Moodie v Nationwide News Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 21 min read

MOODIE -v- NATIONWIDE NEWS PTY LTD [2002] WASC 246


Link to Appeal :

SUPREME COURT OF WESTERN AUSTRALIACitation No:[2002] WASC 246
Case No:CIV:2531/20018 OCTOBER 2002
Coram:HASLUCK J31/10/02
13Judgment Part:1 of 1
Result: Application to strike out allowed
B
PDF Version
Parties:MICHAEL MOODIE
NATIONWIDE NEWS PTY LTD (ACN 008 438 828)

Catchwords:

Defamation
Application to strike out certain paragraphs of the proposed defence
Polly Peck defence struck out
Qualified privilege defence concerning a parliamentary report struck out
Whether a plea concerning the plaintiff's reputation was permissible
Turns on own facts

Legislation:

Criminal Code 1913, s 354
Rules of the Supreme Court 1971, O 20 r 19

Case References:

General Steel Industries Inc v Commissioner for Railways of New South Wales (1964) 112 CLR 125
Gumina v Williams (No 2) (1990) 3 WAR 351
Plato Films Ltd v Speidel [1961] AC 1090
Polly Peck (Holdings) plc v Trelford [1986] QB 1000
Scott v Sampson [1882] 8 QBD 491
Taylor v Jecks (1993) 10 WAR 309
Templeman v Jones [1984] 1 NZLR 448
Woodger v Federal Capital Press of Australia Pty Ltd (1992) 107 ACTR 1

Anderson v Nationwide News Pty Ltd [2001] VSC 335
Bookbinder v Tebbit [1989] 1 All ER 1169
David Syme & Co Ltd v Hore-Lacy (2000) 1 VR 667
Jackson v ACP Publishing Pty Ltd [2001] WASC 121
Jakudo Pty Ltd v SA Telecasters Ltd (No 2) (1997) 69 SASR 440
Khashoggi v IPC Magazines Ltd [1986] 3 All ER 577
Moir v Flint & Anor [2001] WASC 183
Monte v Mirror Newspapers Ltd [1979] 2 NSWLR 663
Reynolds v Nationwide News Pty Ltd [2001] WASC 90
Vitale & Ors v Bednall & Anor [2001] WASC 278
Wallis & Ors v Wallis [2001] WASC 134

JURISDICTION : SUPREME COURT OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA
    IN CHAMBERS
CITATION : MOODIE -v- NATIONWIDE NEWS PTY LTD [2002] WASC 246 CORAM : HASLUCK J HEARD : 8 OCTOBER 2002 DELIVERED : 31 OCTOBER 2002 FILE NO/S : CIV 2531 of 2001 BETWEEN : MICHAEL MOODIE
    Plaintiff

    AND

    NATIONWIDE NEWS PTY LTD (ACN 008 438 828)
    Defendant



Catchwords:

Defamation - Application to strike out certain paragraphs of the proposed defence - Polly Peck defence struck out - Qualified privilege defence concerning a parliamentary report struck out - Whether a plea concerning the plaintiff's reputation was permissible - Turns on own facts




Legislation:

Criminal Code 1913, s 354


Rules of the Supreme Court 1971, O 20 r 19


Result:

Application to strike out allowed



(Page 2)

Category: B

Representation:


Counsel:


    Plaintiff : Ms E McCloskey
    Defendant : Mr S M Davies


Solicitors:

    Plaintiff : Tottle Christensen
    Defendant : Edwards Wallace


Case(s) referred to in judgment(s):

General Steel Industries Inc v Commissioner for Railways of New South Wales (1964) 112 CLR 125
Gumina v Williams (No 2) (1990) 3 WAR 351
Plato Films Ltd v Speidel [1961] AC 1090
Polly Peck (Holdings) plc v Trelford
CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Moodie v Nationwide News Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2002] WASC 246
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Michael Moodie commenced defamation proceedings against Nationwide News Pty Ltd, the publisher of "The Sunday Times", over two articles published in the newspaper. The articles were titled "Chief a 'Toecutter'" and "Moodie Blues in a Sick Situation", which allegedly contained defamatory imputations about Moodie's management style and conduct. The defendant filed a statement of defence, which led to the plaintiff seeking to strike out certain paragraphs. The court had to decide whether the defendant should be granted leave to plead in terms of a further minute of proposed substituted defence. The issues included the admissibility of a Polly Peck defence, a qualified privilege defence concerning a parliamentary report, and a plea concerning the plaintiff's reputation.

