MZYVD v Minister for Immigration

Link copied
Case Copied 12 min read

FEDERAL CIRCUIT COURT OF AUSTRALIA

MZYVD & ORS v MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION & ANOR [2013] FCCA 607
Catchwords:
MIGRATION – Review of recommendation of Independent Merits Reviewer that the applicants not be recognised as refugees – unlawful employment only in country of habitual residence – whether such a threat to capacity to subsist – review dismissed.

Legislation

Migration Act 1958 (Cth), s.91R(2)(f)

Cases Cited

Minister for Immigration and Citizenship v SZMDS  [2010] HCA 16
SZPZI v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship & Anor [2011] FMCA 530
Applicants: MZYVD, MZYVE, MZYVF
First Respondent: MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION & CITIZENSHIP
Second Respondent: WENDY BODDISON (IN HER CAPACITY AS INDEPENDENT MERITS REVIEWER)
File Number: MLG 180 of 2012
Judgment of: Judge O’Dwyer
Hearing date: 22 August 2012
Date of Last Submission: 22 August 2012
Delivered at: Melbourne
Delivered on: 24 June 2013

REPRESENTATION

Counsel for the Applicants: Mr Anderson
Solicitors for the Applicants: Victoria Legal Aid
Counsel for the First Respondent: Ms E. Latif
Solicitors for the First Respondent: Clayton Utz

ORDERS

  1. The application filed on 20 February 2012, as amended, is dismissed.

  2. The first and second applicants pay the first respondent’s costs.

FEDERAL CIRCUIT COURT
OF AUSTRALIA
AT MELBOURNE

MLG 180 of 2012

MZYVD, MZYVE, MZYVF

Applicants

And

MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION & CITIZENSHIP

First Respondent

WENDY BODDISON (IN HER CAPACITY AS INDEPENDENT MERITS REVIEWER)

Second Respondent

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

Introduction

  1. This proceeding is an application for judicial review of the recommendation made by the second respondent (the reviewer) in her report dated 30 December 2011 which did not recommend that the applicants be recognised as persons to whom Australia has protection obligations under the 1951 Convention relating to the Status of Refugees, as amended by the 1967 Protocol relating to the Status of Refugees (“the Convention”).

Background and claims

  1. The first applicant is the husband of the second applicant, and both are the parents of the third applicant (a child of 3 years).


    They constitute a family of Faili Kurds, born in Iran and are Shia Muslims. They claim to fear persecution by reason of their Faili Kurd race or ethnicity; and imputed political opinion as persons who have sought asylum in Australia.

  2. They entered Australia by boat which was intercepted and taken to Christmas Island on 18 June 2010.

  3. On 21 August 2010 they requested an assessment by the Department of Immigration of their refugee status. A negative assessment was given. In forming that assessment, the Department’s officer accepted that the applicants were stateless Faili Kurds and that Iran was the country of former habitual residence. However, the officer was not persuaded that the discrimination the applicants may have faced in Iran amounted to persecution. The officer considered that the Iranian authorities may impose punitive measures in accordance with Iranian law for breaches of travel and exit regulations, but considered these were laws of general application and would not be applied to target the applicants for any Convention reason.

  4. In response, on 10 November 2010, the applicants applied for an independent…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read MZYVD v Minister for Immigration and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2013] FCCA 607
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The applicant, MZYVD, sought judicial review of a decision made by the Minister for Immigration, which affirmed a decision to refuse to grant a protection visa. The dispute concerned the applicant's claims for protection, which were based on a fear of persecution in their home country. The matter came before the Federal Court of Australia.

The primary legal issue before the Court was whether the delegate of the Minister had failed to consider relevant information when assessing the applicant's claims. Specifically, the applicant argued that the delegate had overlooked or inadequately considered evidence relating to their alleged experiences of persecution and their reasons for fearing future harm. This raised questions about the proper application of the *Migration Act 1958* (Cth) and the principles of administrative decision-making, including the duty to consider all relevant evidence.

