Naxatu Pty Ltd v Perpetual Trustee Co Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 78 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Naxatu Pty Limited v Perpetual Trustee Company Limited [2012] FCAFC 163

Citation: Naxatu Pty Limited v Perpetual Trustee Company Limited [2012] FCAFC 163
Appeal from: Naxatu Pty Limited v Perpetual Trustee Company Limited; In the Matter of Sterling Estates Development Corporation Pty Limited (Receivers and Managers Appointed) (Subject to a Deed of Company Arrangement) [2011] FCA 669
Parties: NAXATU PTY LIMITED ACN 002 197 131 v PERPETUAL TRUSTEE COMPANY LIMITED ACN 000 001 007
File number: NSD 1107 of 2011
Judges: DOWSETT, JAGOT AND YATES JJ
Date of judgment: 16 November 2012
Catchwords:

MORTGAGES – rule in Hopkinson v Rolt [1861] 9 HL Cas 519; (1861) 11 ER 829 – whether rule is engaged where advances made by first and second mortgagees before notice of the other’s mortgage – effect of s 58(3) Real Property Act 1900 (NSW)

PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – whether leave should be granted to tender further evidence pursuant to s 27 Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth)

Legislation:

Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) ss 9, 420, 423

Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) s 27

Real Property Act 1900 (NSW) ss 36, 56A, 58

Cases cited:

Across Australia Finance Pty Ltd v Kalls [2008] NSWSC 783, 14 BPR [26,265] cited
Bank of New South Wales v City Mutual Life Assurance Society Ltd [1969] VR 556 cited
Chase Corporation (Australia) Pty Ltd v North Sydney Brick & Tile Co Ltd (1994) 35 NSWLR 1 cited
Commonwealth Bank of Australia v Grubic (27 August 1993 – unreported on this point; BC 9300359) cited
Commonwealth Trading Bank v Colonial Mutual Life Assurance Society Ltd [1970] Tas S R 120 considered
Deeley v Lloyds’ Bank Ltd [1912] AC 756 cited
Gordon v Graham (1716) 2 Eq Cas Abr 598; 22 ER 502 considered
Hall v Poolman (2009) 75 NSWLR 99 cited
Hopkinson v Rolt (1861) 11 ER 829; 9 HL Cas 519 considered
Lawrance v Goldsworthy (1857) 3 Jur NS 1049 cited
London and County Banking Co v Ratcliffe (1881) 6 App Cas 722 cited
Macchia v Nilant (2001) 110 FCR 101 cited
Matzner v Clyde Securities Ltd (1975) 2 NSWLR 293 cited
Mercantile Credits Ltd v ANZ Banking Group Ltd (1988) 48 SASR 407 cited
Miles v Official Receiver in Bankruptcy (1963) 109 CLR 501 cited
Mir Bros Projects Pty Ltd v Lyons (1977) 2 NSWLR 192 cited
Naxatu Pty Limited v Perpetual Trustee Company Limited; In the Matter of Sterling Estates Development Corporation Pty Limited (Receivers and Managers Appointed) (Subject to a Deed of Company Arrangement) [2011] FCA 669 considered
Northbourne Developments Pty Ltd v Reiby Chambers Pty Ltd (1989) 19 NSWLR 434 cited
Oamington Pty Ltd (Receiver & Manager Appointed) v Commissioner of Land Tax (1997) 98 ATC cited
Sarge Pty Ltd v Cazihaven Homes Pty Ltd (1994) 34 NSWLR 658 cited
Webb v Smith (1885) 30 Ch D 192 cited
West v Williams [1899] 1 Ch 132 cited
Westpac Banking Corporation v Adelaide Bank [2005] NSWSC 517; 12…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Naxatu Pty Ltd v Perpetual Trustee Co Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2012] FCAFC 163
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Naxatu Pty Ltd v Perpetual Trustee Company Limited, the dispute revolved around the validity and priority of mortgages held over a property, specifically challenging the application of the rule in Hopkinson v Rolt and the admissibility of new evidence during the appeal. The Federal Court of Australia was tasked with determining whether the rule in Hopkinson v Rolt applied, considering the sequence of mortgage registrations and the effect of section 58(3) of the Real Property Act 1900 (NSW). Additionally, the court had to decide whether Naxatu was entitled to tender further evidence under section 27 of the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth).

