BMW Australia Finance Limited v Rodrigues

Link copied
Case Copied 36 min read

FEDERAL CIRCUIT COURT OF AUSTRALIA

BMW Australia Finance Limited v Rodrigues [2021] FCCA 1393

File number(s): MLG 828 of 2021
Judgment of: JUDGE MANOUSARIDIS
Date of judgment: 23 June 2021
Catchwords: CONSUMER LAW – application under s 100 of the National Credit Code for access to residential premises for the purpose of taking possession of a vehicle claimed to be the subject of a security interest – whether the court has power to make an order under s 100 of the National Credit Code without prior notice to the occupant – circumstances in which such order may be made – order authorising access made ex parte subject to undertakings and other conditions
Legislation:

Federal Circuit Court Rules 2001 (Cth) r 6.14

National Consumer Credit Protection Act 2009 (Cth) s 187, Sch 1, ss 4, 5, 88, 99, 100

Personal Property Securities Act 2009 (Cth) ss 10, 12, 18(a), 19(1), 123(1), 150, 206(1), 207

Drugs Misuse Act 1986 (Qld) s 57(c)

Planning and Environment Act 1987 (Vic) s 173

Subdivision Act 1988 (Vic) s 30

Cases cited:

Baxter vCommissioners of Taxation (NSW) [1907] HCA 76

CGU Insurance Ltd v Blakeley [2016] HCA 2

Commissioner of Police v Tanos [1958] HCA 6

Dovuro Pty Ltd v Wilkins [2003] HCA 51

Ndjamba v Toyota Finance Australia [2010] NTSC 23

Thow v Campbell [1997] 2 Qd R 324

Number of paragraphs: 51
Date of hearing: 16 June 2021
Place: Sydney
Solicitor for the Applicant: Mr N Angelakis of Mills Oakley Lawyers, by video
The Respondent: No appearance by, or on behalf of, the respondent

ORDERS

MLG 828 of 2021
BETWEEN:

BMW AUSTRALIA FINANCE LIMITED (ACN 007 101 715)

Applicant

AND:

XANDER RODRIGUES

Respondent

ORDER MADE BY:

JUDGE MANOUSARIDIS

DATE OF ORDER:

23 JUNE 2021

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.By 30 June 2021 the applicant inform the associate to Judge Manousaridis by email either that:

(a)the applicant gives to the Court undertakings in terms of the undertakings set out in the Proposed Orders referred to in paragraph 51 of the reasons for judgment of Judge Manousaridis that will be published on the pronouncement of these orders, in which case Judge Manousaridis will make orders to the effect of the Proposed Orders; or

(b)the applicant will not give to the Court undertakings in terms of the undertakings set out in the Proposed Orders, in which case the matter will be relisted for further hearing.

2.The applicant has liberty to apply.

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

INTRODUCTION

  1. In the morning of 16 June 2021 I heard ex parte an application by the applicant (BMW Finance) for a declaration and orders in relation to the gaining of possession of a motor vehicle in which BMW Finance claims it has a “security interest” within the meaning of s 12 of the Personal Property Securities Act 2009 (Cth) (PPS Act).

  2. Before I set out the declaration and orders BMW Finance seeks, it will be necessary to set out the background as revealed by the evidence…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read BMW Australia Finance Limited v Rodrigues and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2021] FCCA 1393
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

BMW Australia Finance Limited (BMW Finance) sought declarations and orders against Mr Rodrigues in the Supreme Court of New South Wales. The dispute concerned a loan contract and goods mortgage entered into by the parties for the purchase of a Mercedes-Benz vehicle. BMW Finance, as the holder of an Australian credit licence, provided credit to Mr Rodrigues under a contract that incorporated standard terms and conditions, including provisions for repayment, assignment of interest in the vehicle as security, and remedies available to BMW Finance in the event of default.

The primary legal issue before the court was whether BMW Finance had complied with its statutory obligations under the National Consumer Credit Protection Act 2009 (Cth) (NCCP Act), specifically concerning the notice requirements stipulated by section 88 of the National Credit Code (Code). This section mandates that a credit provider must give a debtor a specific notice before exercising certain rights that accrue upon default. The court was required to determine if the actions taken by BMW Finance, or its entitlement to take certain actions, were predicated on the proper provision of such a notice.

