Ndjamba v Toyota Finance Australia Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 13 min read

Ndjamba v Toyota Finance Australia Ltd [2010] NTSC 23

PARTIES:  Edouard Ndjoku Ndjamba
v
Toyota Finance Australia
TITLE OF COURT:  SUPREME COURT OF THE
NORTHERN TERRITORY
JURISDICTION:  SUPREME COURT OF THE
NORTHERN TERRITORY
EXERCISING TERRITORY
JURISDICTION
FILE NO:  21003602
DELIVERED:  19 May 2010
HEARING DATES:  12 May 2010
JUDGMENT OF:  BLOKLAND J
APPEAL FROM:  Local Court
CATCHWORDS: 

PROCEDURE -- Miscellaneous procedural maters -- ex parte proceedings

Appeal form the Local Court against ex parte orders made by a Magistrate - whether matter ought to have proceeded ex parte - no error of law by Magistrate in proceeding ex parte - the appellant has a right to re-hearing before the Local Court - appeal dismissed

Consumer Credit Code ss 66, 70, 78, 80(1), 86, 87, 88, 89, 90, 92, 94, 111,
114, 145, 146,
Local Court Act ss 19(1), 20
Local Court Rule 36.01
The Owners of the SS Kalibia v Alexander Wilson (1910-11) 11 CLR 689 at
694

Cairns, Australian Civil Procedure, 407

REPRESENTATION:

Counsel:

Appellant:  Self
 Respondent:  Mr Close

Solicitors:

Appellant:  Self
Respondent:  Vincent Close Solicitors

Judgment category classification: C

Judgment ID Number:  BLO1003
Number of pages:  12
IN THE SUPREME COURT
OF THE NORTHERN TERRITORY
OF AUSTRALIA
AT DARWIN

Ndjamba v Toyota Finance Australia Ltd [2010] NTSC 23

No. 21003602

BETWEEN:

EDOUARD NDJOKU NDJAMBA

Appellant

AND:

TOYOTA FINANCE GROUP LTD

Respondent

CORAM:  BLOKLAND J

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

(Delivered 19 May 2010)

Introduction

  1. This is an appeal against two orders made by a Magistrate in the Local Court on 4 February 2010 firstly, permitting Toyota Finance Australia Limited, (“the Respondent”) to proceed ex parte and secondly, authorising the Respondent’s agent to enter the garden area or garage areas of 79 Byrne Circuit, Moil for the purpose of taking possession of a 2003 Toyota Kluger Motor Vehicle, Registration No. (NT) 932-566. The grounds of appeal are:

    1.         That the matter ought not have been determined ex parte.

    2.         That given that it did the Appellant had no opportunity to defend the application.

  2. The Appellant appeared in person to argue the appeal. He told the Court he had obtained legal advice to assist him drafting the grounds of appeal. The Appellant advised the Court he was originally from the Congo. He declined an opportunity to adjourn the hearing of the Appeal in order to attempt to

arrange a French interpreter, despite an acknowledgment he may have been
at a disadvantage due to language difficulties. In spite of the difficulties the
Appellant sought to proceed.
[3]

effect the issue raised by the Appellant is whether the Local Court was
authorised as a matter of law to proceed ex parte. A procedural fairness
issue is expressly raised by the second ground. If the Local Court was
authorised as a matter of law to proceed ex parte, the second ground will fail
as a consequence. Although it is unusual for a Court to proceed with a
hearing in the absence of a party, there are some circumstances that permit

Appeals from the Local Court…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Ndjamba v Toyota Finance Australia Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2010] NTSC 23
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Ndjamba v Toyota Finance Australia Ltd involved an application by the respondent for permission to enter private premises to repossess a vehicle. The Local Court granted the application, allowing the respondent's agent to enter the property to retrieve the vehicle. The appeal was brought by the borrower, arguing against the legality and fairness of the court's decision. The primary issues for the court were whether the Local Court was correct in authorising the entry and repossession, and if the decision was balanced against the borrower's rights under the Consumer Credit Code.

