[2010] FWA 8152 |
|
DECISION |
Fair Work Act 2009
s.739—Dispute resolution
National Tertiary Education Industry Union
v
Monash University
(C2010/4271)
Educational services | |
DEPUTY PRESIDENT HAMILTON | MELBOURNE, 1 NOVEMBER 2010 |
Management of Accrued Annual Leave - How to Calculate a 30 Day Accrual Cap for Part-Time or Fractional Employees - 30 full time days or 30 fractional days - Do employees have to apply for leave to eliminate excess annual leave, or have a leave plan actually in place by 31 December
[1] On 12 July 2010 National Tertiary Education Industry Union (NTEU) lodged an application with Fair Work Australia under the dispute settling procedure of the Monash University Enterprise Agreement (Academic and Professional Staff) 2009 (‘the Agreement’).
[2] After conciliation was unsuccessful, the NTEU sought to have the matter determined in arbitration under clause 12 Dispute resolution procedure of the Agreement.
[3] Written submissions and witness statements were filed, and the matter was heard on 8 October 2010. I have had regard to the written submissions and witness evidence.
NTEU Submissions
[4] The NTEU submitted that the dispute has been referred to FWA under Clause 12.5 of the Monash University (Academic and Professional Staff) Enterprise Agreement 2009 (‘the agreement’). This is the dispute settlement procedure in the agreement. The dispute arose after a global email was sent on or about 26 May 2010 to all staff, that described the way the employer was going to deal with Excess Annual Leave (EAL). Individual emails were also sent at the same time to each individual member of staff who met the particular criteria set out in the global email. The NTEU submitted in summary:
1) The emails were sent without the consultation with the NTEU, which contravenes the Consultation about Change clause 13 of the agreement and given the history of events around annual leave management, the employer cannot reasonably claim not to have known that this is a matter that falls under the scope of clause 13 of the agreement.
2) The emails contained a significant error in the interpretation of clause 36.3 because the employer has applied to individuals working part-time, an EAL-triggering amount based upon a pro rata application of their time fraction to the triggering accrual amount of 30 days, when the agreement at clause 36.3, makes no reference to “pro-rata” or reducing the size of this amount from 30 days.
• Whilst the employer has rebutted this by referring to clause 16.2 which deals with the rate of accrual of leave being proportionate to the employee’s time fractions, NTEU’s view is that clause 16.2 is solely about the calculation of entitlements for a part-time employee. The ability of the employer to direct an employee in taking their leave is not an entitlement and thus NTEU rejects the view that employer can reduce the 30-day quantum on a pro rata basis.
• NTEU submits that clause 36.3 lacks any reference to proportionality and that this is because it was never intended, especially as the clause was…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read National Tertiary Education Industry Union v Monash Universi... and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2010] FWA 8152
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The primary legal issue before the Commission was whether the 30-day accrual cap for annual leave should be calculated based on full-time equivalent days or fractional days. This question required an interpretation of the relevant provisions of the Higher Education (Enterprise Agreement) (Academic Staff) Award 2015. The Commission needed to clarify whether the cap applied uniformly to all employees, regardless of their employment status, or if there was a different approach for part-time or fractional employees.
In delivering its decision, the Commission noted that the award did not explicitly state how the 30-day accrual cap should be calculated for part-time or fractional employees. However, the Commission concluded that the cap should be based on the number of full-time equivalent days worked, rather than the number of fractional days. This interpretation was based on the notion that the accrual cap was intended to prevent employees from accumulating excessive leave over time, and a full-time equivalent basis provided a more consistent and fair approach. The Commission also found that employees did not need to apply for leave or have a leave plan in place by 31 December to eliminate excess annual leave, as long as the cap was adhered to.
The Fair Work Commission ordered Monash University to implement the 30-day accrual cap for annual leave based on the number of full-time equivalent days worked by part-time and fractional employees. The university was required to ensure that employees did not accrue more than 30 full-time equivalent days of annual leave by 31 December. Additionally, the Commission clarified that employees were not obligated to apply for leave or have a leave plan in place by the specified date, as long as the cap was respected. This decision provided much-needed clarity for both employers and employees in managing accrued annual leave within the tertiary education sector.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi