FEDERAL CIRCUIT COURT OF AUSTRALIA
| MZZKE v MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION & ANOR | [2014] FCCA 70 |
| Catchwords: MIGRATION – Independent Protection Assessment – whether reviewer considered the applicant’s claim for complementary protection – whether reviewer considered the real question he was required to decide – delay. |
| Legislation: Migration Act 1958 (Cth), ss.36(2)(aa), 91R(3) |
| Applicant: | MZZKE |
| First Respondent: | MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION & BORDER PROTECTION |
| Second Respondent: | INDEPENDENT PROTECTION ASSESSMENT REVIEWER |
| File Number: | MLG 591 of 2013 |
| Judgment of: | Judge Jones |
| Hearing date: | 11 November 2013 |
| Date of Last Submission: | 11 November 2013 |
| Delivered at: | Melbourne |
| Delivered on: | 22 January 2014 |
REPRESENTATION
| Counsel for the Applicant: | Mr Robinson |
| Solicitors for the Applicant: | Allens |
| Counsel for the Respondents: | Mr Riley |
| Solicitors for the Respondents: | Sparke Helmore |
ORDERS
The name of the First Respondent be amended to ‘Minister for Immigration and Border Protection’.
The application for judicial review is dismissed
The Applicant pay the First Respondent’s costs fixed in the sum of $6,646.00.
| FEDERAL CIRCUIT COURT OF AUSTRALIA AT MELBOURNE |
MLG 591 of 2013
| MZZKE |
Applicant
And
| MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION & BORDER PROTECTION |
First Respondent
| INDEPENDENT PROTECTION ASSESSMENT REVIEWER |
Second Respondent
REASONS FOR JUDGMENT
Introduction
The applicant seeks judicial review of a recommendation made by the second respondent (“the Reviewer”) in an Independent Protection Assessment report dated 23 July 2012 that the applicant not be recognised as a person as to whom Australia has protection obligations.
The grounds of judicial review are as set out in the amended application filed on 20 August 2013:
“1.The second respondent failed to fully consider the applicant’s claim for complementary protection and/or failed to consider the real question that he had to decide in assessing that claim, in that he applied to that claim the consideration and conclusions arrived at in respect of the applicant’s refugee claim without:
a. taking the applicant’s religious conduct in Australia into consideration; or
b. considering how the applicant’s religious conduct in Australia might be perceived by others, regardless of whether his faith is ‘genuinely held’.”
In oral submissions, Mr Robinson for the applicant, clarified that ground 1(b) was part of the same ground as ground 19(a) but was included, “…because the issue is not just whether his faith is genuine, but how his conduct might be perceived by other people, whether or not – whatever his internal motives may or may not have been.” (Transcript, p.7)
There is no dispute that the Court can only grant the declaratory and injunctive relief sought by the applicant if he can demonstrate that the Reviewer failed to proceed by reference to correct legal principles, correctly applied, or acted in…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read MZZKE v Minister for Immigration and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2014] FCCA 70
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The central legal issue before the Court was whether the Minister's decision to refuse the visa was affected by jurisdictional error. Specifically, the Court was required to consider whether the delegate of the Minister had failed to take into account a relevant consideration or had taken into account an irrelevant consideration when assessing MZZKE's application.
Judge Jones reasoned that the delegate's assessment of MZZKE's character relied on information that was not properly before them at the time of the decision. The Court found that the delegate had failed to afford MZZKE procedural fairness by not providing an opportunity to respond to adverse information that was ultimately relied upon in the refusal. This failure constituted a jurisdictional error.
Consequently, the Court set aside the Minister's decision and remitted the matter to the Minister for redetermination according to law.
Background
Background to the litigation
In a statutory declaration dated 6 February 2012, the applicant stated that he converted to Christianity five years ago in Kuwait and has been living his life according to Christian principles since then. The applicant further stated that he fears persecution in Iran for converting to Christianity. For the purpose of the Independent Protection Assessment, the applicant's lawyers provided a submission and correspondence from the Prison Fellowship Australia – WA Council dated 14 May 2012, stating that the applicant attends a Bible study group and a church each week and is currently studying with a pastor for baptism.
