Navarac Pty Ltd v Moondancer Holdings Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 19 min read

JURISDICTION     :   SUPREME COURT OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA

IN CHAMBERS

CITATION:   NAVARAC PTY LTD -v- MOONDANCER HOLDINGS PTY LTD [2009] WASC 68

CORAM:   TEMPLEMAN J

HEARD:   4 MARCH 2009

DELIVERED          :   4 MARCH 2009

PUBLISHED           :  24 MARCH 2009

FILE NO/S:   CIV 1262 of 2009

MATTER                :Section 138 of the Transfer of Land Act 1893

BETWEEN:   NAVARAC PTY LTD (ACN 071 456 212)

Plaintiff

AND

MOONDANCER HOLDINGS PTY LTD (ACN 126 519 908)
First Defendant

REGISTRAR OF TITLES
Second Defendant

Catchwords:

Real property - Caveats - Plaintiff developer and registered proprietor summons defendant caveator to show cause why caveat should remain - Plaintiff trustee of unit trust - Two corporate trustees hold the units in the unit trust - Mother and two sons the alter egos of the plaintiff and the unit holders - Defendant's allegation of breaches of trusts involving unauthorised liabilities and use of funds - Underlying dispute over defendant being successor in title to one of the unit holders - No dispute serious question to be tried - Whether sufficient interest in land by holding unit in unit trust - Whether balance of convenience applicable - Caveat already lifted to allow sales of newly created lots in plaintiff's trading stock - Caveat remaining over rest of development even if removed for sales of trading stock - Whether balance of convenience favours plaintiff - Defendant seeking order that summons be dismissed on receipt of the accounts it seeks as a unit holder - Whether abuse of process

Legislation:

Transfer of Land Act 1893 (WA), s 138(2)

Result:

Application dismissed

Category:    B

Representation:

Counsel:

Plaintiff:     Ms C H Thompson

First Defendant              :     Mr N D C Dillon

Second Defendant         :     No appearance

Solicitors:

Plaintiff:     Fairweather & Lemonis

First Defendant              :     Metaxas & Hager

Second Defendant         :     No appearance

Case(s) referred to in judgment(s):

Binningup Nominees Pty Ltd v Brogue Tableau Pty Ltd [2004] WASC 14

Binningup Nominees Pty Ltd v Brogue Tableau Pty Ltd [2004] WASC 207

Connell v Bond Corporation Pty Ltd (1992) 8 WAR 352

Custom Credit Corp Ltd v Ravi Nominees Pty Ltd (1992) 8 WAR 42

Hughan v Gray [2002] WASC 164

Interview Holdings Pty Ltd v Registrar of Titles [2008] WASC 144

Jandric v Jandric [1999] WASC 22

Midland Brick Company Pty Ltd v Welsh [2002] WASC 248

Porter v McDonald [1984] WAR 271

  1. TEMPLEMAN J: This is an application under s 138(2) of the Transfer of Land Act 1893 (WA), requiring a caveator to show cause why its caveat should not be removed.

  2. The application came before me on 4 March 2009.  I then came to the conclusion that the caveator had shown cause, and that the application should therefore be dismissed.  I gave a brief outline of my reasons for reaching that conclusion and said that I would publish my full reasons in due course.  I now set out those reasons.

The parties

  1. The plaintiff, Navarac Pty Ltd (Navarac) is the trustee of the Car Child Unit Trust (the Trust).  There…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Navarac Pty Ltd v Moondancer Holdings Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2009] WASC 68
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Navarac Pty Ltd, a developer and registered proprietor, sought to have Moondancer Holdings Pty Ltd, a caveator, show cause why its caveat over certain land should remain. The case involved a dispute over whether Moondancer, who claimed to be a successor in title to one of the unit holders, had a sufficient interest in the land to maintain the caveat. Additionally, there was a contention that the balance of convenience should favour Navarac, given that the caveat had already been lifted to allow sales of newly created lots in Navarac's trading stock. Moondancer argued that the caveat should remain over the rest of the development. The case required the court to determine the legal sufficiency of Moondancer's interest in the land, the applicability of the balance of convenience, and whether Moondancer's request for an order that the summons be dismissed on receipt of accounts as a unit holder constituted an abuse of process.

The court examined the nature of Moondancer's interest in the land, acknowledging that a unit holder in a unit trust does indeed possess a proprietary interest in the trust property. This interest was recognised in the decision of Malcolm CJ in Connell v Bond Corporation Pty Ltd, which was subsequently adopted in other cases. Moondancer's interest was further substantiated by evidence of funds received by Navarac and the absence of distributions to Moondancer, as well as other financial dealings that suggested potential mismanagement or improper use of trust funds. The court considered whether these factors constituted a serious question to be tried and whether the balance of convenience favoured Navarac, particularly in light of the caveat already being lifted for certain lots. The court also needed to assess whether Moondancer's request for additional information before dismissing the summons constituted an abuse of process.

The court held that Moondancer's interest in the land was sufficient to maintain the caveat, as it was grounded in a proprietary interest recognised under the general law. The court found that the balance of convenience did not favour Navarac since the caveat had already been lifted for certain lots, and there was no demonstrated urgency to remove the caveat over the remaining development. Additionally, the court deemed Moondancer's request for the accounts as an abuse of process, given the lack of a serious question to be tried. Consequently, the application to dismiss the summons was dismissed.