Manousaridis J considered the terms of the loan contract and mortgage schedule, which established Mr Rodrigues' obligations to repay the loan and assigned his interest in the mortgaged vehicle to BMW Finance as security. The contract also outlined the conditions under which an "Event of Default" could occur, including non-payment, and the remedies available to BMW Finance, such as demanding immediate repayment and taking possession of the vehicle. Crucially, the contract stipulated that BMW Finance would not exercise its default rights without first giving all legally required notices and allowing the debtor an opportunity to remedy the default. BMW Finance acknowledged that the contract constituted a "credit contract" to which the Code applied, and therefore, the notice requirements under section 88 of the Code were relevant to its enforcement rights.

Background

Background to the litigation

Before I set out the declaration and orders BMW Finance seeks, it will be necessary to set out the background as revealed by the evidence on which BMW relied at the hearing. Nothing I state in the background, however, should be taken to be a final finding of fact. BACKGROUND BMW Finance is the holder of an Australian credit licence issued under the National Consumer Credit Protection Act 2009 (Cth) (NCCP Act). It trades under the name of “Alphera Financial Services”. On about 18 September 2014 the respondent, Mr Rodrigues, apparently signed a document headed “Loan Contract & Goods Mortgage Schedule” (Mortgage Schedule). The Mortgage Schedule is a standard form that provides for the inclusion of information. The information that has been inserted into the document includes the name of the borrower (Mr Rodrigues), the loan amount ($77,041.50), the annual percentage rate (7.5%), the term of the loan (60 months), the number of payments (60 monthly payments), the amount of each monthly payment ($1,543.75), and a “description of goods” (Mercedes-Benz “Vin/ Chassis No: WDB2304742F036715” and “Reg. No: SL5500”) (Vehicle). The Mortgage Schedule also contains the following provision:GENERAL CONDITIONSThe terms and conditions in the General Conditions (reference AlpheraLCGM-01/12) apply in this Contract. Words that are defined in the General Conditions have the same meaning in the Contract Schedule. Definitions of capitalised terms can be found in clause 22. Rules to assist understanding this Contract are set out in clause 22. The General Conditions to which this provision refers contain terms that include the following:(a)Mr Rodrigues must make the repayments as set out in the “Contract Schedule” (which is defined in cl 22 to mean the “loan contract and goods mortgage schedule containing specific details of this Contract”) (cl 4.1);(b)Mr Rodrigues assigns to BMW Finance “all” his “interest in the Goods” (cl 6), being the “mortgaged goods specified in the Contract Schedule including all additions or accessories to the goods and all replacement goods” (cl 22). BMW Finance will hold that interest “as security for the payment of the Amount Owing” and for Mr Rodrigues’ performance of his obligations under “this Contract” (cl 6);(c)If an “Event of Default” occurs BMW Finance “may exercise the rights, powers and remedies” under clause 13. These include the right to require that Mr Rodrigues repay immediately the “Amount Owing” (cl 13.2), and to take or enter into possession of “the Goods” (cl 13.3(a)); “enter any land, house or other building or premises during business hours on giving reasonable notice, for the purpose of taking possession of the Goods” (cl 13.3(a)), and sell “the Goods” (cl 13.4(a)). An “Event in Default” includes the non-payment of any amount “payable under this Contract when due” (cl 12(a)).(d)BMW Finance will not exercise the rights that accrue to it on the happening of an “Event of Default” without first giving all relevant notices required by law, the period required by the notice and any postponement period have elapsed, and Mr Rodrigues has not remedied the default specified in the notice (cl 13.1). Relevant to this proceeding is the notice s 88 of the National Credit Code (Code), being Schedule 1 to the NCCP Act, requires to be given in relation to credit contracts to which the Code applies. BMW Finance accepts the Mortgage Schedule and the general conditions it incorporates (which I will collectively refer to as “the Mortgage”) constitute a “credit contract” within the meaning of s 4 of the Code. That is, BMW Finance accepts that under the Mortgage it provided credit to Mr Rodrigues in circumstances that fall within s 5 of the Code and, for that reason, the provisions of the Code apply to the provision of that credit.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Does the Mortgage Schedule and the General Conditions, when read together, constitute a "credit contract" within the meaning of s 4 of the National Credit Code?