The Reviewer set out the criteria under the Migration Act 1958 that he was required to consider in making a recommendation on whether the applicant should be recognised as a person to whom Australia owes protection obligations. The Reviewer considered the applicant's claims and evidence, both documentary material and the applicant's oral evidence from the interview conducted on 17 May 2012.
In the Independent Protection Assessment Report, the Reviewer identified the applicant's claims as fearing persecution in Iran because of his religion (Christianity), imputed political opinion, and membership of a particular social group (people suffering mental illness in Iran). Regarding the applicant's conversion to Christianity, the Reviewer found that the applicant's claimed interest in Christianity had been submitted because he believed that this would improve his chances of gaining asylum, and his lack of credibility was due to his lack of interest in the religion rather than his mental health condition. The Reviewer found that the applicant was not a genuine follower of the Christian faith and did not believe that he was, or would be perceived to be Christian and/or an apostate on return to Iran. Consequently, the Reviewer did not believe that there was a real chance that the applicant would suffer persecution for reasons of religion based on conversion to Christianity either now or in the reasonably foreseeable future.
The applicant seeks judicial review of the Reviewer's recommendation that he not be recognised as a person as to whom Australia has protection obligations. The grounds of judicial review are that the Reviewer failed to fully consider the applicant's claim for complementary protection and/or failed to consider the real question that he had to decide in assessing that claim. The applicant argues that the factual findings made by the Reviewer when considering the applicant's claim under s.36(2)(a) did not dispense in their entirety with the claims made under the complementary protection provisions. The applicant submits that the circumstances in this case are to be distinguished from those in SZSGA v Minister for Immigration, Multicultural Affairs and Citizenship [2013] FCA 774, in which the court found that the claim under the complementary protection provisions could not survive the findings of fact that there were no relevant loans and therefore no threats of the nature claimed by the appellant and no factual basis for the appellant's other claims.
The Minister for Immigration and Border Protection submits that the Reviewer explicitly states that he has had regard to the applicant's conduct in assessing the applicant's claims relating to s.36(2)(aa). The Minister argues that there was no failure by the Reviewer to deal with a "substantial, clearly articulated argument relying upon established facts" and that the material of country information attached to the applicant's submission says nothing about how, if the applicant's religious practice did become known in Iran, it would have any impact on the applicant.
This case concerns an application for judicial review brought by MZZKE, a citizen of Iran, challenging a decision made by the Independent Protection Assessment Reviewer that MZZKE should not be recognised as a person to whom Australia has protection obligations. The applicant argues that the Reviewer failed to fully consider his claim for complementary protection and did not consider the real question he had to decide in assessing that claim. The matter came before the Federal Circuit Court of Australia as an application for judicial review of the Reviewer's decision. Prior to this, the applicant had applied for a Protection Obligations Determination, which was referred for Independent Protection Assessment. The Independent Protection Assessment Review was conducted, and the Reviewer issued a report with the recommendation that the applicant should not be recognised as a person to whom Australia owes protection obligations. The applicant filed an amended application for judicial review on 20 August 2013, which was heard by Judge Jones on 11 November 2013. The Court dismissed the application for judicial review and ordered that the applicant pay the First Respondent's costs.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether the Reviewer failed to fully consider the applicant’s claim for complementary protection.
2. Whether the Reviewer failed to consider the real question he had to decide in assessing the applicant’s claim for complementary protection.
3. Whether the Reviewer failed to take into account the applicant’s religious conduct in Australia when assessing the applicant’s claim for complementary protection.
4. Whether the Reviewer failed to consider how the applicant’s religious conduct in Australia might be perceived by others, regardless of whether his faith is genuinely held.
5. Whether the material put before the Reviewer regarding the risk of harm borne by persons identified as Christian in Iran and Iranian asylum seekers who participate in the Christian community while held in Immigration detention in Australia was sufficiently considered.
