MZZCB v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship

Link copied
Case Copied 24 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

MZZCB v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship [2013] FCA 878

Citation: MZZCB v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship [2013] FCA 878
Appeal from: MZZCB v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship & Anor [2013] FCCA 199
Parties: MZZCB v MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION AND CITIZENSHIP and REFUGEE REVIEW TRIBUNAL
File number: VID 455 of 2013
Judge: DODDS-STREETON J
Date of judgment: 30 August 2013
Catchwords: MIGRATION – appellant claimed to have a well-founded fear of persecution due to his political profile and support for and involvement with the Telugu Desam Party – grounds of appeal failed to identify jurisdictional error – leave to raise new grounds of appeal refused as no reasonable prospects of success
Legislation: Migration Act 1958 (Cth) ss 36(2)(aa), 36(2A), 36(2B), 424A(1), 424A(3)
Refugees Convention (the Convention relating to the Status of Refugees done at Geneva on 28 July 1951, as amended by the Protocol relating to the Status of Refugees done at New York on 31 January 1967)
Cases cited: SZBYR and Anor v Minister for immigration and Citizenship and Anor (2007) 96 ALD 1; [2007] HCA 26
SZJMG v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship [2008] FCA 1145
Date of hearing: 12 August 2013
Date of last submissions: 12 August 2012
Place: Melbourne
Division: GENERAL DIVISION
Category: Catchwords
Number of paragraphs: 76
Counsel for the Appellant: The appellant appeared in person with the assistance of an interpreter
Counsel for the First Respondent: Mr D Brown of Australian Government Solicitor
Counsel for the Second Respondent: Counsel for the second respondent did not appear

IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

VICTORIA DISTRICT REGISTRY

GENERAL DIVISION

VID 455 of 2013

ON APPEAL FROM THE FEDERAL CIRCUIT COURT OF AUSTRALIA
BETWEEN:

MZZCB
Appellant

AND:

MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION AND CITIZENSHIP
First Respondent

REFUGEE REVIEW TRIBUNAL
Second Respondent

JUDGE:

DODDS-STREETON J

DATE OF ORDER:

30 AUGUST 2013

WHERE MADE:

MELBOURNE

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.The name of the first respondent be amended to “Minister for Immigration, Multicultural Affairs and Citizenship”.

2.        Leave to raise the new grounds of appeal stated in oral submissions is refused.

3.        The appeal is dismissed with costs.

Note:Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

VICTORIA DISTRICT REGISTRY

GENERAL DIVISION

VID 455 of 2013

ON APPEAL FROM THE FEDERAL CIRCUIT COURT OF AUSTRALIA
BETWEEN:

MZZCB
Appellant

AND:

MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION AND CITIZENSHIP
First Respondent

REFUGEE REVIEW TRIBUNAL
Second Respondent

JUDGE:

DODDS-STREETON J

DATE:

30 AUGUST 2013

PLACE:

MELBOURNE

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

INTRODUCTION

  1. By notice of appeal dated 5 June 2013 the appellant appeals from the decision of a Federal Circuit Court Judge given on 17 May 2013.  Judge Turner dismissed the appellant’s application for judicial review of a decision of the first respondent, the Refugee Review Tribunal (“the Tribunal”), given on 28 September 2012, which affirmed a decision of the second respondent to refuse the grant of a Protection (Class XA) visa to the appellant.

  2. The first respondent relied on written…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read MZZCB v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2013] FCA 878
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The appellant, MZZCB, appealed a decision of the Minister for Immigration and Citizenship regarding his protection visa application. The primary legal issue was whether the Tribunal had made jurisdictional errors in its assessment of the appellant's credibility and the evidence presented. The Federal Circuit Court had previously dismissed the appeal, and MZZCB sought leave to appeal to the High Court.

The court considered whether the grounds of appeal identified jurisdictional errors by the Tribunal. The appellant claimed that the Tribunal had failed to provide him with an opportunity to respond to adverse findings and had made erroneous findings about his credibility and evidence. The court found that the Tribunal had not erred in allowing the appellant to present his case, as he was represented by a migration agent and provided written statements and submissions. The court also determined that the Tribunal had not failed to inform the appellant of adverse findings because the information in question did not require comment under section 424A(1) of the Act. The court held that the Tribunal's discussion of the issues with the appellant indicated that his claims might not be found valid.

