Motlap v Workers' Compensation Regulator

Link copied
Case Copied 27 min read

QUEENSLAND INDUSTRIAL RELATIONS COMMISSION

CITATION:

Motlap v Workers' Compensation Regulator [2020] QIRC 196

PARTIES:

Motlap, Phillip Justin
(Appellant)

v

Workers' Compensation Regulator
(Respondent)

CASE NO:

WC/2018/222

PROCEEDING:

Appeal against decision of Workers' Compensation Regulator

DELIVERED ON:

17 November 2020

HEARING DATE: 

23 and 24 June 2020

MEMBER:

HEARD AT:

O'Connor VP

Cairns

ORDERS:

1.      The appeal is upheld;

2.      The decision of the Respondent dated 22 November 2018 is set aside;

3. The Commission substitutes a new decision that the Appellant is a worker for the purposes of s 11 of the Workers' Compensation and Rehabilitation Act 2003;

4. The matter is remitted back to WorkCover Queensland for the determination of whether the Appellant has suffered an injury within the meaning given to that term under s 32 of the Workers' Compensation and Rehabilitation Act 2003; and,

5.      The Respondent is to pay the Appellant's costs of and incidental to this appeal to be agreed or, failing agreement, to be the subject of a further application to the Commission.

CATCHWORDS:

WORKERS' COMPENSATION - APPEAL AGAINST DECISION - where the appellant stepped onto a large batten screw causing injury to his left foot - where appellant alleges injury sustained whilst carrying out work duties at lodging houses - whether the duties were completed at the direction and under the control of the employer - where credibility of witnesses is in issue - whether the appellant is a worker pursuant to s 11 of the Workers' Compensation and Rehabilitation Act 2003.

LEGISLATION:

CASES:

Workers' Compensation and Rehabilitation Act 2003, s 11, s 32

Carna Group Pty Ltd v The Griffin Coal Mining Company (No 2) [2019] FCA 2209
Jones v Dunkel (1959) 101 CLR 298
RHG Mortgage Limited v Rosario Ianni [2015] NSWCA 56
Shane Joseph Farrell AND Q-COMP [2013] QIRC 19

APPEARANCES:

Mr D.G.H. Turnbull, Counsel instructed by Mr R. Anderson, Bounty Law for the Appellant.

Ms L.A. Neil, Counsel directly instructed by Ms R. Jamieson, Workers' Compensation Regulator for the Respondent.

Reasons for Decision

  1. Mr Phillip Justin Motlap (the Appellant) has appealed a decision of the Respondent dated 22 November 2018 confirming the decision of WorkCover to reject his application for compensation for an injury to the 'left foot & lower left leg & nerve damage w/related back pain'.  The Appellant alleges the injury was sustained as a result of stepping on a large batten screw 'whilst carrying out work duties at lodging houses' in the backyard of premises at 26 and 28 Clare Street, Paramatta Park, Cairns.  The application for compensation states that at the relevant time the Appellant was employed as a Labourer by Mr Carlo Van Smoorenburg.

  2. The issue for determination in this matter is whether the Appellant was employed as a worker pursuant to s 11 of the Workers' Compensation and Rehabilitation Act 2003 (WCR Act) or that he was performing work for an employer when he sustained the injury.

  3. During the course of the hearing the Commission heard from two witnesses.  The Appellant gave evidence…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Motlap v Workers' Compensation Regulator and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2020] QIRC 196
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Motlap v Workers' Compensation Regulator, the appeal was lodged by the appellant, Mr Motlap, against the decision of the Workers' Compensation Regulator (the respondent) to refuse his claim for workers' compensation. The dispute arose from an incident where Mr Motlap injured his left foot after stepping onto a large batten screw while working at two lodging houses owned by Mr Van Smoorenburg. Mr Motlap argued that he was employed by Mr Van Smoorenburg to undertake various labouring tasks at the properties, whereas Mr Van Smoorenburg denied that Mr Motlap was ever employed by him and suggested that the claim for compensation was fraudulent. The key legal issue before the court was whether Mr Motlap was a "worker" under section 11 of the Workers' Compensation and Rehabilitation Act 2003.

The court considered the credibility of the witnesses and the evidence provided by both parties. Mr Motlap testified that he entered into an agreement with Mr Van Smoorenburg to perform work at his direction and under his control, including tasks such as building a fence, cementing, constructing an A-frame, installing paving, and painting. He claimed that Mr Van Smoorenburg provided tools and work boots and worked alongside him on site. Conversely, Mr Van Smoorenburg denied that Mr Motlap was employed by him, stating that the claim was fraudulent and that Mr Motlap should have lodged his claim against Middleman Australia Pty Ltd, a company he owned for unrelated business purposes. The court was required to determine which version of events was more credible.

In its decision, the court found that the appellant's evidence was more credible and that the appellant had satisfied the burden of proof to establish that he was a worker for the purposes of section 11 of the Act. The court accepted that Mr Motlap entered into an agreement with Mr Van Smoorenburg to perform work at his direction and under his control, and that he was injured in the course of carrying out these tasks. The appeal was therefore upheld, and the decision of the respondent was set aside. The court substituted a new decision that Mr Motlap was a worker for the purposes of section 11 of the Act, and the matter was remitted back to WorkCover Queensland to determine whether Mr Motlap had suffered an injury within the meaning given to that term under section 32 of the Act. Additionally, the court ordered that the respondent pay the appellant's costs of and incidental to this appeal.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The appeal is upheld;

2. The decision of the Respondent dated 22 November 2018 is set aside;

3. The Commission substitutes a new decision that the Appellant is a worker for the purposes of s 11 of the Workers' Compensation and Rehabilitation Act 2003;

4. The matter is remitted back to WorkCover Queensland for the determination of whether the Appellant has suffered an injury within the meaning given to that term under s 32 of the Workers' Compensation and Rehabilitation Act 2003; and,

5. The Respondent is to pay the Appellant's costs of and incidental to this appeal to be agreed or, failing agreement, to be the subject of a further application to the Commission.

