National Transport Insurance Ltd v Chalker

Link copied
Case Copied 36 min read

NEW SOUTH WALES COURT OF APPEAL

CITATION:      NATIONAL TRANSPORT INSURANCE LIMITED v CHALKER & ORS [2005]  NSWCA 62

FILE NUMBER(S):
40384/03

HEARING DATE(S):               16 August 2004, 17 August 2004

JUDGMENT DATE: 15/03/2005

PARTIES:
NATIONAL TRANSPORT INSURANCE LIMITED
MARK WENTWORTH CHALKER
REX J ANDREWS PTY LTD
LEITH HALLORAN GRIEVE
QBE INSURANCE

JUDGMENT OF:       Mason P Tobias JA Grove J   

LOWER COURT JURISDICTION: District Court

LOWER COURT FILE NUMBER(S):          DC 8483/00

LOWER COURT JUDICIAL OFFICER:     Black DCJ

COUNSEL:
Appellant: L King SC / M J Stevens
1st Respondent: P G Mahony
2nd Respondent: M Ward
3rd Respondent: D Campbell SC/ C Burge
4th Respondent: P Deakin QC

SOLICITORS:
Appellant: Fraser Clancy, Sydney
1st Respondent: Cragg Braye & Thornton, Singleton
2nd Respondent: McCabe Terrill, Sydney
3rd Respondent: Beston Macken McManis, Sydney
4th Respondent: Wordsworth Lawyers, Sydney

CATCHWORDS:
Negligence - employer liability to indemnify - s3(1)(b) Employees Liability Act - independent contractor - employment status - deemed employment -Schedule 1 Cl 2(1) Workplace Injury Management and Workers Compensation Act - non-delegable duty of care - contributory negligence - Law Reform (Miscellaneous Provisions) Act 1946- motor vehicle insurance - contractual indemnity - costs - Sanderson order. (D)

LEGISLATION CITED:
Contracts Review Act 1980
Employees' Liability Act 1991 s3(1)(b)
Industrial Relations Act 1996 s106
Law Reform (Miscellaneous Provisions) Act 1946
Workers Compensation Act 1926 s6(3)(a)
Workplace Injury Management and Workers Compensation Act 1998

DECISION:
Appeal allowed in part.

JUDGMENT:

IN THE SUPREME COURT
OF NEW SOUTH WALES
COURT OF APPEAL

CA 40384/03

MASON P
TOBIAS JA
GROVE J

Tuesday 15 March 2005

NATIONAL TRANSPORT INSURANCE LIMITED v Mark Wentworth CHALKER & Ors

JUDGMENT

  1. MASON P:  

    Introduction

  2. The third respondent, Mr Grieve (hereafter “the plaintiff”) was injured when struck by a flying piece of pipe that sprang backwards when being used by the first respondent, Mr Chalker (hereafter “Chalker”) to loosen a chain that was part of the apparatus of heavy moving equipment under his control.  It is no longer disputed that Chalker was negligent and that the plaintiff is entitled to recover damages for his injuries.  Those damages were assessed at $157,657.15 and judgment in that sum was entered in the District Court against Chalker.

  3. The issues in dispute in this appeal are:

    •whether the second respondent, Rex J Andrews Pty Limited (hereafter “Andrews”) is liable to indemnify Mr Chalker or contribute to the verdict ordered against him;

    •whether the appellant as the insurer of Chalker’s prime mover is liable under its Policy to indemnify Chalker with respect to his liability to the plaintiff.

    The facts in detail

  4. Andrews is a haulage company specialising in the transport of bulky and/or heavy items.  It operates from premises at Mount Riverview.  It owns purpose-built trailers and other specialist haulage equipment including dollies and jinkers which are each wheeled conveyances for carrying long loads, the dolly being attached to the prime mover and the jinker being at the back of the load.