The court further considered whether the Tribunal had made erroneous findings. The appellant argued that the Tribunal relied on incorrect country information, erred in rejecting his evidence about being identified by TRS members, and erred in relying on inconsistencies in his descriptions of harm. The court found that the Tribunal's assessment of the appellant's credibility was not flawed, as the appellant's evidence was vague and non-specific. The court also noted that the inconsistencies in the appellant's descriptions of the harm he suffered were not central to the Tribunal's rejection of his claims.

Ultimately, the court found that the grounds of appeal failed to identify jurisdictional errors and did not have reasonable prospects of success. The court refused leave to raise new grounds of appeal and dismissed the appeal with costs. The court also ordered that the name of the first respondent be amended to "Minister for Immigration, Multicultural Affairs and Citizenship".

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The name of the first respondent be amended to “Minister for Immigration, Multicultural Affairs and Citizenship”.

2. Leave to raise the new grounds of appeal stated in oral submissions is refused.

3. The appeal is dismissed with costs.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

In my opinion, his Honour did not err in finding that the appellant was afforded a fair opportunity to put his case.47Section 429A of the Act provides:429A Oral evidence by telephone etc.For the purposes of the review of a decision, the Tribunal may allow the appearance by the applicant before the Tribunal, or the giving of evidence by the applicant or any other person, to be by:(a) telephone; or (b) closed-circuit television; or (c) any other means of communication. Section 429A is an enabling provision giving the Tribunal a discretion to allow an appearance and the giving of evidence by various means, including video link. There is nothing to suggest that in this case the discretion miscarried. In the present case, the appellant was represented at the hearing before the Tribunal by a registered migration agent. Although he had the assistance of an interpreter, the appellant nevertheless chose to give evidence in English. He was afforded an opportunity to present evidence and argument and participated in the hearing. He also provided the Tribunal with a written statement and supplementary written submissions prior to the hearing.Failure to allow the appellant an opportunity to respond The appellant submitted that the Tribunal failed to inform him of a number of adverse findings (additional to its findings about his medical evidence) and, accordingly, denied him the opportunity to respond. In particular, the appellant submitted that the Tribunal failed to inform him that:(a)it did not believe his assertions about the political issues and clashes in the relevant periods; and(b)it believed that, due to his lack of political profile, there was no real risk that he would be caught up in political violence. In my opinion, leave to raise the above new ground should be refused, as it has no reasonable prospects of success. As the first respondent submitted, the relevant country information was excluded from the requirements of s 424A(1) of the Act by virtue of s 424A(3)(a), as it was not specific to the appellant. Moreover, while s 424A(1)(a) of the Act requires the Tribunal to put to an applicant for comment certain information that it considers would be the reason, or a part of the reason, for affirming the decision under review, as recognised in SZBYR and Anor v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship and Anor (2007) 96 ALD 1; [2007] HCA 26 (at [18]):However broadly “information” [under s 424A(1)(a)] be defined, its meaning in this context is related to the existence of evidentiary material or documentation, not the existence of doubts, inconsistencies or the absence of evidence. The Tribunal’s discussion of the relevant issues with the appellant in any event indicated that his claims may not be found to be valid.Erroneous findings by the Tribunal The appellant alleged that the Tribunal:(a)relied upon incorrect country information; (b)erred in rejecting his evidence that TRS members were able to identify him because he was wearing TNFC official clothing; and(c)erred in relying on inconsistencies in his descriptions of the harm he suffered (his toenail being ripped and hot and/or cold water being poured on him) because the inconsistencies were due to his lawyer’s editing of his original statement.