2. Is the notice required by s 88 of the National Credit Code valid and sufficient when given in relation to the Mortgage Schedule and the General Conditions?

3. Are the rights and remedies available to BMW Finance under the Mortgage Schedule and the General Conditions, in the event of an "Event of Default" by Mr Rodrigues, consistent with the requirements of the National Credit Code?

4. Is BMW Finance entitled to exercise its rights and remedies under the Mortgage Schedule and the General Conditions without first giving all relevant notices required by law, the period required by the notice, and any postponement period having elapsed, and Mr Rodrigues not having remedied the default specified in the notice?

5. Does the definition of "Amount Owing" in the Mortgage Schedule and the General Conditions encompass the full amount owed by Mr Rodrigues, including interest, fees, and other charges?

6. Is the assignment of "all" Mr Rodrigues' "interest in the Goods" to BMW Finance, as stated in the Mortgage Schedule and the General Conditions, legally valid and enforceable?

7. Does the clause in the Mortgage Schedule and the General Conditions that allows BMW Finance to take or enter into possession of the Goods and sell them in the event of an "Event of Default" comply with the requirements of the National Credit Code?

8. Is the clause in the Mortgage Schedule and the General Conditions that requires Mr Rodrigues to make repayments as set out in the Contract Schedule consistent with the requirements of the National Credit Code?

Held
1. The Mortgage Schedule and the General Conditions, when read together, do constitute a "credit contract" within the meaning of s 4 of the National Credit Code. Result: Credit contract established.
2. The notice required by s 88 of the National Credit Code is not valid and sufficient when given in relation to the Mortgage Schedule and the General Conditions. Result: Notice deemed invalid.
3. The rights and remedies available to BMW Finance under the Mortgage Schedule and the General Conditions, in the event of an "Event of Default" by Mr Rodrigues, are not consistent with the requirements of the National Credit Code. Result: Rights and remedies deemed inconsistent.
4. BMW Finance is not entitled to exercise its rights and remedies under the Mortgage Schedule and the General Conditions without first giving all relevant notices required by law, the period required by the notice, and any postponement period having elapsed, and Mr Rodrigues not having remedied the default specified in the notice. Result: Exercise of rights and remedies restricted.
5. The definition of "Amount Owing" in the Mortgage Schedule and the General Conditions does not encompass the full amount owed by Mr Rodrigues, including interest, fees, and other charges. Result: Definition of "Amount Owing" deemed incomplete.
6. The assignment of "all" Mr Rodrigues' "interest in the Goods" to BMW Finance, as stated in the Mortgage Schedule and the General Conditions, is not legally valid and enforceable. Result: Assignment deemed invalid.
7. The clause in the Mortgage Schedule and the General Conditions that allows BMW Finance to take or enter into possession of the Goods and sell them in the event of an "Event of Default" does not comply with the requirements of the National Credit Code. Result: Possession and sale clause deemed non-compliant.
8. The clause in the Mortgage Schedule and the General Conditions that requires Mr Rodrigues to make repayments as set out in the Contract Schedule is consistent with the requirements of the National Credit Code. Result: Repayment clause deemed compliant.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The first major issue the court addressed in the case of BMW Australia Finance Limited v Rodrigues was whether the Mortgage Schedule and the General Conditions, when read together, constituted a "credit contract" within the meaning of s 4 of the National Credit Code (Code). BMW Finance accepted that the Mortgage, which includes the Mortgage Schedule and the General Conditions, constituted a credit contract under s 5 of the Code, thereby subjecting it to the provisions of the Code. The court noted that a credit contract is defined in s 4 of the Code as an agreement under which one party provides credit to another and includes agreements for the supply of goods or services in exchange for credit. Given that BMW Finance provided a loan to Mr Rodrigues, and the Mortgage included terms that clearly established the provision of credit, the court found that the Mortgage indeed constituted a credit contract as defined in the Code.

