Mrs Saloshna (Vanessa) Naicker v Epworth Foundation

Link copied
Case Copied 74 min read
[2017] FWC 4928
FAIR WORK COMMISSION

DECISION


Fair Work Act 2009

s.394 - Application for unfair dismissal remedy

Mrs Saloshna (Vanessa) Naicker
v
Epworth Foundation
(U2016/12795)

DEPUTY PRESIDENT GOSTENCNIK

MELBOURNE, 1 NOVEMBER 2017

Application for relief from unfair dismissal; whether refusal to comply with reasonable lawful direction; whether direction was reasonable; whether employee could not fulfil the inherent requirements of the position; whether employee engaged in inappropriate and threatening conduct directed towards other employee; whether denial of conduct alleged was dishonest; consideration whether there was a valid reason for dismissal; consideration of proportionality of dismissal as a response to conduct; dismissal not harsh, unjust or unreasonable; application dismissed.

[1] Mrs Saloshna Naicker (Applicant) is a theatre nurse. She had worked as a theatre nurse in various hospitals in South Africa between 1991 and 1997 1 before migrating to New Zealand.2 There she worked as a theatre nurse in public and private hospitals3 until migrating to Australia in 2005.4 In Australia, the Applicant commenced work as an agency nurse, working as a theatre nurse at various hospitals in Melbourne.5 The Applicant commenced causal employment with Epworth Foundation (Respondent) at its East Melbourne facility in June 2012 and became a full time employee in or around May 2015.6

[2] On or around 4 July 2016, the Applicant was placed on special paid leave pending an independent medical examination  7 and investigation. The Applicant was dismissed from her employment with the Respondent on 29 September 2016, effective immediately with a payment of 4 weeks’ pay in lieu of notice.8 Her dismissal was said to be on serious misconduct grounds because she refused to comply with a lawful and reasonable direction, her conduct towards Ms Genevieve Toop, Senior Human Resource Manager and her inability to fulfil the inherent requirements of her role for the foreseeable future.9 The Respondent relies on a further independent reason for the Applicant’s dismissal after an admission she had made during the proceeding before me. The Respondent says that the Applicant dishonestly denied to the Respondent that she used inappropriate language towards Ms Toop during a telephone call on 23 September 2016.10

[3] On 20 October 2016, the Applicant applied under s.394 of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Act) for an unfair dismissal remedy.

[4] Turning first to deal with the initial matters which must be decided before the merits of an application are considered. 11 These matters were not in dispute, and I find that:

  • The application was made within the time prescribed in s.394(2) of the Act;


  • The Applicant was, at the date of her dismissal, protected from unfair dismissal within the meaning of s.382 of the Act;


  • The Epworth Health Care Nurses Enterprise Agreement 2012 - 2016 (Agreement) covered the Applicant in her employment with the Respondent and applied to her at the time of her dismissal;


  • The Respondent was not a small-business employer within the meaning of the Act and so the Small Business Fair Dismissal Code did not apply; and


  • The dismissal was not effected…
CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Mrs Saloshna (Vanessa) Naicker v Epworth Foundation and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2017] FWC 4928
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The applicant, Mrs Saloshna (Vanessa) Naicker, brought an application for relief from unfair dismissal against her former employer, Epworth Foundation. The dispute arose from the termination of Naicker's employment following a series of events that culminated in her dismissal. The case was heard and determined in the Fair Work Commission, Australia's workplace relations tribunal.

The primary legal issues the Commission had to decide were whether the Foundation had refused to comply with a reasonable lawful direction, whether the direction given was reasonable, and whether Naicker could not fulfil the inherent requirements of her position. Furthermore, the Commission considered whether Naicker engaged in inappropriate and threatening conduct directed towards another employee and whether her denial of such conduct was dishonest. The Commission also assessed whether there was a valid reason for Naicker's dismissal and whether the dismissal was proportionate to her conduct. Ultimately, the Commission had to determine whether the dismissal was harsh, unjust, or unreasonable.

The Commission found that the direction given to the Foundation was reasonable and that Naicker could not fulfil the inherent requirements of her position. While Naicker denied engaging in inappropriate and threatening conduct towards another employee, the Commission determined that her denial was dishonest. The Commission considered the Foundation's reasons for dismissal, finding them valid, and assessed the proportionality of the dismissal in response to Naicker's conduct. The Commission concluded that the dismissal was not harsh, unjust, or unreasonable, and dismissed Naicker's application for relief from unfair dismissal.

The Commission made no orders regarding costs or further relief. The decision stands as a clear articulation of the principles governing the validity of dismissals in Australia, emphasizing the importance of both procedural and substantive fairness in employment terminations.