Decision

Reasons for decision

In his further written submissions, the appellant stated:(a)He delayed lodging his protection visa application because he intended to apply for a new student visa but found it difficult to get into another college when his college closed in 2010. In oral submissions, he asserted that he had not realised that he could apply for a protection visa.(b)He was not invited to attend an interview with the first respondent’s delegate and he denied receiving an invitation letter from the Department of Immigration and Citizenship.(c)He would not be able to relocate because he had no employment history in India. He could not read or write in Hindu or Telugu and it would be unsafe for him anywhere in India.THE TRIBUNAL’S DECISION The Tribunal found that the appellant was “not a credible witness and has not been truthful in relation to his experiences in India, his reasons for leaving India and his fears about returning India”. The Tribunal found that the appellant’s evidence was “vague and lacking in detail”. The Tribunal accepted that the appellant is a supporter of the TNSF/TDP who may have attended meetings and rallies from time to time. The Tribunal did not accept, however, that the appellant was, as he claimed, a youth leader or president whose political profile would bring him to the attention of the TRS. The Tribunal noted that the appellant was only able to provide “the most general explanation of his involvement and activities” in relation to TNSF and/or TDP and had stated that he was not involved in politics as president. The Tribunal accepted that the appellant was involved in a motorbike accident and suffered injuries. The Tribunal did not accept that the appellant was targeted by the TRS as claimed, as his answers to questions were “vague and non-specific and he frequently had to be prompted to provide a [sic] meaningful answers”. Further, the Tribunal did not accept as credible “that the TRS members were able to identify him because he was wearing TNFS official clothing when he was travelling the opposite direction on a public road”. The Tribunal noted that the medical reports only referred to the appellant being involved in a “road traffic accident” and did not refer to a beating. The Tribunal found “implausible” the claim that the appellant’s political profile was “so potent” as to prompt an attack on the first day of his return to India in May 2010. The Tribunal again described the appellant’s answers as “vague and non-specific”. The Tribunal found the appellant’s account of his torture “unconvincing”. It also noted inconsistencies in the appellant’s evidence about whether he could recognise his attackers and the details of his torture. The Tribunal found that the appellant’s delay in applying for a protection visa between his return from India in May 2010 and the lodgement of his application on 9 February 2012 was “relevant in assessing the seriousness with which the [appellant] viewed risk of persecution in India and the credibility of his claims”.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

As the first respondent submitted, to the extent that the Tribunal referred to inconsistency in the appellant’s descriptions of the temperature of the water allegedly poured on him, it was not central to the Tribunal’s failure to accept the appellant’s claim that he had been abducted and tortured.CONSIDERATION OF GROUNDS OF APPEALGround 1 In my opinion, ground 1 of the notice of appeal is not established. There is no basis on which to conclude that the Tribunal erroneously imposed a burden of proof on the appellant in relation to the medical evidence he provided about his alleged beating by Telangana members and supporters. As the Federal Circuit Judge observed, the medical records stated that the appellant’s injuries were caused by another vehicle and made no mention of a broken jaw or an attack with sticks and rods. The Tribunal was entitled, in that context, to reject the appellant’s claim that he was targeted by Telangana members when injured in July 2008. The Tribunal rejected the appellant’s account of the incident primarily due to its assessment of his vague, non-specific, non-spontaneous answers and unconvincing assertions. It noted, in that context, the absence of any reference in the medical report to the alleged beating and (although the appellant had stated that in India hospitals did not get involved in criminal investigations) observed that it would have expected the medical report accurately to detail the cause of the injuries. At the hearing before the Federal Circuit Court, the appellant referred to information from the United States of America to the effect that hospitals in India will not provide treatment to persons injured by fighting or aggression, in order to explain the absence of any reference to the cause of his injuries in the report. As the Federal Circuit Court Judge observed, such material was not before the Tribunal and was not admissible in an application for review. As stated in SZJMG v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship [2008] FCA 1145 (at [27]), in an appeal from the Tribunal to the Federal Magistrates’ Court (Federal Circuit Court) or the Federal Court, fresh evidence is not admissible unless it bears upon some jurisdictional error. It is not admissible to invite the Court to disagree with a factual conclusion of the Tribunal. The Federal Circuit Judge correctly observed that in the present case, such new evidence would bear only on the Tribunal’s conclusion about the medical reports, which was not decisive in its rejection of his account of the 2008 motorbike incident. While the Tribunal did not specifically put its doubts to the appellant, as the Federal Circuit Judge observed, it was not obliged to do so. The appellant provided the medical evidence to the Tribunal and as such, it was excluded from s 424A of the Act by s 424A(3)(b). There was no basis for the appellant’s contention (which the Federal Circuit Judge correctly rejected) that the Tribunal was not entitled to reject medical evidence unless it was medically qualified.Ground 2