The court found that the proposed Polly Peck defence concerning the plaintiff's management style was not permissible as it attempted to justify different meanings that watered down the original allegations of criminal or ruthless conduct. The court allowed the strike-out application for certain paragraphs concerning the Polly Peck defence, but allowed the plea in relation to the plaintiff's dishonest assertions concerning the true reason for criticism of him. The court also found that the proposed qualified privilege defence concerning a parliamentary report was not sustainable as the references to the report were gratuitous asides used selectively to underpin criticisms of the plaintiff's management style in another state. However, the court allowed the plea concerning the plaintiff's general reputation to be raised in mitigation of damages, as evidence of general bad reputation is admissible in such circumstances.

The court struck out certain paragraphs of the proposed defence relating to the Polly Peck and qualified privilege defences, but allowed the plea concerning the plaintiff's reputation to proceed. The defendant was granted leave to amend its defence accordingly.

Background

Background to the litigation

Michael Moodie has commenced defamation proceedings against Nationwide News Pty Ltd in respect of two articles published in the defendant's newspaper, "The Sunday Times." The first article, published on 8 October 2000, was titled "Chief a 'Toecutter'" and concerned Moodie's standing down as Chief Executive of Princess Margaret and King Edward Memorial Hospitals. The second article, also published on 8 October 2000, was titled "Moodie Blues in a Sick Situation" and spoke of Moodie being thrown on the Public Service scrapheap. Moodie alleges that both articles contained defamatory imputations about his honesty, management style, and conduct. The defendant has filed a statement of defence and a proposed substituted defence, leading to Moodie's application to strike out certain paragraphs of the defence.

Moodie issued a chamber summons to strike out certain paragraphs of the defendant's defence, dated 21 February 2002. The summons was not yet disposed of when the defendant sought leave to plead in terms of a further minute of proposed substituted defence dated 4 September 2002. Moodie filed an amended chamber summons on 4 October 2002, seeking to strike out specific paragraphs of the defendant's minute. The case came before Hasluck J for the Supreme Court of Western Australia, who heard the matter on 8 October 2002 and delivered the judgment on 31 October 2002.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the defendant should be granted leave to plead in terms of the proposed substituted defence dated 4 September 2002.
2. Whether the defendant's proposed Polly Peck defence should be allowed.
3. Whether the defendant's proposed qualified privilege defence should be allowed.
4. Whether the defendant's plea concerning the plaintiff's reputation should be allowed.

Held
1. The court denied the defendant's leave to plead in terms of the proposed substituted defence dated 4 September 2002 for the Polly Peck defence and the qualified privilege defence concerning a parliamentary report. The application to strike out these parts of the defence was allowed.
2. The defendant's proposed Polly Peck defence was struck out as it did not disclose a reasonable defence and might prejudice, embarrass or delay the fair trial of the action.
3. The defendant's proposed qualified privilege defence concerning a parliamentary report was struck out as the court found it did not disclose a reasonable defence.
4. The court allowed the defendant's plea concerning the plaintiff's reputation as it was found to be permissible and not prejudicial to the fair trial of the action.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court considered the plaintiff's application to strike out certain paragraphs of the proposed defence, focusing on three major issues: the Polly Peck defence, the qualified privilege defence, and the plea concerning the plaintiff's reputation. In regard to the Polly Peck defence, the court held that the defendant's proposed plea was significantly different from the case advanced by the plaintiff, and thus, the Polly Peck defence must be narrowly confined to imputations and meanings similar to the imputations contended for by the plaintiff. As a result, the court allowed the plaintiff's application to strike out the Polly Peck plea in certain paragraphs of the proposed defence. Regarding the qualified privilege defence, the court found that the defendant's proposed pleading did not disclose a reasonable defence, as it was based on a passing and obviously incomplete reference to an inquiry in another state. Consequently, the court struck out the qualified privilege plea in the proposed defence. Finally, concerning the plea about the plaintiff's reputation, the court determined that the proposed line of defence was permissible and not prejudicial to the fair trial of the action. Therefore, the court allowed the defendant's plea concerning the plaintiff's reputation. The ratio decidendi of this case is that a Polly Peck defence must be narrowly confined to imputations and meanings similar to the imputations contended for by the plaintiff, and a plea concerning a plaintiff's reputation is permissible if it is not prejudicial to the fair trial of the action.