Nenad Grubisic v Chubb Security Services Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 16 min read

[2011] FWA 4322


FAIR WORK AUSTRALIA

DECISION

Fair Work Act 2009
s.394—Unfair dismissal

Nenad Grubisic
v
Chubb Security Services Limited
(U2011/5257)

DEPUTY PRESIDENT HAMILTON

MELBOURNE, 21 JULY 2011

Dismissal of union delegate - valid reason - dismissal not unfair

[1] On 18 February 2011 Mr.Nenad Grubisic filed an application under s.394 of the Fair Work Act 2009 (‘the Act’) against Chubb Security Services Limited for an unfair dismissal remedy for his dismissal on 7 February 2011. This was a summary dismissal.

The matter was conciliated and no settlement was reached. The matter was set down for arbitration before me, and pursuant to s.399 the matter was heard by hearing given the decision of the parties to cross examine witnesses. Written submissions and witness statements were filed:

Nenad Grubisic

Goce Avromoski

Clyde Hugh Bainbridge-Robb

Adam Joseph Scott Dalrymple

Emmanuel Spiteri

David Dalziell

Brian David Wright

[2] I have had regard to all the submissions and evidence.

Valid Reason - Section 387(a)

[3] The term ‘valid reason’ was considered by Northrop J in Selvachandran v. Petron Plastics Pty Ltd 1 , in relation to s.170DE of the Industrial Relations Act 1988. He said:

    “Section 170DE(1) refers to a `valid reason, or valid reasons’, but the Act does not give a meaning to those phrases or the adjective `valid’. A reference to dictionaries shows that the word `valid’ has a number of different meanings depending on the context in which it is used. In the Shorter Oxford Dictionary, the relevant meaning given is” `2. Of an argument, assertion, objection, etc; well founded and applicable, sound, defensible: Effective, having some force, pertinency, or value.’ In the Macquarie Dictionary the relevant meaning is `sound, just or well founded; a valid reason.’

    In its context in s 170DE(1), the adjective `valid’ should be given the meaning of sound, defensible or well founded. A reason which is capricious, fanciful, spiteful or prejudiced could never be a valid reason for the purposes of s170DE(1). At the same time the reason must be valid in the context of the employee’s capacity or conduct or based upon the operational requirements of the employer’s business. Further, in considering whether a reason is valid, it must be remembered that the requirement applies in the practical sphere of the relationship between an employer and an employee where each has rights and privileges and duties and obligations conferred and imposed on them. The provisions must `be applied in a practical, commonsense way to ensure that’ the employer and employee are each treated fairly, see what was said by Wilcox CJ in Gibson v Bosmac Pty Ltd (1995) 60 IR 1, when considering the construction and application of a s170DC.”

[4] This decision continues to be of relevance and continues to be applied.

First Incident of 23 August 2010

[5] Mr.Wright gave evidence that Mr.Grubisic attended work on 23 August 2010. Mr.Wright said that he saw Mr.Grubisic arguing with Mr.Montalto in relation to going to work. He said that he questioned Mr.Grubisic on being late…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Nenad Grubisic v Chubb Security Services Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2011] FWA 4322
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case before the Federal Court of Australia involved Nenad Grubisic, a former employee of Chubb Security Services Limited, who sought relief for his dismissal. Grubisic, who held the position of union delegate, claimed that his termination was unfair and not for a valid reason. Chubb Security Services Limited, the respondent, argued that the dismissal was justified and lawful.

The central legal issues that the Court had to address were whether Grubisic's dismissal was for a valid reason, and if it was, whether the dismissal was fair. The Court considered whether the employer had provided a valid reason for the dismissal and whether the process followed was procedurally fair. The Court also needed to determine if the dismissal breached any provisions of the Fair Work Act 2009, specifically in relation to the protection of union delegates.

The Court found that the employer had provided a valid reason for the dismissal, as it was based on misconduct and insubordination. It was established that Grubisic had breached company policy and failed to follow instructions, which justified the dismissal. The Court also determined that the dismissal process was procedurally fair, as proper procedures were followed, and Grubisic was given an opportunity to respond to the allegations against him. The Court concluded that the dismissal did not contravene any provisions of the Fair Work Act, as the employer had acted in accordance with the law.

As a result of the Court's findings, Grubisic's claim for unfair dismissal was dismissed. The Court ruled that the dismissal was valid and lawful, and therefore, the respondent was not liable for any compensation or remedy in relation to the dismissal. The Court's decision highlighted the importance of following proper procedures and providing valid reasons for dismissal, particularly in cases involving union delegates.