Circelli v Mulhern's Waste Oil Removal Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 27 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Full Court)

CIRCELLI v MULHERN'S WASTE OIL REMOVAL PTY LTD

[2010] SASC 116

Judgment of The Full Court

(The Honourable Chief Justice Doyle, The Honourable Justice Anderson and The Honourable Justice Layton)

28 April 2010

ENVIRONMENT AND PLANNING - POLLUTION - WASTE DISPOSAL - OFFENCES - PENALTY

Offences against s 79(2) and s 45(5) of the Environment Protection Act 1993 (SA) - respondent pleaded guilty to all ten counts - offences in two groups - reconsideration of penalty.

CRIMINAL LAW - SENTENCE - RELEVANT FACTORS  - TOTALITY - GENERAL PRINCIPLES

Application for permission to appeal and appeal from judgment of single judge of this court - judge reduced penalties applied by ERDC judge - judge held that penalties were manifestly excessive and that double punishment had been applied - application granted - merits of the appeal considered - whether ERDC judge had regard to the totality principle - whether double punishment was applied by ERDC judge in respect of same offensive conduct - whether there was an error in the ERDC judge's exercise of discretion under s 18A of the Criminal Law (Sentencing) Act 1988 (SA) - whether penalties applied by ERDC judge were manifestly excessive - whether weight given to mitigating factors by ERDC judge was appropriate.

Held:  appeal allowed - orders set aside - penalties imposed by judge of this court failed to reflect the seriousness of the offending and the need for general deterrence and were manifestly inadequate - judge's finding that ERDC judge doubly punished in respect of counts 1 and 9 upheld - penalty imposed by ERDC judge in respect of count 1 was manifestly excessive - judge of this court erred in finding double punishment in respect of counts 1 and 8 - in respect of counts 1, 8 and 9 a penalty of $155,000 fixed to reflect principles of specific and general deterrence - in respect of counts 2 to 7 and 10, penalties imposed by ERDC judge reinstated.

Environment Protection Act 1993 (SA) s 45(5) and s 79(2); Criminal Law (Sentencing) Act 1988 (SA) s 18A, referred to.
Circelli v Mulhern's Waste Oil Removal Pty Ltd [2009] SAERDC 17; Mulhern's Waste Oil Removal Pty Ltd v Circelli [2009] SASC 353; Camilleri's Stock Feeds Pty Ltd v Environment Protection Authority (1993) 32 NSWLR 683; House v The King (1936) 55 CLR 499; Piva v Brinkworth (1992) 59 SASR 92, considered.

CIRCELLI v MULHERN'S WASTE OIL REMOVAL PTY LTD
[2010] SASC 116

  1. DOYLE CJ:          I agree with the orders proposed by Anderson J and with his reasons.  There is nothing that I wish to add.

    ANDERSON J:

    Introduction

  2. This is an application for permission to appeal from a decision of a single judge of this Court. That judge heard an appeal from a decision of a judge of the Environment Resources and Development Court (“the ERD Court”). I will refer to the judge of this court as the appeal judge, and I will refer…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Circelli v Mulhern's Waste Oil Removal Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2010] SASC 116
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Mulhern's Waste Oil Removal Pty Ltd was charged with multiple offences under the Environment Protection Act 1993 (SA) following a significant oil spill that occurred at their Largs North site in 2007. The respondent pleaded guilty to all ten counts, which included causing serious environmental harm, breaches of licence conditions, and failure to ensure employee compliance. The Environmental Resources Development Court (ERDC) imposed penalties, which were subsequently reduced by an appeal judge of the Supreme Court. Mr Circelli, an employee of the Environment Protection Authority, appealed the appeal judge's decision to the Full Court, seeking a reconsideration of the penalties.

The central legal issues in the case involved whether the penalties imposed by the ERDC judge were manifestly excessive, whether double punishment had been applied for the same offensive conduct, and if the appeal judge had appropriately exercised discretion under the Criminal Law (Sentencing) Act 1988 (SA). The Full Court also considered the principle of totality in sentencing, ensuring that the cumulative effect of multiple penalties did not disproportionately exceed the gravity of the offences. The court examined whether the mitigating factors considered by the ERDC judge were appropriate and whether the penalties accurately reflected the seriousness of the environmental harm caused.

The Full Court granted permission for the appeal and allowed it, setting aside the penalties imposed by the appeal judge. The court determined that the penalties imposed by the ERDC judge were not manifestly excessive but noted that the appeal judge had correctly identified instances of double punishment. The Full Court adjusted the penalties accordingly, reducing the penalty for counts 1, 8, and 9 to $197,250 and rounding it off to $155,000. The penalties for counts 2 to 7 and 10 were left unchanged. The court concluded that the adjusted penalties appropriately reflected the nature of the offending and the need to deter future breaches of environmental standards.

