. Accordingly, it is useful to set out the facts as described by his Honour in full:a.For the purposes of this application, the relevant employment period for Ms Keen was 3 April, 2006 to 2 September, 2009;b.Over the course of the relevant employment period Ms Keen’s terms and conditions of employment were set by:(i) from 3 April, 2006 to 1 July, 2009:1. the Workplace Relations Act 1996 (Cth);2. the Workplace Relations Regulations 2006 (Cth);3.a Notional Agreement Preserving the Photographic Employees’ Award State – 2003 (Qld); and4.the Australian Pay and Classification Scale derived from the Photographic Award NAPSA;(ii) from 1 July, 2009 to 2 September, 2009:1.the Fair Work (Transitional Provisions and Consequential Amendments) Act 2009 (Cth);2. the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth);3. the Fair Work Regulations 2009 (Cth); and4.the Transitional APCS derived from the Photographic Award NAPSA.c.Ms Keen was employed as a casual employee by [New Image Photographics] for the period 3 April, 2006 to 30 June, 2006;d.Ms Keen was a casual employee for the entirety of the relevant employment period and therefore entitled to casual loading for the hours worked;e.Ms Keen was not paid the appropriate casual loading for any of the hours worked by her during the relevant employment period;f.Initially, when she commenced employment with “New Image”, Ms Keen was employed by [New Image Photographics]. [New Image Photographics] contends that her employment was “transferred” to New Image Beauty Salons Pty Ltd from 1 July, 2006;g.Ms Keen had a key to the relevant business premises and was usually the first person to arrive at work. She would unlock the door and turn off the security alarms;h.[New Image Photographics] (or the entity that was Ms Keen’s employer) paid its telemarketing staff according to the number of hours they worked. When they commenced work, they logged on to the business’ computer system. The log-on time was recorded. When they completed their work, or went on breaks, they logged-off the computer system. The “logged-on” hours were, subject to the evidence of Ms Piazza set out below, prima facie the hours for which an employee was entitled to be paid.i. Ms Keen contracted a terminal illness and passed away in March, 2010.His Honour’s judgments Relevantly his Honour delivered three judgments in this matter. All three judgments are being challenged. The first judgment of his Honour was delivered on 26 March 2013 (Fair Work Ombudsman v New Image Photographics Pty Ltd (No.3) [2013] FCCA 1016) (“first judgment”). In that judgment his Honour refused an application by New Image Photographics and Mr Bedington for leave to file and read an affidavit sworn by Mr Bedington on 26 March 2013. Grounds 1 and 2 of the appellants’ notice of appeal are referable to findings and reasons of his Honour in the first judgment.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The decisions of his Honour in relation to the additional affidavit of Mr Bedington and the adjournment of the trial were exercises of judicial discretion. In the circumstances of this case I consider his Honour was fully justified in refusing to not only permit new and relatively extensive evidence to be filed so as to “ambush” the respondent, but to refuse to adjourn the proceedings and thus disrupt the progress of a three day hearing for no better reason than the unexplained convenience of the appellants. Concern for management of these proceedings and the impact of disruption of the trial on the respondent validated the decisions of his Honour. In my view, Aon Risk Services is squarely applicable to the circumstances of this case.Cogency of evidence In any event, I am not satisfied on the material before the Court that the evidence sought to be filed would have led unequivocally to a different result at the trial.A key question before the learned Federal Magistrate concerned the identity of the employer of Ms Keen at relevant times. In submissions at the hearing before me Counsel for the appellants emphasised annexure BCB 14 to Mr Bedington’s affidavit, being the memorandum of 3 May 2006. This document was on the letterhead of New Image Photographics and provided as follows:MemoTo : All Telemarketing StaffFrom : B C BedingtonRe : Change of Employer3/05/2006Transfer of Staff from New Image Photographics to New Image Beauty SalonsManagement has decided to create a new Marketing Profit centre within the Company accounts to better assess Costs and Returns from the Marketing effort.Presently our in-field Photographers and Make-up Artists are agents of New Image Beauty Salons.It is our intention to cease employing Telemarketing Staff through New Image Photographics and offer all Telemarketers a similar position at New Image Beauty Salons.This change will not effect [sic] your pay and work conditions. The only difference you will see is that the Employer name on your Group Certificate and Sun Super will change from New Image Photographics to New Image Beauty Salons.What you should doIf you are happy to make the change to New Image Beauty Salons do nothing and we will transfer your employment from New Image Photographics from June 2006.If you have doubts or would just like to talk about the changes ask Connie or Tracey to make an appointment to speak to me.Bryan BedingtonManaging Director. However as submitted by the respondent it is unlikely that, had that material been admitted, it would have dictated any particular outcome on its own with respect to the question whether Ms Keen had consented to a transfer of her employment. It is trite that a variation of a contract (including such a fundamental matter as the substitution of the employer in an employment contract) requires the consent of the parties: Sinclair, Scott & Company Limited v Naughton (1929) 43 CLR 310 at 317. Mr Bain QC referred to the 2006 memorandum being “an open Carlill v Carbolic Smokeball Company-type memorandum”. However I do not consider that the outcome can be so simply described when viewed through the prism of the relevant industrial relations legislation and rights imposed on workers by that legislation. As his Honour below observed, the authorities are firm that the consent of the employee to a change of employer may be express or implied, but it must be real and not simply raised by “operation of law”: Denham v Midland Employers Mutual Assurance Ltd [1955] 2 QB 437 at 443, Romero v Auty [2000] VSC 462 at [43], Re C & T Grinter Transport Services Pty Ltd (in liq): ex parte Fitzgerald [2004] FCA 1148 at [20].

