Myles Pearce & Co Pty Ltd v Leuci and Martin

Link copied
Case Copied 24 min read

IN THE FULL COURT OF THE SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

DOYLE CJ, DUGGAN AND BLEBY JJ

Contracts - particular parties - vendor and purchaser - contract for the sale of land - purchasers purported to rescind the contract apparently outside the time prescribed by s88 of the Land Agents, Brokers and Valuers Act 1973 - whether purported vendor's statement served under s90 of the Act was a valid statement - failure to disclose the existence of a mortgage, information about a previous transaction affecting the land, and the nature and extent of an encumbrance each separately invalidated the vendor's statement - need for substantial compliance, having regard to the purpose of the statement - whether s91G provides exclusive remedies for defective vendor's statements. Land Agents, Brokers and Valuers Act 1973 ss88,90,91,103; Land Agents, Brokers and Valuers Regulations 1986 , referred to. Golden-Brown v Hunt (1972) 19 FLR
438; South Australian Planning Commission and Wylie v McNeil (1985) 42 SASR
524; Wilson v City of Mitcham (1986) 61 LGRA 126, discussed.

Damages - measure and remoteness of damages in actions for tort - whether the measure of damages awarded to the vendor against the agents for legal costs incurred as a result of the agent's breach of its duty of care was excessive - held that it was not.

ADELAIDE, 4 August 1997 (hearing), 12 September 1997 (decision)

#DATE 12:9:1997

#ADD 22:9:1997

Appearances:

Appellant:

Counsel: Mr R W Sallis

Solicitors: Andersons

Respondent:

Alfredo Leuci:

Counsel: Mr G W Dart

Solicitors: Ward & Partners

Respondents Robert Martin and Roslyn Jean Martin:

Counsel: Mr G A Britton

Solicitors: Geoffrey Adam & Co

Order: appeal dismissed.

DOYLE CJ

In my opinion the appeal should be dismissed. I agree with the reasons of Bleby J for dismissing the appeal, and I have nothing to add to those reasons.

DUGGAN J

I am of the view that this appeal should be dismissed for the reasons given by Bleby J.

BLEBY J

The appellant ("the agent") was at all material times a land agent licensed under the provisions of the Land Agents, Brokers and Valuers Act 1973 ("the Act"), which Act has since been repealed, but the repeal does not affect its operation for the purpose of these proceedings.

The first respondent ("the vendor") was the vendor of a house property situated at 41 Bowden Grove, Marion. The first respondent engaged the agent to effect a sale of the property.

The second respondents, Mr and Mrs Martin ("the purchasers"), on 30 December 1995, signed a contract for the purchase of the property for the sum of $185,000, which contract was negotiated through the agency of the agent.

So far as is relevant s88 of the Act reads as follows:

"88. (1) Subject to this section, a purchaser under contract for the sale of land or a small business may, by giving the vendor written notice before the prescribed time of the purchaser's intention not to be bound by the contract, rescind the contract.

....

(3) If…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Myles Pearce & Co Pty Ltd v Leuci and Martin and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1997] SASC 6360
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Myles Pearce & Co Pty Ltd v Leuci and Martin involved the validity of a vendor's statement under the Land Agents, Brokers and Valuers Act 1973. The case focused on whether certain defects in the vendor's statement rendered it invalid, thereby affecting the purchasers' right to rescind the contract under section 88 of the Act. The key legal issues revolved around the necessity for substantial compliance with the statutory requirements of section 90 and the prescribed particulars in Form 18, and whether the statutory remedies under section 91G provided an exclusive remedy for defects in the vendor's statement. The court held that the failure to disclose a mortgage, information about a previous transaction affecting the land, and the nature and extent of an encumbrance each constituted material defects that invalidated the vendor's statement. The court reasoned that the purpose of the statutory scheme was to ensure that purchasers had all necessary information to make an informed decision, and that substantial compliance with the statutory requirements was necessary. The court further held that section 91G did not provide an exclusive remedy for defective vendor's statements, allowing purchasers the option to either cool-off or seek damages under section 91G or at common law. Finally, the court upheld the damages awarded to the vendor for legal costs incurred due to the agent's breach of duty, finding the assessment reasonable under the circumstances.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case involves a contract for the sale of a property at 41 Bowden Grove, Marion, between the vendor and the purchasers, mediated by a licensed land agent. The purchasers signed the contract on 30 December 1995, subject to obtaining finance under certain conditions, with a settlement date set for 27 March 1995. On the same day, the vendor delivered a purported vendor's statement to the purchasers, which was intended to comply with the requirements of the Land Agents, Brokers and Valuers Act 1973. The purchasers exercised their right to rescind the contract on 24 February 1995, claiming that the vendor's statement was invalid due to defects. The vendor subsequently sold the property at a lower price at a public auction.

The vendor commenced an action in the Civil Division of the Magistrates' Court of South Australia against the purchasers, or in the alternative against the agent, seeking damages for the breach of contract and the agent's duty of care. The magistrate found in favour of the vendor, awarding damages against the agent. The agent appealed to a single judge of the Supreme Court of South Australia, who dismissed the appeal. The agent further appealed to the Full Court against the dismissal of the appeal.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the purported vendor's statement served under s90 of the Land Agents, Brokers and Valuers Act 1973 was a valid statement.
2. Whether the failure to disclose the existence of a mortgage, information about a previous transaction affecting the land, and the nature and extent of an encumbrance each separately invalidated the vendor's statement.
3. Whether s91G of the Act provides exclusive remedies for defective vendor's statements.
4. Whether the measure of damages awarded to the vendor against the agents for legal costs incurred as a result of the agent's breach of its duty of care was excessive.

Held
1. The purported vendor's statement served under s90 of the Land Agents, Brokers and Valuers Act 1973 was not a valid statement.
2. The failure to disclose the existence of a mortgage, information about a previous transaction affecting the land, and the nature and extent of an encumbrance each separately invalidated the vendor's statement.
3. Section 91G of the Act does not provide exclusive remedies for defective vendor's statements.
4. The measure of damages awarded to the vendor against the agents for legal costs incurred as a result of the agent's breach of its duty of care was not excessive.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The appeal was dismissed by the Full Court, with the Court finding that the vendor's statement was defective and invalid. The Court held that the failure to disclose the existence of a mortgage, information about a previous transaction affecting the land, and the nature and extent of an encumbrance each separately invalidated the vendor's statement. The Court further held that s91G of the Act does not provide exclusive remedies for defective vendor's statements, and that the right to cool-off under s88 of the Act remains available to the purchaser. The Court also found that the measure of damages awarded to the vendor against the agents for legal costs incurred as a result of the agent's breach of its duty of care was not excessive. The Court found that the magistrate was justified in reducing the amount actually incurred by almost one half due to the meagre information before him. The Court held that the purpose of s88 of the Act is to enable purchasers to make an informed decision about whether they will proceed with the contract or exercise their rights to cool-off, and that the information required to be given about an encumbrance should not require the purchaser to conduct searches at Government offices in order to ascertain the nature and extent of the encumbrance. The Court found that the failure to provide information as to the existence of a mortgage is a material defect which invalidates the notice, and that the failure to disclose at all or the disclosure of incomplete information may also render the notice invalid. The Court distinguished the case from Golden-Brown v Hunt (1972) 19 FLR 438, South Australian Planning Commission and Wylie v McNeil (1985) 42 SASR 524, and Wilson v City of Mitcham (1986) 61 LGRA 126, holding that the test to be applied is whether the notice, when read as a whole, substantially complies with and achieves the purpose of the statutory scheme.