Mount Cathay Pty Ltd v The Trust Company Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 28 min read

SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

Mount Cathay Pty Ltd & Anor v The Trust Company Ltd & Anor [2023] QSC 102

PARTIES:

MOUNT CATHAY PTY LTD
ACN 010 482 461

(first plaintiff)

ILIFE FACTORY PTY LTD
ACN 101 777 182

(second plaintiff)

v
THE TRUST COMPANY LTD
ACN 004 027 749
(first defendant)
BUILDCORP GROUP PTY LTD
ACN 091 336 168

(second defendant)

FILE NO/S:

BS 11907 of 2020

DIVISION:

Trial Division

PROCEEDING:

Claim

DELIVERED ON:

17 May 2023

DELIVERED AT:

Brisbane

HEARING DATE:

2 to 4 May 2023

JUDGE:

Bradley J

ORDER:

1.   The plaintiffs’ claim against the defendants is dismissed.

2.   There be judgment for the defendants against the plaintiffs, with costs.

CATCHWORDS:

GENERALLY – VICARIOUS LIABILITY, NON-DELEGABLE DUTY AND RELATED MATTERS – INDEPENDENT CONTRACTORS – where the first plaintiff was the registered lessee of land – where the first defendant contracted with the second defendant to perform works adjacent to the leased premises – where the second defendant subcontracted to a third party the performance of the works –where the second defendant instructed the third party not to enter or be near the premises – where, in contravention of this direction, the third party entered the premises – whether the defendants were liable for trespass

DAMAGES – GENERALLY – EXEMPLARY, PUNITIVE, AGGRAVATED AND LIKE DAMAGES – EXEMPLARY DAMAGES – where the first plaintiff was the registered lessee of land – where the first defendant contracted with the second defendant to perform works adjacent to the leased premises – where the second defendant subcontracted to a third party the performance of the works – where the first plaintiff had explicitly denied the defendants access to the premises for the performance of the works – where the second defendant had redesigned the works to avoid entering the premises and had instructed the third party not to enter or be near the premises – where, in contravention of this direction, the third party entered the premises – whether the trespass, in the context of the first plaintiff’s explicit refusal of consent to entry, constituted a contumelious disregard for the first plaintiff’s rights – whether the plaintiffs were entitled to exemplary damages for trespass

MISCELLANEOUS TORTS – INTENTIONAL INTERFERENCE WITH CONTRACT – OTHER PARTICULAR CASES – where the first plaintiff was the registered lessee of land – where, by the lease, the first plaintiff was to enjoy access to the leased premises via a particular street in common with all persons lawfully using the same street – where the first defendant contracted with the second defendant to perform works adjacent to the premises – where the first plaintiff alleged that the second defendant or its contractors blocked the driveway from the street into the premises – where a report revealed that only one car was blocked from entering or exiting the driveway over a 14 day period – where the plaintiffs adduced no evidence as to the state of mind of either defendant – whether the defendants were liable for intentional…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Mount Cathay Pty Ltd v The Trust Company Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] QSC 102
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the matter of Mount Cathay Pty Ltd v The Trust Company Ltd, the plaintiffs sought relief from the court due to alleged trespass and interference with their contractual rights by the defendants. Mount Cathay Pty Ltd, the first plaintiff, was the registered lessee of certain land, and the second defendant, Buildcorp, had contracted with the first defendant, TCL, to perform works adjacent to the leased premises. Buildcorp subcontracted the performance of these works to a third party, APS Plumbing (Qld) Pty Ltd. The plaintiffs contended that despite explicit instructions prohibiting entry onto the leased premises, APS workers entered the premises, leading to claims of trespass. Furthermore, the plaintiffs alleged that the defendants had intentionally interfered with their contractual relations by blocking access to their property.

The court was tasked with determining whether the defendants were liable for the trespass committed by APS workers who entered the leased premises against explicit instructions. Additionally, the court had to consider whether the plaintiffs were entitled to exemplary damages given the contumelious disregard for their rights. The court also needed to decide if the defendants were liable for intentionally interfering with the plaintiffs' contractual relations by blocking access to their property.

The court dismissed the plaintiffs' claims, ruling that the defendants were not liable for the trespass or for intentionally interfering with the plaintiffs' contractual relations. The court found that the plaintiffs had not provided sufficient evidence to support their claims. In particular, the plaintiffs failed to demonstrate that the workers observed entering the premises were indeed APS employees, as required by their own evidence. Furthermore, the court held that the plaintiffs were not entitled to exemplary damages, as the alleged trespass did not meet the threshold of a contumelious disregard for their rights. The court ordered that the plaintiffs' claims against the defendants be dismissed, with the defendants to recover costs from the plaintiffs.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The plaintiffs’ claim against the defendants is dismissed.

2. There be judgment for the defendants against the plaintiffs, with costs.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The plaintiffs asked the Court to infer that the workers observed by Mr Liu and Mr Quadrio, and those shown on the CCTV footage, were workers engaged by APS Plumbing (Qld) Pty Ltd (APS). For this inference, the plaintiffs relied on the evidence of Mr Reece.Mr Reece’s evidence According to Mr Reece, Buildcorp engaged APS, Programmed Electrical, and Thor Demolition to undertake certain works on the lower ground level of Valley Metro. APS’s work included installing three pipes along the block wall: a 300mm PVC stormwater pipe, a trade waste pipe, and a sewerage pipe. The block wall is indicated on the Survey Plan as being outside the Tenement. Buildcorp and APS are parties to a major works subcontract, dated 1 April 2020, for work including this work. In this instrument, TCL is identified as the Principal. TCL and Buildcorp executed a design and construct contract for works, likely including these works, dated 7 February 2020. According to Mr Reece, before works commenced on the lower ground level, he was directed that “we were not allowed to access lease J.” Following this direction, Buildcorp undertook several design changes, including a “complete redesign of [the] stormwater drainage”. Buildcorp engaged a surveying company to ascertain the leases on the lower ground level including Lease J. This was the Survey Plan. Mr Reece said he gave Paul Serra and Michel Serra from APS, and Brian Dencher from Programmed Electrical, a direction “that the hydraulic works, in particular, had been redesigned to be excluded from lease J and they weren’t to enter lease J.” Mr Reece said he gave a direction to all the Buildcorp employees concerned with the Valley Metro works that “under no circumstances” were they to enter the Tenement, that they “were banned from walking on it”, and “no one was to go on to lease J or be near lease J.” Mr Reece explained that Buildcorp used the two columns on the Survey Plan as markers to say, “Stay away from these columns. Don’t go any further.” Mr Reece identified the columns to which he was referring in exhibit 19. They correspond to the sixth and seventh columns in the third row on the Survey Plan. He said Buildcorp used one of these (the sixth column) to say that “everyone on the site was told to stay away from that column at all times and never go past it as a physical marker on the site.” Mr Reece said some markings were placed on the ground from the surveyor’s pin and some temporary fencing was erected, including between the sixth and seventh columns in the third row, to encourage compliance by APS with Buildcorp’s direction. At one point, a length of bunting was put in place between the end of the concrete wall near the QR signal box gap and the sixth column in the second row to represent a “safe path” along the block wall. He told APS “they couldn’t go on the other side of the bunting.” Mr Reece said he instructed Buildcorp’s own employees and the subcontractors and their employees that they were not to walk straight ahead beyond the speed bump located from the sixth column in the third row, and not to move machinery there. He agreed in cross-examination that the workers were told, if they approached from Alden Street, they were to “turn right” before the seventh column in the third row, “go across” to the block wall, “and then move up on the western side of those four columns”, which were the third to sixth columns in the second row.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.