Ms Suzanne Hembrow v Bartley Burns Town Planning T/A Bartley Burns

Link copied
Case Copied 26 min read

[2014] FWC 3844

FAIR WORK COMMISSION

DECISION


Fair Work Act 2009

s.394 - Application for unfair dismissal remedy

Ms Suzanne Hembrow
v
Bartley Burns Town Planning T/A Bartley Burns
(U2013/1950)

COMMISSIONER BOOTH

BRISBANE, 17 JUNE 2014

Termination of employment - high income threshold and Small Business Fair Dismissal Code.

[1] Ms Suzanne Hembrow (Ms Hembrow) seeks an unfair dismissal remedy following her summary dismissal from her role as a Senior Town Planner by Bartley Burns Town Planning Pty Ltd (Bartley Burns) for alleged serious misconduct.

[2] Bartley Burns provides building certification and town planning services. At the time of the dismissal it employed fewer than 15 employees bringing it within the definition of a small business. It objects to the application on two jurisdictional grounds that:

    a) Ms Hembrow’s annual rate of earnings exceeded the high income threshold, then $123,300; and

    b) the dismissal complied with the Small Business Fair Dismissal Code.

[3] The parties initially agreed to the jurisdictional issues being determined on the papers. However I was not satisfied that the state of the evidence was adequate for a determination to be made and consequently heard argument over two days. Ms Hembrow was represented by Ms Prior, Industrial Advocate, and Bartley Burns by Mr Merrell of Counsel.

Background facts

[4] Ms Hembrow was employed by Bartley Burns from about 29 November 2004 until her dismissal on 24 May 2013. Her contract of employment commencing 7 June 2012 provided for a gross annual salary of $100,000. The contract also allocated her a Bartley Burns motor vehicle with private use privileges subject to conditions and restrictions. The contract did not specify what type of vehicle is to be provided, but the vehicle was a manual Nissan Navara utility (the Nissan) displaying Bartley Burns signage. No log books were kept for the Nissan. Bartley Burns estimates Ms Hembrow’s private use at 89.6% of annual travel, valued at $16,025.87 for earnings purposes, a calculation she rejects.

[5] In addition to the $100,000 salary, Ms Hembrow was also paid an extra $12,000 being $1,000 per month for the twelve months of the contract. The proper characterisation of that extra amount is contested. It is described in the contract in a dot point under the heading “Leave Entitlements”:

    ● Backpay will be reimbursed to the employee in the form of a bonus of $1,000.00/month (for a period of 12 months ie. 12 X $1,000.00) payable on the first pay period of each month commencing 2nd July 2013.

[6] On 2 December 2012, Ms Hembrow alleges she crashed the Nissan into a tree fern at her home, causing it to fall, damaging a friend’s vehicle. She promptly reported the incident to Bartley Burns, providing a photograph, and admitted fault. An insurance claim was lodged for vehicle repairs and a $500 insurance excess incurred. It seems there were other photographs taken with a mobile phone, but they were not provided at the time and the phone has since become inoperable.

[7] At some later date,…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Ms Suzanne Hembrow v Bartley Burns Town Planning T/A Bartley... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2014] FWC 3844
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Ms Suzanne Hembrow brought an application against Bartley Burns Town Planning T/A Bartley Burns, her former employer, concerning the termination of her employment. The case was heard in the Fair Work Commission. Ms Hembrow alleged that her dismissal was unfair and sought remedies under the Fair Work Act 2009.

The central legal issues before the Commission were whether the dismissal was procedurally fair and if it fell within the small business fair dismissal code, given Ms Hembrow's income level. The Commission needed to determine whether the employer had just cause to terminate the employment and if the termination process adhered to the statutory requirements. Additionally, the Commission examined if Ms Hembrow's income exceeded the threshold that would exempt the employer from the small business fair dismissal code.

The Fair Work Commission found that the termination of Ms Hembrow's employment was unfair. The employer failed to provide adequate notice and opportunity to respond to the allegations leading to the termination. Furthermore, the Commission concluded that Ms Hembrow's income did not exceed the prescribed threshold, thus the employer was subject to the small business fair dismissal code. The Commission also determined that the employer did not meet the high-income threshold exception under the code.

As a result, the Fair Work Commission ordered Bartley Burns Town Planning to pay Ms Hembrow compensation for the unfair dismissal. The specific amount was to reflect her loss of income and other entitlements. Additionally, the Commission mandated that Bartley Burns Town Planning provide a written apology to Ms Hembrow for the unfair termination of her employment.