The court examined the provisions of the Consumer Credit Code, specifically Section 92, which allows a credit provider to enter residential premises to take possession of mortgaged goods if certain conditions are met. The evidence presented to the Local Court demonstrated that the loan was in arrears, and the vehicle was located within the borrower's private premises. The court also considered the potential for the borrower to hide or move the vehicle if notified of the proceedings, which would cause unnecessary expense and delay. The borrower's right to reclaim the vehicle upon payment of the arrears and repossession expenses was preserved under Section 94 of the Consumer Credit Code, and the borrower also had the right to apply for a rehearing under Section 20 of the Local Court Act.

In its decision, the court upheld the Local Court's authorisation for the entry and repossession, finding that the evidence supported the inference that the borrower might not cooperate if aware of the proceedings. The court balanced the borrower's rights against the respondent's need to recover the vehicle, concluding that the Local Court's decision was justified. The court dismissed the appeal, affirming the validity of the Local Court's order.

The court concluded that the Local Court's order was lawful and appropriately balanced the interests of both parties. The respondent was permitted to repossess the vehicle, and the borrower retained the right to reclaim it by paying the outstanding debt and repossession expenses. The appeal was dismissed with no orders for costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The Respondent’s application before the Local Court was for an Order seeking permission pursuant to s 92 Consumer Credit Code to authorise the Respondent’s agent to enter the garden and garage area of 79 Byrne Circuit Moil for the purpose of taking possession of the vehicle . The Respondent asserted it was entitled to possession of the vehicle. Section 92 of the Consumer Credit Code provides: 92. The Court may, on the application of a credit provider that is entitled to take possession of mortgaged goods, authorise the credit provider to enter residential premises for the purpose of taking possession of mortgaged goods. Evidence before the Local Court in Support of the Application Before the Local Court there was information indicating that the loan agreement was in arrears; the vehicle the subject of the mortgage was identified as being within private enclosed premises and the borrowers In the circumstances outlined in my view the Local Court was authorised to make the ex parte order. Although His Honour did not give formal reasons, he reviewed the material and clearly relied on the material filed before Given the failure to give consent when otherwise the evidence indicated a failure to give consent to enter the premises, it was open in my view for an inference to be drawn that the Appellant may not cooperate if aware of the proceedings. This in turn gives rise to reasonable grounds to suspect the vehicle may be hidden or its position changed if notice of repossession proceedings were given. The Respondent consequentially may have suffered harm or unnecessary expense in locating the vehicle and the debt may have remained unsatisfied. In balancing those factors against the hardship that may be occasioned to the Appellant, it must be noted that the Appellant is still able to reclaim the vehicle by payment of the arrears to the Respondent. The Appellant’s rights to recover the vehicle after the payment of arrears owing and the reasonable repossession expenses are paid are preserved by s 94 of the Consumer Credit Code which provides: 94.(1) Notice to be given. A credit provider that has taken possession of goods under a mortgage must, within 14 days after doing so, give the mortgagor a written notice containing the following matters – Further, the Appellant has the right to bring an application for re-hearing to set aside the Local Court order. That right is not subject to a time limitation and the Respondent concedes the Appellant could still bring the application. Section 20 of the Local Court Act provides: 20 Re-hearing (1) Where, other than in a proceeding by way of appeal to the Court, an order is made by the Court against a person who: The Appellant’s concerns outlined to this Court are directed to a considerable degree to a first repossession of the vehicle on 9 September 2009. He complains about procedure not being followed in relation to that re-possession. That is not material that can bear on this Appeal concerning the Orders of 4 February 2010. He complains that he has felt “harassed”, discriminated against and has been the “victim of an unlawful judgment”, “moral torture” and “human rights abuse” from a number of persons involved in the enforcement procedure.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.