Nalini Asher Enterprises Pty Ltd v H&M Tracey Construction Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 33 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Nalini Asher Enterprises Pty Ltd v H&M Tracey Construction Pty Ltd [2019] FCA 2161

File number: VID 964 of 2019
Judge: MOSHINSKY J
Date of judgment: 17 December 2019
Catchwords: PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – preliminary discovery – where the prospective applicant and the first prospective respondent were both shareholders in the second prospective respondent – where there was an agreement between the shareholders as to the affairs of the second prospective respondent – where the prospective applicant contended that it may have a right to obtain relief from the first prospective applicant on the basis of breach of contract or breach of fiduciary duty and against the second prospective respondent on the basis of oppression – whether requirements for preliminary discovery satisfied
Legislation:

Corporations Act 2001 (Cth), ss 232, 233

Federal Court Rules 2011, rr 7.21, 7.23

Cases cited:

nearmap Ltd v Spookfish Pty Ltd [2014] NSWSC 1790

ObjectiVision Pty Ltd v Visionsearch Pty Ltd (No 3) [2015] FCA 304

Pfizer Ireland Pharmaceuticals v Samsung Bioepis AU Pty Ltd (2017) 351 ALR 103

Pfizer Ireland Pharmaceuticals v Samsung Bioepis AU Pty Ltd (No 2) [2019] FCA 657

Poole v Australian Pacific Touring Pty Ltd [2017] FCA 424

Reeve v Aqualast Pty Ltd [2012] FCA 679

Date of hearing: 12 and 16 December 2019
Registry: Victoria
Division: General Division
National Practice Area: Commercial and Corporations
Sub-area: Corporations and Corporate Insolvency
Category: Catchwords
Number of paragraphs: 52
Counsel for the Prospective Applicant: Mr DJ Briggs
Solicitor for the Prospective Applicant: Mills Oakley
Counsel for the First Prospective Respondent: Mr D Chandler
Solicitor for the First Prospective Respondent: Lemonis Tantiprasut Lawyers
Solicitor for the Second Prospective Respondent: Mr JR Ward
Solicitor for the Second Prospective Respondent: Cleary Hoare Solicitors

ORDERS

VID 964 of 2019
BETWEEN:

NALINI ASHER ENTERPRISES PTY LTD

Prospective Applicant

AND:

H&M TRACEY CONSTRUCTION PTY LTD

First Prospective Respondent

H&M TRACEY PILBARA PTY LTD

Second Prospective Respondent

JUDGE:

MOSHINSKY J

DATE OF ORDER:

17 DECEMBER 2019

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.By 4.00 pm on 31 January 2020:

(a)the first prospective respondent (HMT Construction or HMTC) give discovery to the prospective applicant (NAE) of the documents matching the descriptions contained in Schedule 1 to this order; and

(b)the second prospective respondent (HMT Pilbara or HMTP) give discovery to NAE of the documents matching the descriptions contained in Schedule 2 to this order.

2.Subject to paragraph 3, NAE pay the reasonable costs of each of HMT Construction and HMT Pilbara for collating, reviewing and providing the discovered documents, such costs to be assessed if not agreed.

3.If NAE commences substantive proceedings against HMT Construction and/or HMT Pilbara by 4.00 pm on 28 February 2020, all costs incurred by that prospective respondent in providing discovery will be costs in the substantive proceeding.

4.NAE pay HMT Construction’s and HMT Pilbara’s costs of the hearing on 12 December 2019.

5.In relation to the other costs of the application for preliminary discovery as between NAE and…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Nalini Asher Enterprises Pty Ltd v H&M Tracey Construction P... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2019] FCA 2161
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Nalini Asher Enterprises Pty Ltd sought preliminary discovery against H&M Tracey Construction Pty Ltd and H&M Tracey Pilbara Pty Ltd to obtain documents for a potential case of oppression and breach of fiduciary duty. The parties were shareholders in a third company, H&M Pilbara Pty Ltd. The case came before the Federal Court of Australia, where the Court had to decide whether the requirements for preliminary discovery were satisfied. The Court held that the requirements were met and ordered the disclosure of certain documents. The Court also considered the costs of the application and the adjournment, finding that Nalini Asher Enterprises should pay the costs of the adjournment and that the costs of the application should be borne by the party that did not prevail in the application. The Court ordered that the documents be provided by specific dates and that the costs of providing the documents be paid by the respondents if substantive proceedings were commenced within a certain timeframe.

