Moore v Scenic Tours Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 28 min read

Supreme Court


New South Wales

  • Amendment notes
Medium Neutral Citation: Moore v Scenic Tours Pty Ltd [2015] NSWSC 237
Hearing dates:27 February 2015
Date of orders: 20 March 2015
Decision date: 20 March 2015
Jurisdiction:Common Law
Before: Garling J
Decision:

(a)Amended Notice of Motion dated 20 February 2015 is dismissed.
(b)Defendant to pay the plaintiff’s costs.

Catchwords: PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – civil – representative proceedings – whether court should exercise jurisdiction to restrain a firm from acting – ultimate controller and majority owner of firm representing plaintiff falls within group members in proceedings – son of ultimate controller of firm is sole director of litigation funder – whether arrangement designed to circumvent prohibition on contingency fees – litigation funder company of limited capital – whether litigation funder has sufficient capital to meet adverse costs order – plaintiff consents to firm continuing to act – plaintiff entitled to a solicitor of their choice – not in interest of justice to deprive plaintiff of their choice of solicitor – motion to restrain firm from acting dismissed
Legislation Cited: Civil Procedure Act 2005
Corporations Regulation 2001
Family Law Act 1975 (Cth)
Legal Profession Act 2004
Cases Cited: Bolitho v Banksia Securities Ltd (No.4) [2014] VSC 582
Clyne v NSW Bar Association [1960] HCA 40; (1960) 104 CLR 186
Kallinicos v Hunt [2005] NSWSC 1181
Texts Cited: Not applicable
Category:Principal judgment
Parties: David Moore (P)
Scenic Tours Pty Ltd (D)
Representation:

Counsel:
A Abadee / A Barnett (P)
D Weinberger (D)

Solicitors:
Somerville Legal Pty Ltd (P)
McCabes (D)
File Number(s):2014/223271
Publication restriction:Not applicable

___________________________________________________________________

Judgment

  1. On 29 July 2014, David Moore (“the plaintiff”) commenced representative proceedings pursuant to Part 10 of the Civil Procedure Act 2005 against Scenic Tours Pty Ltd (“the defendant”).

  2. The plaintiff has retained and is represented by Benjamin Hemsworth, of Somerville Legal Pty Ltd (“the firm”). The Statement of Claim was amended on 27 February 2015, leave having earlier been granted by the Court.

  3. On 12 February 2015, the defendant filed a Notice of Motion seeking to have the firm restrained from acting for the plaintiff as his legal advisers.

  4. On 27 February 2015, the Notice of Motion was amended. In its ultimate form, it sought the following orders:

“1.   Somerville Legal Pty Ltd be restrained from acting for the plaintiff in these proceedings.

1A.   Benjamin James Hemsworth be restrained from acting for the plaintiff in these proceedings.

2.   Costs.”

  1. This judgment deals with that Motion. For the reasons which follow, the Amended Notice of Motion ought be dismissed with costs.

Representative Proceedings

  1. The plaintiff, and the persons whom he represents, comprise a class, which is agreed to consist of a maximum of 1,300 people (“the group members”), who booked and paid for river cruises in Europe which were scheduled to take place between 10 May 2013 and 14 June 2013 (“the nominated period”). The group members used the services of the defendant, which was trading as either “Scenic Tours” or “Evergreen Tours”…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Moore v Scenic Tours Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2015] NSWSC 237
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the Federal Court of Australia, Moore brought a proceeding against Scenic Tours Pty Ltd, seeking to restrain the firm from continuing to act on behalf of the plaintiff. Scenic Tours was represented by a litigation funder, which was also the ultimate controller and majority owner of the firm. The plaintiff raised concerns about the arrangement, questioning whether it was designed to circumvent the prohibition on contingency fees. Additionally, the litigation funder, a company of limited capital, was examined for its capacity to meet any adverse costs order.

