Musumeci v Robina Shopping Village

Link copied
Case Copied 8 min read

[2005] QDC 022

DISTRICT COURT

CIVIL JURISDICTION

JUDGE ROBIN QC

No D692 of 2004

ALBA CLARA MUSUMECI Applicant

and

ROBINA SHOPPING VILLAGE CTS 18262 Respondent

SOUTHPORT

..DATE 07/02/2005

ORDER

CATCHWORDS:  Personal Injuries Proceedings Act 2002 (PIPA) S9, S36, S40, S43, S59 - would-be plaintiff who had complied with PIPA but not fully (on account of lack of cooperation by the putative defendant which said there was no point in a compulsory conference and that any mandatory final offer would be "nil"), filed a claim and statement of claim on eve of expiry of limitation period, then applied for leave under PIPA and orders compelling the respondent to comply so that matters might advance - whether the claim was a nullity considered - applicant permitted to proceed on it by filing a new verified statement of claim - stay thereafter under PIPA complied with.  

HIS HONOUR:  This is an application by Ms Musumeci, who is already the plaintiff in a claim filed on the 5th of November 2004 on the eve of the expiration of the three year limitation period which would apply in respect of a tripping accident she asserts she had at the defendant/respondent's shopping centre on the 7th of November 2001.

Within the claim, she filed on 17th of December 2004 an application seeking leave to proceed and/or alternative relief by way of extending the statute of limitations. The application also seeks an order for attendance of the parties at a compulsory conference and a further order for mandatory offers to be exchanged. Although the application does not refer to it, it was brought with the Personal Injuries Proceedings Act 2002 in mind, with a view to regularising the applicant's situation under it.

The status of her claim and statement of claim is obscure given that at the time of filing, the pre-litigation proceedings required by the Act had not been complied with. There is argument about the extent to which that proposition is true and also where the blame might lie. For some time, it has been conclusively established that proceedings to which the Motor Accident Insurance Act 1994 as amended in 2000 applies started without compliance with pre-litigation proceedings mandated by the legislation are nullities.

The approach appears to have been taken that proceedings commenced prematurely from the point of view of the PIPA are in the same case. The parties today are inclined to take that same approach without going into the correctness of it as happened, for example, in Kash v. S M and T J Cedergren Builders [2003] QSC 426. See paragraph [2] of the reasons for judgment.

Mr Grenacs, for the applicant, however, is hopeful of avoiding the necessity for Ms Musumeci to pay further filing fees.  In other words, he wants to make use of the claim and statement of claim filed.  His case is somewhat coy about the section of the PIPA which is relied on.  It may be section 43; it may be section 59, neither of which…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Musumeci v Robina Shopping Village and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2005] QDC 22
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Alba Clara Musumeci filed a claim against Robina Shopping Village CTS 18262, the respondent, on the eve of the expiration of the three-year limitation period. The claim was based on an alleged tripping accident that occurred at the respondent's shopping centre on November 7, 2001. The applicant filed the claim and statement of claim on November 5, 2004, and subsequently applied for leave to proceed under the Personal Injuries Proceedings Act 2002 (PIPA) and for orders compelling the respondent to comply with the pre-litigation requirements of the Act, including a compulsory conference and mandatory final offers. The applicant's application was made because the respondent had not cooperated with the pre-litigation proceedings and had stated that any mandatory final offer would be "nil."

The legal issues before the court were whether the claim was a nullity and whether the applicant was permitted to proceed with it by filing a new verified statement of claim. The court considered whether the pre-litigation proceedings required by the PIPA had been complied with and whether the claim and statement of claim were invalidated by the lack of compliance. The court also considered the provisions of the PIPA that might apply to the circumstances of the case and the arguments of both parties.

The court found that although the applicant had complied with the notice requirement under section 9 of the PIPA, the claim and statement of claim were filed without compliance with the compulsory conference requirement under section 36 of the PIPA. However, the court was not convinced that the claim and statement of claim were a nullity or beyond saving. The court held that the applicant had not been seeking to avoid compliance with the PIPA pre-litigation procedures and that the purpose of the application was to ensure that they were carried out. The court directed the parties to attend a compulsory conference within 60 days and to make mandatory final offers within 14 days of the conference, which would remain open for acceptance for a further 14 days before the proceeding advanced further.

