Muldowney v Flinders University No. Scciv-02-267

Link copied
Case Copied 16 min read

MULDOWNEY v FLINDERS UNIVERSITY
[2002] SASC 313

Magistrates Appeal:  Civil

  1. MULLIGHAN J                 These appeals are brought by the appellant against decisions made by learned Magistrates on 3rd July 2001 and 29th January 2002 upon an application by the appellant to remit the amount due by him to the respondent by reason of orders for costs made against him in favour of the respondent.

  2. The appellant was formerly a mature age student at the Flinders University of South Australia which I have concluded is the respondent on this appeal for reasons which I mention shortly. He had enrolled and undertaken study for the Degree of Bachelor of Commerce but has not completed that study. He has only progressed a little way and has not attended at the Flinders University since 1995. On 15th December 1995 the Deputy Director of Administration and Registrar of the respondent made a complaint against the appellant seeking a restraining order in which it was alleged that the appellant, unless restrained, would behave in an intimidating or offensive manner towards a number of named individuals, including students at the Flinders University and employees of the respondent and the proprietor of a cleaning business engaged by the respondent to undertake cleaning services at the respondent. Earlier in that year proceedings were taken against the appellant by the Police alleging assault and later seeking a restraining order but they were withdrawn.

  3. The appellant contested the complaint laid on behalf of the respondent which came to trial in the Magistrates Court at Adelaide. Judgment was delivered on 12th June 1996 and the Magistrate ordered that the appellant be restrained from behaving in an intimidating or offensive manner to various persons at the premises of the respondent, from assaulting, approaching, threatening or otherwise interfering with those persons, from entering upon or remaining in the vicinity of or upon the campus of Flinders University at Bedford Park (“the Flinders University”), excluding the Flinders Medical Centre, and from damaging or threatening to cause damage to the real or personal property of the respondent. The Magistrate ordered the appellant to pay the respondent’s costs fixed at $19,470.50. The restraining order was subsequently varied in a way which is not relevant for present purposes.

  4. The appellant applied for an extension of time within which to appeal against the restraining order and the order for costs. That application was refused on 19th April 1999. Martin J, who heard the application, made the following observation which is relevant for present purposes:

    “The evidence points to a rather unpleasant and disturbing picture of ongoing and widespread offensive and intimidatory behaviour over a period of time. It is not unfair to describe the evidence as demonstrating that the applicant was aggressive and obnoxious in the extreme. His conduct gave rise, understandably, to a reasonable apprehension of violence and of a continuation of that pattern of behaviour.”

  5. Enforcement of the orders for costs was undertaken pursuant to Division 3 of Part 9 of the Criminal…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Muldowney v Flinders University No. Scciv-02-267 and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2002] SASC 313
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Muldowney v Flinders University is an appeal against decisions by Magistrates declining to remit the amount of costs owing by the appellant to the respondent. The appellant had been restrained by order of the Magistrate from intimidating or offending certain individuals and from entering the campus of Flinders University. He was ordered to pay costs in the sum of $19,470.50. The appellant had paid about $650 over six years and further amounts were deducted when he was in custody. He sought to have the outstanding amount remitted. The Magistrates declined to remit the amount of the costs owing and ordered that it be paid by instalments of $50 per month. The appellant appealed against those decisions. The court held that the Magistrates erred in the exercise of their discretion. The appellant could not pay the amount due within a reasonable time. Even if the amount was substantially reduced the appellant did not have the means to pay. It was clearly established that the appellant could not pay any significant amount within a reasonable time without hardship. That situation is not likely to change. In the court's view, this is a clear case to remit the amount due. It is now an old debt and the scheme of the legislation is that a person should not be saddled with a debt which he or she simply cannot pay and has no prospects of paying in a reasonable time. The court allowed the appeal and remitted the amount of costs due in its entirety. No substitute penalty should be imposed. The court set aside the orders made by the Magistrates for payment of the amount due by instalments.

The court considered the appellant's submissions that the Magistrates erred in not remitting the total balance of the costs due under the various orders and did not have power to substitute another penalty pursuant to s 70I(3). The court found that the Magistrates erred in the exercise of their discretion by not remitting the amount of costs due by the appellant and by ordering that it be paid over a period in excess of 32 years. The court also doubted that there was power under s 70I to order payment by instalments. The court considered that the appellant had no prospect of paying the costs in his working lifetime. The court found that the interests of the respondent could not overshadow the scheme of the legislation which is that no person must bear a financial liability which cannot be paid in a reasonable time without hardship. The court held that the discretion under s 70I(3) is being exercised afresh and that no substitute penalty should be imposed. The court held that the pecuniary sum should be remitted in its entirety.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

MULLIGHAN J

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: MULLIGHAN J