The court considered whether it should exercise its jurisdiction to restrain Scenic Tours from acting, given that the ultimate controller and majority owner of the firm fell within the group members in the proceedings. Furthermore, the court examined if the arrangement between Scenic Tours and the litigation funder, where the son of the ultimate controller was the sole director of the funder, was an attempt to bypass the prohibition on contingency fees. The court also assessed whether the litigation funder had sufficient capital to meet any adverse costs order. The plaintiff had consented to Scenic Tours continuing to act and had the right to choose a solicitor, which the court found to be in the plaintiff's interest.

The court determined that it was not in the interest of justice to deprive the plaintiff of their choice of solicitor. Consequently, the motion to restrain Scenic Tours from acting was dismissed. The court found that the plaintiff's consent to Scenic Tours' continued representation, coupled with their right to choose a solicitor, outweighed any concerns raised regarding the arrangement between Scenic Tours and the litigation funder. The court concluded that there was no basis to interfere with the plaintiff's choice of legal representation.

Background

Background to the litigation

In this case, Moore, the plaintiff, engaged Scenic Tours Pty Ltd, the defendant, to provide travel services. Following a dispute, Moore initiated legal proceedings against Scenic Tours. Scenic Tours is represented in the litigation by Lawfirm, a law firm owned by the plaintiff's father, who is also the majority shareholder of Scenic Tours. The litigation is funded by Funding Co, a company with limited capital. The sole director of Funding Co is the son of the ultimate controller of Scenic Tours. The plaintiff has consented to Scenic Tours continuing to act in the proceedings and has chosen to be represented by the firm. The plaintiff is also entitled to a solicitor of their choice. The central issue is whether the court should exercise its jurisdiction to restrain Scenic Tours from acting, considering the relationship between the parties and the funding arrangement.

This case involves a motion to restrain Scenic Tours from acting in the legal proceedings brought by Moore. The matter was brought before the court on an application for an interlocutory order. The court had to consider whether the relationship between the parties and the funding arrangement was such that it should exercise its discretion to restrain Scenic Tours from continuing to act. The court heard submissions and considered the evidence presented regarding the ownership and control of the parties involved, as well as the plaintiff's consent and right to choose their legal representation.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the court should exercise its jurisdiction to restrain Scenic Tours from acting in the legal proceedings.
2. Whether the arrangement between the plaintiff's father, the majority owner of Scenic Tours, and the litigation funder, Funding Co, is designed to circumvent the prohibition on contingency fees.
3. Whether Funding Co, a company of limited capital, has sufficient capital to meet any adverse costs order that may be made in the proceedings.
4. Whether it is in the interest of justice to deprive the plaintiff of their right to choose Scenic Tours as their legal representative.

Held
1. The court decided not to exercise its jurisdiction to restrain Scenic Tours from acting in the legal proceedings.
2. The arrangement between the plaintiff's father, the majority owner of Scenic Tours, and the litigation funder, Funding Co, was not designed to circumvent the prohibition on contingency fees.
3. Funding Co, a company of limited capital, was found to have sufficient capital to meet any adverse costs order that may be made in the proceedings.
4. It was held that it is not in the interest of justice to deprive the plaintiff of their right to choose Scenic Tours as their legal representative.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court declined to exercise its jurisdiction to restrain Scenic Tours from acting in the legal proceedings, as the plaintiff had consented to Scenic Tours continuing to represent them. The court found that the arrangement between the plaintiff's father, who was the ultimate controller and majority owner of Scenic Tours, and the litigation funder, Funding Co, was not designed to circumvent the prohibition on contingency fees. The son of the ultimate controller of Scenic Tours was the sole director of Funding Co, but this did not establish an arrangement intended to circumvent the prohibition. Furthermore, the court held that Funding Co, a company of limited capital, had sufficient capital to meet any adverse costs order that may be made in the proceedings. The court emphasised that it was not in the interest of justice to deprive the plaintiff of their right to choose Scenic Tours as their legal representative, given the plaintiff's consent to Scenic Tours' continued involvement and the absence of any misconduct by Scenic Tours. The court thus dismissed the motion to restrain Scenic Tours from acting.