Judge O’Dwyer found that the delegate’s assessment of the applicant’s claims was flawed. The Court determined that the delegate had not adequately engaged with significant portions of the evidence provided by the applicant, particularly concerning the specific nature of the alleged persecution and the applicant's subjective fear. The reasoning applied was that administrative decision-makers must demonstrably consider all relevant information placed before them, and a failure to do so can render the decision invalid. The Court concluded that the delegate’s decision was affected by jurisdictional error due to this failure to consider relevant evidence.

The Court set aside the decision of the Minister and remitted the application for a protection visa to the Minister for redetermination according to law.

Background

Background to the litigation

The applicants, MZYVD, MZYVE, and MZYVF, are a family of Faili Kurds, born in Iran and are Shia Muslims. They claim to fear persecution by reason of their Faili Kurd race or ethnicity and imputed political opinion as persons who have sought asylum in Australia. The family entered Australia by boat on 18 June 2010, which was intercepted and taken to Christmas Island. On 21 August 2010, they requested an assessment of their refugee status from the Department of Immigration, which was negative. In response, the applicants applied for an independent merits review conducted by Wendy Boddison. In her report dated 30 December 2011, the reviewer did not recommend that the applicants be recognised as persons to whom Australia has protection obligations under the 1951 Convention relating to the Status of Refugees. The applicants sought judicial review of the reviewer's recommendation, which is the subject of this case.

During the review process, the applicants claimed they faced discrimination and limitations on their rights to employment, education, and property ownership in Iran. The first applicant indicated that he had worked as a labourer in a furniture-making business from 2002 to 2010, but he had to work illegally due to his statelessness as a Faili Kurd. The reviewer summarised country information relevant to the work rights of refugees in Iran, which indicated that most refugees worked illegally, a practice that was widely, but not consistently, tolerated by the Iranian authorities. The first applicant maintained that there was a real risk of no employment, and that a lack of employment would threaten his (and his family's) ability to subsist. The reviewer, however, found that there was no real chance that the first applicant would be unable to find employment in the future.

The applicants abandoned two of their four grounds for review, leaving two grounds extant. The first ground was that the reviewer applied the wrong legal test in determining whether MZYVD was a person to whom Australia has obligations under the Refugees Convention. The applicants contended that the correct legal test was whether a denial of lawful employment to the first applicant threatened his capacity to subsist, and that the reviewer failed to give proper consideration to this aspect. The second ground was that the reviewer's recommendation was irrational or illogical in concluding that the applicants had continuous, albeit low paying, employment in the past, and that there was no real chance that MZYVD would not be able to obtain employment in the reasonably foreseeable future. The applicants contended that the reviewer's findings were not supported by the evidence.

The court dismissed the applicants' grounds for review, finding that the reviewer applied the correct legal test and made findings that were supported by the evidence. The court found that the reviewer gave due regard to the issue of the unlawful nature of employment for the first applicant and that the evidence presented about the work experience of the first applicant entitled the reviewer to conclude that he was in "continuous employment". The court also found that the reviewer's conclusions about the applicants' employment and the child applicant's rights to an education were consistent with the evidence before her and were open to her. The court concluded that the reviewer had not committed an error of law in considering the applicants' claims and applying the law.

