Rae v Police
Magistrates Appeal
GRAY J This is an appeal against sentence.
Background
The appellant, Jason Lee Rae was convicted of assault occasioning actual bodily harm and damaging property without lawful authority.[1]
[1] The information was in the following terms:
Mr Rae had been drinking with a friend after work on the night of 13 September 2002. They continued drinking together until the early hours of the morning. At some time Mr Rae’s friend received a phone call advising him that the victim, a friend of his, was upset and requesting that he attend at his home. Mr Rae accompanied his friend to the victim’s house. Mr Rae and his friend spent some time consoling the victim. At some stage the victim went to the bathroom and Mr Rae and his friend left the house. For reasons that were not explained to the magistrate, Mr Rae returned to the house. He broke through the closed bathroom door and assaulted the victim, punching him in the face, kneeing and kicking him. The victim suffered a fractured nose. Following the assault Mr Rae took a piece of wood broken from a doorframe, walked out and damaged the victim’s car.
Magistrate’s Findings
When sentencing the magistrate noted that Mr Rae had been under the influence of alcohol at the time of the offences.
…the fact of the matter is that you and others like you need to understand that, if you place yourself into an intoxicated condition and then you act violently towards other persons, you are still responsible for you actions.
The magistrate considered Mr Rae’s antecedents.
You have for a 25 year old man an appalling history of criminal offending. True it is, as your counsel points out, most of it is for driving offences but you do have prior convictions recorded on 29 April 1997 in the Adelaide Magistrate’s Court for offences of disorderly behaviour, assault police and resist arrest. There is in you background at least that prior instance of acting violently towards other person.
The magistrate imposed a sentence of ten months imprisonment. He declined to exercise his discretion to suspend the sentence:
I have absolutely no hesitation in saying that your offending is deserving of orders for imprisonment. You need to understand, as do others in the community, that in a so-called civilised society there is no place for this sort of violence, and especially violence where serious injury is the result.
Your counsel has argued for a suspended sentence of imprisonment but I am sorry to say that I consider the facts of this matter too serious to allow for a suspended sentence of imprisonment.
I start from a head sentence for both the assault occasioning actual bodily harm and the damage to the vehicle of 12 months imprisonment. I give you credit for your pleads of guilty and I reduce the sentence of imprisonment for both of those offences to 10 months. That sentence of imprisonment is to commence forthwith…
The…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Rae v Police No. Scciv-03-391 and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2003] SASC 270
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court found that the magistrate had placed undue emphasis on Mr Rae’s past criminal record, which, when properly assessed, indicated a significant improvement in his conduct leading up to the offence in question. Additionally, the court noted that the magistrate had not sufficiently considered the appellant’s potential for rehabilitation. The court held that the magistrate’s failure to adequately weigh these factors warranted a re-sentencing of Mr Rae. Further evidence, including pre-sentence and psychological reports, was considered, and it was noted that Mr Rae had been raised in a dysfunctional family environment and had witnessed violent incidents. These factors, along with his history of mental instability and depression, suggested a fair to good prognosis for rehabilitation with the appropriate support and programs.
Consequently, the court ordered a re-sentencing of Mr Rae, taking into account his prospects for rehabilitation and the need for structured support. The court recommended that Mr Rae participate in anger management and victim awareness group programs and consider ongoing psychological support to manage conflict situations effectively. The court’s decision emphasised the importance of a balanced approach to sentencing, considering both the offender’s past and future potential.
Orders
Orders of the court
Full text does not contain this section.
Background
Background to the litigation
Full text does not contain this section.
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Full text does not contain this section.
Decision
Reasons for decision
Full text does not contain this section.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
Established by: GRAY J
The magistrate gave too much weight to what he considered to be an ‘appalling history of criminal offending’. When properly understood this was Mr Rae’s first real offence involving violence. His record disclosed that there had been a marked improvement in Mr Rae’s conduct during the years leading to the present offending. It is also apparent that the magistrate did not give adequate consideration to Mr Rae’s prospects for rehabilitation. For these reasons, it is necessary to re-sentence the appellant.Considerations on Re-sentencingFurther Evidence Further evidence was placed before this court. Pre-sentence and psychological reports were provided. In the course of submissions counsel outlined circumstances of Mr Rae’s psychiatric treatment. Counsel for the Crown accepted that the further evidence was relevant material to be considered. Personal Antecedents Mr Rae is a 26 year old Aboriginal man. He was born in Adelaide but lived with his parents in Whyalla. His father left and moved to Brisbane when Mr Rae was six years of age. Mr Rae’s mother met a new partner when Mr Rae was 9 years of age. His mother’s new partner had an alcohol problem. He was violent. Mr Rae was witness to that violence. Mr Rae remained at school until year 11. He was heavily involved in school sport. Mr Rae then held various jobs for short periods. He was later involved in the Community Development Employment Projects (CDEP) program for two years. Most recently he has worked in a vineyard. He is involved in professional football and receives about $500 a game. He commenced an aquaculture course at Flinders University, however had to withdraw following injuries suffered in a road accident. Mr Rae has also been involved in a serious road accident in 2001. He suffered injuries to his lower back.Psychological History A psychological report disclosed a history of mental instability and depression. In September 2000 Mr Rae received inpatient treatment in a psychiatric unit following a psychotic episode. Following discharge he received psychiatric treatment for more than 12 months. The psychologist noted that Mr Rae had been raised in a dysfunctional family. Mr Rae witnessed a number of violent incidents between his mother and her partner. He considered that Mr Rae had lacked a male role model from a young age. The psychologist noted:His mother’s partner was a violent alcoholic who was physically abusive and threatening towards Mr Rae’s family members…His actions were motivated to prevent this man from further abusing his family and served to justify or sanction the use of violence for Mr Rae in these types of circumstances…Consequently, with the assistance of a structured and supervised rehabilitation program, Mr Rae’s propensity not to re-offend in a seminal manner is fair to good, given that Mr Rae’s family history does not indicate any propensity towards violent conduct (ie antisocial personality disorder) and that his previous offence history has generally included alcohol-related incidents centred around motor vehicles rather than a pattern of assault-related offences.The Department for Correctional Services offers programs for offenders who display difficulty with the appropriate expression of anger, as well as programs for individuals who have difficulty appreciating the impact of their offences upon their victim. Consequently, I would recommend that Mr Rae be required to attend an Anger Management Group Program to gain insight into his specific triggers and to learn coping strategies for dealing more effectively with frustrating situations. In addition, Mr Rae would gain benefit from attending Victim awareness Group Program to gain insight into the impact of violent crime upon others in the community in terms of primary and secondary victims. Further, Mr Rae may gain insight into the effects of substances such as alcohol on the individual and the community as a whole. These group programs are offered within custodial institutions as well as in community correctional centres.In addition, Mr Rae could gain benefit from accessing the services of a psychologist to provide him with ongoing assertiveness skills for managing conflict situations. Mr Rae could access the services of a clinical psychologist through being referred to the Forensic Mental Health Services Outpatient Department at James Nash House. Equally, the Department for Correctional Service has recently been seeking to employ psychologists in the community locations such as Adelaide CCC. Which could be easier for Mr Rae to access, should he receive a non-custodial sentence.Gravity of the Conduct