  5. Andrews contracts to transport heavy items for its clients.  It performs an organising or entrepreneurial role…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read National Transport Insurance Ltd v Chalker and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2005] NSWCA 62
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The appeal concerned the liability of Rex J Andrews Pty Limited ("Andrews") to indemnify Mr Chalker, and the liability of National Transport Insurance Ltd ("NTI") under its policy to indemnify Chalker. The dispute arose from an accident involving the plaintiff, who was a driver engaged by Andrews.

The court was required to determine whether Andrews was liable to indemnify Mr Chalker or contribute to the verdict ordered against him. Furthermore, the court had to ascertain whether NTI, as the insurer of Chalker's prime mover, was liable under its policy to indemnify Chalker for his liability to the plaintiff. A central issue was the employment status of drivers like Mr Chalker, specifically whether they were deemed employees under the *Workplace Injury Management and Workers Compensation Act* or independent contractors.

The court considered the nature of the relationship between Andrews and the drivers. Andrews operated as a haulage company, organising the transport of heavy items by engaging owner-drivers of prime movers. While Andrews did not purport to employ these drivers, the factual circumstances of their engagement, including the exclusive work for Andrews, payment structure, provision of fuel cards and toll passes, and the use of Andrews' branded attire and dockets, were examined to determine their employment status. The court also considered the concept of a non-delegable duty of care owed by Andrews.

The appeal was allowed in part.

Orders

Orders of the court

Appeal allowed in part.

Background

Background to the litigation

The issues in dispute in this appeal are:•whether the second respondent, Rex J Andrews Pty Limited (hereafter “Andrews”) is liable to indemnify Mr Chalker or contribute to the verdict ordered against him;•whether the appellant as the insurer of Chalker’s prime mover is liable under its Policy to indemnify Chalker with respect to his liability to the plaintiff.The facts in detail Andrews is a haulage company specialising in the transport of bulky and/or heavy items. It operates from premises at Mount Riverview. It owns purpose-built trailers and other specialist haulage equipment including dollies and jinkers which are each wheeled conveyances for carrying long loads, the dolly being attached to the prime mover and the jinker being at the back of the load. Andrews contracts to transport heavy items for its clients. It performs an organising or entrepreneurial role that includes obtaining the services of owner-drivers of prime movers, organising requisite permits from the Road & Transport Authority (RTA) to use public roads, and the co-ordination of pick up and delivery of the load. Andrews does not purport to employ the drivers who are involved. The drivers owning prime movers are, to use a neutral term, engaged job by job. The precise relationship between Andrews and these drivers is one of the issues in this appeal. Under the direction of Andrews’ employees, the drivers attend designated pick-up spots with their prime movers after having collected the appropriate “rolling stock” from Andrews’ premises. The plaintiff and Chalker were among the drivers on Andrews’ books. The plaintiff had worked for Andrews since 1992, Chalker having been first engaged in July 1998. Since his engagement, Chalker had worked exclusively for Andrews, being paid monthly based on sums calculated job by job. Andrews supplied its drivers with a BP card, a Shell card and a tollways pass, but deducted expenditure on such matters from the monthly remittance. Chalker estimated that he worked an average of 12 hours per day, five and sometimes seven days per week for Andrews. Chalker wore Andrews’ company shirts and caps when working for Andrews and used dockets provided by Andrews. There was no controlling written contract. The plaintiff’s accident occurred on 8 November 1998 at the RTA building site for the Eastern Distributor in Palmer Street, Woolloomooloo. It was on the occasion of Chalker’s fourth load to the site. The plaintiff had also brought earlier loads, but he had not previously met Chalker. These were two of several drivers engaged by Andrews to transport concrete beams from a CSR depot at Rooty Hill to the Woolloomooloo site. Each beam was 38m in length and it weighed approximately 41 tonnes. The beams were loaded on and off the trailers by crane. One end of the beam rested on the dolly attached to the prime mover, the other on the jinker. The dolly and jinker were linked by a bull chain which was a collection of smaller chains joined together and tensioned by two or more “chain dogs”.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.