The matter before the Federal Circuit Court of Australia in MZYVD v Minister for Immigration & Anor is an application for judicial review of the recommendation made by an Independent Merits Reviewer (IMR) under the Migration Act 1958 (Cth). The applicants, MZYVD, MZYVE, and MZYVF, are a family of Faili Kurds from Iran seeking refugee status in Australia. They were intercepted while attempting to enter Australia by boat and were taken to Christmas Island. Their initial assessment for refugee status by the Department of Immigration was negative, prompting an independent merits review by the IMR, Wendy Boddison. The IMR recommended that the applicants not be recognised as refugees, a decision which the applicants sought to challenge in the Federal Circuit Court. The applicants filed an application for judicial review on 20 February 2012, which was amended prior to the hearing on 22 August 2012. The applicants contended that the IMR's recommendation was affected by errors of law, including the application of an incorrect legal test and irrational or illogical conclusions. The court ultimately dismissed the application for judicial review, finding that the IMR's recommendations were supported by the evidence and did not exhibit any jurisdictional error.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Was the Independent Merits Reviewer's recommendation affected by an error of law in that she did not apply the correct legal principles in determining that MZYVD was not a person to whom Australia has obligations under the Refugees Convention?
2. Was the Independent Merits Reviewer's recommendation affected by an error of law in that it was irrational or illogical?
3. Did the Independent Merits Reviewer's recommendation err in finding that MZYVF (the child) would not suffer serious harm as envisaged by section 91R(2)(f) of the Act, given the country information on the child's rights to education, employment, and property ownership?

Held
1. The court concluded that the Independent Merits Reviewer did not err in applying the correct legal principles in determining that MZYVD was not a person to whom Australia has obligations under the Refugees Convention. The appeal on this issue was dismissed.
2. The court concluded that the Independent Merits Reviewer's recommendation was not affected by an error of law in that it was not irrational or illogical. The appeal on this issue was dismissed.
3. The court concluded that the Independent Merits Reviewer's recommendation did not err in finding that MZYVF (the child) would not suffer serious harm as envisaged by section 91R(2)(f) of the Act, given the country information on the child's rights to education, employment, and property ownership. The application on this issue was dismissed.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court's reasoning focused on three major issues presented in the case of MZYVD v Minister for Immigration. Firstly, the court examined whether the Independent Merits Reviewer's recommendation was affected by an error of law in that she did not apply the correct legal principles in determining that MZYVD was not a person to whom Australia has obligations under the Refugees Convention. The court referred to section 91R(2)(f) of the Migration Act 1958 (Cth), which defines "serious harm" as including a "denial of capacity to earn a livelihood of any kind, where the denial threatens the person's capacity to subsist." The applicants argued that the reviewer should have considered whether a denial of lawful employment to the first applicant threatened his capacity to subsist. However, the court found that the reviewer had applied the correct legal test and made findings supported by the evidence. Therefore, this ground was dismissed.

Secondly, the court considered whether the Independent Merits Reviewer's recommendation was affected by an error of law in that it was irrational or illogical. The applicants contended that the reviewer's conclusions about the applicant's employment were irrational. However, the court found that the reviewer had applied a probative logic to the evidence available to her and the applicable law. The court referred to the decision in Minister for Immigration and Citizenship v SZMDS, which sets out the principles applying to the determination of illogicality and irrationality. The court found that the evidence contradicted the applicants' contentions and that the reviewer's findings were open to her on the material before her. Therefore, this ground was also dismissed.

Lastly, the court assessed whether the Independent Merits Reviewer's recommendation erred in finding that MZYVF (the child) would not suffer serious harm as envisaged by section 91R(2)(f) of the Act, given the country information on the child's rights to education, employment, and property ownership. The reviewer concluded that the child's rights would be limited, but such limitations did not amount to serious harm and therefore persecution, which would entitle the child to protection under the Convention. The applicants argued that the reviewer's findings were irrational. However, the court found that the reviewer had addressed the issues of education raised by country information and determined, as a question of fact, that the limitations did not amount to harm of the requisite kind. The court found that the findings were consistent with the evidence before the Tribunal and were open to the reviewer. Therefore, this ground was also dismissed.

In conclusion, the court found that the Independent Merits Reviewer had not committed an error of law in considering the applicants' claims, on the evidence before her and in how she had applied the law. The application for judicial review was dismissed, and the first and second applicants were ordered to pay the first respondent's costs.

The ratio decidendi of this case is that the Independent Merits Reviewer applied the correct legal principles and made findings supported by the evidence when determining that the applicants were not persons to whom Australia has obligations under the Refugees Convention. The court found no error of law or irrationality in the reviewer's decision, and therefore, the application for judicial review was dismissed.