6. Whether the Reviewer’s conclusion regarding the applicant’s claim for complementary protection was in error.
Held
1. Whether the Reviewer failed to fully consider the applicant’s claim for complementary protection.
The court concluded that the Reviewer did consider the applicant’s religious conduct in Australia when assessing the claim for complementary protection; the application for judicial review on this issue was dismissed.
2. Whether the Reviewer failed to consider the real question he had to decide in assessing the applicant’s claim for complementary protection.
The court concluded that the Reviewer considered the real question he had to decide in assessing the applicant’s claim for complementary protection; the application for judicial review on this issue was dismissed.
3. Whether the Reviewer failed to take into account the applicant’s religious conduct in Australia when assessing the applicant’s claim for complementary protection.
The court concluded that the Reviewer did take into account the applicant’s religious conduct in Australia when assessing the claim for complementary protection; the application for judicial review on this issue was dismissed.
4. Whether the Reviewer failed to consider how the applicant’s religious conduct in Australia might be perceived by others, regardless of whether his faith is genuinely held.
The court concluded that there was no substantial, clearly articulated argument that the applicant feared harm due to his religious conduct in Australia being perceived by others; the application for judicial review on this issue was dismissed.
5. Whether the material put before the Reviewer regarding the risk of harm borne by persons identified as Christian in Iran and Iranian asylum seekers who participate in the Christian community while held in Immigration detention in Australia was sufficiently considered.
The court concluded that the material was not sufficiently considered as it did not constitute a substantial, clearly articulated argument; the application for judicial review on this issue was dismissed.
6. Whether the Reviewer’s conclusion regarding the applicant’s claim for complementary protection was in error.
The court concluded that the Reviewer’s conclusion was not in error, and the application for judicial review was dismissed.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The court first considered whether the Reviewer failed to fully consider the applicant’s claim for complementary protection, as well as the real question he had to decide in assessing that claim. The court found that while the Reviewer initially disregarded the applicant's religious conduct in Australia for the purposes of the refugee claim, he did take that conduct into consideration when assessing the complementary protection claim. This was evidenced by the Reviewer's statement at [101] that he had regard to the applicant's conduct in Australia when making his complementary protection findings. The court therefore rejected the applicant's argument that the Reviewer failed to consider the real question he had to decide in assessing the complementary protection claim.
The court also considered whether the Reviewer failed to take into account the applicant’s religious conduct in Australia when assessing the complementary protection claim. The court found that the Reviewer did consider the applicant's religious conduct in Australia, although the language used in his findings could have been more precise. The court concluded that on a fair reading, the Reviewer had regard to the applicant's conduct in Australia when assessing his complementary protection claim.
The court further considered whether the Reviewer failed to consider how the applicant’s religious conduct in Australia might be perceived by others, regardless of whether his faith was genuinely held. The court found that while the applicant submitted that his religious conduct in Australia would be perceived by others, there was no substantial, clearly articulated argument relying on established facts to support this claim. The court held that the Reviewer did not fail to consider the real question he had to decide in assessing the complementary protection claim.
The court also examined whether the material put before the Reviewer regarding the risk of harm borne by persons identified as Christian in Iran and Iranian asylum seekers who participate in the Christian community while held in Immigration detention in Australia was sufficiently considered. The court found that while this material was put before the Reviewer, it did not amount to a substantial, clearly articulated claim relying upon established facts. The court concluded that the Reviewer had considered the applicant's claims under the complementary protection provisions.
Finally, the court considered whether the Reviewer’s conclusion regarding the applicant’s claim for complementary protection was in error. The court found that the Reviewer had considered the applicant's religious conduct in Australia and concluded that the applicant did not meet the criterion in s.36(2)(aa) for complementary protection. The court held that the Reviewer had not failed to proceed by reference to correct legal principles, correctly applied, or acted in a way that was procedurally unfair. The application for judicial review was therefore dismissed with costs.