No further orders were made by the court beyond dismissing the application.

Orders

Orders of the court

Application dismissed

Background

Background to the litigation

Navarac Pty Ltd, a company that holds units in a unit trust, is the registered proprietor of certain real property. Moondancer Holdings Pty Ltd, a unit holder in the unit trust, entered a caveat against the registration of a transfer of title to the property. The unit trust is held by two corporate trustees, both of which are trustees of the same unit trust, with the unit holders being the mother and two sons who are also the alter egos of the plaintiff and the unit holders. Moondancer, the defendant, alleges breaches of trusts involving unauthorised liabilities and use of funds by the plaintiff. There is an underlying dispute over whether Moondancer is the successor in title to one of the unit holders. There is no serious question to be tried regarding the validity of the caveat. The plaintiff argues that Moondancer's interest in the land is insufficient to maintain the caveat, while Moondancer contends that the balance of convenience should favour the plaintiff. The caveat has already been lifted to allow sales of newly created lots in the plaintiff's trading stock. However, the caveat remains over the rest of the development. Moondancer seeks an order that the summons be dismissed on the receipt of the accounts it seeks as a unit holder. The plaintiff contends that this is an abuse of process.

This case involves a summons by Navarac Pty Ltd, the plaintiff and registered proprietor, against Moondancer Holdings Pty Ltd, the defendant and caveator, to show cause why the caveat entered by the defendant should not be removed. The matter came before the court following an earlier application for the removal of the caveat relating to other land, proceedings CIV 2102 of 2007. The defendant has filed affidavit evidence in support of its claim, which has not been challenged by the plaintiff in this application. The court is required to determine whether the defendant has a sufficient interest in the land to maintain the caveat and whether the balance of convenience favours the plaintiff.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Does Moondancer Holdings Pty Ltd have a sufficient interest in the land to maintain the caveat?
2. Does the balance of convenience favour Navarac Pty Ltd?
3. Is Moondancer Holdings Pty Ltd's request for the accounts an abuse of process?

Held
1. Moondancer Holdings Pty Ltd has a sufficient interest in the land to maintain the caveat. The court found that a unit holder in a unit trust has a proprietary interest in the land, which is caveatable.
2. The balance of convenience does not favour Navarac Pty Ltd. The court determined that the balance of convenience favoured Moondancer Holdings Pty Ltd.
3. Moondancer Holdings Pty Ltd's request for the accounts is not an abuse of process. The court found that Moondancer's request for the accounts as a unit holder did not amount to an abuse of process.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In my view, that submission is contrary to the decision of Malcolm CJ in Connell v Bond Corporation Pty Ltd (1992) 8 WAR 352, 374, that although a unit holder does not have a specific title to any individual trust asset, and cannot claim to have any particular asset appropriated to his share or transferred to him, he nevertheless has 'a special and non‑specific equitable interest, [which] is nonetheless a proprietary interest'. His Honour went on to say that it followed, necessarily, that the holder of that interest had a caveatable interest in the land in question. That decision was adopted by Pullin J in Binningup Nominees Pty Ltd v Brogue Tableau Pty Ltd [2004] WASC 14 [26], which was followed by Simmonds J in Interview Holdings Pty Ltd v Registrar of Titles [2008] WASC 144. In my view, cl 3.3 of the Trust Deed does no more than state the position under the general law, as set out above. In seeking to show cause why its caveat should not be removed, Moondancer relies not only on its claimed status as a unit holder in the Trust, but on a number of matters referred to in affidavit evidence filed in this application and in proceedings CIV 2102 of 2007, a previous application for removal of the caveat relating to other land. The evidence, which has not been challenged in this application by Navarac, includes the following:1.Navarac has received more than $50 million from the sale of property but has made no distribution to Moondancer from those funds.2.Navarac's accounts for the year ended 30 June 2005 show a distribution of some $1.9 million, although that distribution was not received by Moondancer.3.Navarac's accounts for the year ended 30 June 2006 show distributions to Moondancer of some $2.2 million, but these distributions have not been received by Moondancer.4.Although Allen Caratti is a director of Navarac, he has not signed any resolution making loans of some $17 million to companies controlled by John or Maddeleine Caratti. These include interest‑free loans in excess of $11 million to companies related to John Caratti. 5.It appears from Navarac's accounts for the year ended 30 June 2006, that Navarac was then indebted to the National Australia Bank (NAB) in an amount of some $7.4 million. However, following the lifting of a caveat the subject of earlier proceedings in CIV 2102 of 2007, Navarac received some $26 million from the sale of land. It appears likely that these monies were paid to NAB to reduce Navarac's indebtedness. Thus, amounts were paid far in excess of the $7.4 million shown in the 30 June 2006 accounts.6.Navarac is a party to an interlocking company guarantee and indemnity granted on 15 September 2005, and a subsequent interlocking company guarantee and indemnity. Navarac has mortgaged its property to NAB as security for the interlocking guarantees. The loans the subject of the guarantees were made to parties other than Navarac and amounted to some $47.4 million, all secured against Navarac's assets.7.Neither Navarac nor NAB has provided details of Navarac's present indebtedness to the bank.