MZWDL v Minister for Immigration and

Link copied
Case Copied 19 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

MZWDL v Minister for Immigration and
Multicultural Affairs [2006] FCA 1153

MZWDL AND MZWDQ v MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION AND MULTICULTURAL AFFAIRS AND REFUGEE REVIEW TRIBUNAL

VID 360 OF 2006

NORTH J
8 AUGUST 2006
MELBOURNE


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

VICTORIA DISTRICT REGISTRY

VID 360 OF 2006

ON APPEAL FROM THE FEDERAL MAGISTRATES COURT OF AUSTRALIA

BETWEEN:

MZWDL
First Appellant

MZWDQ
Second Appellant

AND:

MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION AND MULTICULTURAL AFFAIRS
First Respondent

REFUGEE REVIEW TRIBUNAL
Second Respondent

JUDGE:

NORTH J

DATE OF ORDER:

8 AUGUST 2006

WHERE MADE:

MELBOURNE

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

(1)the appeal is dismissed; and

(2)the appellants are to pay the first respondent's costs of the appeal.

Note:    Settlement and entry of orders is dealt with in Order 36 of the Federal Court Rules.


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

VICTORIA DISTRICT REGISTRY

VID 360 OF 2006

ON APPEAL FROM THE FEDERAL MAGISTRATES COURT OF AUSTRALIA

BETWEEN:

MZWDL
First Appellant

MZWDQ
Second Appellant

AND:

MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION AND MULTICULTURAL AFFAIRS
First Respondent

REFUGEE REVIEW TRIBUNAL
Second Respondent

JUDGE:

NORTH J

DATE:

8 AUGUST 2006

PLACE:

MELBOURNE

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

  1. Before the Court is an appeal against a judgment of Federal Magistrate McInnis, delivered on 21 March 2006.  His Honour dismissed an application for review of a decision of the Refugee Review Tribunal made on 15 January 2004.  That decision affirmed the decision of the delegate of the first respondent, the Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs, not to grant protection visas to the appellants.  The appellants are husband and wife.  The primary claim was made by the husband, so that the wife's appeal depends on the success of the husband's appeal.  Consequently, I will refer to the husband as the appellant in this judgment. 

    BACKGROUND

  2. The appellant's visa application briefly outlines the essence of his claim, which was elaborated upon in his evidence before the tribunal.  The tribunal noted certain differences between the claims made in the appellant's visa application, and his oral evidence before the tribunal.  However, those differences do not assume significance in this appeal.  The claims made by the appellant are set out in the decision of the tribunal in detail.  It is therefore only necessary for me to summarise the substance of those claims. 

  3. The appellant claimed that he was a businessman; a shopkeeper in Gujarat, India, and that he was a Muslim.  He described how people from the Vishva Hindu Parishad (VHP) demanded protection money from him to protect him and his business.  In relation to this extortion, he stated that:

    … VHP group is supported by Gujarat Government.  Its [sic] is the political party against the Muslims in entire Gujrat state. …

  4. He explained that on one occasion, people from the VHP came and demanded a very large amount of money, which he could not afford to pay.  Previously, he had made the requested payments.  On this occasion, following his refusal, the VHP threatened to kill him and his family if the amount was not paid.…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read MZWDL v Minister for Immigration and and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2006] FCA 1153
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case before the court involves an appeal against a decision made by Federal Magistrate McInnis on 21 March 2006, which dismissed an application for review of a decision by the Refugee Review Tribunal dated 15 January 2004. The tribunal had upheld a decision by the delegate of the Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs not to grant protection visas to the appellants, a husband and wife from India. The husband's appeal is considered the primary one, as the wife's appeal hinges on his success. The appellant, a Muslim businessman from Gujarat, India, claimed that he suffered extortion and violence due to his religious identity and business, perpetrated by the Vishva Hindu Parishad (VHP), a Hindu nationalist group.

The court was required to decide whether the appellant's claims of persecution due to his Muslim identity were valid under the Refugees Convention. This involved examining the specific incidents of alleged persecution and the broader context of religious conflict in Gujarat, India. The court needed to determine if the appellant's experiences were due to his religion or if they were isolated incidents of extortion and violence that could happen to anyone in a similar socio-economic position, irrespective of religion.

