Murphy Operator Pty Ltd v Gladstone Ports Corporation Ltd (No 3)

Link copied
Case Copied 22 min read

SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

Murphy Operator Pty Ltd & Ors v Gladstone Ports Corporation Ltd (No 3) [2019] QSC 118

PARTIES:

MURPHY OPERATOR PTY LTD (ACN 088 269 596)

(first plaintiff/first applicant)

AND

TOBARI PTY LTD (ACN 010 172 237)
(second plaintiff/second applicant)

AND

SPW VENTURES PTY LTD (ACN 135 830 036)

(third plaintiff/third applicant)

v

GLADSTONE PORTS CORPORATION LIMITED (ACN 131 965 896)

(defendant/first respondent)

LCM OPERATIONS PTY LTD

(second respondent)

FILE NO/S:

SC No 7495 of 2017

DIVISION:

Trial Division

PROCEEDING:

Application

ORIGINATING COURT:

Supreme Court at Brisbane

DELIVERED ON:

14 May 2019

DELIVERED AT:

Rockhampton

HEARING DATE:

26 April 2019

JUDGE:

Crow J

ORDER:

Notices to group members

1. Pursuant to section 103T(5) of the Civil Proceedings Act 2011 (Qld) (CPA), notice (Application Notice) be given to group members of the matters stated in the notices referred to in paragraphs 2 and 3 below.

2. Pursuant to s 103U of the CPA, the Application Notice be in the terms set out in:

a)   for notices sent to group members’ postal or email addresses, and the website of the plaintiffs’ solicitors – Annexure A to these Orders;

b)   for newspaper notices – Annexure B to these Orders.

3. Pursuant to s103T(5) and s 103U(2) of the CPA, the Application Notice be given to group members by the solicitors for the plaintiffs, within 14 days after the date of these Orders, causing notices:

a)   in respect of group members who have already registered with the plaintiffs' solicitors – to be sent in the terms of Annexure A by email to the registered email address, alternatively by pre-paid ordinary post to the registered postal address, of the group member;

b)   for all group members – to be published in terms of Annexure B published in one edition of each of:

(i)     Courier-Mail;

(ii)   Gladstone Observer;

(iii) Fraser Coast Chronicle;

(iv) The Morning Bulletin (Rockhampton);

(v)   News Mail (Bundaberg);

(vi) Daily Mercury (Mackay);

(vii)   Gympie Times; and

(viii)  Sunshine Coast Daily;

and posted in terms of Annexure A on the website of the plaintiffs’ solicitors on a page accessible via a link prominently displayed on the homepage dedicated to this proceeding.

4.   Within 21 days after the last publication pursuant to order 3 above, the solicitors for the plaintiffs shall file and serve an affidavit deposing to the steps taken pursuant to Order 3 above, the rates of ‘returned’ mail, and the rates and nature of enquiries from group members in response to the Application Notice.

Points of Claim documents

5.   By 4pm on 17 May 2019 the plaintiffs file and serve on the defendant and the second respondent a Points of Claim document which identifies the factual and legal issues they contend are relevant to the court’s determination of paragraphs 6 and 7 of the Funding Application.

6.   By 4pm on 24 May 2019, the defendant and the second respondent file and serve on the plaintiffs and each other a Points of Defence document…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Murphy Operator Pty Ltd v Gladstone Ports Corporation Ltd (N... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2019] QSC 118
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Murphy Operator Pty Ltd v Gladstone Ports Corporation Ltd (No 3) involved an application by the applicants for a declaration that the relevant funding agreements were not unenforceable due to maintenance, champerty, or public policy. Additionally, the applicants sought an order stating a case to the Court of Appeal pursuant to rule 483 of the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules and, alternatively, a declaration under s 103ZA of the Civil Proceedings Act or the inherent jurisdiction of the Court. Gladstone Ports Corporation Ltd (GPC) opposed the application, arguing that the factual basis underpinning the questions was uncertain and that a determination must be left until all parties with an interest in the subject matter were before the court.