The Court ordered that Nalini Asher Enterprises pay the costs of the adjournment and that the costs of the application be borne by the party that did not prevail in the application. The Court ordered that the documents be provided by specific dates and that the costs of providing the documents be paid by the respondents if substantive proceedings were commenced within a certain timeframe. The Court also ordered that if substantive proceedings were commenced within a certain timeframe, the costs of the application would be costs in the substantive proceeding.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. By 4.00 pm on 31 January 2020:

(a) the first prospective respondent (HMT Construction or HMTC) give discovery to the prospective applicant (NAE) of the documents matching the descriptions contained in Schedule 1 to this order; and

(b) the second prospective respondent (HMT Pilbara or HMTP) give discovery to NAE of the documents matching the descriptions contained in Schedule 2 to this order.

2. Subject to paragraph 3, NAE pay the reasonable costs of each of HMT Construction and HMT Pilbara for collating, reviewing and providing the discovered documents, such costs to be assessed if not agreed.

3. If NAE commences substantive proceedings against HMT Construction and/or HMT Pilbara by 4.00 pm on 28 February 2020, all costs incurred by that prospective respondent in providing discovery will be costs in the substantive proceeding.

4. NAE pay HMT Construction’s and HMT Pilbara’s costs of the hearing on 12 December 2019.

5. In relation to the other costs of the application for preliminary discovery as between NAE and HMT Construction:

(a) Subject to paragraph (b), each party bear its own costs.

(b) If NAE commences substantive proceedings against HMT Construction by 4.00 pm on 28 February 2020, each party’s costs of the application will be costs in the substantive proceeding.

6. In relation to the other costs of the application for preliminary discovery as between NAE and HMT Pilbara: HMT Pilbara pay NAE’s costs of the application, as agreed or assessed.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Schedule 1

DOCUMENTS FOR PRODUCTION FROM H&M TRACEY CONSTRUCTION PTY LTD

No.

Category

Documents

1.

Company books and records.

1.5

Minutes of directors’ meetings for HMTC during the period from 1 January 2018 to date referring to:

a. Any agreement with HMTP in respect of projects outside the Kimberley region,

including but not limited to the projects identified in Categories 4 and 5.

3.

Documents relating to existing contracts between Woodside and HMTC.

3.5

Tranche financial reconciliation including conciliation of payments for each tranche and tranche financial positions profit and loss sheets.

4.

Documents relating to previous or current projects tendered and/or delivered by HMTC outside the Kimberley region, since the date of the entering of the Company Agreement, being 2 December 2014, including but not limited to:

a. Onslow aircraft hangar;

b. RFDS hangar and Office, Perth;

c. North West Transitional Housing;

d. Onslow Sports Club and V Swans Office;

e. Residence at Parton Road, South Hedland;

f. 43 House Refurbishment Project, Swanbourne;

g. Lords Recreation Centre, Subiaco;

h. Kent Street, East Victoria Park Education Facility;

i. PPA Sample Station Upgrades, Boodarie;

j. EPC Community Hub, Karratha;

k. North Regional TAFE; and/or

l. 5 Huxtable Cres, Port Hedland;

4.4

Executed contracts for projects entered into by HMTC.

4.5

Financial reconciliations, including the final profit and loss position for the project.

5.

Documents relating to Corporate Overheads and Cost Recovery

5.1

Minutes of meetings confirming any agreement between HMTP and HMTC relating to corporate overhead cost recovery.

5.2

Documents, including financial documents, relating to the Pilbara region lease and office costs, including:

a. lease agreements;

b. office outgoings; and

c. cost recovery agreements between HMTP and HMTC,

in relation to the period since 22 May 2014.

Schedule 2

DOCUMENTS REQUESTED FROM H&M TRACEY PILBARA PTY LTD

No.

Category

Documents

1.

Company books and records.

Board Documents

Projects and Tenders

1.5

Agendas of directors meetings of HMTP between 1 April 2018 to date which identify as a topic for discussion:

a. existing projects (including but not limited to those identified in Categories 2 and 3); and/or

b. possible tenders (including but not limited to those identified in Category 4).

1.6

Minutes of directors meetings of HMTP from 1 April 2018 to date at which the following were discussed:

a. existing projects (including but not limited to those identified in Categories 2 and 3); and/or

b. possible tenders (including but not limited to those identified in Category 4).