The court found that while the appellant did experience extortion and violence, these incidents were not related to his religious identity but rather his status as a business owner in a region prone to such activities. The court also noted that while there had been significant violence between Hindus and Muslims in Gujarat, particularly in 2002, this did not necessarily mean that the appellant would face persecution upon his return to Gujarat. The court concluded that the appellant's fear of future persecution was not well-founded, as he could potentially relocate within Gujarat to an area less affected by communal violence. Consequently, the appeal was dismissed, and the appellants were ordered to pay the costs of the appeal.

Orders

Orders of the court

(1) the appeal is dismissed; and

(2) the appellants are to pay the first respondent's costs of the appeal.

Background

Background to the litigation

Before the Court is an appeal against a judgment of Federal Magistrate McInnis, delivered on 21 March 2006. His Honour dismissed an application for review of a decision of the Refugee Review Tribunal made on 15 January 2004. That decision affirmed the decision of the delegate of the first respondent, the Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs, not to grant protection visas to the appellants. The appellants are husband and wife. The primary claim was made by the husband, so that the wife's appeal depends on the success of the husband's appeal. Consequently, I will refer to the husband as the appellant in this judgment. BACKGROUND The appellant's visa application briefly outlines the essence of his claim, which was elaborated upon in his evidence before the tribunal. The tribunal noted certain differences between the claims made in the appellant's visa application, and his oral evidence before the tribunal. However, those differences do not assume significance in this appeal. The claims made by the appellant are set out in the decision of the tribunal in detail. It is therefore only necessary for me to summarise the substance of those claims. The appellant claimed that he was a businessman; a shopkeeper in Gujarat, India, and that he was a Muslim. He described how people from the Vishva Hindu Parishad (VHP) demanded protection money from him to protect him and his business. In relation to this extortion, he stated that:… VHP group is supported by Gujarat Government. Its [sic] is the political party against the Muslims in entire Gujrat state. … He explained that on one occasion, people from the VHP came and demanded a very large amount of money, which he could not afford to pay. Previously, he had made the requested payments. On this occasion, following his refusal, the VHP threatened to kill him and his family if the amount was not paid. He reported this extortion to the police and several of the extortionists were arrested. As a result, the appellant was abducted and told he would not be released unless he withdrew the charges. He felt that he had no choice and did withdraw the charges. He was seriously bashed and thrown from a motor vehicle, which resulted in hospitalisation for some time. The appellant further claimed that he was approached by the VHP to give property to them. When he refused, two people came to his shop, and fired shots, causing the death of a client. The police were called, and certain people were arrested. The appellant was able to identify the murderer. As a result, the VHP tried to prevent him from giving evidence in the Court by harassment and threats. THE DECISION OF THE TRIBUNAL After setting out the claims made by the appellant, the tribunal outlined independent information about India. It reviewed the place of Muslims in India, noting that followers of Islam make up about 12 percent of India's population, while 81 percent are Hindu. Nine percent of the population of Gujarat is Muslim. It then examined the serious incidences of violence between Hindus and Muslims in India in the 1990s. Turning to Gujarat in particular, the tribunal described the 2002 Godhra railway massacre, where 58 passengers were killed, most of them VHP activists returning from Ayodhya. It described the retaliation brought against the Muslim community. It described the political events in Gujarat in 2002, and noted the re-election of the BJP with its strongly pro-Hindu, traditional Hindu ideology. A picture was painted of very serious communal violence at certain times in Gujarat.