The court ordered that the applicant have leave to start a proceeding against the respondent on condition that she file a new statement of claim, verified by her own affidavit, which includes the substance of the allegations in items 14 and 15 of her form 1 notice of claim under the PIPA. The proceeding may advance pursuant to the claim filed on November 5, 2004, and the new statement of claim, but shall be stayed to permit the parties to attend to the compulsory conference and the making of mandatory final offers. The costs of the application, excluding the applicant's costs of complying with the order to file a new statement of claim, were to be the party's costs in the cause.

Background

Background to the litigation

Alba Clara Musumeci filed a claim against Robina Shopping Village on the eve of the expiration of the three-year limitation period, asserting she had a tripping accident at the respondent's shopping centre on 7 November 2001. The pre-litigation proceedings required by the Personal Injuries Proceedings Act 2002 (PIPA) had not been complied with at the time of filing. The status of her claim and statement of claim was unclear due to the incomplete compliance with the pre-litigation proceedings, and there was a dispute over the extent of this non-compliance and where the blame might lie. It was established that proceedings commenced without compliance with pre-litigation proceedings mandated by the legislation were nullities, but the parties were inclined to treat the prematurely commenced proceedings in the same way. Musumeci's legal representatives hoped to avoid her paying further filing fees by making use of the claim and statement of claim already filed.

There was no evidence before the court to describe the alleged accident and how it happened, and how the defendant might be held to blame. The statement of claim was uninformative in these respects. The respondent's representatives had been dismissive of Musumeci's claim, indicating there was no point in holding a compulsory conference and that any mandatory final offer would be "nil." Faced with an inability to achieve the cooperation of opposed parties which PIPA required, Musumeci's lawyers decided to file the proceeding in Court on the eve of the expiration of the three-year limitation period. The court found that the proceeding was not necessarily a nullity, and ordered Musumeci to file a new verified statement of claim and for the parties to attend a compulsory conference and make mandatory final offers.

The matter before the District Court of Queensland, Civil Jurisdiction, is an application brought by Alba Clara Musumeci against Robina Shopping Village CTS 18282, originally filed on 5 November 2004 on the eve of the expiration of the limitation period. Musumeci, the applicant, seeks leave to proceed with her claim and/or alternative relief extending the statute of limitations. This application was made under the Personal Injuries Proceedings Act 2002 (PIPA). The claim stems from an alleged tripping accident at the respondent's shopping centre on 7 November 2001. Although Musumeci filed her claim and statement of claim on the deadline, the pre-litigation proceedings required by PIPA had not been fully complied with. The respondent has been uncooperative, refusing to participate in a compulsory conference and stating that any mandatory final offer would be "nil". The primary issue in this application is whether Musumeci's claim is a nullity due to non-compliance with PIPA requirements. The Court considered the matter and allowed Musumeci to proceed with the claim by filing a new verified statement of claim, subject to certain conditions including the holding of a compulsory conference and the exchange of mandatory final offers. The Court directed that the proceeding be stayed to allow these steps to be completed.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Is the claim filed by Ms Musumeci a nullity given that the pre-litigation proceedings required by the Personal Injuries Proceedings Act 2002 (PIPA) were not fully complied with?
2. Can Ms Musumeci proceed with the claim filed on the eve of the limitation period by filing a new verified statement of claim?
3. Is the respondent obligated to participate in the compulsory conference under section 36 of the PIPA?
4. Should the proceeding be stayed to permit the parties to attend to the compulsory conference and the making of mandatory final offers as required by section 40 of the PIPA?
5. Can the Court exercise a dispensing power under section 40(9) of the PIPA to bypass the mandatory final offer stage in this case?

Held
1. Is the claim filed by Ms Musumeci a nullity given that the pre-litigation proceedings required by the Personal Injuries Proceedings Act 2002 (PIPA) were not fully complied with?
The Court concluded that the claim and statement of claim are not a nullity and can proceed on condition that Ms Musumeci files a new verified statement of claim.