The legal issues before the court included whether it was appropriate to make an order stating a case to the Court of Appeal and whether an order should be made to hear the funding application in the trial division. The applicants argued that the questions were issues of law and that a factual inquiry into issues of "control" was irrelevant to the existence or non-existence of champerty. GPC, however, contended that the issues to be stated to the Court of Appeal involved factual matters that were critical to the questions at hand.

The court found that it was inappropriate to make an order stating a case to the Court of Appeal on an interlocutory application without full argument from the parties and without reference to persons whose interests may be affected by such a ruling. The court noted that the resolution of the issues was complicated by the lack of a rational basis for the continuation of the torts of maintenance and champerty in modern times. The court also accepted that it was easier to say what was not maintenance than to say what was maintenance, as stated by Fletcher Moulton LJ. The court further held that it was not appropriate to make a definitive examination of the case stated issues on the basis that "control" had no relevance to the existence or nonexistence of champerty.

The court made several orders, including notices to group members, points of claim documents, and deadlines for filing affidavits and written submissions. The court also scheduled a hearing for the funding application and reserved costs of the hearing on 26 April 2019. The court granted liberty to apply and provided for costs to be reserved.

Orders

Orders of the court

Notices to group members

1. Pursuant to section 103T(5) of the Civil Proceedings Act 2011 (Qld) (CPA), notice (Application Notice) be given to group members of the matters stated in the notices referred to in paragraphs 2 and 3 below.

2. Pursuant to s 103U of the CPA, the Application Notice be in the terms set out in:

a) for notices sent to group members’ postal or email addresses, and the website of the plaintiffs’ solicitors – Annexure A to these Orders;

b) for newspaper notices – Annexure B to these Orders.

3. Pursuant to s103T(5) and s 103U(2) of the CPA, the Application Notice be given to group members by the solicitors for the plaintiffs, within 14 days after the date of these Orders, causing notices:

a) in respect of group members who have already registered with the plaintiffs' solicitors – to be sent in the terms of Annexure A by email to the registered email address, alternatively by pre-paid ordinary post to the registered postal address, of the group member;

b) for all group members – to be published in terms of Annexure B published in one edition of each of:

(i) Courier-Mail;

(ii) Gladstone Observer;

(iii) Fraser Coast Chronicle;

(iv) The Morning Bulletin (Rockhampton);

(v) News Mail (Bundaberg);

(vi) Daily Mercury (Mackay);

(vii) Gympie Times; and

(viii) Sunshine Coast Daily;

and posted in terms of Annexure A on the website of the plaintiffs’ solicitors on a page accessible via a link prominently displayed on the homepage dedicated to this proceeding.

4. Within 21 days after the last publication pursuant to order 3 above, the solicitors for the plaintiffs shall file and serve an affidavit deposing to the steps taken pursuant to Order 3 above, the rates of ‘returned’ mail, and the rates and nature of enquiries from group members in response to the Application Notice.

Points of Claim documents

5. By 4pm on 17 May 2019 the plaintiffs file and serve on the defendant and the second respondent a Points of Claim document which identifies the factual and legal issues they contend are relevant to the court’s determination of paragraphs 6 and 7 of the Funding Application.

6. By 4pm on 24 May 2019, the defendant and the second respondent file and serve on the plaintiffs and each other a Points of Defence document which identifies:

a) whether it agrees or disagrees that the issues identified by the plaintiffs in their Points of Claim document are relevant to the court’s determination of paragraphs 6 and 7 of the Funding Application;

b) any other issues it contends are relevant to the court’s determination of paragraphs 6 and 7 of the Funding Application.

7. By 4pm on 29 May 2019 the plaintiffs file and serve on the defendant and the second respondent a Points of Reply document which identifies whether they agree or disagree that the issues referred to in paragraph 6(b) above are relevant to the court’s determination of paragraphs 6 and 7 of the Funding Application.

Affidavits and disclosure

8. By 4pm on 7 June 2019:

a) the plaintiffs file and serve any further affidavit evidence on which they intend to rely in relation to the Funding Application;

b) LCM file and serve any affidavit evidence on which it intends to rely in relation to the Funding Application.

9. By 4pm on 14 June 2019, the defendant:

a) file and serve any affidavit evidence on which it intends to rely in relation to the Funding Application;

b) file and serve any application for an order for disclosure by the plaintiffs and/or the second respondent in relation to the Funding Application, and any material intended to be relied in support of such an application.

