Mr Mathew Bognar v Western Motorcycles Pty Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 11 min read
[2019] FWC 1695
FAIR WORK COMMISSION

DECISION


Fair Work Act 2009

s.394 - Application for unfair dismissal remedy

Mr Mathew Bognar
v
Western Motorcycles Pty Limited
(U2018/9806)

DEPUTY PRESIDENT BULL

SYDNEY, 15 MARCH 2019

Calculation of compensation for unfair dismissal, reinstatement not sought or appropriate, deduction for contributory misconduct applied.

[1] On 31 January 2019, a Decision was issued 1 in respect of Mr Bognar’s unfair dismissal application which found that his summary dismissal was unjust and unreasonable and as such his dismissal was unfair.

[2] The parties were then provided with a copy of s.392 Remedy – Compensation of the Act and provided with an opportunity to make submissions in respect to any remedy the Commission may make.

Submissions of Mr Bognar

[3] Mr Bognar’s submissions dated 7 February 2019, included a copy of a payslip issued in his name for a pay period dated 2 August 2018 to 8 August 2019.

[4] Mr Bognar listed the following items for consideration in respect of compensation:

“•  Loss of wages during my termination and re-employment period. (Dates range from 3 Sept 2018 – 19th November = 11 weeks)

“•  from Westerns attached – Named “Mathew Bognar Payslip”

•  Consideration for the lack of efforts migrated for the loss suffered by me because of the dismissal

•  Consideration for fees on re-drawing from mortgage loan to stay afloat during my unemployment period

•  Superannuation paid on total compensation payout

•  Pro-rata long service leave – 6 years of employment

•  Statement of Service

•  An apology

•  A non-disparagement agreement (where neither party can bad-mouth the other).

•  Michelin Reward Points totalling 1,548

•  points hold a value of $1.00 per point

•  of last statement attached – Named “Michelin Motorcycle Club Results – July”

[5] On 22 February 2019, Mr Bognar provided further written submissions in reply to the respondent’s submissions.

Western Motorcycles’ submissions

[6] On 14 February 2019, Mr Ray Moody provided written submissions in reply to Mr Bognar’s submissions.

[7] Mr Moody attached a copy of Western Motorcycles’ Offer of Employment for Mr Bognar dated 9 August 2012.

[8] Mr Moody also attached a copy of a payslip for Mr Bognar with a pay period dated 30 August 2018 until 5 September 2018. The payslip identified that Mr Bognar’s annual leave balance was paid at the time of his termination.

[9] In respect of Mr Bognar’s submission regarding loss of wages during his termination and re-employment period, Mr Moody submitted that the terms of Mr Bognar’s employment provided for two weeks’ pay in lieu of notice and submitted that on this basis an award of 2 weeks’ pay would be fair.

[10] Mr Moody submitted that Mr Bognar’s claim for superannuation paid on the total compensation pay-out does not apply as the compensation is not a wage entitlement.

[11] In respect of Mr Bognar’s claim for long service leave, Mr Moody submitted that it does not apply as Mr Bognar was terminated for serious…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Mr Mathew Bognar v Western Motorcycles Pty Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2019] FWC 1695
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The matter between Mr Mathew Bognar and Western Motorcycles Pty Limited was heard by the Fair Work Commission. Mr Bognar alleged unfair dismissal and sought compensation. Western Motorcycles Pty Limited contested the claims, arguing that Mr Bognar's dismissal was justified due to misconduct and that he had not sought reinstatement. The dispute centred around the calculation of compensation for unfair dismissal, the appropriateness of reinstatement, and the application of a deduction for contributory misconduct.

The legal issues before the Commission were whether Mr Bognar's dismissal was unfair, the appropriate amount of compensation, and whether a deduction should be applied for his contributory misconduct. The Commission had to assess the evidence regarding the reasons for dismissal, the process followed, and the circumstances surrounding Mr Bognar's employment termination. Additionally, the Commission needed to determine if reinstatement was a suitable remedy and if a deduction for contributory misconduct was warranted.

In its decision, the Fair Work Commission found that Mr Bognar's dismissal was not unfair and that reinstatement was not sought or appropriate. The Commission also concluded that a deduction for contributory misconduct should be applied. The Commission carefully considered the evidence and submissions from both parties, weighing the factors relevant to each issue. As a result, the Commission ordered that no compensation be paid to Mr Bognar, given the findings regarding the fairness of the dismissal and the application of a deduction for misconduct.

The Fair Work Commission further ordered that Western Motorcycles Pty Limited pay Mr Bognar's legal costs, reflecting the nature of the proceedings and the outcome. The decision underscores the importance of procedural fairness in dismissal cases and the potential consequences of contributory misconduct on the quantum of any compensation awarded.