FAMILY COURT OF AUSTRALIA
| NARKIS & NARKIS AND ANOR (NO. 2) | [2018] FamCA 1026 |
| FAMILY LAW – PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – where there are some modest disputes about the nature of the process – where the wife seeks orders under s 79A of the Act but will now file a statement of claim which will seek relief against the trustee of a family trust – where despite there being no present formulated claim, the court accepts there will be and as such, anticipatory orders can be made – where there is a parenting dispute about a 15 year old child and the wife refuses to indicate where she is living despite the child’s father having sole parental responsibility – orders made for the filing of comprehensive evidence to resolve that issue. |
| Family Law Act 1975 (Cth) |
| B Pty Ltd and Ors & K and Anor [2008] FamCAFC 113 Narkis & Narkis [2016] FamCA 976 Narkis & Narkis (No. 3) [2016] FamCA 1048 Narkis & Narkis [2017] FamCA 52 Narkis & Narkis (No. 2) [2017] FamCA 118 Narkis & Narkis (No. 3) [2017] FamCA 184 Narkis & Narkis (No. 4) [2017] FamCA 200 Narkis & Narkis (No. 5) [2017] FamCA 225 Narkis & Narkis (No. 6) [2017] FamCA 226 Re K Appeal [1994] FamCA 21; (1994) FLC 92 461 |
| APPLICANT: | Ms Narkis |
| RESPONDENT: | Mr Narkis |
| PROPOSED INTERVENOR: | Mr HH Narkis |
| FILE NUMBER: | MLC | 210 | of | 2014 |
| DATE DELIVERED: | 28 March 2018 |
| PLACE DELIVERED: | Melbourne |
| PLACE HEARD: | Melbourne |
| JUDGMENT OF: | Cronin J |
| HEARING DATE: | 28 March 2018 |
REPRESENTATION
| COUNSEL FOR THE APPLICANT: | Mr McEvoy QC with Ms Matson |
| SOLICITOR FOR THE APPLICANT: | Farrar Gesini Dunn |
| COUNSEL FOR THE RESPONDENT: | Ms Lane |
| SOLICITOR FOR THE RESPONDENT: | Cantwell Family Lawyers |
| COUNSEL FOR THE INTERVENOR: | Mr Wraith |
| SOLICITOR FOR THE INTERVENOR: | Tisher Liner FC Law |
Orders
Parenting
That all outstanding applications are adjourned to a date to be fixed.
That the Wife file and serve an affidavit on or before 4pm 13 April 2018 addressing:
a. The basis upon which she alleges the Husband should not be provided with the child’s residential address; and
b. Details of the child’s living arrangements and conditions.
The Husband be at liberty to file an Affidavit in answer to the Wife’s Affidavit within 14 days of service of the Wife’s affidavit.
That pursuant to Section 68L(2) the Family Law Act 1975 the child E born on the … 2002 be separately represented AND IT IS REQUESTED that Victoria Legal Aid arrange such separate representation.
That forthwith upon appointment by the said Victoria Legal Aid or otherwise the Independent Children’s Lawyer file a Notice of Address for Service.
That within 48 hours of notification of such appointment the parties, and if represented the solicitors for the respective parties, provide to the Independent Children’s Lawyer copies of all relevant documents relied upon.
That pursuant to section 91B Family Law Act 1975, the Department of Health and Human Services be invited to intervene in these proceedings.
Financial matters
That in relation…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Narkis and Narkis and Anor (No. 2) and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2018] FamCA 1026
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court was required to determine several legal issues. In relation to parenting, the court needed to address the Wife's assertion that the Husband should not be provided with the child's residential address and to gather details of the child's living arrangements. The court also considered the separate representation of the child, E, pursuant to section 68L(2) of the *Family Law Act 1975* (Cth), and the potential intervention of the Department of Health and Human Services under section 91B of the same Act. Financially, the court was tasked with allocating responsibility for outstanding expenses related to a property at M Street, Suburb N, and arranging for inspections of properties at M Street, Suburb N, and Q Street, Suburb R, to assess necessary repairs. Procedurally, the court had to consider the Wife's application to join Mr HH Narkis as trustee of the Family Trust as a party, the basis of any relief sought against the Trust, and whether the court's power under section 79 of the *Family Law Act 1975* had been exhausted by previous final orders.
Cronin J made orders addressing these matters. The Wife was directed to file an affidavit detailing her objections to the disclosure of the child's address and the child's living arrangements. The court ordered that the child E be separately represented by an Independent Children's Lawyer and invited the Department of Health and Human Services to intervene. Regarding financial matters, the Wife was ordered to pay specific outstanding expenses for the M Street property and to facilitate inspections of both the M Street and Q Street properties, with differing cost allocations for each. Procedurally, the Wife was required to file an amended initiating application seeking to join the Family Trust and provide submissions on the exhaustion of section 79 powers and the joinder of the trustee. Directions were given for the Husband and the Family Trust trustee to file responses, and the matter was listed for mention to address the joinder, section 79 power, and further directions. The costs of the parties and Mr HH Narkis were reserved, with liberty to apply. A notation indicated an agreement for 45 per cent of the proceeds of sale of the Suburb T property to be held on trust pending determination of the proceedings.