The court addressed the issue of whether the rule in Hopkinson v Rolt, which traditionally prevents subsequent mortgagees from asserting priority over prior mortgages without notice, should apply in this case. The court found that the rule must yield to the express agreement between the parties involved, as the priority of mortgages was established through a registrable dealing under section 56A of the Real Property Act 1900 (NSW). The agreement between the original mortgagee and the subsequent mortgagee, evidenced by a registrable form, took precedence over the rule. The court held that the rule’s underlying rationale of preventing equitable fraud was not engaged, as there was no evidence of bad faith or any impugning of the transaction's validity. Furthermore, the court rejected Naxatu’s attempt to tender additional evidence, determining that such evidence was immaterial and would not have altered the outcome of the case.

The Federal Court dismissed Naxatu’s appeal, affirming the lower court’s decision. The court held that the agreements between the parties governed the priority of the mortgages, and the rule in Hopkinson v Rolt did not apply. Consequently, the appeal was dismissed with costs awarded to the respondent, Perpetual Trustee Company Limited. The court emphasized that Naxatu’s claims were fundamentally flawed due to their failure to establish a proper basis for the relief sought. The final orders of the court mandated the dismissal of the appeal and required Naxatu to pay the costs of the appeal to Perpetual Trustee Company Limited.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The appeal be dismissed; and

2. the appellant pay the respondent’s costs of the appeal.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

I have not resolved this appeal on the basis (put by Perpetual in its submissions to the primary judge and in the appeal) that Naxatu failed to prove any indebtedness at all under the Naxatu mortgage. Nor did the primary judge determine the case on that basis. In this sense, the fresh evidence is immaterial. The fact that Naxatu was forced to attempt to tender this evidence during the appeal, however, discloses a misconception in Naxatu’s approach from the outset. Naxatu was seeking to demonstrate a proper basis for an inquiry under s 423 of the Corporations Act and the making of declaratory relief in its favour. It was always a matter for Naxatu to adduce sufficient evidence to provide a proper basis for the relief it sought. It was not incumbent upon Perpetual to deny any debt due under the Naxatu mortgage in order for this most basic of facts to be in issue before the primary judge. Naxatu’s apparent belief that it could assert the mortgages and nothing more without proving the existence of any debt at all was unfounded and plainly wrong in principle. Similarly, Naxatu’s apparent assumption that it was entitled to a discharge of Perpetual’s mortgages (the rights it claimed to have been denied) was also wrong. Even if Naxatu’s claims had the benefit of a sound legal and factual foundation (which they do not) the result could not have transformed the money owed to Perpetual into an unsecured debt. Naxatu’s reliance on what it described as the practical position (based on its assertion of indebtedness under the Naxatu mortgage exceeding the value of the secured property) was not a proper foundation for the relief it sought in this regard. As the fresh evidence is immaterial it should not be permitted to be tendered. Indeed, even if it were material in some way, I would have reached the same conclusion for all of the reasons which Perpetual identified as set out above.Conclusion For these reasons, the appeal should be dismissed with costs. I agree that the appeal should be dismissed with costs, substantially for the reasons given by Dowsett J. I wish to add the following remarks. The rule in Hopkinson v Rolt (1861) 9 HLC 514; 11 ER 829 must give way to the agreement of the relevant parties. The rationale for the rule is based on considerations of justice and fair dealing between competing mortgagees and, in particular, the prevention of equitable fraud affecting the interests of a subsequent mortgagee: West v Williams [1899] 1 Ch 132 at 143-144 and 146; Matzner v Clyde Securities Ltd [1975] 2 NSWLR 293 at 299; Central Mortgage Registry of Australia Ltd v Donemore Pty Ltd [1984] 2 NSWLR 128 at 132. Here the appellant’s (Naxatu’s) security (Mortgage 7805323) – which it had acquired through a chain of transfers – had been postponed in its entirety to Mortgages 8965248 and 8968538 (the Permanent mortgages) by agreement between the original mortgagee Macquarie Australia Management Services Pty Limited (Macquarie) and Permanent Trustee Australia Limited (Permanent), as mortgagee of the Permanent mortgages. It is manifest that, at the time of that agreement, the Permanent mortgages were “all moneys” mortgages. The postponement of Mortgage 7805323 to the Permanent mortgages was made under the provisions of s 56A of the Real Property Act 1900 (NSW) (the Real Property Act) by a dealing in registrable form. Upon registration, that dealing had effect as a deed between Permanent and Macquarie: s 36(11) of the Real Property Act. As Dowsett J has observed, those parties should be held to the terms of their deed. There is nothing that has been put before us that would impugn the validity of the transaction between Permanent and Macquarie or which could have maintained, in those circumstances, any intervening equity in Macquarie. When it acquired its interest in Mortgage 7805323, Naxatu could have been in no better position than Macquarie as against Permanent or its transferee, Perpetual Trustee Company Limited (Perpetual), the current proprietor of the Permanent mortgages and the respondent in this appeal.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.