10. Any application filed under paragraph 9 (b) be heard at 9am on 17 June 2019 at Rockhampton.

11. By 4pm on 21 June 2019 the plaintiffs and the second respondent file and serve any responsive affidavit material on which they intend to rely in relation to the Funding Application.

12. The plaintiffs file and serve written submissions on the defendant and second respondent by 8 July 2019.

13. The second respondent file and serve written submissions on the plaintiffs and the defendant by 10 July 2019.

14. The defendant file and serve its written submissions on the plaintiffs and the second respondent by 5pm 15 July 2019.

15. The plaintiffs and second respondent file and serve any written submissions in reply by 5pm 17 July 2019.

16. There be a hearing of paragraphs 6 and 7 of the Funding Application at 9.00am on 18 July 2019 at Rockhampton.

17. Liberty to apply.

18. Costs of the hearing on 26 April 2019 be reserved.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Rule 483 of the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 1999 (Qld) provides:483 Order for decision and statement of case for opinion(1)The court may make an order for the decision by the court of a question separately from another question, whether before, at, or after the trial or continuation of the trial of the proceeding.(2)The Supreme Court, other than the Court of Appeal, may also state a case for the opinion of the Court of Appeal. In Land and Resources Tribunal v Schmidt,[2] the Court of Appeal stated:“A case stated is a process by which a court or Tribunal in the course of proceedings before it submits to a superior court for its decision or opinion on a question of law that arises from facts as found by the court or Tribunal and stated in the case: Industrial Equity Ltd v. Commissioner for Corporate Affairs [1990] V.R. 780, 782 — 783.”[2] [2006] 1 Qd R 161 Annexed to the application are three annexures. Annexure A is the draft statement of case. Paragraph 12 of Annexure A sets out four questions being the ultimate questions which the applicants seek to be stated to the Court of Appeal. Annexure B consists of the funding terms and Annexure C sets out not only the draft notice to group members but also some 430 further pages of marked annexures. The questions that the applicants seek to be stated to the Court of Appeal are defined with specificity and it is accepted that resolution of the issues is important to class action litigation in Queensland. If there was certainty as to the factual basis underpinning the questions then undoubtedly it would be appropriate to state a case to the Court of Appeal. The applicants argue that no evidence is required beyond the material set forth in the draft case stated. The applicants argue that the issues to be stated to the Court of Appeal are issues of law and that a factual inquiry into issues of “control” have no relevance to the existence or non-existence of champerty. GPC disputes this fundamental proposition as not reflective of the true state of the law and submits there are factual issues between the parties relating to the issue of control which are critical to the questions which seek to be stated. The resolution of this issue in the applicants’ favour requires sharp distinctions to be drawn between champerty (as an aggravated form of maintenance), abuse of process and contrariety to public policy which, as the plurality of the High Court in Fostif’s case[3] demonstrate has eluded courts now for more than a century. [3] Campbells Cash and Carry Pty Ltd v Fostif Pty Ltd (2006) 229 CLR 386. The difficulty, as explained by the plurality in Fostif’s case is that the torts of maintenance and champerty appear to have little if any rational basis in “modern” times. The plurality accepted that[4] over a 111 years ago (in 1908) the torts were not based upon any “logical principle”. I would respectfully adopt the conclusion of Fletcher Moulton LJ that “in my opinion it is far easier to say what is not maintenance than to say what is maintenance.” It is inappropriate in my view on an interlocutory application, and without full argument from the parties and without reference to persons whose interests may be affected by such a ruling (ie the group members), to embark upon a definitive examination of the case stated issues on the basis that “control” (in the sense of a degree of intermeddling), has no relevance to the existence or nonexistence of champerty. Resolution of such issues is complicated by the lack of an apparent rational basis for the continuation of torts which emerged several hundred years ago in their application to “modern” times.[4] Paragraph 78 at 430 citing Fletcher Moulton LJ in British Cash and Parcel Conveyors Ltd v Lamson Store Service Co Ltd [1908] 1 KB 1006 at 1013-1014.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.