Decision

Reasons for decision

At [7] of his Honour’s judgment of 2 April 2013 (Fair Work Ombudsman v New Image Photographics Pty Ltd [2013] FMCA 227) the background facts are summarised in some detail. His Honour described these facts as “uncontentious”. It appears that this description is itself not contentious. Accordingly, it is useful to set out the facts as described by his Honour in full:a.For the purposes of this application, the relevant employment period for Ms Keen was 3 April, 2006 to 2 September, 2009;b.Over the course of the relevant employment period Ms Keen’s terms and conditions of employment were set by:(i) from 3 April, 2006 to 1 July, 2009:1. the Workplace Relations Act 1996 (Cth);2. the Workplace Relations Regulations 2006 (Cth);3.a Notional Agreement Preserving the Photographic Employees’ Award State – 2003 (Qld); and4.the Australian Pay and Classification Scale derived from the Photographic Award NAPSA;(ii) from 1 July, 2009 to 2 September, 2009:1.the Fair Work (Transitional Provisions and Consequential Amendments) Act 2009 (Cth);2. the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth);3. the Fair Work Regulations 2009 (Cth); and4.the Transitional APCS derived from the Photographic Award NAPSA.c.Ms Keen was employed as a casual employee by [New Image Photographics] for the period 3 April, 2006 to 30 June, 2006;d.Ms Keen was a casual employee for the entirety of the relevant employment period and therefore entitled to casual loading for the hours worked;e.Ms Keen was not paid the appropriate casual loading for any of the hours worked by her during the relevant employment period;f.Initially, when she commenced employment with “New Image”, Ms Keen was employed by [New Image Photographics]. [New Image Photographics] contends that her employment was “transferred” to New Image Beauty Salons Pty Ltd from 1 July, 2006;g.Ms Keen had a key to the relevant business premises and was usually the first person to arrive at work. She would unlock the door and turn off the security alarms;h.[New Image Photographics] (or the entity that was Ms Keen’s employer) paid its telemarketing staff according to the number of hours they worked. When they commenced work, they logged on to the business’ computer system. The log-on time was recorded. When they completed their work, or went on breaks, they logged-off the computer system. The “logged-on” hours were, subject to the evidence of Ms Piazza set out below, prima facie the hours for which an employee was entitled to be paid.i. Ms Keen contracted a terminal illness and passed away in March, 2010.His Honour’s judgments Relevantly his Honour delivered three judgments in this matter. All three judgments are being challenged. The first judgment of his Honour was delivered on 26 March 2013 (Fair Work Ombudsman v New Image Photographics Pty Ltd (No.3) [2013] FCCA 1016) (“first judgment”). In that judgment his Honour refused an application by New Image Photographics and Mr Bedington for leave to file and read an affidavit sworn by Mr Bedington on 26 March 2013. Grounds 1 and 2 of the appellants’ notice of appeal are referable to findings and reasons of his Honour in the first judgment.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.