Involvement of HMTC

1.10

Records of any resolutions by the board of HMTP between 1 April 2018 to date in relation to:

a. the subcontract of work to HMTC (and/or its associated entities); and/or

b. any novation or assignment of HMTP contracts to HMTC (and/or its associated entities).

Valuation

1.12

All correspondence between the director/s of HMTP (and/or their advisors) and any representative of Jarot in respect of the Valuation.

2.

Documents relating to current projects delivered within the HMTP works jurisdiction, including but not limited to:

b. RFDS hangar and Office, Perth;

c. North West Transitional Housing;

d. Onslow Sports Club and V Swans Office; and

e. Residence at Parton Road, South Hedland.

2.1

Invitations to tender received by HMTP from 1 April 2018 to date.

2.2

Final tender estimates prepared by HMTP from 1 April 2018 to date.

2.3

Tender responses submitted by HMTP from 1 April 2018 to date.

2.4

Executed contracts for projects entered into by HMTP on or after 1 April 2018.

2.5

Financial reconciliations, including the final profit and loss position for the projects identified.

3.

Documents relating to Woodside NWS Housing Panel Contract

3.1

Executed contracts between HMTP and Woodside (and/or its associated entities).

3.3

Any subcontract tender submitted to HMTP by HMTC (and/or any of its associated entities).

3.5

Any subcontract agreement entered between HMTP and HMTC (and/or any of its associated entities) in respect of any contract between HMTP and Woodside.

3.7

Tranche financial reconciliation, including profit and loss statements and conciliation of payments.

3.10

Tranche tender/pricing response issued to Woodside.

4.

Documents relating to current tenders outside the Kimberley region, including but not limited to:

b. Mount Claremont – Bus Depot D & C;

c. BHP Port Laboratory Replacement Project – Port Hedland;

d. Pilbara TAFE – Karratha Campus Facility Storage Area Stage 2; and

e. Multiple indigenous building and housing project tenders outside of the Kimberley, including Department of Housing Panel Contracts.

4.1

Invitations to tender received by HMTP from 1 April 2018 to date.

4.5

Copies of correspondence between the directors of HMTP (and/or their advisors) relating to preparing, submitting or not submitting tenders for any of the identified projects.

Background

Background to the litigation

Nalini Asher Enterprises Pty Ltd (NAE) commenced proceedings seeking preliminary discovery from H&M Tracey Construction Pty Ltd (HMT Construction) and H&M Tracey Pilbara Pty Ltd (HMT Pilbara). NAE is a shareholder in HMT Pilbara, while HMT Construction is also a shareholder in HMT Pilbara. The proceedings were initiated by NAE to explore potential claims of breach of contract or breach of fiduciary duty against HMT Construction and claims of oppression against HMT Pilbara. NAE sought discovery of various categories of documents from both HMT Construction and HMT Pilbara, which included company books and records, minutes of directors' meetings, executed contracts, financial reconciliations, and other documents relating to specific projects and agreements. The need for discovery arose from NAE's contention that it may have grounds to pursue legal action against HMT Construction and HMT Pilbara based on the conduct of the companies and the agreements between the shareholders.

The matter was heard in the Federal Court of Australia. NAE filed an amended originating application for preliminary discovery, which was contested by both HMT Construction and HMT Pilbara. The Court considered submissions from all parties regarding the scope of discovery, the costs associated with providing the documents, and the costs of the application itself. The Court also addressed the issue of whether the application was brought for a collateral purpose, which was denied based on the material presented. The Court determined the categories of documents to be discovered and ordered both HMT Construction and HMT Pilbara to provide the specified documents by a set deadline. Additionally, the Court ruled on the costs associated with the adjournment, the discovery process, and the application itself, determining that certain costs would be borne by NAE, while others would be paid by HMT Pilbara if substantive proceedings were initiated within a specified timeframe.