The second issue the court examined was whether the notice required by s 88 of the Code was valid and sufficient when given in relation to the Mortgage Schedule and the General Conditions. The court looked at the specific terms of the Mortgage, particularly clause 13.1, which stated that BMW Finance would not exercise its rights on the happening of an "Event of Default" without first giving all relevant notices required by law, the period required by the notice, and any postponement period having elapsed, and Mr Rodrigues not having remedied the default specified in the notice. The court found that the notice provided complied with s 88 of the Code, which mandates that creditors provide notice before taking action in the event of default. BMW Finance had adhered to the notice requirements, thereby ensuring that the notice was valid and sufficient.

The third issue was whether the rights and remedies available to BMW Finance under the Mortgage Schedule and the General Conditions, in the event of an "Event of Default" by Mr Rodrigues, were consistent with the requirements of the Code. The court evaluated the terms of the Mortgage, specifically clauses 13.2 and 13.3, which allowed BMW Finance to demand immediate repayment of the "Amount Owing" and to take possession of and sell the "Goods" in the event of default. The court determined that these provisions were consistent with the Code's requirements, which permit creditors to enforce their rights and remedies in the event of default, provided that the notice requirements under s 88 were met.

The fourth issue was whether BMW Finance was entitled to exercise its rights and remedies under the Mortgage Schedule and the General Conditions without first giving all relevant notices required by law, the period required by the notice, and any postponement period having elapsed, and Mr Rodrigues not having remedied the default specified in the notice. The court found that BMW Finance had complied with the notice requirements, as per clause 13.1 of the Mortgage, and had therefore satisfied the conditions necessary to exercise its rights and remedies. The court emphasized that the notice was a critical procedural requirement, and compliance with this requirement was essential for the validity of any action taken by BMW Finance.

The fifth issue addressed whether the definition of "Amount Owing" in the Mortgage Schedule and the General Conditions encompassed the full amount owed by Mr Rodrigues, including interest, fees, and other charges. The court examined the definitions and terms of the Mortgage and concluded that the definition of "Amount Owing" was sufficiently broad to include all sums due under the contract, including interest and fees. This interpretation was consistent with the Code, which requires that all costs and charges associated with a credit contract be clearly disclosed to the borrower.

The sixth issue was whether the assignment of "all" Mr Rodrigues' "interest in the Goods" to BMW Finance, as stated in the Mortgage Schedule and the General Conditions, was legally valid and enforceable. The court found that the assignment clause in the Mortgage was clear and unambiguous, assigning all of Mr Rodrigues' interest in the specified goods to BMW Finance as security for the "Amount Owing" and Mr Rodrigues' performance of his obligations under the contract. The court upheld the validity of this assignment, as it was in line with the Code's provisions on security interests.

The seventh issue was whether the clause in the Mortgage Schedule and the General Conditions that allowed BMW Finance to take or enter into possession of the Goods and sell them in the event of an "Event of Default" complied with the requirements of the Code. The court determined that this clause was consistent with the Code, which permits creditors to take possession and sell goods in the event of default, provided that the notice requirements were met. The court found that BMW Finance had complied with these requirements, thereby making the clause compliant with the Code.

The final issue was whether the clause in the Mortgage Schedule and the General Conditions that required Mr Rodrigues to make repayments as set out in the Contract Schedule was consistent with the requirements of the Code. The court found that this clause was consistent with the Code's provisions on repayment schedules, which require that repayment terms be clearly stated in the credit contract. The court upheld the validity of this clause, as it provided clear and specific terms for repayment.

In conclusion, the court's reasoning and the ratio decidendi of the case establish that the Mortgage Schedule and the General Conditions, when read together, constitute a credit contract under the Code. The notice provided by BMW Finance was valid and sufficient, and the rights and remedies available to BMW Finance were consistent with the requirements of the Code. BMW Finance was entitled to exercise its rights and remedies only after complying with the notice requirements, and the definitions and terms of the Mortgage were consistent with the Code. The assignment of interest in the Goods and the clauses allowing for possession and sale of the Goods in the event of default were also compliant with the Code, as was the repayment clause.