Ms Benyan Yao v Murray Farming Pty Ltd T/A Natures Haven

Link copied
Case Copied 62 min read
[2020] FWC 2990
FAIR WORK COMMISSION

DECISION


Fair Work Act 2009

s.394 - Application for unfair dismissal remedy

Ms Benyan Yao
v
Murray Farming Pty Ltd T/A Natures Haven
(U2019/12319)

COMMISSIONER HUNT

BRISBANE, 24 JUNE 2020

Application for an unfair dismissal remedy – jurisdictional objection – genuine redundancy – position no longer required to be performed by anyone – consultation obligation under enterprise agreement – not reasonable in the circumstances to redeploy – jurisdictional objection upheld – application dismissed.

[1] On 5 November 2019, Ms Benyan Yao made an application under s.394 of the Fair Work Act 2009 (the Act) for an unfair dismissal remedy with respect to her dismissal by Murray Farming Pty Ltd T/A Natures Haven (Murray Farming).

[2] Murray Farming raised a jurisdictional objection that Ms Yao’s dismissal was a case of genuine redundancy, and on that basis, Ms Yao was not able to pursue an unfair dismissal application.

[3] On allocation to me, I determined that both the jurisdictional objection and the merits application should be heard at the same time. A determinative conference took place by telephone on 21 April 2020. At the determinative conference, Ms Yao appeared on her own behalf with the assistance of an interpreter. Murray Farming was represented by Mr Donald Murray, Owner, and Ms Jodi Murray, Dispatch Manager. Ms Murray is Mr Murray’s daughter.

Request for order of attendance and production of documents

[4] On 2 April 2020, Ms Yao filed an application for an order requiring three witnesses to attend and give evidence before the Commission. On 6 April 2020, Ms Yao filed an application for the production of a very substantial number of documents to be produced. The documents sought included all text messages sent between herself and seven people.

[5] On 6 April 2020, Ms Yao also produced a medical report from Dr Kerry Francis, Clinical Psychologist dated 29 March 2020. On 6 April 2020, the following email was sent from my chambers to the parties:

“The Commissioner has reviewed the letter dated 29 March 2020 from Dr Kerry Francis, Clinical Psychologist.  The Commissioner wishes to make it very clear that the matter will proceed as a telephone hearing on 21 April 2020……….. Dr Francis has stated the following:

“It is for these reasons that I believe that Ms Yao will require support to continue with complaint proceedings. Having interpreter services are vitally important for her to present her case appropriately. Additionally, a support person would be ideal. I strongly recommend that she not be placed in the same room as her ex-employer, nor be present if these people speak on the telephone, as these situations would be very triggering. She may struggle to maintain her equilibrium and this in turn would prejudice her ability to present her case. She is also likely to require breaks to enable her to downregulate her nervous system.”

The Commissioner advises that it will indeed be necessary for the Applicant to remain on the phone and hear the evidence of the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Ms Benyan Yao v Murray Farming Pty Ltd T/A Natures Haven and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2020] FWC 2990
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The applicant, Ms Benyan Yao, applied for an unfair dismissal remedy against her former employer, Murray Farming Pty Ltd trading as Natures Haven. The matter was heard in the Fair Work Commission. The crux of the dispute was whether Ms Yao's dismissal was unjust, and if so, whether the Commission had jurisdiction to hear the case, given a jurisdictional objection raised by the respondent.

The primary legal issue before the Commission was whether the dismissal was genuine and whether the respondent had adequately consulted with Ms Yao regarding the redundancy as required by their enterprise agreement. Additionally, the Commission had to determine if it was reasonable in the circumstances to redeploy Ms Yao to another position within the organisation. The respondent argued that Ms Yao's position had genuinely been made redundant and that it was not reasonable to redeploy her.

The Commission found that while Ms Yao's dismissal was potentially unfair, the jurisdictional objection raised by the respondent regarding the redundancy was valid. The Commission held that the position Ms Yao held was no longer required to be performed by anyone, which satisfied the genuine redundancy criteria. Furthermore, the Commission found that it was not reasonable in the circumstances to redeploy Ms Yao due to her specific skill set and the nature of her role. The consultation obligations under the enterprise agreement were also deemed to have been fulfilled as per the evidence presented. Consequently, the application for an unfair dismissal remedy was dismissed.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established