Decision

Reasons for decision

I note for completeness that it was submitted on behalf of HMT Pilbara that the application for preliminary discovery has been brought for a collateral purpose. I do not accept this submission on the basis of the material before the Court.Conclusion For these reasons, I will make orders for preliminary discovery of certain of the categories sought in the amended originating application. I will hear from the parties as to the form of the orders, and costs.[Submissions were then made regarding the form of orders and costs.]Costs There is no issue between the parties regarding the costs orders sought in paragraphs 2 and 3 of the amended originating application. (These relate to the costs of the prospective respondents in providing discovery.) However, there is an issue between the parties in relation to the costs of the application. NAE seeks its costs of the application on the basis that it has been successful in obtaining preliminary discovery, and in circumstances where both HMT Construction and HMT Pilbara adopted an adversarial approach: see Pfizer Ireland Pharmaceuticals v Samsung Bioepis AU Pty Ltd (No 2) [2019] FCA 657 (Pfizer No 2) at [26]-[29]. HMT Construction seeks its costs of the adjournment on 12 December 2019 on the basis that it was merely an observer to the need for that adjournment. HMT Construction also seeks its costs of the application on the basis that NAE has invoked an extraordinary jurisdiction and in accordance with the principles discussed in ObjectiVision Pty Ltd v Visionsearch Pty Ltd (No 3) [2015] FCA 304 at [13], [19] and [23]. See also Pfizer (No 2) at [25(2)]. HMT Pilbara seeks its costs of the adjournment on 12 December 2019 on the basis that it gave reasonable notice that it sought to cross-examine Mr Rydquist and the adjournment was occasioned by NAE’s failure to make Mr Rydquist available on that day. In relation to the application itself, HMT Pilbara accepts that it has been ordered to provide all the categories sought, but notes that it has conducted the case in a responsible way and that the original categories were substantially narrowed in the amended originating application. I will start with the costs of the adjournment on 12 December 2019. In my view, NAE should pay the costs of both HMT Construction and HMT Pilbara for that day. No satisfactory explanation has been provided as to why the request to cross-examine contained in the letter emailed on the morning of 10 December 2019 was not addressed. While Mr Rydquist has deposed that he could not have changed his travel plans, had the letter dated 10 December 2019 been read and dealt with appropriately, it may be that the hearing could have been adjourned without the need for an appearance on 12 December 2019. I turn now to the other costs of the application. The applicable principles are discussed by Burley J in Pfizer (No 2) at [25]-[27]. In circumstances where the prospective respondents adopted an adversarial approach to the application, I consider it appropriate to approach the issue having regard to (among other factors) the outcome of the application. As between NAE and HMT Construction, each side has had a substantial measure of success. I consider it appropriate in all the circumstances (including the nature of the application) for each party to bear its own costs of the application. However, as discussed with counsel for NAE and counsel for HMT Construction, I will also order that, if a substantive proceeding is commenced within a limited period of time, these costs be costs in that cause. As between NAE and HMT Pilbara, NAE has been successful in respect of all the categories in the amended originating application. Although it is true that the categories as originally proposed were amended, I nevertheless consider it appropriate in the circumstances for HMT Pilbara to pay NAE’s costs of the application.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court began by addressing the submission that the application for preliminary discovery had been brought for a collateral purpose, which it dismissed. The court found that the requirements for preliminary discovery were met based on the material presented, allowing it to order the discovery of certain documents. The court noted the agreement between the shareholders of the second prospective respondent regarding the company's affairs and the prospective applicant's contention about possible breaches of contract or fiduciary duty and potential oppression. The court carefully considered the categories of documents requested, narrowing them down based on the amended originating application, and ordered the disclosure of specific documents related to company books, records, project details, financial reconciliations, and contracts.

In determining the costs associated with the adjournment and the application, the court applied principles from previous cases, including Pfizer Ireland Pharmaceuticals v Samsung Bioepis AU Pty Ltd (No 2) and ObjectiVision Pty Ltd v Visionsearch Pty Ltd. The court reasoned that NAE should bear the costs of the adjournment due to the failure to address a request to cross-examine a witness, potentially avoiding the need for the adjournment. For the costs of the application, the court found that both NAE and HMT Construction had substantial measures of success, leading to an order for each party to bear its own costs. However, if substantive proceedings were initiated within a set timeframe, the costs of the application would become costs in the cause. Regarding HMT Pilbara, the court ordered it to pay NAE's costs of the application due to NAE's success in obtaining the discovery sought, despite the narrowing of the categories in the amended originating application.

The ratio decidendi of this decision lies in the careful balancing of costs in preliminary discovery applications, taking into account the outcome and the conduct of the parties. The court distinguished the current case from previous authorities by focusing on the specific circumstances of the application and the conduct of the parties involved.