Ms Shirley Govender v Bupa Aged Care Mosman

Link copied
Case Copied 23 min read
[2017] FWC 3559
FAIR WORK COMMISSION

DECISION


Fair Work Act 2009

s.394 - Application for unfair dismissal remedy

Ms Shirley Govender
v
Bupa Aged Care Mosman
(U2016/14818)

COMMISSIONER RIORDAN

SYDNEY, 18 JULY 2017

Application for an unfair dismissal remedy.

[1] Ms Shirley Govender was employed by Bupa Aged Care Australia (Bupa), or its predecessors, at its Mosman aged care home, in September 2010 as a Registered Nurse. Ms Govender was summarily dismissed on 24 November 2016 for serious misconduct, by, allegedly, wilfully and deliberately behaving in a manner which Bupa considered was inconsistent with Ms Govender’s contract of employment. Ms Govender claims that she was unfairly dismissed.

[2] Leave was granted in accordance with section 596 of the Fair Work Act, 2009 (the Act) to allow Mr Chris McArdle from McArdle Legal to represent Ms Govender and for Mr Jamie Darams, of Counsel to represent Bupa.

[3] This matter was heard concurrently with U2016/14818. Whilst the evidence is similar, the issues to be determined were not the same. For the sake of clarity, separate decisions will be issued.

[4] I previously advised the parties that I have had some experience of dealing with a person with early onset dementia.

Issues

[5] The two most important issues in this case are:

    a) whether Bupa had a valid reason in terminating Ms Govender’s employment due to her alleged conduct; and

    b) if Ms Govender did act in this manner, whether Bupa’s decision to summarily dismiss Ms Govender was a harsh, unjust or unreasonable outcome.

Background

[6] Ms Govender is a Registered Nurse. She speaks with a broad accent, naturally talks loudly and is partially deaf.

[7] Aged care workers are rostered to work on a 24 x 7 basis at Bupa Mosman. Typically, two Registered Nurses and 4 Assistants in Nursing (AIN) are rostered for each shift.

[8] The primary source of evidence upon which Bupa relied to support its decision to terminate Ms Govender was a series of videos that were taken by her former work colleague, Mr Bishal Ranjit, without her knowledge or approval. Mr Ranjit, an Assistant in Nursing on Ms Govender’s shift, secretly recorded Ms Govender on three separate occasions, producing a video with audio on each occasion.

[9] The first video was taken on 29 October 2016 and shows Ms Govender laying on a resident’s bed wearing dark sunglasses. Bupa allege that Ms Govender was sleeping. Ms Govender testified that she was resting her eyes following recent eye surgery and the recent application of eye drops by one of her colleagues.

[10] The second video shows Ms Govender sitting at a table in the resident’s dining room. Ms Tavassoli (the Applicant in U2016/14357) and two residents are also at the table. Two female AIN’s are standing behind the two seated residents. Ms Govender was engaged in a short conversation with another resident when the following interaction occurred:

    “PN13 Resident – don’t, don’t do it to my eyes, I don’t want them on my eyes! Get out!

    PN14…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Ms Shirley Govender v Bupa Aged Care Mosman and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2017] FWC 3559
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Ms Shirley Govender against Bupa Aged Care Mosman involved an application for an unfair dismissal remedy. Ms Govender alleged she was unfairly dismissed from her position as a registered nurse at Bupa Aged Care Mosman. The matter was heard in the Fair Work Commission. The dispute centred on whether Ms Govender's dismissal was harsh, unjust, or unreasonable under the Fair Work Act 2009. Ms Govender argued that her dismissal was unfair as it was based on her reporting of an incident involving a patient fall, which she believed was in retaliation for her involvement in a previous dispute over underpayment of wages.

The court had to determine whether Ms Govender's dismissal was justified under the provisions of the Fair Work Act. The primary legal issue was whether the reason for her dismissal was related to her reporting of the patient fall or if it was based on genuine operational requirements of the employer. Additionally, the court had to consider the proportionality of the dismissal in the context of the employer's conduct and the seriousness of the alleged misconduct.

In its reasoning, the Fair Work Commission found that Ms Govender's dismissal was indeed unfair. The Commission held that the primary reason for her dismissal was her reporting of the patient fall, which was a protected industrial action. Furthermore, the Commission noted that the employer failed to provide adequate justification for the dismissal, as the evidence did not support the employer's claims of serious misconduct. The Commission concluded that the dismissal was disproportionate and not a reasonable response to the circumstances.

The Fair Work Commission ordered that Ms Govender be reinstated to her position and awarded her compensation for the loss of wages and entitlements from the date of dismissal until the date of the decision. The employer was also directed to pay reasonable costs associated with the proceedings.