2. Can Ms Musumeci proceed with the claim filed on the eve of the limitation period by filing a new verified statement of claim?
The Court allowed Ms Musumeci to proceed with the claim on the condition that she files a new verified statement of claim, verified by her own affidavit, which includes the substance of the allegations in items 14 and 15 of her form 1 notice of claim under the PIPA.

3. Is the respondent obligated to participate in the compulsory conference under section 36 of the PIPA?
The Court directed that the parties attend a compulsory conference within 60 days of the date of the order.

4. Should the proceeding be stayed to permit the parties to attend to the compulsory conference and the making of mandatory final offers as required by section 40 of the PIPA?
The Court stayed the proceeding to permit the parties to attend the compulsory conference and make mandatory final offers under section 40 of the PIPA.

5. Can the Court exercise a dispensing power under section 40(9) of the PIPA to bypass the mandatory final offer stage in this case?
The Court did not exercise the dispensing power under section 40(9) of the PIPA and instead directed the parties to follow the mandatory final offer stage as required by the PIPA.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The District Court, in its decision, approached the issues raised by the application filed by Ms Musumeci with a focus on the procedural requirements of the Personal Injuries Proceedings Act 2002 (PIPA). The court began by examining whether Ms Musumeci's claim could be considered a nullity due to the incomplete compliance with the pre-litigation proceedings mandated by PIPA. The court noted that while the initial claim filed by Ms Musumeci on the eve of the limitation period might not have fully complied with the Act's requirements, it did not automatically render the claim a nullity. The court acknowledged the arguments that proceedings commenced prematurely under PIPA could be nullities, as seen in cases like Kash v. S M and T J Cedergren Builders, but chose not to apply this rule strictly in this case. The court found that Ms Musumeci had not deliberately avoided compliance with the Act and, given the circumstances, was inclined to allow her to proceed with the claim by filing a new verified statement of claim.

Addressing the second issue, the court considered whether Ms Musumeci could proceed with the claim by filing a new verified statement of claim. The court reasoned that the initial claim, although filed prematurely, was not a nullity. Instead, the court granted Ms Musumeci leave to file a new statement of claim that included the substance of her allegations from the initial notice of claim under PIPA. This decision was based on the court's discretion to ensure that the issues were defined and resolved in a convenient and inexpensive manner, in line with the philosophy set out in N5 of the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules.

The third issue concerned the respondent's obligation to participate in the compulsory conference under section 36 of PIPA. The court observed that while section 36 does not explicitly impose an obligation on the claimant to participate in a conference, it mandates that one must occur before starting a court proceeding based on a claim. The respondent had initially appeared to dispense with the conference, but upon the court's indication to allow Ms Musumeci to proceed, both parties expressed interest in holding the conference. The court directed that a compulsory conference be held within 60 days of the decision.

Regarding the fourth issue, whether the proceeding should be stayed to permit the parties to attend the compulsory conference and make mandatory final offers as required by section 40 of PIPA, the court found that it was necessary to ensure compliance with the Act. The court ordered that the proceeding be stayed to allow for the holding of the compulsory conference and the making of mandatory final offers, which must remain open for acceptance for a further 14 days before the proceeding advances further.

Lastly, the court addressed the issue of whether it could exercise a dispensing power under section 40(9) of PIPA to bypass the mandatory final offer stage in this case. The court noted that while there is a dispensing power in the Court, there is no express acknowledgment in PIPA of the parties' ability to bypass the mandatory final offer stage. The court decided against bypassing this stage, emphasizing the importance of adhering to the statutory requirements to facilitate an early and inexpensive resolution of the matter.

In summary, the ratio decidendi of this case is that the court may, in special circumstances, permit a party to proceed with a claim that was not fully compliant with the pre-litigation requirements of PIPA by allowing the filing of a new verified statement of claim, provided the party has not deliberately avoided compliance and the circumstances justify such a course. The court also reinforced the importance of adhering to the compulsory conference and mandatory final offer stages as prescribed by PIPA.