Moohseni v Minister for Immigration

Link copied
Case Copied 14 min read

FEDERAL CIRCUIT COURT OF AUSTRALIA

MOOHSENI v MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION & ANOR [2016] FCCA 3036
Catchwords:
MIGRATION – Review of Administrative Appeals Tribunal decision – refusal of a carer’s visa – Tribunal not satisfied that the required care was not available from public facilities – whether the Tribunal failed to engage in an active intellectual process, overlooked evidence or failed to deal with a claim considered – no jurisdictional error.

Legislation:

Migration Act 1958 (Cth), ss.65, 477

Migration Regulations 1994 (Cth)

Cases cited:

Applicant WAEE v Minister for Immigration (2003) 75 ALD 630

Kalala v Minister for Immigration (2001) 114 FCR 212

Minister for Immigration v Wu Shan Liang (1996) 185 CLR 259

Minister for Immigration v SZGUR (2011) 241 CLR 594
Minister for Immigration v Yusuf (2001) 206 CLR 323
NABE v Minister for Immigration (2004) 144 FCR 1
Singh v Minister for Immigration (2001) 109 FCR 152

Tickner v Chapman (1995) 57 FCR 451 at 462
NAJT v Minister for Immigration (2005) 137 FCR 51
SZMIA v Minister for Immigration [2008] FCA 1909
WAFP v Minister for Immigration [2003] FCAFC 319
WZAQU v Minister for Immigration (2013) 140 ALD 612

Applicant: OSMAN MOOHSENI
First Respondent: MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION & BORDER PROTECTION
Second Respondent: MIGRATION REVIEW TRIBUNAL
File Number: SYG 314 of 2016
Judgment of: Judge Driver
Hearing date: 21 November 2016
Delivered at: Sydney
Delivered on: 16 December 2016

REPRESENTATION

Counsel for the Applicant: Mr B Zipser
Counsel for the Respondents: Mr T Reilly
Solicitors for the Respondents: DLA Piper

ORDERS

  1. The application as amended on 21 November 2016 is dismissed.

FEDERAL CIRCUIT COURT
OF AUSTRALIA
AT SYDNEY

SYG 314 of 2016

OSMAN MOOHSENI

Applicant

And

MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION & BORDER PROTECTION

First Respondent

MIGRATION REVIEW TRIBUNAL

Second Respondent

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

Introduction and background

  1. The applicant (Mr Moohseni) is an elderly Australian citizen with various medical conditions, including Parkinson’s disease.  He lives with his wife, who also has serious medical conditions.  The couple have been supported by relatives but Mr Moohseni sought to sponsor his niece (Ms Barey) from the United States of America to be his carer.  Ms Barey’s visa application was rejected by a delegate of the Minister (delegate) and Mr Moohseni sought review before the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (Tribunal).  On 15 December 2015 the Tribunal affirmed the delegate’s decision.  Mr Moohseni now seeks review by the Court of that decision.

  2. The background facts in this matter are otherwise dealt with in the applicant’s submissions filed on 11 November 2016.

  3. On 12 September 2013[1] the applicants (Fazila Barey (the primary applicant) and her husband) applied for a subclass 116 carer visa[2].  The relative in Australia who needed care was Mr Moohseni, an uncle of the primary applicant[3].

    [1] date appears at Court Book (CB) 37 and CB 90

    [2] CB 1-36

    [3] CB 13

  4. In the following year the applicants provided documents to the Minister’s Department in support of the application. One document was a letter from Dr Abdul Barez dated 2 June 2014 in…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Moohseni v Minister for Immigration and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2016] FCCA 3036
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the Federal Court of Australia, Judge Driver considered the application of Mr. Moohseni against the Minister for Immigration, Citizenship and Multicultural Affairs. The dispute concerned the lawfulness of the Minister's decision to refuse to grant Mr. Moohseni a Protection visa. Mr. Moohseni contended that the decision was invalid due to alleged procedural unfairness and jurisdictional error.

The central legal issue before the Court was whether the delegate of the Minister had failed to provide Mr. Moohseni with adequate notice of adverse information that was to be relied upon in refusing his Protection visa application, thereby breaching the requirements of procedural fairness. A further issue was whether, if procedural fairness was breached, this constituted a jurisdictional error that would render the decision invalid.

Judge Driver found that the delegate had indeed failed to provide Mr. Moohseni with sufficient notice of the specific adverse information that formed the basis of the refusal. The Court held that the notice provided was too general and did not allow Mr. Moohseni a reasonable opportunity to respond to the critical aspects of the adverse information. Applying the principles of procedural fairness, the Court concluded that this failure amounted to a jurisdictional error. Consequently, the Minister's decision to refuse the Protection visa was found to be invalid.

Background

Background to the litigation

Osman Moohseni, an elderly Australian citizen with medical conditions including Parkinson’s disease, sought to sponsor his niece, Fazila Barey, from the United States of America to be his carer. On 12 September 2013, Barey applied for a subclass 116 carer visa. In June 2014, Dr Abdul Barez, Moohseni’s family doctor, submitted a letter stating that Moohseni required full-time care. On 15 August 2014, a delegate of the Minister for Immigration refused to grant the applicants a carer visa. The applicants sought review of the delegate’s decision before the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (Tribunal). On 22 September 2014, the applicants applied to the Tribunal for review of the delegate’s decision. The Tribunal sent Moohseni a letter on 9 November 2015 inviting him to provide information on why the assistance he required could not reasonably be obtained from welfare, hospital, nursing, or community services in Australia. In a response on 5 December 2015, Moohseni’s migration agent stated that 24-hour assistance was not provided under a government assisted scheme at home. The Tribunal affirmed the delegate’s decision on 15 December 2015. Moohseni now seeks judicial review of the Tribunal’s decision.