Decision

Reasons for decision

NORTH J
The appellant further claimed that he was approached by the VHP to give property to them. When he refused, two people came to his shop, and fired shots, causing the death of a client. The police were called, and certain people were arrested. The appellant was able to identify the murderer. As a result, the VHP tried to prevent him from giving evidence in the Court by harassment and threats. THE DECISION OF THE TRIBUNAL After setting out the claims made by the appellant, the tribunal outlined independent information about India. It reviewed the place of Muslims in India, noting that followers of Islam make up about 12 percent of India's population, while 81 percent are Hindu. Nine percent of the population of Gujarat is Muslim. It then examined the serious incidences of violence between Hindus and Muslims in India in the 1990s. Turning to Gujarat in particular, the tribunal described the 2002 Godhra railway massacre, where 58 passengers were killed, most of them VHP activists returning from Ayodhya. It described the retaliation brought against the Muslim community. It described the political events in Gujarat in 2002, and noted the re-election of the BJP with its strongly pro-Hindu, traditional Hindu ideology. A picture was painted of very serious communal violence at certain times in Gujarat. The tribunal then gave its reasons for rejecting the appellant's application. Firstly, it dealt with the subject of extortion and said at 15-16:The applicant has claimed that he was for an extended period, he said for a number of years, subjected to demands for money from people he said were with the VHP, a Hindu group. I accept that as a shop owner, and so someone thought to have money, the applicant was subjected to such demands as were other business people. The applicant said that Hindus were not pressed to pay the money as the Muslims shop owners were but his evidence was that they were asked just as he was. The applicant said that he had previously complained to the police about the extortion demands but they had done nothing. The applicant suggested that this was because the state was governed by Hindus. He said that he had not provided a statement for fear that the harassment from the goondas would have worsened. The applicant states that the demands increased after the eruption in communal violence following the Godhra incident in February 2002 and I accept that those who had extorted money could have taken advantage of the troubled situation to increase their demands. The applicant said that he usually gave the money but had once refused and been beaten up and had to have stitches. What the applicant said he feared seemed to me to be analogous with the circumstances described in Ram v MIMA (1995) 57 FCR 565. In his judgment (at 569), Justice Burchett stated:Plainly, extortionists are not implementing a policy, they are simply extracting money from a suitable victim. Their forays are disinterestedly individual. … [The appellant] does not fear persecution for reasons of membership of a particular social group, but extortion based on a perception of his personal wealth and aimed at him individually.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: NORTH J

Having made the findings that each of the claimed incidents of persecution was not related to a reason provided for in the Refugees Convention, the tribunal moved to consider whether the general situation in Gujarat for Muslims did engage the Refugees Convention. That is, would the appellant suffer persecution for the reason that he was Muslim. The tribunal stated at 18-19:Notwithstanding my conclusion that matters associated with the extortion demands and having witnessed a crime do not engage the provisions of the Refugee Convention, the applicant is a Muslim from a state where there has been over the last two years, including time when the applicant was still there, terrible violence between Hindus and Muslims in which Muslims have been most of the victims. Independent information confirms that they was large scale retaliatory action taken against Muslims in many parts of Gujarat after the burning of the train at Godhra in February 2002. I accept that the troubles are not over and that the situation remains volatile. Such conflict would not only be manifested in acts of extreme violence and information I have read indicates that there has also been suspicion, harassment, abuse and intimidation between followers of the two religions. The applicant has submitted that the BJP government of Gujarat has been complicit in aspects of the mistreatment of Muslims and independent information suggests that there were occasions when this was so. It has pointed also to concerns that the issues of concern to Hindus have been given greater attention that those where Muslims have been affected.That some people in a country have suffered or suffer persecution and that an applicant claims to have suffered as these people have, or to be in similar circumstances as those who have suffered and so be at risk of similar treatment, does not, of itself, establish that an applicant’s claimed fear is well-founded within the meaning of the Refugees Convention. The Tribunal is obliged to consider the totality of the evidence about the particular circumstances of the applicant against information about conditions in the country in reaching its conclusions about what has happened to the applicant in the past, what might follow on the applicant’s return to their country and how these facts relate to the definition of a refugee in the Refugees Convention. I have had regard to the evidence which indicates that the applicant has not experienced persecution on account of his religion in the past even though he lived in a Hindu area. As well, I have had in mind the number of Muslims in Gujarat (some 4 million in a population of some 50 million), the numbers of people who have been killed or displaced in the violence and the information I have read which indicates that most of these have occurred in eruptions of violence in a limited number of particular localities. It has been at these times when state protection has been found to be less than adequate. I note that the applicant has stated that he lives in a Hindu area and consider that he could choose to move to live in a different area of the city. While I can understand the applicant’s wish to leave his country, I have come to the view that the chance of the applicant coming to serious harm, of a kind which could constitute persecution, as a consequence of communal trouble in the reasonably foreseeable future on account of his religion is remote.CONSIDERATION OF THE GROUNDS OF APPEAL