The Full Court's final orders included granting permission to appeal, allowing the appeal in part, setting aside the penalties imposed by the appeal judge, and substituting the penalties for counts 1, 8, and 9 with a total penalty of $155,000. The court also directed the parties to provide submissions on the costs of the appeal to both the appeal judge and the Full Court.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

The appeal judge, after hearing the appeal from the decision of the ERD judge, substantially reduced the penalties imposed by the ERD judge. The questions for this Court are whether the appeal judge was right to interfere and substitute different penalties, and if so, whether the substituted penalties imposed by the judge correctly reflected the gravity of the offending.Background The appellant, Mr Circelli, is an employee of the Environment Protection Authority. The respondent, Mulhern’s Waste Oil Removal Pty Ltd (“Mulherns”), carries on the business of collecting various waste oils, including used cooking oils, engine oils and transmission fluid, from various businesses for a fee. The waste oils are collected and transported using vacuum pump trucks. The waste oil is transferred from the vacuum trucks to tanks at Mulherns premises for storage awaiting treatment. Mulherns’ Largs North site has a 6.8 mega litre capacity tank and four concrete “Manacon tanks”. Each Manacon tank has a capacity of approximately 20,000 litres. Treated oil is then on-sold by Mulherns. To carry on such a business, a proprietor must be licensed under the Act. Mulherns holds Licence 2994. Licence 2994 states that Mulherns must “store any substances that are not contained in the 6.8 mega litre tank, and which have the potential to cause environmental harm, in accordance with the Environment Protection Act guideline entitled “Bunding and Spill Management” (per Condition 12). Mulherns is also required to mark each container of waste with a description of the nature of the waste contained inside (per Condition 11). At some point in 2007 Mulherns ceased to comply with Environment Protection Act guideline “Bunding and Spill Management”. One of the four Manacon tanks was not bunded or marked while waste oil was stored in it. On 26 July 2007 an incident occurred during which 10,000 litres of oil escaped from a Manacon tank. The oil spill spread on adjoining land. This oil was subsequently cleaned up with no permanent damage to the land. Mulherns paid for the clean-up. The incident was caused by vandals. Counts 1, 8 and 9 arise as a result of this incident. In 2008, after the spill, Mr Robert Richardson, then employed as Operations General Manager, was employed as Mulherns’ general manager. Mr Richardson made a statement describing “the history and nature of Mulhern’s business … and information in regard to the company’s activities [and] details of the directors and staff”: see Mulhern’s Waste Oil Removal Pty Ltd v Circelli [2009] SASC 353 at [22]. The statement gave details of amounts paid by Mulherns for remedial work done post-spill. It also referred to guidelines and procedures put in place post-spill. As earlier mentioned, Mulherns pleaded guilty to all 10 counts. Mr Richardson’s statement was tendered by consent to the ERD court at the time of sentencing. The ten counts charged were as follows:Count 1Causing serious environmental harm contrary to s 79(2) Environment Protection Act 1993.Counts 2 – 4Breaches of condition 1 of EPA licence by receiving waste water.Count 5Breach of condition 1 of EPA licence by receiving unauthorised waste.Counts 6 – 7 Breaches of condition 1 of EPA licence by receiving slurry.Count 8Breach of condition 11 of EPA licence by storing oil in an unmarked tank.Count 9Breach of condition 12 of EPA licence by storing oil in an unbunded tank.Count 10Breach of condition 17 of EPA licence by failing to ensure that an employee driver was aware of EPA licence conditions that related to his responsibilities as an employee of Mulherns.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

It is my view that the penalties imposed by the appeal judge of $70,000 and $75,000 respectively do not properly taken into account the nature of the offending, the fact that it was deliberate offending, the commercial considerations of balancing an increased profit against compliance with the conditions of licence, and finally the need to send a message not only to the respondent but to anyone who might be of like mind in breaching these important environmental standards.Conclusion I would grant permission to appeal. I would then allow the appeal. I would set aside the orders made in this court on 20 November 2009. I would allow the appeal against penalty in respect of counts 1, 8 and 9. In relation to counts 1, 8 and 9, because of my view that the ERD judge has doubled up in her sentences for count 1 and count 9, I would make an adjustment for count 1 and impose a penalty of 25% of the maximum, which means a reduction to $125,000. The total for counts 1, 8 and 9 then becomes $197,250. I would then make reductions similar to those made by the ERD judge and round off the figure to $155,000. I would then substitute that penalty. I would dismiss the appeal to the appeal judge in respect of counts 2 to 7 and 10. I would hear the parties on the costs of the appeal, both to the appeal judge and to the Full Court. LAYTON J: I would grant permission to appeal and allow the appeal. I agree with the penalties proposed by Anderson J and with his reasons.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.