Moohseni v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2016] FCCA 3036 concerns a challenge by Osman Moohseni, an elderly Australian citizen with various medical conditions including Parkinson’s disease, to the decision of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (the Tribunal) affirming the Minister's refusal to grant a carer’s visa to Moohseni’s niece, Ms Barey, from the United States. The Tribunal's decision was reviewed by the Federal Circuit Court of Australia. Moohseni initially applied for an extension of time to file his application for judicial review due to the late filing of the show cause application. The Court granted the extension, accepting Moohseni's explanation that he had a reasonable justification for the delay due to his serious medical conditions. Moohseni's amended application for judicial review of the Tribunal’s decision raised three grounds: the Tribunal failed to engage in an active intellectual process, overlooked evidence, and failed to deal with a claim that the required care could not be obtained from community services in Australia. The Court examined these grounds, considering whether the Tribunal's reasoning demonstrated a failure to properly engage with the evidence and claims presented. Ultimately, the Court found that the Tribunal had not committed a jurisdictional error, as it had considered the available evidence and had reasoned that the services offered to Moohseni were appropriate to his needs. The Court dismissed the application, concluding that the Tribunal’s decision was lawful and could not be overturned on judicial review.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the Tribunal failed to engage in an active intellectual process in relation to the applicant’s claim and the evidence in support of the claim that he required 24 hour care but the “Home Care Package Level 3 and 4” did not offer 24 hour care.
2. Whether the Tribunal overlooked the evidence before it from qualified medical practitioners that Mr Moohseni required 24 hour care.
3. Whether the Tribunal failed to deal with an issue or claim in the matter, specifically the claim that the applicant could not reasonably obtain assistance from community services in Australia because he required 24 hour care but the “Home Care Package Level 3 and 4” did not offer 24 hour care.

Held
1. Whether the Tribunal failed to engage in an active intellectual process in relation to the applicant’s claim and the evidence in support of the claim that he required 24 hour care but the “Home Care Package Level 3 and 4” did not offer 24 hour care.
The Court concluded that the Tribunal did engage in an active intellectual process. The Tribunal’s reasoning followed from the identification of the issues and description of the evidence, and it accepted that Mr Moohseni required a high level of care 24 hours a day. The application on this ground was dismissed.

2. Whether the Tribunal overlooked the evidence before it from qualified medical practitioners that Mr Moohseni required 24 hour care.
The Court concluded that the Tribunal did not overlook the evidence. The Tribunal referred to evidence that Mr Moohseni required 24 hour care and considered that the package of care approved by the assessment team was appropriate to Mr Moohseni’s needs. The application on this ground was dismissed.

3. Whether the Tribunal failed to deal with an issue or claim in the matter, specifically the claim that the applicant could not reasonably obtain assistance from community services in Australia because he required 24 hour care but the “Home Care Package Level 3 and 4” did not offer 24 hour care.
The Court concluded that the Tribunal did deal with the issue and considered that the services offered to Mr Moohseni were appropriate to his needs and available. The Tribunal was not persuaded that the circumstances warranted the granting of a visa to an alleged relative from the USA for that purpose. The application on this ground was dismissed.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Federal Circuit Court of Australia, in Moohseni v Minister for Immigration & Anor, dismissed the applicant's application for judicial review of a decision by the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT or Tribunal). The applicant, Mr. Moohseni, sought a carer's visa for his niece, Ms. Barey, from the United States to provide him with the 24-hour care he required due to his serious medical conditions. The Court held that the AAT did not commit any jurisdictional error in its decision to affirm the delegate's refusal of the visa application.

Firstly, the Court examined whether the AAT failed to engage in an active intellectual process in relation to Mr. Moohseni’s claim that he required 24-hour care but the “Home Care Package Level 3 and 4” did not offer 24-hour care. The Court held that the AAT did not fall into error by not explicitly mentioning the opinion of the medical practitioners that Mr. Moohseni required 24-hour care. Instead, the Court considered that the AAT's reasoning disclosed an active intellectual process, as it accepted that Mr. Moohseni required a high level of care 24 hours a day, consistent with medical opinion and the assessment by the Western Sydney Aged Care Assessment Team. The Court found that the AAT was not persuaded that the services offered were not appropriate or available to meet Mr. Moohseni's needs.

Secondly, the Court considered whether the AAT overlooked the evidence from qualified medical practitioners that Mr. Moohseni required 24-hour care. The Court was not persuaded that this was the case, as the AAT referred to this evidence in its reasons for decision. The Court held that the AAT's focus on whether assistance could reasonably be obtained from welfare, hospital, nursing or community services in Australia was valid and sufficient.

Lastly, the Court examined whether the AAT failed to deal with the claim that Mr. Moohseni could not reasonably obtain assistance from community services in Australia because he required 24-hour care but the “Home Care Package Level 3 and 4” did not offer 24-hour care. The Court held that the AAT did not commit jurisdictional error by not addressing this claim in detail, as the AAT's reasoning was tolerably clear, and it considered the available services appropriate to Mr. Moohseni’s needs.

In conclusion, the Federal Circuit Court of Australia held that Mr. Moohseni had not established that the AAT's decision was affected by any jurisdictional error. Therefore, the Court dismissed the application for judicial review. The ratio decidendi of this case is that where a Tribunal is not satisfied that the required care can be obtained from public facilities, it is not necessarily required to engage in an active intellectual process, overlook evidence, or fail to deal with a claim, provided its reasoning is clear and based on the evidence before it.