Background

Background to the litigation

During the course of the hearing the Commission heard from two witnesses. The Appellant gave evidence on his own behalf and the Respondent called Mr Van Smoorenburg. The credibility of their evidence is the determining factor as to whether the Appellant is a worker.The Facts In or around February 2018, Mr Motlap was unemployed, and he became aware through Mr Alan Tregenza that Mr Van Smoorenburg had a room available for rent which was less than he was paying. He approached Mr Van Smoorenburg to become a boarder at one of his properties. The Appellant alleges that two separate oral agreements were entered into around the beginning of February 2018. The first is said to be a rental agreement between the Appellant and Mr Van Smoorenburg to pay $170.00 per week to reside in one of the two adjoining lodging houses owned by Mr Van Smoorenburg. The second agreement involved Mr Van Smoorenburg offering the Appellant, "$15.00 an hour to do labouring work all around the house, because he's actually renovating the whole two properties".[1] The Appellant said there was nothing mentioned about tax.[1] TR1-11, LL1-2. In terms of the rental agreement, the Appellant stated that Mr Van Smoorenburg said, "everyone chips in to clean, part of the keeping it clean and just general weeding and general gardening. Just maintaining the place like it's my own home".[2][2] TR1-14, LL12-14. It was claimed by Mr Van Smoorenburg that three days after the Appellant moved in, he said, " … because I told him I was a plumber. I was in business and he proposed, so you want to do a WorkCover scam?". Mr Van Smoorenburg said he laughed this off as a joke at the time and told him to "fuck off".[3] [3] TR2-5, LL 24-28. The Appellant holds a white card issued by the Queensland Building Services Authority to undertake labouring and construction work on construction sites.[4] The Appellant told the Commission that Mr Van Smoorenburg identified daily tasks for him to undertake.[5] Some of the construction work performed by the Appellant included building the whole wooden fence on both properties, "… I had to dig the holes for the posts to be in … I used that with a shovel and a crowbar … I did the heights by string lines … I put the posts in. Then I cemented it …".[6] In addition, he put together an A-frame on top of the gate; installed paving inside the front yard and out the back of house No. 26[7]; and performed a lot of painting including concrete painting.[8][4] TR1-4, LL3-6.[5] TR1-27, LL21-24.[6] TR1-17, LL21-26.[7] TR1-19, LL7-14.[8] TR1-20, L2. The Appellant said that Mr Van Smoorenburg worked onsite all the time with him.[9][9] TR1-22, L11. The Appellant's evidence was that Mr Van Smoorenburg said, "I'll provide you all the tools and that, I need a lot of work done. I'll supply you with work boots". The Appellant said that when he told Mr Van Smoorenburg that he only had thongs, Mr Van Smoorenburg said, "That's fine. Just work with them". While Mr Van Smoorenburg said he had all those items including a hard hat and vest, they were not provided.[10][10] TR1-28, L43 - TR1-29, L14.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

During cross-examination, Mr Van Smoorenburg said the claim should have been against Middleman Australia Pty Ltd (Middleman) which is a company he maintains for some business purpose. Mr Van Smoorenburg acknowledged that the company does not have a WorkCover insurance policy and its services were unrelated to renovation work.[49] The existence of this company was not mentioned to WorkCover in the conversation on 15 June 2018.[49] TR1-136, LL27-28.Consideration This matter is a factual dispute and the burden of proof rests on the Appellant to establish that he was a worker for the purposes of s 11 of the WCR Act. In assessing the evidence, let me respectfully adopt the approach of McKenna J who described his fact-finding process in a paper delivered at the University College, Dublin in 1973: The versions of events given by the Appellant and Mr Van Smoorenburg differ markedly. Indeed, they are diametrically opposed. The only common ground appears to be the acceptance that both men entered into a verbal rental agreement whereby the Appellant would pay $170.00 per week for a room at No. 28 Clare Street which included some utilities but with a condition that the Appellant undertake some household chores to "…keep the house nice and tidy".[51] [51] TR1-84, LL42 - TR1-85, L20-21. In its simplest form, the Appellant's evidence is that he entered into an agreement with Mr Van Smoorenburg to undertake work at his direction at 26 and 28 Clare Street in return for a payment of $15.00 per hour. He undertook a range of tasks including fence building on both properties; cementing; construction of an A-frame on top of the gate; installed paving inside the front yard and out the back of house No. 26; and painting. Whilst moving a long piece of timber, he stepped back off the deck and onto a long batten screw measuring 90 millimetres which went straight into his foot. He was transferred to hospital after suffering 'left foot & lower left leg & nerve damage w/related back pain'. The Appellant alleges that Mr Van Smoorenburg told him to say that he was not injured at work and that he would look after him. In the weeks following the Appellant's discharge from hospital, relations between both men deteriorated. The Appellant was not looked after as had been promised and the Appellant left the rental property after not being paid approximately $750.00 which was owing to him. Mr Van Smoorenburg's evidence was that he owned the two properties at 26 and 28 Clare Street, Cairns. Mr Van Smoorenburg denied the Appellant was employed by him in any capacity. The Appellant did not undertake any work for him; he was not injured at his property and claimed that he did not know where he was injured; he had no conversation with the Appellant regarding being injured and certainly did not suggest to the Appellant that he should not tell anyone that he was injured at work. Mr Van Smoorenburg alleged that the claim was fraudulent. Mr Van Smoorenburg was not the holder of a policy of insurance with WorkCover. He said that the Appellant was asked to leave after being issued with an R12 Form.