SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA
(Appeals to a Single Judge: Criminal)
MULHERN'S WASTE OIL REMOVAL PTY LTD v CIRCELLI
[2009] SASC 353
Judgment of The Honourable Justice Gray
20 November 2009
ENVIRONMENT AND PLANNING - POLLUTION - WASTE DISPOSAL - OFFENCES - PENALTY
CRIMINAL LAW - SENTENCE - RELEVANT FACTORS - TOTALITY - GENERAL PRINCIPLES
Appeal from orders of Judge of Environmental Resources and Development Court of South Australia - appellant charged with 10 offences under Environmental Protection Act 1993 (SA) - penalty of $200,000.00 imposed in respect of three offences - penalty of $260,000.00 imposed in respect of seven offences - whether penalties manifestly excessive - whether double punishment in respect of same misconduct - whether adequate weight given to matters in mitigation - consideration of principle of totality.
Held: appellant's cooperation with EPA and its financial expenditure represented significant factors in mitigation - appellant punished twice in respect of same conduct - penalty manifestly excessive - penalty reconsidered - penalty of $75,000.00 fixed in respect of three offences - penalty of $70,000.00 fixed in respect of seven offences.
Environment Protection Act 1993 (SA) s 132; Summary Procedures Act 1921 (SA); Environment, Resources and Development Court Act 1993 (SA) s 7(3) and s 7(3)(a); Criminal Law (Sentencing) Act 1988 (SA) s 18A, referred to.
Resourceco Pty Ltd v Harvey (2007) 96 SASR 495; Circelli v Mulhern's Waste Oil Removal P/L [2009] SAERDC 17; Camilleri's Stock Feeds Pty Ltd v Environment Protection Authority (1993) 32 NSWLR 683; Pearce v The Queen (1998) 194 CLR 610, considered.
MULHERN'S WASTE OIL REMOVAL PTY LTD v CIRCELLI
[2009] SASC 353Civil
GRAY J.
Before the Court is an appeal by Mulhern’s Waste Oil Removal Pty Ltd from a decision of a Judge of the Environment Resources and Development Court of South Australia.
Mulhern’s Waste Oil Removal carries on a business as a collector of waste oils. Generally, the oils are collected from a customer’s premises and are then taken either to one of the defendant’s two premises or elsewhere for treatment. The customer pays a fee to Mulherns for the collection service. Mulherns on-sells the treated used oil.
The orders the subject of this appeal were made in proceedings in which Mulherns was charged with 10 offences against the provisions of the Environment Protection Act 1993 (SA). Three of the 10 offences related to events occurring on 26 July 2007. The remaining related to ongoing offending from January 2007 to July 2007. The Judge imposed two monetary penalties, one in respect of the three offences, of $200,000.00 and the other in respect of the remaining seven offences, of $260,000.00. The Judge further ordered that Mulherns pay the costs of the prosecution, fixed at $800.00.
Mulherns has appealed against the penalties imposed. It was said that the penalty identified by the Judge in respect of each offence was manifestly excessive and that each of the penalties ultimately imposed in respect of the two groups of offending were also manifestly excessive.…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Mulhern's Waste Oil Removal Pty Ltd v Circelli and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2009] SASC 353
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The central legal issues addressed by the court involved the appropriateness of the principle of totality in determining monetary penalties for environmental offences and the assessment of the penalties imposed in light of mitigating factors and the principle of totality. The court had to determine whether the penalties were excessive and whether the appellant was punished twice for the same misconduct. It also had to consider whether the mitigating factors, such as the appellant's cooperation with the EPA and financial expenditure, were adequately weighed.
The court found that the principle of totality was appropriately applied in determining monetary penalties, following the precedents set by the New South Wales Court of Appeal in Camilleri and by Debelle J in Resourceco. The court acknowledged that the appellant's cooperation with the EPA and its financial expenditure were significant mitigating factors. However, it also found that the appellant was punished twice for the same conduct, and the penalties imposed were manifestly excessive. After considering all relevant factors, including the principle of totality, the court reduced the penalties. For three offences, the court fixed a penalty of $75,000.00, and for seven offences, it fixed a penalty of $70,000.00. The total penalty was thus reduced to $145,000.00.
The court concluded that the appeal with respect to penalty was allowed. The one penalty imposed for counts one, eight, and nine was a fine of $75,000.00, and for counts two, three, four, five, six, seven, and ten, the one penalty was a fine of $70,000.00. The total monetary penalty was $145,000.00, and the other orders of the Judge of the Environment Resources and Development Court of South Australia remained unchanged.
Orders
Orders of the court
Full text does not contain this section.
Background
Background to the litigation
Full text does not contain this section.
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Full text does not contain this section.
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
Established by: GRAY J
However, in the above remarks, the Judge did not have proper regard to the statement of Mr Richardson as to the steps taken to ensure that the offending of the type referred to in the second group of offences would not occur in the future. When this fact is considered in light of the other responsible steps taken by Mulherns, it was contended that it was clear that Mulherns had been personally deterred from further offending conduct. It was argued that this was a significant mitigatory factor overlooked by the Judge. I agree. In my view, the overlooking of this mitigatory factor involved an error of sentencing principle and calls for this Court to reconsider the appropriate penalty to be imposed for this group of offending.Reconsideration of Penalty It was open to and appropriate for the Judge to consider counts one, eight and nine as all part of the same incident and to impose the one penalty pursuant to section 18A of the Criminal Law (Sentencing) Act 1988 (SA) in respect to all of this offending. However, in my view, the penalty identified by the Judge was manifestly excessive. The explanation lies in the errors referred to above. In the circumstances, it was appropriate to make a reduction of one quarter on account of the pleas of guilty. I would fix the one penalty of $75,000.00 in respect of these three offences. In fixing this penalty, I have had regard to the whole of the offending conduct in respect of counts one, eight and nine and I have specifically avoided imposing any double punishment. I have also had regard, as a final step, to the principle of totality. In respect of the second group of offending, it is to be recognised that this was serious, ongoing, deliberate offending. However, there was no environmental damage. In all the circumstances I consider it appropriate to fix a penalty of $70,000.00. In arriving at this penalty, I have made a reduction of one quarter, on account of the pleas of guilty. I have had regard to the whole of the offending the subject of the seven counts. I have had regard to the principle of totality. In arriving at the above penalties, I have taken into account all of the factual background as well as the circumstances of the offending referred to earlier in these reasons. I have had regard to the circumstances of aggravation and mitigation arising from those matters. In the course of the Judge’s remarks, reference was made to the possible inappropriateness of considering the principle of totality when determining monetary penalties. This issue was addressed by the New South Wales Court of Appeal in Camilleri and by Debelle J in Resourceco. Those decisions establish that it is appropriate to have regard to the principle of totality. Accordingly, I have done so. Conclusion The appeal with respect to penalty is allowed. In respect of counts one, eight and nine, pursuant to section 18A of the Sentencing Act, the one penalty is imposed, a fine of $75,000.00. In respect of counts two, three, four, five, six, seven and ten, the one penalty is imposed, a fine of $70,000.00. The total monetary penalty, as a consequence, is an amount of $145,000.00. Otherwise, the orders of the Judge of the Environment Resources and Development Court of South Australia remain.