Orders
Orders of the court
Parenting
1.
That all outstanding applications are adjourned to a date to be fixed.
2.
That the Wife file and serve an affidavit on or before 4pm 13 April 2018 addressing:
a. The basis upon which she alleges the Husband should not be provided with the child’s residential address; and
b. Details of the child’s living arrangements and conditions.
3.
The Husband be at liberty to file an Affidavit in answer to the Wife’s Affidavit within 14 days of service of the Wife’s affidavit.
4.
That pursuant to Section 68L(2) the Family Law Act 1975 the child E born on the … 2002 be separately represented AND IT IS REQUESTED that Victoria Legal Aid arrange such separate representation.
5.
That forthwith upon appointment by the said Victoria Legal Aid or otherwise the Independent Children’s Lawyer file a Notice of Address for Service.
6.
That within 48 hours of notification of such appointment the parties, and if represented the solicitors for the respective parties, provide to the Independent Children’s Lawyer copies of all relevant documents relied upon.
7.
That pursuant to section 91B Family Law Act 1975, the Department of Health and Human Services be invited to intervene in these proceedings.
Financial matters
8.
That in relation to the real property know as M Street, Suburb N the Wife shall pay the following expenses for the said property in addition to the monthly sum of $4,167 including but not limited to:
a. Land tax owing in the amount of $8,094;
b. Land tax instalment due in March $5,772 and all further instalments of land tax as and when they fall due;
c. Building insurance premium $2,438; and
d. Accounts owing for repairs in the amount of $2,500.
9.
That within 14 days the Wife provide the names of 3 appropriately qualified tradespersons to the Husband to inspect the real properties as follows:
a. With respect to the real property at M Street, Suburb N in order to identify necessary repairs (if any) and provide a quotation as to the works to be done, with particular attention to water damage and the door lock system, with such attendance and report (if any) to be at the equal expense (if any) of the husband and the wife; and
b. With respect the real property at Q Street, Suburb R in order to ascertain in general terms the nature and extent of works to be done, with the expense (if any) of such attendance and report (if any) to be at the Wife’s sole expense.
c. With the Husband to make his election of tradespeople within a further 7 days and notify the Wife of his election.
d. The Wife’s solicitors to contact the tradespeople to facilitate the inspections of the properties; and
e. The Wife is not permitted to attend either of the properties for the purposes of any inspection.
Procedural matters
10.
That on before 4pm 4 May 2018 the Applicant Wife file and serve:
a. an Amended Initiating Application (if any) seeking to join Mr HH Narkis in his capacity as trustee of the Ms JK & Mr Narkis Family Trust (“the Family Trust”) as a party to the proceeding, annexing a Statement of Claim setting out the basis of any relief sought against the Family Trust or its assets and particularising the basis of any claim under section 79A Family Law Act 1975 (Cth);
b. any affidavit in support thereof;
c. written submissions in relation to:
i. her assertion that the power of the Court pursuant to section 79 Family Law Act 1975 was not exhausted after the making of final orders on 13 April 2017 with respect to each of:
1. the superannuation fund; and
2. the Family Trust.
ii. the joinder of Mr HH Narkis in his capacity as trustee of the Family Trust.
11.
That no later than 4pm 5 June 2018 the Respondent Husband file an Amended Response attaching a Defence to any Statement of Claim so filed and submissions.
12.
That no later than 4pm 15 June 2018, Mr HH Narkis in his capacity as trustee of the Family Trust file and serve a Defence and a response to the submissions of the Applicant and First Respondent (if necessary) in so far as they relate to the Family Trust or the assets of the trust and the question of joinder.
13.
That matter be listed for mention on a date to be advised by the Court for any further oral submissions as may be required by the Court and/or the release of judgment on the question of the joinder and any claim that the power under section 79 was not exhausted by the Orders of 13 April 2017 and further directions in relation to the conduct of the matter generally.
14.
The costs of the parties and Mr HH Narkis are reserved.
15.
Liberty to Apply.
NOTATION
The parties have agreed that the solicitors for Mr HH Narkis will hold 45 per cent of the proceeds of sale of the real property at S Street, Suburb T (“The Suburb T property”) on trust in the name of the Trustee in an interest bearing account until the determination of the proceeding.
A. That of the 55 per cent of the proceeds of sale of the property the Suburb T property the parties agree that the funds will only be used to meet expenses and investments of the Trust including those payments set out in paragraph 15 of the Affidavit of Mr HH Narkis dated 22 March 2018 and otherwise there be no distributions from these funds to beneficiaries pending determination of these proceedings
Note: The form of the order is subject to the entry of the order in the Court’s records.
Background
Background to the litigation
Full text does not contain this section.
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Full text does not contain this section.
Decision
Reasons for decision
Full text does not contain this section.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
Full text does not contain this section.